TheBayreuth Festival(German:Bayreuther Festspiele) is a music festival held annually inBayreuth,Germany, at which performances of stage works by the 19th-century German composerRichard Wagnerare presented. Wagner himself conceived and promoted the idea of a special festival to showcase his own works, in particular his monumental cycleDer Ring des NibelungenandParsifal.

Bayreuther Festspiele
Bayreuth Festival
Festspielhausin Bayreuth, the festival's main venue, in 2006
GenreCanonofWagner's stage works
FrequencyAnnual
Location(s)Bayreuth,Bavaria, Germany
Inaugurated1876;148 years ago(1876)
Websitewww.bayreuther-festspiele.de
Bayreuth Festspielhaus in 1882

Performances take place in a specially designed theatre, theBayreuth Festspielhaus.Wagner personally supervised the design and construction of the theatre, which contained many architectural innovations to accommodate the huge orchestras for which Wagner wrote as well as the composer's particular vision about the staging of his works. The Festival has become a pilgrimage destination for Wagnerians and classical-music enthusiasts.[1]

Origins

edit

The origins of the Festival itself lie rooted in Richard Wagner's interest in establishing his financial independence. A souring of the relationship with his patron,Ludwig II of Bavaria,led to his expulsion from Munich, where he had originally intended to launch the festival. Wagner next considered Nuremberg, which would have reinforced the thematic significance of works such asDie Meistersinger von Nürnberg.On the advice ofHans Richter,however, the focus fell uponBayreuthwhich enjoyed three distinct advantages.

First, the town boasted a splendid venue: theMarkgräfliches Opernhausbuilt forMargrave Frederickand his wife,Friederike Sophie Wilhelmine(sister ofFrederick the Great) in 1747. With its ample capacity and strong acoustics, the opera house seemed a good match for Wagner's vision. Second, the town of Bayreuth was located outside those regions where Wagner no longer owned the rights to the performance of his own works, which he had sold off in 1864 in order to alleviate pressing financial concerns. Finally, the town had no cultural life that could offer competition to Wagner's own artistic dominance. The Festival, once launched, would be the dominant feature of Bayreuth's cultural landscape. In addition, "Richard Wagner did not want his works interpreted amid the hustle and noise or the distractions of a large city; he sought a place remote from the usual theatrical world where it was so quiet so that the hearers could concentrate their whole attention on the work offered, and could in the pauses refresh themselves in natural surroundings.[2]"

In April 1870, Wagner and his wifeCosimavisited Bayreuth. On inspection, the opera house proved to be inadequate. It was built to accommodate thebaroqueorchestras of the 18th century and was therefore unsuited for the complex stagings and large orchestras that Wagner's later stage works required. Nonetheless, the burgermeisters proved open to assisting Wagner with the construction of an entirely new theatre, and the Festival was planned to launch in 1873. After a fruitless meeting in the spring of 1871 with the German ChancellorOtto von Bismarckto obtain funds, Wagner embarked on a fundraising tour across Germany, including Leipzig and Frankfurt.

An initial public subscription proved disappointing until Wagner, at the suggestion of his friend and admirer Emil Heckel, launched a number ofWagner Societiesto increase participation in the Festival's subscription. Societies were established in Leipzig, Berlin, Vienna and other places.

Despite making direct appeals based on Wagner's role as a composer of the new German Reich, the Societies and other fundraising channels were well short of the needed sum by the end of 1872. Wagner made another appeal to Bismarck in August 1873 and was again denied.

Desperate, Wagner turned to his former patron, Ludwig II, who reluctantly agreed to help. In January 1874, Ludwig granted 100,000Thalerand construction on the theatre, designed by architectGottfried Semper,started shortly thereafter. A planned 1875 debut was postponed for a year due to construction and other delays.

Early history

edit
Felix MottlconductedTristan und Isoldeat Bayreuth in 1886

Since its opening in 1876, the Bayreuth Festival has been a socio-cultural phenomenon. The inauguration took place on 13 August 1876, with a performance ofBeethoven's"Choral" Symphony,which is occasionally programmed during the festival. (It was played at the post-war reopening in 1951, and subsequently in 1953, 1954, 1963, 2001, and had been planned for the cancelled 2020 season.)[3]Then came the first performance ofDas Rheingold.Present at this unique musical event wereKaiser Wilhelm,Dom Pedro IIof Brazil, King Ludwig (who attended in secret, probably to avoid the Kaiser), and other members of the nobility, as well as the philosopherFriedrich Nietzschewho committed much effort to helping his then good friend Wagner establish the festival,[4]and such accomplished composers asAnton Bruckner,Edvard Grieg,Pyotr Tchaikovsky,Franz Liszt,and the youngArthur Foote.

