Wikipedia

Near-death experience

For other uses, seeNear Death Experience (disambiguation).
"Near death" redirects here. For the comics, seeNear Death (comics).
"NDE" redirects here. For other uses, seeNDE (disambiguation).

Anear-death experience(NDE) is a profound personal experience associated withdeathor impending death, which researchers describe as having similar characteristics. When positive, which the great majority are,[1]such experiences may encompass a variety of sensations including detachment from the body, feelings of levitation, total serenity, security, warmth, joy, the experience of absolute dissolution, review of major life events, the presence of a light, and seeing dead relatives. When negative, such experiences may include sensations of anguish, distress, a void, devastation, and seeinghellishimagery.[1][2][3]

PassagebyAnna Sahlstén

NDEs usually occur during reversibleclinical death.Explanations for NDEs vary from scientific to religious.Neuroscienceresearch hypothesizes that an NDE is asubjectivephenomenon resulting from "disturbed bodily multisensory integration" that occurs during life-threatening events.[4]Sometranscendentalandreligiousbeliefs about anafterlifeinclude descriptions similar to NDEs.[2][5][6][7][8]

Etymology

edit

The equivalentFrenchtermexpérience de mort imminente( "experience of imminent death" ) was proposed by FrenchpsychologistandepistemologistVictor Egger as a result of discussions in the 1890s amongphilosophersand psychologists concerningclimbers'stories of the panoramiclife reviewduring falls.[9][10]

In 1892, a series of subjective observations by workers falling from scaffolds, soldiers who suffered injuries, climbers who had fallen from heights and other individuals who had come close to death such as in near drownings and accidents was reported byAlbert Heim.This was also the first time the phenomenon was described as a clinical syndrome.[11]

In 1968,Celia Greenpublished an analysis of 400 first-hand accounts ofout-of-body experiences.[12]This represented the first attempt to provide ataxonomyof such experiences, viewed simply as anomalous perceptual experiences orhallucinations.

In 1969, Swiss-Americanpsychiatristand pioneer in near-death studiesElisabeth Kübler-Rosspublished her well-known bookOn Death and Dying: What the Dying Have to Teach Doctors, Nurses, Clergy, and Their Own Families.[13]

The term "near-death experience" was used byJohn C. Lillyin 1972.[14]The term was popularized in 1975 by the work of psychiatristRaymond Moody,who used it as an umbrella term for out-of-body experiences (OBEs), the "panoramic life review", the Light, the tunnel, or the border.[11]

Characteristics

edit

Common elements

edit
Ascent of the BlessedbyHieronymus Boschis associated by some NDE researchers with aspects of the NDE.[15][16]

Researchershave identified the common elements that define near-death experiences.[6]Bruce Greysonargues that the general features of the experience include impressions ofbeing outside one's physical body,visions of deceased relatives and religious figures, andtranscendenceofegoticandspatiotemporalboundaries.[17]Many common elements have been reported, although the person's interpretation of these events often corresponds with thecultural,philosophical,orreligiousbeliefs of the person experiencing it. For example, in the US, where 46% of the population believes inguardian angels,the Light will often be identified as angels or deceased loved ones (or will be unidentified), while Hindus will often identify them as messengers of thegod of death.[18][19]

Common traits that have been reported by NDErs are:

  • A sense/awareness of being dead.[6]
  • A sense ofpeace,well-being,painlessness and other positiveemotions.A sense of removal from the world.[6]An intense feeling ofunconditional loveandacceptance.[20]Experiencing euphoric environments.[21]
  • Anout-of-body experience(OBE). A perception of one's body from an outside position, sometimes observing medical professionals performing resuscitation efforts.[6][22]
  • A "tunnel experience" or entering a darkness. A sense of moving up, or through, a passageway or staircase.[6][22]
  • A rapid movement toward and/or sudden immersion in a powerful light (or "Being(s) of Light" or "Being(s) dressed in white" ) who communicate telepathically with the person.[23][6]
  • Being reunited with deceased loved ones.[22]
  • Receiving alife review,commonly referred to as "seeing one's life flash before one's eyes".[6]
  • Approaching a border or a decision by oneself or others to return to one's body, often accompanied by a reluctance to return.[6][22]
  • Suddenly finding oneself back inside one's body.[24]
  • Connection to the cultural beliefs held by the individual, which seem to dictate some of the phenomena experienced in the NDE, but more so affects the later interpretation thereof.[18][page needed]

Note that an OBE may be part of an NDE, but can happen in instances other than when a person is about to die, such as fainting, deep sleep, and alcohol or drug use.[25]

Stages

edit

A 1975 study conducted by psychiatrist Raymond Moody on around 150 patients who all claimed to have witnessed an NDE stated that such an experience has nine steps.

The steps are:[25]

  1. Sudden peace and relief from pain.
  2. Perception of a relaxing sound or other-worldly music.
  3. Consciousness or spirit ascending above the person's body, sometimes remotely viewing medical professionals' attempts at resuscitation (autoscopy).
  4. The person's spirit leaving the earthly realm and ascending rapidly through a tunnel of light in a universe of darkness.
  5. Arriving at a brilliant "heavenly place."
  6. Being met by "people of the light," who are usually deceased friends and family, in a joyous reunion.
  7. Meeting with a deity that is often perceived as their religious culture would have perceived it, or as an intense mass emitting pure love and light.
  8. In the presence of the deity, the person undergoes an instantaneous life review and understands how all the good and bad they have done has affected them and others.
  9. The person returns to their earthly body and life, because either they are told it is not their time to die or they are given a choice and they return for the benefit of their family and loved ones.

Moody also explained how not every NDE will have each and every one of these steps, and how it could be different for each experience.

Moody describes the correct approach to an NDE patient is to "Ask, Listen, Validate, Educate, and Refer".[25]Due to the potential confusion or shock attributed to those who experience near-death experiences, it is important to treat them in a calm and understanding way right after their return from the NDE.