Artistically, the festival was a success. ( "Something has taken place at Bayreuth which our grandchildren and their children will still remember", wroteTchaikovsky,attending the Festival as a Russian correspondent.) Financially, however, the festival was a disaster and did not begin to make money until several years later. Wagner abandoned his original plan to hold a second festival the following year, and travelled to London to conduct a series of concerts in an attempt to make up the deficit. Although the festival was plagued by financial problems in its early years, it survived through state intervention and the continued support of influential Wagnerians, includingKing Ludwig IIof Bavaria.

Following the financial failure of the initial Bayreuth Festival, as well as Wagner's death in 1883, there was a political discourse of Wagner's works involving a disenchantment with the Reich that led to a cultural lull of the festival. The declining popularity of the current centralized government created an artistic shift away from Richard Wagner who had preemptively popularized his works amongst the German government in an attempt to gain mass popularity and recognition. This consequently led to a general lack of public interest in the festival in its early history.[5]

From its inception, the festival has attracted leading conductors and singers, many of whom performed without pay. Among these wasHans Richter,who conducted the premiere of the Ring Cycle in 1876. Another was the talented conductorHermann Levi,who was personally chosen by Richard Wagner to conduct the debut ofParsifalin 1882 with the assistance of the youngEngelbert Humperdinck.[6]

Following Wagner's death, his widowCosimacontinued running the festival at one or, more frequently, two-year intervals. She gradually introduced the early operas which complete theBayreuth canonof Wagner's last ten mature works. Levi, the son of arabbi,remained the festival's principal conductor for the next two decades.Felix Mottl,who was involved with the festival from 1876 to 1901, conductedTristan und Isoldethere in 1886. Until the 1920s, performances were strictly in accordance with the traditions established under King Ludwig's patronage. Not a note was "cut" from any of the enormous scores; no concessions were made to the limits of human patience on the part of the audiences.Cosima Wagnerpreserved the productions ofParsifaland the Ring just as they had been in Wagner's day, defending any proposed changes with appeals to her sonSiegfried:"Was this not how Papa did it in 1876?" During her era of leadership, the festival became increasingly associated withantisemitism.[7]

After Cosima's retirement in 1906, Siegfried Wagner took over management of the festival, introducing new staging and performance styles. His early death in 1930 left the Festival in the hands of his English-born wifeWinifred Wagner,withHeinz Tietjenas artistic director.

Bayreuth under Nazi Germany

edit
Patronage certificate for funding the Bayreuth festival, issued 22. May 1922

In the 1920s, well before the rise of theNazi Party,Winifred Wagner became a strong supporter and close personal friend ofAdolf Hitler;her correspondence with Hitler has never been released by the Wagner family. She and other festival leaders were members of Nazi chief ideologueAlfred Rosenberg'sKampfbund für deutsche Kultur,which actively suppressed modernist music and works by "degenerate" artists. The festival maintained some artistic independence underNazi rule.Ironically, Hitler attended performances that included Jewish and foreign singers, long after they had been banned from all other venues across Germany (including homosexualheldentenorMax Lorenz,married to a well-known Jewish woman). Winifred's influence with Hitler was so strong that at her behest, he wrote a letter to anti-fascist Italian conductorArturo Toscanini,inviting him to lead the festival.[8]Toscanini, who had conducted there in 1930 and 1931, refused in 1933. From 1933 to 1942, the festival was conducted principally byKarl Elmendorff.

It was in Nazi Germany that the festival made its first break from tradition, abandoning the deteriorating 19th century sets created by Richard Wagner. Many protested at the changes, including prominent conductors such as Toscanini andRichard Strauss,and even some members of the Wagner family. In their view, any change to the festival was a profanation against "the Master" (Wagner). Nevertheless, Hitler approved of the changes, thus paving the way for more innovations in the decades to come.

During the war, the festival was turned over to the Nazi Party, which continued to sponsor performances for wounded soldiers returning from the front. These soldiers were forced to attend lectures on Wagner before the performances, and most found the festival to be tedious.[6]However, as "guests of the Führer", none complained.

Bayreuth Memorial

edit
Memorial to Jewish singers in the Bayreuth Festival Park

During the 1970s Winifred Wagner was repeatedly petitioned to install a memorial to the Jewish singers at the Bayreuth Festival who had been murdered in concentration camps.[9]A plaque was finally installed honouringOttilie Metzger-LattermannandHenriette Gottliebafter Winifred's death.