Entering darkness, seeing the light

Kenneth Ring(1980) subdivided the NDE on a five-stagecontinuum,using Moody's nine step experiment as inspiration. The subdivisions were:[26]

  1. Peace
  2. Body separation
  3. Entering darkness
  4. Seeing the light
  5. Entering another realm of existence, through the light

The final stage is the person being resuscitated.[27]

Charlotte Martial, a neuropsychologist from theUniversity of Liègeand the University Hospital of Liège who led a team that investigated 154 NDE cases, concluded that there is not a fixed sequence of events.[28]Dr. Yvonne Kason classified near-death experiences into three types: "Out-of-Body", "Mystical" or "White-Light", and "Distressing".[29]

Clinical circumstances

edit

Kenneth Ring states that NDEs experienced following attempted suicides are statistically no more unpleasant than NDEs resulting from other situations.[30]

In one series of NDEs, 22% occurred during general anesthesia.[31]

Bruce Greyson found that NDEs had a lack of precision in diagnosis, so he created a questionnaire for those who had experienced NDE composed of 80 characteristics to study common effects, mechanisms, sensations and reactions.[32]Greyson replaced that questionnaire in 1983 with an exemplary scale for researchers to use.[32]

Bruce Greyson's composition of final NDE Scale[32]
Component and question Weighted response
Did time seem to speed up? 2 = Everything seemed to be happening all at once

1 = Time seemed to go faster than usual

0 = Neither

Were your thoughts sped up? 2 = Incredibly fast

1 = Faster than usual

0 = Neither

Did scenes from your past come back to you? 2 = Past flashed before me, out of my control

1 = Remembered many past events

0 = Neither

Did you suddenly seem to understand everything? 2 = About the universe

1 = About myself or others

0 = Neither

Did you have a feeling of peace or pleasantness? 2 = Incredible peace or pleasantness

1 = Relief or calmness

0 = Neither

Did you have a feeling of joy? 2 = Incredible joy

1 = Happiness

0 = Neither

Did you feel a sense of harmony or unity with the universe? 2 = United, one with the world

1 = No longer in conflict with nature

0 = Neither

Did you see or feel surrounded by a brilliant light? 2 = Light clearly of mystical or other-worldly origin

1 = Unusually bright light

0 = Neither

Were your senses more vivid than usual? 2 = Incredibly more so

1 = More so than usual

0 = Neither

Did you seem to be aware of things going on elsewhere, as if byESP? 2 = Yes, and facts later corroborated

1 = Yes, but facts not yet corroborated

0 = Neither

Did scenes from the future come to you? 2 = From the world's future

1 = From personal future

0 = Neither

Did you feel separated from your physical body? 2 = Clearly left the body and existed outside it

1 = Lost awareness of the body

0 = Neither

Did you seem to enter some other, unearthly world? 2 = Clearly mystical or unearthly realm

1 = Unfamiliar, strange place

0 = Neither

Did you seem to encounter a mystical being or presence? 2 = Definite being, or voice clearly of mystical or other-worldly origin

1 = Unidentifiable voice

0 = Neither

Did you see deceased spirits or religious figures? 2 = Saw them

1 = Sensed their presence

0 = Neither

Did you come to a border or point of no return? 2 = A barrier I was not permitted to cross, or "sent back" to life involuntarily

1 = A conscious decision to "return" to life

0 = Neither

According to theRasch Rating Scale Model,Greyson's 16 multiple-choice questionnaire can be universally applied to all NDEs. It yields the same results no matter the age and gender of the victim, the intensity of the experience, or how much time elapsed between taking the survey and the NDE itself. With the results ranging from 0 to 32, the average score is 15 and the one standard deviation below the mean is 7. A score below 7 is considered a "subtle" NDE; a score between 7 and 21 is a "deep" NDE; and a score 22 or above is a "profound" NDE.[33]

This scale has helped many researchers advance and enrich their discovery, most notably, Dr. Jeffrey Long. Long set out to discover the "reality" of NDEs mostly linked to cardiac arrest patients by using this scale and reviewing Near Death Experience Research Foundation studies.[34]His first line of evidence shows that 835 out of 1,122 people who had experienced NDE seemed to feel an increase in alertness and consciousness although studies proved no sign of electrical brain activity.[35]His second line of evidence studies the increase of accuracy developed by NDErs defining their resuscitation process with a 97.6% accuracy rate.[35]Long documented seven more lines of evidence that all point to realism in NDE experiences, yet not all of them verifiable or defined by today's medical advances and technology.[35]Having such an abnormally large amount (95.6% of 1,000 participants) of those who had experienced NDE proclaiming NDEs as real experiences, he concludes that although NDE are medically inexplicable, they are most probably a real phenomenon.[35]

After-effects

edit

NDEs are associated with changes in personality and outlook on life.[6]Ring has identified a consistent set of value and belief changes associated with people who have had an NDE. Among these changes, he found a greater appreciation for life, higher self-esteem, greater compassion for others, less concern for acquiring material wealth, a heightened sense of purpose and self-understanding, desire to learn, elevated spirituality, greater ecological sensitivity and planetary concern, a feeling of being more intuitive,[6]no longer worrying about death, and claiming to have witnessed an afterlife.[36]Although people who have had experienced NDEs become more spiritual, it does not mean they become necessarily more religious.[37]

However, not all after-effects are beneficial[38]and Greyson describes circumstances in which changes in attitudes and behavior can lead to psychosocial and psychospiritual problems.[39]

Historical reports

edit

NDEs have been recorded since ancient times.[40]The oldest known medical report of near-death experiences was written by Pierre-Jean du Monchaux, an 18th-century French military doctor who described such a case in his bookAnecdotes de Médecine.[41]Monchaux hypothesized that an influx of blood in the brain stimulated a strong feeling in the individual, and therefore caused a near-death experience.[41]In the 19th century a few studies moved beyond individual cases – one privately done by members ofthe Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints[42]and one in Switzerland. Up to 2005, 95% of world cultures are known to have made some mention of NDEs.[40]

In the U.S., an estimated nine million people have reported an NDE according to a 2011 study inAnnals of the New York Academy of Sciences.Most of these near-death experiences resulted from serious injury affecting the body or brain.[43]

A number of more contemporary sources report the incidence of near death experiences as:

  • 17% amongst critically ill patients, in nine prospective studies from four different countries.[44]
  • 10–20% of people who have come close to death.[11]

Near-death studies

edit
Main article:Near-death studies
EEGresearch data by Gang Xu,et al.