New festival

edit

Two-thirds of the town of Bayreuth weredestroyed by American bombingin the final days of World War II, taking with it the rotunda, living room and guest room ofWahnfried,though the theatre itself was undamaged. Following the war, Winifred Wagner was sentenced to probation by a war court for her support of the Nazi Party. The court also banned her from administration of the Bayreuth Festival and its assets, which fell eventually to her two sons,WolfgangandWieland.

During American occupation of the region after World War II, the theatre was used for army recreation and religious services for American soldiers. Only popular concerts and mixed entertainment were allowed: comedy, dancing, acrobatics, and then onlyDie Fledermauswas staged. When the Festival House was handed over to the city of Bayreuth in 1946, it was used for concerts of the Bayreuth Symphony Orchestra and the performances of such operas as Beethoven'sFidelio,d'Albert'sTiefland,Puccini'sMadama Butterfly,and Verdi'sLa traviataand talks about reopening of the Wagnerian Festival started. Finally, it reopened on 29 July 1951 with, as always, a performance by theBayreuth Festival Orchestraunder conductorWilhelm Furtwänglerof Beethoven's 9th Symphony, followed by the first post-war performance of Wagner'sParsifal.[10]

Under the direction of Wieland Wagner, the "New Bayreuth" ushered in an era that was no less than revolutionary. Gone were the elaborate naturalistic sets, replaced with minimalist modern productions. In comparison, the pre-war changes seemed tame. For the first time in its history, the Bayreuth audience booed at the end of productions. Wieland was particularly derided for his 1956 production ofDie Meistersinger von Nürnberg.Stripped of its pageantry, conservatives viewed the breaking of this "sacred German tradition" as an outrage.[6]

Wieland defended the changes as an attempt to create an "invisible stage" that would allow the audience to experience the full psychosocial aspects of the drama without the baggage and distraction of elaborate set designs. Others have speculated that by stripping Wagner's works of their Germanic and historic elements, Wieland was attempting to distance Bayreuth from its nationalistic past and create productions with universal appeal. Over time, many critics came to appreciate the unique beauty of Wieland's reinterpretation of his grandfather's works.[6]

Wieland's innovative productions invited comparison to Wolfgang's, which critics unanimously found to be uninspired. If Wieland's productions were radical, Wolfgang's were regressive. Although still minimalist in approach, Wolfgang resurrected much of the naturalistic and romantic elements of pre-war productions. Thus, when Wieland died prematurely from lung cancer in 1966, many wondered if Bayreuth had a future. They began to question Bayreuth's primacy among German opera houses, and some suggested that more interesting productions were being staged elsewhere.[6]

Around this time (1955), in order to broaden its audience, the whole Bayreuth Festival company conducted performances in Paris and Barcelona, performingParsifal,Die WalküreandTristan und Isolde.

In 1973, faced with overwhelming criticism and family infighting, the Bayreuth Festival and its assets were transferred to a newly createdRichard Wagner Foundation.The board of directors included members of the Wagner family and others appointed by the state. As chairman, Wolfgang Wagner remained in charge of administration of the festival.

The WagnerWerkstatt

edit

While Wolfgang Wagner continued to administer the festival, beginning in the 1970s, production was handled by a number of new directors in what Wolfgang calledWerkstatt Bayreuth(Bayreuth Workshop). The idea was to turn the festival into an opportunity for directors to experiment with new methods for presenting the stage works. The change came out of necessity, as it was impossible for Wolfgang to both administer and direct the festival. It also provided an opportunity for Bayreuth to renew itself with each production, rather than continue to present the same stage works in the same way, year after year.Ingmar Bergman,who famously made afilm version in Swedishof Mozart'sDie Zauberflöte,turned down an invitation to direct the festival.

The most sensational production inWerkstatt Bayreuthwas the centennialRingcycle (Jahrhundertring) directed byPatrice Chéreau,who used an updated 19th-century setting, following the interpretation ofGeorge Bernard Shawwho regarded the Ring as a social commentary on the exploitation of the working class by wealthy 19th-century capitalists.[11]The audience reaction was initially split between those who saw the production as an offence and those who considered it the best Ring Cycle ever produced. The ensuing conflict, short only of outright riot, between supporters and detractors was unprecedented in the history of the festival. Later, the performances proved influential for the concept ofRegietheater.

Other notable directors to have participated inWerkstatt BayreuthincludedJean-Pierre Ponnelle,SirPeter Hallof theRoyal Shakespeare Company,Götz Friedrichof theDeutsche Oper Berlin,Harry Kupferof theBerlin State Operain the former communist East Germany andHeiner Müllerof theBerliner Ensemble.In the end, Wolfgang's decision to bring in experimental directors helped rejuvenate Bayreuth and restore its reputation as the world leader in Wagnerian opera.

21st century

edit

There was uncertainty over how the Festival was to be managed after the retirement of Wolfgang Wagner at the end of August 2008. In 2001, the Festival's 21-member board of directors had voted for his daughter,Eva Wagner-Pasquier,to succeed him. Wolfgang Wagner, however, proposed to hand control over to his second wife, Gudrun, and their daughter Katharina.[12]Gudrun died in 2007.[13]No successor was named at that time, but it was speculated that Wagner-Pasquier and Katharina would eventually be named as joint directors of the festival.[14]Directors have stated that preference will be given to descendants of Richard Wagner, and that a non-descendant would have to be a clearly better candidate.[citation needed]

On 1 September 2008, Wolfgang Wagner's daughters,Eva Wagner-PasquierandKatharina Wagner,were named by Bavaria's culture minister,Thomas Goppel,to take over the Festival. They were to take up their duties immediately, since their father had announced his retirement at the conclusion of the 2008 Festival.[12]They were chosen ahead of the pair of their cousin,Nike Wagner,andGerard Mortier,who had placed a late bid for the directorship on 24 August.[15][16]The conductorChristian Thielemannhas agreed to act as chief adviser to the new directors, effectively taking the role of music director of the Festival.[17]

In 2014 it was announced that Eva would be stepping down from the co-directorship leaving, in accord with her father's will,[18]Katharina in sole charge.[19]

On the 31 March 2020 it was announced that, due to the COVID-19 pandemicand the resulting restrictions, the 2020 festival (due to take place from 25 July to 30 August) would be cancelled.[20] The newDer Ring des Nibelungenproduction planned for that festival would be postponed until at least 2022.

Restrictions were eased for the 2021 festival, which went ahead with a limited audience capacity and testing/vaccination requirements.[21][22] The 2022 festival went ahead as normal, including the new production of theRing.

In 2023 the festival had mixed opinions due to the use of AR goggles and 3D glasses to enhance the experience. The festival has attempted to modernize to aid with low ticket sales.[23]

Tickets

edit

The festival draws thousands of Wagner fans to Bayreuth every summer. It is very difficult to get tickets, because demand (estimated at 500,000) greatly exceeds supply (58,000 tickets); the waiting time is between five and ten years (or more). The process entails submitting an order form every summer; applicants are usually successful after about ten years. Failure to make an application every year results in being placed at the back of the queue. Although some tickets are allocated by lottery, preference is given to members of the Society of Friends of Bayreuth (financial donors), famous patrons, and to regional and international Wagner societies, which are distributed to their own members through lottery or the willingness to pay a high contribution.

However, in 2013 tickets for one opera production were offered exclusively online, on a first come first served basis with no preferential eligibility. It is reported that they sold out within seconds.[citation needed] This offer was repeated for the 2014 season, with tickets being available for eight performances including one complete Ring cycle.[24]As of 2014, retail ticket prices ranged from €320 for a front row stalls seat to €45 for a gallery (third level) back row seat.[25]

The Festival authorities assiduously police the traffic of tickets, and monitor sites such aseBay.On admission patrons may be required to show photographic identification matching the name on the ticket, with any not matching being refused admission to the performance.

In 2011 it was revealed that the GermanBundesrechnungshof(federal audit office) were investigating the situation where, for a publicly subsidised event, only 40 percent of the tickets were actually available to the general public.[26][27]Early in 2012 it was announced that changes would be made to the allocation system, including the ending of allocations toWagner Societies(but not including the Society of Friends of Bayreuth as they make a substantial financial contribution) and a reduction in the proportion reserved for travel agents and hotels. As a result, the proportion of tickets available to the general public would increase to about 65 percent of the total available.[28]

Der Ring des Nibelungen

edit

A new production ofDer Ring des Nibelungen,or theRingcycle, is presented every five to seven years, following a year in which noRingis presented. In years in which theRingis staged, three other works are also presented. When noRingis staged, five other works are presented. Tickets for theRingare normally sold only as a complete set for all four performances.[25]

TheRingproduced for the Festival's centenary in 1976 was produced by a French team around directorPatrice Chéreauand conductorPierre Boulez.Known as theJahrhundertring,it was filmed.