Bruce Greyson (psychiatrist),Kenneth Ring(psychologist), andMichael Sabom(cardiologist), helped to launch the field of near-death studies and introduced the study of near-death experiences to the academic setting. From 1975 to 2005, some 2,500 self-reported individuals in the US had been reviewed in retrospective studies of the phenomena,[40]with an additional 600 outside the US in the West,[40]and 70 in Asia.[40]Additionally, prospective studies had identified 270 individuals. Prospective studies review groups of individuals (e.g., selected emergency room patients) and then find who had an NDE during the study's time; such studies cost more to perform.[40]In all, close to 3,500 individual cases between 1975 and 2005 had been reviewed in one or another study. All these studies were carried out by some 55 researchers or teams of researchers.[40]

Melvin L. Morse,head of the Institute for the Scientific Study of Consciousness, and colleagues[22][45]have investigated near-death experiences in a pediatric population.[46]

Researchers from theUniversity of Michiganled by Jimo Borjigin discovered that areas of the brain responsible for interior visual experience were more active during cardiac arrest. According to the study, a sudden surge in brain activity at the time of cardiac arrest may be what causes people to perceive a bright white light when having a near-death experience.[47]

Following the rapid gamma activation locally within the posterior TPO zones, the long-range, global, and interhemispheric communications in gamma oscillations between the TPO zones and the prefrontal areas were activated in the dying brain, evidenced by the delayed activation of temporofrontal, parietofrontal, and Occipitofrontal networks when heart rate began to decline. Intriguingly, the long-range gamma connectivity between the posterior hot zones and the prefrontal areas at near-death was significantly higher over baseline only for those crossing the midline. Studies suggest that interhemispheric circuitry is important for memory recall, and gamma synchrony across the midlines is critical for learning, information integration, and perception.[47]

Clinical research in cardiac arrest patients

edit

Parnia's study in 2001

edit

In 2001,Sam Parniaand colleagues published the results of a year-long study of cardiac arrest survivors that was conducted at Southampton General Hospital. 63 survivors were interviewed. They had been resuscitated after beingclinically deadwith no pulse, no respiration, and fixed dilated pupils. Parnia and colleagues investigated out-of-body experience claims by placing figures in areas where patients were likely to be resuscitated on suspended boards facing the ceiling, not visible from the floor. Four had experiences that, according to the study criteria, were NDEs but none of them experienced the out-of-body experience. Thus, they were not able to identify the figures.[48][49][50]

PsychologistChris Frenchwrote regarding the study "unfortunately, and somewhat atypically, none of the survivors in this sample experienced an out of body experience".[49]

Van Lommel's study

edit
Pim van Lommel

In 2001,Pim van Lommel,a cardiologist from the Netherlands, and his team conducted a study on NDEs including 344 cardiac arrest patients who had been successfully resuscitated in 10 Dutch hospitals. Patients not reporting NDEs were used as controls for patients who did, and psychological (e.g., fear before cardiac arrest), demographic (e.g., age, sex), medical (e.g., more than onecardiopulmonary resuscitation(CPR)), and pharmacological data were compared between the two groups.

The work also included a longitudinal study where the two groups (those who had had an NDE and those who had not had one) were compared at two and eight years, for life changes. One patient had a conventional out of body experience. He reported being able to watch and recall events during the time of his cardiac arrest. His claims were confirmed by hospital personnel. "This did not appear consistent with hallucinatory or illusory experiences, as the recollections were compatible with real and verifiable rather than imagined events".[50][51]

Awareness during resuscitation (AWARE) study

edit

While at the University of Southampton, Parnia was the principal investigator of the AWARE Study, which was launched in 2008.[13]The study, which concluded in 2012, included 33 investigators across 15 medical centers in the UK, Austria and the US and tested consciousness, memories and awareness during cardiac arrest. The accuracy of claims of visual and auditory awareness was examined using specific tests.[52]One such test consisted of installing shelves, bearing a variety of images and facing the ceiling, hence not visible to hospital staff, in rooms where cardiac-arrest patients were more likely to occur. The results of the study were published in October 2014.[53][54]

A review article analyzing the results reports that, out of 2,060 cardiac arrest events, 101 of 140 cardiac arrest survivors could complete the questionnaires. Of these 101 patients, 9% could be classified as near-death experiences. Two more patients (2% of those completing the questionnaires) described "seeing and hearing actual events related to the period of cardiac arrest". These two patients' cardiac arrests did not occur in areas equipped with ceiling shelves, hence no images could be used to objectively test for visual awareness claims. One of the two patients was too sick and the accuracy of her recount could not be verified. For the second patient, however, it was possible to verify the accuracy of the experience and to show that awareness occurred paradoxically some minutes after the heart stopped, at a time when "the brain ordinarily stops functioning and cortical activity becomes isoelectric (i.e., without any discernible electric activity)." The experience was not compatible with an illusion, imaginary event or hallucination since visual (other than of ceiling shelves' images) and auditory awareness could be corroborated.[50]

As of May 2016,a posting at the UK Clinical Trials Gateway website described plans forAWARE II,a two-year multicenter observational study of 900–1,500 patients experiencing cardiac arrest, which said that subject recruitment had started on 1 August 2014 and that the scheduled end date was 31 May 2017.[55]The study was extended, continuing until 2020.[56]In 2019, a report of a condensed version of the study with 465 patients was released. Only one patient remembered the auditory stimuli while none remembered the visual.[57]

Meditation-induced NDEs

edit

A three-year longitudinal study has revealed that someBuddhist meditationpractitioners are able to willfully induce near-death experiences at a pre-planned point in time. Unlike traditional NDEs, participants were consciously aware of experiencing the meditation-induced NDE and retained control over its content and duration.[58]TheDalai Lamahas also asserted that experienced meditators can deliberately induce the NDE state during meditation, being able to recognize and sustain it.[59]

Explanatory models

edit

In a 2005 review article, psychologistChris French[49]categorized models that try to explain NDEs into three broad groups which "are not distinct and independent, but instead show considerable overlap": spiritual (or transcendental), psychological, and physiological.

Spiritual or transcendental models

edit

French summarizes this model by saying: "the most popular interpretation is that the NDE is exactly what it appears to be to the person having the experience".[49]The NDE would represent evidence of the immaterial existence of a soul or mind, which leaves the body upon death, and provides information about an immaterial world where the soul journeys after death.[49]

According to Greyson,[11]some NDE phenomena cannot be easily explained with our current knowledge of human physiology and psychology. For instance, at a time when they were unconscious, patients could accurately describe events "from an out-of-body spatial perspective". In two different studies of patients who had survived a cardiac arrest, those who had reported leaving their bodies could describe accurately their resuscitation procedures or unexpected events, whereas others "described incorrect equipment and procedures".[11]Sam Parnia also refers to two cardiac arrest studies and one deep hypothermic circulatory arrest study where patients reported visual and/or auditory awareness occurring when their brain function had ceased. These reports "were corroborated with actual and real events".[60][50]

Five prospective studies have been carried out, to test the accuracy of out of body perceptions by placing "unusual targets in locations likely to be seen by persons having NDEs, such as in an upper corner of a room in the emergency department, the coronary care unit, or the intensive care unit of a hospital." Twelve patients reported leaving their bodies, but none could describe the hidden visual targets. Although this is a small sample, the failure of purported out-of-body experiencers to describe the hidden targets raises questions about the accuracy of the anecdotal reports described above.[11]

  • Some patients floated in the opposite direction of the targets
  • Some patients were floating just above the body, thus not high enough to see the targets
  • One patient reported that he was too focused on observing the body to look for any targets. Also, he alleges that he would have been able to see them if he had been told to look for them.

Criticism

edit

PsychologistJames Alcockhas described the afterlife claims of NDE researchers aspseudoscientific.Alcock has written the spiritual or transcendental interpretation "is based on belief in search of data rather than observation in search of explanation."[61]Chris French has noted that "the survivalist approach does not appear to generate clear and testable hypotheses. Because of the vagueness and imprecision of the survivalist account, it can be made to explain any possible set of findings and is therefore unfalsifiable and unscientific."[62]

Psychological models

edit

French summarises the main psychological explanations, which include: the depersonalization, the expectancy and the dissociation models.[49]

Depersonalization model

edit

A depersonalization model was proposed in the 1970s by professor of psychiatry Russell Noyes and clinical psychologist Roy Kletti, which suggested that the NDE is a form ofdepersonalization,experienced under emotional conditions such as life-threatening danger, potentially inescapable danger, and that the NDE can best be understood as ahallucination.[49][63][64][65][66]According to this model, those who face their impending death become detached from their surroundings and bodies, no longer feel emotions, and experience time distortions.[11]

This model suffers from a number of limitations to explain NDEs for subjects who do not experience a sensation of being out of their bodies; unlike NDEs, these hallucinatory experiences are dreamlike, unpleasant and characterized by "anxiety, panic and emptiness".[11]Also, during NDEs subjects remain very lucid of their identities, and their sense of identity is not changed, unlike those experiencing depersonalization.[11]

Expectancy model

edit

Another psychological theory is called the expectancy model. It has been suggested that although these experiences could appear very real, they had actually been constructed in the mind, either consciously or subconsciously, in response to the stress of an encounter with death (or perceived encounter with death), and did not correspond to a real event. In a way, they are similar to wish-fulfillment: because someone thought they were about to die, they experienced certain things in accordance with what they expected or wanted to occur. Imagining a heavenly place was, in effect, a way for them to soothe themselves through the stress of knowing that they were close to death.[49]Subjects use their own personal and cultural expectations to imagine a scenario that would protect them against an imminent threat to their lives.[11]

However, subjects' accounts often differed from their own "religious and personal expectations regarding death", which contradicts the hypothesis they may have imagined a scenario based on their cultural and personal background.[11]

Although the term NDE was first coined in 1975 and the experience first described then, recent descriptions of NDEs do not differ from those reported earlier than 1975. The only exception is the more frequent description of a tunnel. Hence, the fact that information about these experiences could be more easily obtained after 1975 had not influenced people's reports of the experiences.[11]

Another flaw of this model can be found in children's accounts of NDEs. These are similar to adults', despite children being less strongly affected by religious and cultural influences about death.[11]

Dissociation model

edit

The dissociation model proposes that NDE is a form of withdrawal to protect an individual from a stressful event. Under extreme circumstances, some people may detach from certain unwanted feelings in order to avoid experiencing the emotional impact and suffering associated with them. The person also detaches from one's immediate surroundings.[49]

Birth model

edit

The birth model suggests that near-death experiences could be a form of reliving the trauma of birth. Since a baby travels from the darkness of the womb to light and is greeted by the love and warmth of the nursing and medical staff, and so, it was proposed, the dying brain could be recreating the passage through a tunnel to light, warmth and affection.[49]

Reports of leaving the body through a tunnel are equally frequent among subjects who were born by cesarean section and natural birth. Also, newborns do not possess "the visual acuity, spatial stability of their visual images, mental alertness, and cortical coding capacity to register memories of the birth experience".[11]

Physiological models

edit

A wide range of physiological theories of the NDE have been put forward, including those based uponcerebral hypoxia,anoxia,andhypercapnia;endorphinsand otherneurotransmitters;and abnormal activity in thetemporal lobes.[49]

Neurobiologicalfactors in the experience have been investigated by researchers in the field of medical science and psychiatry.[67]Among the researchers and commentators who tend to emphasize a naturalistic and neurological base for the experience is theBritishpsychologistSusan Blackmore(1993), with her "dying brain hypothesis".[68]

Neuroanatomical models

edit

According to Greyson,[11]multiple neuroanatomical models have been proposed, wherein NDEs have been hypothesized to originate from different anatomical areas of the brain, namely: thelimbic system,thehippocampus,the lefttemporal lobe,Reissner's fiberin the central canal of the spinal cord, theprefrontal cortex,and the right temporal lobe.

NeuroscientistsOlaf Blankeand Sebastian Dieguez (2009),[69]from theEcole Polytechnique Fédérale de Lausanne,Switzerland,propose a brain-based model with two types of NDEs:

  • "type 1 NDEs are due to bilateralfrontalandoccipital,but predominantly right hemispheric brain damage affecting the righttemporal-parietal junctionand characterized by out-of-body-experiences, altered sense of time, sensations of flying, lightnessvectionand flying "[4]
  • "type 2 NDEs are also due to bilateral frontal and occipital, but predominantly left hemispheric brain damage affecting the left temporal parietal junction and characterized by feeling of a presence, meeting and communication with spirits, seeing of glowing bodies, as well as voices, sounds, and music without vection"[4]
Animation of the human left temporal lobe

They suggest that damage to the bilateral occipital cortex may lead to visual features of NDEs such as seeing a tunnel or lights, and "damage to unilateral or bilateral temporal lobe structures such as the hippocampus andamygdala"may lead to emotional experiences, memory flashbacks or a life review. They concluded that future neuroscientific studies are likely to reveal the neuroanatomical basis of the NDE, which will lead to the demystification of the subject without needing paranormal explanations.[4]

French has written that the "temporal lobe is almost certain to be involved in NDEs, given that both damage to and directcorticalstimulation of this area are known to produce a number of experiences corresponding to those of the NDE, including OBEs, hallucinations, and memory flashbacks ".[49]

Vanhaudenhuyseet al.(2009) reported that recent studies employingdeep brain stimulationandneuroimaginghave demonstrated that out-of-body experiences can result from a deficientmultisensory integrationat the temporal-parietal junction and that ongoing studies aim to further identify the functional neuroanatomy of near-death experiences by means of standardized EEG recordings.[70]