The newest production of theRing(directed byValentin Schwarz) premiered in 2022 after pandemic-related delays.[29][30]Schwarz's modern staging of the cycle— depicting a complex, tangled family drama spanning generations—was met with mixed reviews from audiences and the press.[31][32]

Directors

edit

Recordings

edit

Laserdisc

edit

Historical recordings

edit

Historical performances of Wagner's operas at Bayreuth, available on CD, are too numerous to list. The following are a few outstanding examples.

  • 100 Jahre Bayreuth auf Schallplatte:The Early Festival Singers, 1887–1906, Gebhardt Records
This 12 CD set put together all of the surviving recordings done by the Gramophone andTypewriterCompany in 1904 at Bayreuth and includes some of the original artists from the 1876 debut.Listen
– recorded during the summer of 1928 with the approval of Siegfried Wagner, in the Festspielhaus without an audience, by Columbia EMI onto 40 78rpm sides (for 20 discs)
– several reissues on CD: Grammofono, 2000 AB 78925-26 (2 CDs – "First Bayreuth Recordings Vol. 2" ) | Naxos, CD 8.110200-02 (3 CDs) | Preiser, PSR 90383 (2 CDs)
  • Götterdämmerung(1942) Conductor: Karl Elmendorff, Soloists:Marta Fuchs(Brünnhilde),Camilla Kallab(1. Norne, Waltraute), Else Fischer (Gutrune).Set Svanholm(Siegfried), Friedrich Dalberg (Hagen),Robert Burg(Alberich), Egmont Koch (Gunther)
– from a radio broadcast ofDeutscher Rundfunk;this is what German soldiers would have heard as "Guests of the Führer"
– issued by various labels: among them Music and Arts, CD-1058 (4 CDs) | Preiser, PRE 90164 (4 CDs)
– issued by various labels: among them Grammofono 2000, AB 78602/05 (4 CDs)