Criticism
edit

Blanke et al.[4]admit that their model remains speculative due to the lack of data. In addition, the reports of those who had the brain stimulation were almost nothing like OBEs reported by those who had NDEs, mainly characterized by a sense of elevation and (often limited) spatial awareness, while other characteristics of NDEs were absent. Anomalies such as seeing maps, half-bodies and duplications were also noted.[71][72]

Likewise, Greyson[11]writes that although some, or any of the proposed neuroanatomical models may serve to explain NDEs and pathways through which they are expressed, they remain speculative at this stage, since they have not been tested in empirical studies.[11]

Neurochemical models

edit

Some theories explain reported NDE experiences as resulting from drugs used duringresuscitation(in the case of resuscitation-induced NDEs) ─ for example,ketamine─ or fromendogenouschemicals (neurotransmitters) that transmit signals between brain cells:[49]

  • In the early 1980s, Daniel Carr wrote that the NDE has characteristics that are suggestive of alimbic lobesyndrome and that the NDE can be explained by the release ofendorphinsandenkephalinsin the brain.[73][74]Endorphins are endogenous molecules "released in times of stress and lead to a reduction in pain perception and a pleasant, even blissful, emotional state."[49]
  • Judson and Wiltshaw (1983) noted how the administration of endorphin-blocking agents such asnaloxonehad been occasionally reported to produce "hellish" NDEs.[75]This would be coherent with endorphins' role in causing a "positive emotional tone of most NDEs".[49]
  • Morseet al.(1989) proposed a model arguing thatserotoninplayed a more important role than endorphins in generating NDEs,[76]"at least with respect to mystical hallucinations and OBEs".[49]
  • A 2019 large-scale study found thatketamine,Salvia divinorum,andDMT(and other classicalpsychedelic substances) are linked to near-death experiences.[77]
  • While ketamine, and other endogenous chemicals can be a source for NDE. It can also mimic these NDE and simulate thatout of body experienceslinked to NDE.[78]
Criticism
edit

According to Parnia, neurochemical models are not backed by data. This is true for "NMDA receptoractivation,serotonin,and endorphin release "models.[50]Parnia writes that no data has been collected via thorough and careful experimentation to back "a possible causal relationship or even an association" between neurochemical agents and NDE experiences.[60]

Multi-factorial models

edit

The first formal neurobiological model for NDEs in 1989 included endorphins, neurotransmitters of thelimbic system,the temporal lobe and other parts of the brain.[79]Extensions and variations of their model came from other scientists such as Louis Appleby (1989).[80]

Other authors suggest that all components of near-death experiences can be explained in their entirety via psychological or neurophysiological mechanisms, although the authors admit that these hypotheses have to be tested by science.[81]

Low oxygen levels (and G-LOC) model

edit

Low oxygen levels in the blood (hypoxia or anoxia) have been hypothesized to induce hallucinations and hence possibly explain NDEs.[18][49]This is because low oxygen levels characterize life-threatening situations and also the apparent similarities between NDEs and G-force-induced loss of consciousness (G-LOC) episodes.

These episodes are observed with fighter pilots experiencing very rapid and intense acceleration that results in lack of sufficient blood supply to the brain. Whinnery[82]studied almost 1000 cases and noted how the experiences often involved "tunnel vision and bright lights, floating sensations, automatic movement, autoscopy, OBEs, not wanting to be disturbed, paralysis, vivid dreamlets of beautiful places, pleasurable sensations, psychological alterations of euphoria and dissociation, inclusion of friends and family, inclusion of prior memories and thoughts, the experience being very memorable (when it can be remembered),confabulation,and a strong urge to understand the experience. "[49][82]

However, acceleration-induced hypoxia's primary characteristics are "rhythmic jerking of the limbs, compromised memory of events just prior to the onset of unconsciousness, tingling of extremities..." that are not observed during NDEs.[18]Also, G-LOC episodes do not feature life reviews, mystical experiences and "long-lasting transformational aftereffects", although this may be due to the fact that subjects have no expectation of dying.[49]

Also, hypoxic hallucinations are characterized by "distress and agitation" and this is very different from near-death experiences, which subjects usually report as being pleasant.[11]

Altered blood gas levels models

edit

Some investigators have studied whetherhypercarbiaor higher than normal carbon dioxide levels, could explain the occurrence of NDEs. However, studies are difficult to interpret since NDEs have been observed both with increased levels as well as decreased levels of carbon dioxide, and other studies have observed NDEs when levels had not changed, but there is insufficient data on these factors.[18]

Other models

edit

French said that at least some reports of NDEs might be based uponfalse memories.[83]

According to Engmann (2008), near-death experiences of people who areclinically deadare psychopathological symptoms caused by a severe malfunction of the brain resulting from the cessation of cerebral blood circulation.[84]An important question is whether it is possible to "translate" the bloomy experiences of the reanimated survivors into psychopathologically basic phenomena, e.g., acoasms (nonverbal auditory hallucinations), central narrowing of the visual field, autoscopia, visual hallucinations, activation of limbic and memory structures (according to Moody's stages). The symptoms suppose a primary affliction of the occipital and temporal cortices under clinical death. This basis could be congruent with the thesis ofpathoclisis– the inclination of special parts of the brain to be the first to be damaged in case of disease, lack of oxygen, or malnutrition – established in 1922 byCécile Vogt-MugnierandOskar Vogt.[85]

Professor of neurologyTerence Hines(2003) claimed that near-death experiences are hallucinations caused by cerebral anoxia, drugs, or brain damage.[86]

Greyson has called into question the adequacy of the materialist, mind-brain identity model for explaining NDEs.[31]An NDE often involves vivid and complex mentation, sensation and memory-formation under circumstances of completely disabled brain function during general anesthesia, or near-complete cessation of cerebral blood flow and oxygen uptake during cardiac arrest. Materialist models predict that such conscious experiences should be impossible under these conditions. The mind-brain identity model of classic materialist psychology may need to be expanded to adequately explain an NDE.

See also

edit

References

edit
  1. ^abBush NE, Greyson B (November–December 2014)."Distressing Near-Death Experiences: The Basics".Mo Med.111(6): 486–90.PMC6173534.PMID25665233.
  2. ^abSleutjes, A; Moreira-Almeida, A; Greyson, B (2014). "Almost 40 years investigating near-death experiences: an overview of mainstream scientific journals".J. Nerv. Ment. Dis.202(11): 833–6.doi:10.1097/NMD.0000000000000205.PMID25357254.S2CID16765929.
  3. ^French, Kristen (2022-09-28)."The Afterlife Is in Our Heads".Nautilus.Retrieved2022-12-12.
  4. ^abcdeBlanke, Olaf (2009).The Neurology of Consciousness.London: London: Academic Publishers, 2009. pp. 303–324.ISBN978-0-12-374168-4.
  5. ^Griffith, LJ (2009)."Near-death experiences and psychotherapy".Psychiatry (Edgmont).6(10): 35–42.PMC2790400.PMID20011577.
  6. ^abcdefghijkMauro, James. "Bright lights, big mystery",Psychology Today,July 1992.
  7. ^Vanhaudenhuyse, A.; Thonnard, M.; Laureys, S. (2009)."Towards a Neuro-scientific Explanation of Near-death Experiences?"(PDF).In Vincent, Jean-Louis (ed.).Yearbook of Intensive Care and Emergency Medicine.Berlin, Heidelberg: Springer Berlin Heidelberg.ISBN978-3-540-92276-6.
  8. ^Koch, Christof (June 1, 2020)."What Near-Death Experiences Reveal about the Brain".Scientific American.Retrieved2020-05-20.
  9. ^Egger, Victor (1896). "Le moi des mourants",Revue Philosophique,XLI: 26–38.
  10. ^J. Bogousslavsky, M. G. Hennerici, H Bazner, C. Bassetti (Eds.) (2010).Neurological Disorders in Famous Artists, Part 3.Karger Publishers. p. 189.ISBN9783805593304.{{cite book}}:CS1 maint: multiple names: authors list (link)
  11. ^abcdefghijklmnopqrGreyson, Bruce (2014). "Chapter 12: Near-Death Experiences". In Cardeña, Etzel; Lynn, Steven Jay; Krippner, Stanley (eds.).Varieties of anomalous experience: examining the scientific evidence(Second ed.). Washington, D.C.: American Psychological Association. pp. 333–367.ISBN978-1-4338-1529-4.
  12. ^Green, C.,Out-of-the-body Experiences,London: Hamish Hamilton, 1968.
  13. ^Broom, Sara (30 August 2004)."Milestones - TIME".Archived fromthe originalon 2009-02-24.Retrieved2023-08-15.
  14. ^Schlieter, Jens (2018). What is it like to be Dead? Near-death Experiences, Christianity, and the Occult. New York: Oxford University Press, pp. 205-6.
  15. ^Pim van Lommel (2010).Consciousness Beyond Life: The science of the near-death experience.HarperOne.ISBN978-0-06-177725-7.
  16. ^Evelyn Elsaesser Valarino (1997).On the Other Side of Life: Exploring the phenomenon of the near-death experience.Perseus Publishing. p. 203.ISBN978-0-7382-0625-7.
  17. ^Greyson, Bruce (2003). "Near-Death Experiences in a Psychiatric Outpatient Clinic Population".Psychiatric Services.54(12): 1649–1651.doi:10.1176/appi.ps.54.12.1649.PMID14645808.
  18. ^abcdeHolden, Janice Miner; Greyson, Bruce; James, Debbie, eds. (2009).The handbook of near-death experiences thirty years of investigation.Westport, Conn.: Praeger Publishers.ISBN978-0-313-35865-4.
  19. ^Kennard, Mary J (1998). "A Visit from an Angel".The American Journal of Nursing.98(3): 48–51.doi:10.1097/00000446-199803000-00041.PMID9536180.
  20. ^Long, Jeffrey (2016-06-29)."Opinion | Stories of God's love common among those who almost die, says doctor who studies them".Washington Post.ISSN0190-8286.Retrieved2018-03-27.
  21. ^Newman, Tim (April 27, 2016)."Near-death experiences: Fact or fantasy?".MedicalNewsToday.
  22. ^abcdeMorse, M; Conner, D; Tyler, D (June 1985). "Near-death experiences in a pediatric population. A preliminary report".Am. J. Dis. Child.139(6): 595–600.doi:10.1001/archpedi.1985.02140080065034.PMID4003364.
  23. ^Lovins, LaDonna (April 25, 2015)."Three Beings of Light".iands.org.Retrieved2018-03-30.
  24. ^Moody, Raymond (1975).Life After Life.Mockingbird Books.ISBN978-0-89176-037-5.
  25. ^abcHagan III, John C. (November 18, 2018)."The Near-Death Experience: Diagnosis and Treatment Of a Common Medical Syndrome".Clinical Oncology News.
  26. ^Ring, K. (1980). Life at death: A scientific investigation of the near-death experience. New York: Coward, McCann, & Geoghegan., p. 40
  27. ^Hagan III, John C. (November 12, 2018)."The Near-Death Experience: Diagnosis and Treatment Of a Common Medical Syndrome".Clinical Oncology News.
  28. ^"What happens when you die? Scientists attempt to find out how similar near-death experiences really are".Newsweek.2017-07-27. Archived fromthe originalon 2019-12-22.Retrieved2018-09-26.
  29. ^Kason, Yvonne (2019).Touched by the Light: Exploring Spiritually Transformative Experiences.Toronto, Canada: Dundurn Press. pp. 75–101.ISBN9781459745513.
  30. ^Ring, Kenneth.Heading toward Omega. In search of the Meaning of Near-Death Experience,1984, p. 45. "Subsequent research on suicide-related NDEs by Stephen Franklin and myself [Ring] and by Bruce Greyson has also confirmed my earlier tentative findings the NDEs following suicide attempts, however induced, conform to the classic prototype."
  31. ^abGreyson, Bruce (2010). "Implications of near-death experiences for a postmaterialist psychology".Psychology of Religion and Spirituality.2(1): 37–45.doi:10.1037/a0018548.
  32. ^abcGreyson, Bruce (1983)."The Near-Death Experience Scale Construction, Reliability, and Validity"(PDF).The Journal of Nervous and Mental Disease.171(6): 369–375.doi:10.1097/00005053-198306000-00007.PMID6854303.