Postwar performances

edit

See also

edit

References

edit
  1. ^"How to get tickets for the Wagner Festival in Bayreuth"Archived28 January 2010 at theWayback Machineon wagneropera.net Retrieved 1 July 2013
  2. ^Wagner, Siegfried (1 June 1930). "The Bayreuth Festival Plays".The Musical Times.71(1048): 506–507.doi:10.2307/917356.ISSN0027-4666.JSTOR917356.
  3. ^"Aufführungsdatenbank".
  4. ^Nietzsche, Friedrich,Twilight of the Idols,Penguin Books, 2003. Translator's note (R. J. Hollingdale).
  5. ^Fifield, Christopher (2016).Hans Richter(NED - New ed.). Boydell & Brewer.ISBN978-1-78327-021-7.JSTOR10.7722/j.ctt1c3gx63.
  6. ^abcdeSpotts, Frederic (1994).Bayreuth: A History of the Wagner Festival.New Haven and London: Yale University Press.ISBN0300066651.[page needed]
  7. ^Hilmes, Oliver (12 December 2017)."Cosima Wagner".Yale University.doi:10.12987/9780300168235– via De Gruyter.
  8. ^Civetta, Cesare.Toscanini Defied Mussolini and Protested Against Hitler.Paragraph 6. Website:cesarecivetta.com.
  9. ^Opera.Vol. 48. London. 1997. pp. 914–915.The festival's archive, with its correspondence with Hitler and other documentation of the period, is still closed to research. He has not even been willing to have a modest memorial for the three Bayreuth singers who perished in concentration camps. The proposal for a memorial plaque was proposed to Wolfgang ages ago by a retired singer and Bayreuth antiquarian bookseller, Peer Baedeker. And therein lies a revealing story. When the centenary festival opened in 1976 with a wreath-laying ceremony at Wagner's grave, Baedeker placed his own wreath with a ribbon attached, with the words: In memory of Richard Breitenfeld, Henriette Gottlieb, Ottilie Metzger-Lattermann Honoured as festival singers murdered in Nazi concentration camps. Within 24 hours of the ceremony, the ribbon had vanished. An article about the incident, which later appeared in an Israeli newspaper, was sent to Winifred, who wrote the following ineffable letter to Baedeker: 'Herr Heinrich Schaar in Munich sends me from time to time cuttings from the Israel Nachrichten, including this one.... Herr Schaar appears to suspect that this was my doing or at my behest, since otherwise he would not have sent me the press cutting. In the first place I had no idea you had laid a wreath, and in the second I seldom go to RW's resting place; since it is now permanently open to the public, it is never possible to visit the grave alone. I myself never heard Frau Metzger-Lattermann in Bayreuth. but I know that my husband had a very high impression of her. FrauGottliebsang here in my time and I had a high opinion of her as well. HerrBreitenfeldis unknown to me. But were all three really killed at Auschwitz? I would doubt that in the case of Frau Lattermann, since she must have been terribly old. With best wishes, also to your wife, whom I recently greeted in front of Wahnfried.' – The casualness of this brush-off, the brutal indifference to the murder of three old singers speaks volumes about the attitude in Bayreuth to its past. And so the monument that the festival visitor sees today on the Green Hill – the massive copy of the bust of a glowering Wagner made for Hitler by the Nazi sculptorArno Breker– is, properly viewed, a brazen symbol of Bayreuth's (??){{cite magazine}}:Missing or empty|title=(help)[title missing][author missing][excessive quote]
  10. ^Emmerich, Peter (1992).Wagner in Bayreuth: A Documentary.Belgium: Philips Classics Productions, Baarn. pp. 69–71.
  11. ^Bernard Shaw,The Perfect Wagnerite(1883) online at www.marxists.orgShaw's examination of Wagner's approach to the cycle
  12. ^ab"Daughters chosen to run Bayreuth",BBC News,1 September 2008. Retrieved on 1 September 2008.
  13. ^ObituaryDer Spiegel,28 November 2007
  14. ^"Bayreuth Festival's Wolfgang Wagner to Retire",Deutsche Welle,29 April 2008
  15. ^Hickley, Catherine (1 September 2008)."Wagner Sisters Katharina, Eva Named to Lead Bayreuth (Update2)".Bloomberg.Retrieved1 September2008.
  16. ^McGroarty, Patrick; Ron Blum (1 September 2008)."Bayreuth names Wagner half-sisters as co-directors".International Herald Tribune.Retrieved1 September2008.
  17. ^Roger Boyes,"Wagner hits a note of peace over Bayreuth",The Times(London), 2 September 2008.
  18. ^Service, Tom (26 February 2014)."Eva Wagner to leave Bayreuth - what does this mean for the festival?".The Guardian.Guardian News & Media Limited.Retrieved29 April2020.
  19. ^Gereben, Janos (25 February 2014)."Bayreuth: And Then There Was One".San Francisco Classical Voice.Retrieved29 April2020.
  20. ^"Suspension Bayreuth Festival 2020".Bayreuther Festspiele. 31 March 2020.Retrieved31 March2020.
  21. ^"Audience Capacity 2021".Bayreuther Festspiele. 23 June 2021.Retrieved25 July2023.
  22. ^"Registration Process 2021".Bayreuther Festspiele. 8 July 2021.Retrieved25 July2023.
  23. ^Brug, Manuel (31 July 2023)."Chaos at Bayreuth: what's really going on at Germany's beloved opera festival".The Telegraph.ISSN0307-1235.Retrieved29 April2024.
  24. ^"Bayreuth Festival 2014".Bayreuther Festspiele. Archived fromthe originalon 27 September 2013.Retrieved24 September2013.
  25. ^abBayreuther Festspiele: "Spielfolge/Programme 2014" leaflet, issued September 2013
  26. ^Lucas Wiegelmann:"Mit den Förderzielen des Bundes nicht vereinbar".Die Welt,24 June 2011
  27. ^"Götterdämmerung".The Economist.20 June 2011.Retrieved24 September2013.
  28. ^"Was lange währt: Reform der Ticketvergabe in Bayreuth kommt voran".Klassik Magazine(in German).Retrieved24 September2013.
  29. ^"Performance Database".Bayreuther Festspiele.Retrieved7 September2023.
  30. ^Miller, Ben (28 July 2022)."'A Stone in the Mosaic': A Director Enters the House of Wagner ".The New York Times.ISSN0362-4331.Retrieved7 September2023.
  31. ^Woolfe, Zachary (7 August 2022)."Review: A New 'Ring' at Bayreuth Does Wagner Without Magic".The New York Times.ISSN0362-4331.Retrieved7 September2023.
  32. ^Kettle, Martin (8 August 2022)."The Ring Cycle review – ideas-free patchwork staging signals Bayreuth's fading authority".The Guardian.ISSN0261-3077.Retrieved7 September2023.

Further reading

edit
edit

49°57′36″N11°34′47″E/ 49.96000°N 11.57972°E/49.96000; 11.57972