  33. ^Khanna, Surbhi; Greyson, Bruce (2014)."Near-Death Experiences and Spiritual Well-Being".Journal of Religion and Health.53(6): 1605–1615.doi:10.1007/s10943-013-9723-0.JSTOR24485267.PMID23625172.S2CID8578903.Retrieved2022-05-12.Scores on the NDE Scale can range from 0 to 32; the mean score of NDErs is 15; and a score of 7, one standard deviation below the mean, is generally used as a criterion for considering an experience to be an NDE (Greyson 1983). For the purpose of this study, we categorized NDEs by "depth," with NDE Scale scores less than one standard deviation below the mean considered "subtle," those less than one standard deviation above the mean considered "deep," and those greater than 1 standard deviation above the mean considered "profound."
  34. ^"About Jeff & Jody".Near-Death Experience Research Foundation.
  35. ^abcdLong, Jeffrey (2014)."Near-Death Experiences Evidence for Their Reality".Missouri Medicine.111(5): 372–380.PMC6172100.PMID25438351.
  36. ^Mendoza, Marilyn A. (March 12, 2018)."Aftereffects of the Near Death Experience".Psychology Today.
  37. ^Bendix, Aria (19 March 2022)."People describe near-death experiences in an eerily similar way. They've convinced some researchers that an afterlife exists".Business Insider.Retrieved2022-08-15.
  38. ^Orne, RM (June 1995). "The meaning of survival: the early aftermath of a near-death experience".Res Nurs Health.18(3): 239–47.doi:10.1002/nur.4770180307.PMID7754094.
  39. ^Greyson, B (May 1997). "The near-death experience as a focus of clinical attention".J. Nerv. Ment. Dis.185(5): 327–34.doi:10.1097/00005053-199705000-00007.PMID9171810.
  40. ^abcdefgHolden, Janice Miner; Greyson, Bruce; James, Debbie, eds. (Jun 22, 2009)."The Field of Near-Death Studies: Past, Present and Future".The Handbook of Near-Death Experiences: Thirty Years of Investigation.Greenwood Publishing Group. pp. 1–16.ISBN978-0-313-35864-7.
  41. ^abGholipour, Bahar (July 24, 2014)."Oldest Medical Report of Near-Death Experience Discovered".Live Science.RetrievedOctober 16,2018.
  42. ^Top, Brent L. (2019)."The Near-Death Experience | Religious Studies Center".rsc.byu.edu.
  43. ^Orlando, Alex (Aug 23, 2021)."Can Science Explain Near Death Experiences?".Discover Magazine.Retrieved2022-03-10.
  44. ^Zingrone, N L (2009). "Pleasurable Western adult near-death experiences: Features, circumstances, and incidence". In Holden, J M; Greyson, B; James, D (eds.).The Handbook of Near-Death Experiences: Thirty Years of Investigation(2009 ed.). Santa Barbara, California: Praeger-ABC-CLIO. pp. 17–40.ISBN978-0313358647.
  45. ^Morse M, Castillo P, Venecia D, Milstein J, Tyler DC. (1986) "Childhood near-death experiences".American Journal of Diseases of Children,Nov;140(11):1110–4.
  46. ^Singhji, Sant Rajinder (1 December 2018)."Mystic Mantra: Our soul is immortal".The Deccan Chronicle.Retrieved17 December2021.
  47. ^abXu, Gang; Mihaylova, Temenuzhka; Li, Duan; Tian, Fangyun; Farrehi, Peter M.; Parent, Jack M.; Mashour, George A.; Wang, Michael M.; Borjigin, Jimo (1 May 2023)."Surge of neurophysiological coupling and connectivity of gamma oscillations in the dying human brain".Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences.120(19): e2216268120.Bibcode:2023PNAS..12016268X.doi:10.1073/pnas.2216268120.ISSN0027-8424.PMC10175832.PMID37126719.This article incorporates text from this source, which is available under theCC BY 4.0license.
  48. ^Parnia, S.; Waller, D. G.; Yeates, R.; Fenwick, P. (2001-02-01). "A qualitative and quantitative study of the incidence, features and aetiology of near death experiences in cardiac arrest survivors".Resuscitation.48(2): 149–156.doi:10.1016/s0300-9572(00)00328-2.PMID11426476.
  49. ^abcdefghijklmnopqrsFrench, Christopher C. (2005-01-01). "Near-death experiences in cardiac arrest survivors".The Boundaries of Consciousness: Neurobiology and Neuropathology.Progress in Brain Research. Vol. 150. pp. 351–367.doi:10.1016/S0079-6123(05)50025-6.ISBN9780444518514.PMID16186035.
  50. ^abcdeParnia, Sam (2014-11-01). "Death and consciousness--an overview of the mental and cognitive experience of death".Annals of the New York Academy of Sciences.1330(1): 75–93.Bibcode:2014NYASA1330...75P.doi:10.1111/nyas.12582.PMID25418460.S2CID33091589.
  51. ^van Lommel, P; van Wees, R; Meyers, V; Elfferich, I (15 December 2001). "Near-death experience in survivors of cardiac arrest: a prospective study in the Netherlands".Lancet.358(9298): 2039–45.doi:10.1016/S0140-6736(01)07100-8.PMID11755611.S2CID29766030.
  52. ^Parnia, Sam; Spearpoint, Ken; de Vos, Gabriele; Fenwick, Peter; Goldberg, Diana; Yang, Jie; Zhu, Jiawen; Baker, Katie; Killingback, Hayley (2014-12-01). "AWARE-AWAreness during REsuscitation-a prospective study".Resuscitation.85(12): 1799–1805.doi:10.1016/j.resuscitation.2014.09.004.PMID25301715.
  53. ^Lichfield, Gideon (April 2015)."The science of near-death experiences: Empirically investigating brushes with the afterlife".The Atlantic.Retrieved10 October2016.
  54. ^Weintraub, Pamela (September 2014)."Seeing the light".Psychology Today.Retrieved10 October2016.
  55. ^UK Clinical Trials Gateway.Primary Trial ID Number 17129,entitled "AWARE II (AWAreness during REsuscitation) A Multi-Centre Observational Study of the Relationship between the Quality of Brain Resuscitation and Consciousness, Neurological, Functional and Cognitive Outcomes following Cardiac Arrest" Last updated May 3, 2016. Page archived May 9, 2016
  56. ^"AWARE NDE Study | Psi Encyclopedia".
  57. ^Parnia, Sam; Keshavarz, Tara; McMullin, Meghan; Williams, Tori (2019-11-19)."Abstract 387: Awareness and Cognitive Activity During Cardiac Arrest".Circulation.140(Suppl_2).doi:10.1161/circ.140.suppl_2.387.ISSN0009-7322.S2CID212935146.
  58. ^Van Gordon, William; Shonin, Edo; Dunn, Thomas J.; Sheffield, David; Garcia-Campayo, Javier; Griffiths, Mark D. (2018-12-01)."Meditation-Induced Near-Death Experiences: a 3-Year Longitudinal Study".Mindfulness.9(6): 1794–1806.doi:10.1007/s12671-018-0922-3.ISSN1868-8535.PMC6244634.PMID30524512.
  59. ^Bstan-ʼdzin-rgya-mtsho, Dalai Lama XIV (c. 2006).The universe in a single atom: the convergence of science and spirituality.Broadway Books.ISBN9780767920810.OCLC188546206.
  60. ^abParnia, Sam (February 2017)."Understanding the cognitive experience of death and the near-death experience".QJM: An International Journal of Medicine.110(2): 67–69.doi:10.1093/qjmed/hcw185.PMID28100825.
  61. ^Frazier, Kendrick (1981).Paranormal Borderlands of Science.Buffalo, N.Y.: Prometheus Books. pp. 153–169.ISBN978-0-87975-148-7.
  62. ^French, Chris.(2009).Near-Death Experiences and the Brain.In Craig Murray.Psychological Scientific Perspectives on Out-of-Body and Near-Death Experiences.Nova Science Publishers. pp. 187–203.ISBN978-1-60741-705-7
  63. ^Noyes, R (1972). "The experience of dying".Psychiatry.35(2): 174–184.doi:10.1080/00332747.1972.11023710.PMID5024906.
  64. ^Noyes, R.; Kletti, R. (1976). "Depersonalisation in the face of life-threatening danger: an interpretation".Omega.7(2): 103–114.doi:10.2190/7qet-2vau-ycdt-tj9r.S2CID144273683.
  65. ^Noyes, R.; Kletti, R. (1977). "Depersonalisation in the face of life-threatening danger".Compr. Psychiatry.18(4): 375–384.doi:10.1016/0010-440X(77)90010-4.PMID872561.
  66. ^Noyes, R. and Slymen, D. (1978–1979)The subjective response to life-threatening danger.Omega9: 313–321.
  67. ^Mayank and Mukesh, 2004; Jansen, 1995; Thomas, 2004; Fenwick and Fenwick 2008
  68. ^Bassham, Gregory (2005).Critical Thinking: A Student's Untroduction(2nd ed.). Boston: McGraw-Hill. p. 485.ISBN978-0-07-287959-9.
  69. ^Leaving Body And Life Behind:lnco.epfl.chArchived2014-02-07 at theWayback Machine
  70. ^Vincent, Jean-Louis (2009). "Towards a Neuro-scientific Explanation of Near-death Experiences?".Yearbook of Intensive Care and Emergency Medicine.[S.l.]: Springer New York. pp. 961–968.CiteSeerX10.1.1.368.4580.doi:10.1007/978-3-540-92276-6_85.ISBN978-0-387-92277-5.
  71. ^Blanke O, Ortigue S, Landis T, Seeck M. Stimulating illusory own‐body perceptions. Nature2002; 419: 269–70.
  72. ^Out‐of‐body experience and autoscopy of neurological origin.Brain,Volume 127, Issue 2, February 2004, Pages 243–258, Olaf Blanke, Theodor Landis, Laurent Spinelli, Margitta Seeck.
  73. ^Carr, Daniel (1981). "Endorphins at the Approach of Death".Lancet.317(8216): 390.doi:10.1016/s0140-6736(81)91714-1.S2CID45806328.
  74. ^Carr, Daniel (1982). "Pathophysiology of Stress-Induced Limbic Lobe Dysfunction: A Hypothesis Relevant to Near-Death Experiences".Anabiosis: The Journal of Near-Death Studies.2:75–89.
  75. ^Judson, I. R; Wiltshaw, E. (1983). "A near-death experience".Lancet.322(8349): 561–562.doi:10.1016/s0140-6736(83)90582-2.PMID6136705.S2CID13016282.
  76. ^Morse, M. L; Venecia, D; Milstein, J. (1989). "Near-death experiences: A neurophysiological explanatory model".Journal of Near-Death Studies.8:45–53.doi:10.1007/BF01076138.S2CID18026980.
  77. ^Martial, C; Cassol, H; Charland-Verville, V; Pallavicini, C; Sanz, C; Zamberlan, F; Vivot, RM; Erowid, F; Erowid, E; Laureys, S; Greyson, B; Tagliazucchi, E (March 2019). "Neurochemical models of near-death experiences: A large-scale study based on the semantic similarity of written reports".Consciousness and Cognition.69:52–69.doi:10.1016/j.concog.2019.01.011.hdl:2268/231971.PMID30711788.S2CID73432875.
  78. ^Drinkwater, Ken; Dagnall, Neil (2018-12-04)."Are near-death experiences hallucinations? Experts explain the science behind this puzzling phenomenon".The Conversation.Retrieved2024-09-09.
  79. ^Saavedra-Aguilar, J.C.; Gómez-Jeria, Juan S. (1989)."A Neurobiological Model for Near-Death Experiences"(PDF).Journal of Near-Death Studies.7(4): 205–222.doi:10.1007/bf01074007.S2CID189940970.Retrieved14 August2020.
  80. ^Appleby, L (1989)."Near·death experience: Analogous to other stress induced psychological phenomena".British Medical Journal.298(6679): 976–977.doi:10.1136/bmj.298.6679.976.PMC1836313.PMID2499387.
  81. ^Mobbs, Dean; Watt, Caroline (October 2011)."There is nothing paranormal about near-death experiences: how neuroscience can explain seeing bright lights, meeting the dead, or being convinced you are one of them"(PDF).Trends in Cognitive Sciences.15(10): 447–449.doi:10.1016/j.tics.2011.07.010.hdl:20.500.11820/18d7f026-76f4-4d99-8f39-8b6ac51b6069.PMID21852181.S2CID6080825.
  82. ^abWhinnery, J. E. (1997). "Psychophysiologic correlates of unconsciousness and near-death experiences".J. Near-Death Stud.15:231–258.
  83. ^French, Chris(2001). "Dying to Know the Truth: Visions of a Dying Brain, or False Memories?".Lancet.358(9298): 2010–2011.doi:10.1016/s0140-6736(01)07133-1.PMID11755600.S2CID33004716.
  84. ^Engmann, B (December 2008). "[Near-death experiences: a review of the thesis of pathoclisis, neurotransmitter abnormalities, and psychological aspects]".MMW Fortschr Med.150(51–52): 42–3.doi:10.1007/BF03365763.PMID19156957.S2CID79259801.
  85. ^Vogt C, Vogt O. (1922).Erkrankungen der Großhirnrinde im Lichte der Topistik, Pathoklise und Pathoarchitektonik.Journal für Psychologie und Neurologie; Bd. 28. Joh.- Ambr.- Barth- Verlag. Leipzig. (German).
  86. ^Hines, Terence (2002).Pseudoscience and the Paranormal(2nd ed.). Amherst, N.Y.: Prometheus Books. pp. 101–104.ISBN978-1-57392-979-0.

Further reading

edit
edit
Wikimedia Commons has media related toNear-death experiences.
Retrieved from "https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Near-death_experience&oldid=1255089122"