Wikipedia

Venmo

Venmois an Americanmobile paymentservice founded in 2009 and owned byPayPalsince 2013. Venmo is aimed at users who wish to split their bills. Account holders can transfer funds to others via a mobile phone app; both the sender and receiver must live in the United States. Venmo also operates as a small social network, as users can observe other users' public transactions with posts and emoticons.[1]In 2021, the company handled $230 billion in transactions and generated $850 million in revenue.[2]Users can view transactions on the Venmo website but cannot complete transactions on the website.[3]

Venmo
Original author(s)
  • Andrew Kortina
  • Iqram Magdon-Ismail
Developer(s)Venmo, LLC (subsidiary ofPayPal)
Initial release2009;15 years ago(2009)
Operating systemAndroid,iOS
Available inEnglish
Websitevenmo.com

By default, Venmo publishes every peer-to-peer transaction (excluding the amount), a feature shown by researchers to reveal sensitive details about users' lives in some situations.[4][5]In 2018, the company settled with theFederal Trade Commission(FTC) about several privacy and security violations related to this and other features, and made changes to the corresponding settings. However, Venmo continued to attract criticism for exposing users to possible privacy risks.[5][4]

History

edit
Venmo quarterly US payment volume and annual growth

Venmo was founded by Andrew Kortina and Iqram Magdon-Ismail, who met as freshman roommates at theUniversity of Pennsylvania.According to Kortina, the duo were initially inspired to create a transaction solution while, in the process of helping start a friend's yogurt shop, they "realized how horrible traditionalpoint of salessoftware was ". At a local jazz show, Kortina and Magdon-Ismail conceived the idea of instantly buying anMP3 of the showviatext message.Finally, the idea was cemented when Magdon-Ismail forgot his wallet during a trip to visit Kortina. The process of settling their debt was a considerable inconvenience, especially compared to the possibility of mobile phone-based transactions. Shortly after, they began working on a way to send money through mobile phones.[6]Their original prototype sent money through text messages, but they eventually transitioned from text messages to a smartphone app.[7]In fact, according to Kortina, the name Venmo came from the wordvendere,Latin for “to sell,” and “Mo,” short for “mobile”; they wanted a name that was snappy and could be spelled easily.[8]

In May 2010, the company raised $1.2 million ofseed moneyin a financing round led byRRE Ventures.[9]

In 2012, the company was acquired byBraintreefor $26.2 million.[10][11][12]

In December 2013,PayPalacquired Braintree for $800 million.[13][7][14]

Prior to October 2015, Venmo prohibitedconsumer-to-businesstransactions on the platform.[citation needed]

On January 27, 2016, PayPal announced that Venmo was working with select merchants who would accept Venmo as payment. Initial launch partners includedMuncheryandGametime.[15]All merchants that accept PayPal can now accept Venmo.[16]As of May 2018, Venmo's merchant product did not permit "selling goods or services in person";[17]however, research into mobile payment trends among mom-and-pop restaurants inNew York Citythat month revealed a grey market use case in which some Chinese takeouts and food trucks used personal VenmoQR codesto accept payments from customers. This QR payment behavior was similar to that used via Chinese mobile applicationsWeChatandAlipaywithin these same establishments.[18]

In October 2020, PayPal announced that Venmo along with PayPal services will allow users to purchase and usecryptocurrenciessuch asbitcoin,Bitcoin Cash,Ethereum,andLitecoinin select foreign markets starting in the first half of 2021.[19][20]

On April 20, 2021, Venmo announced that it was beginning its roll out for the ability to buy, hold, and sell cryptocurrencies using the platform.[21]However, only selected users had access to the feature, and it was estimated that the cryptocurrency transfers would become available for the whole userbase only in May 2021.[22]

Products

edit

Users can create an account via amobile apporwebsiteand provide basic information and bank account information. One must have a valid email address and a US mobile phone number to use Venmo. Recipients of transactions can be found via phone number, Venmo username, or email.

Users have a Venmo balance that is used for their transactions. They can link theirbank accounts,debit cards,orcredit cards,to their Venmo account; alternatively users can order a Venmo MasterCard and pay through it.[23]Paying with a bank account or debit card is free, but payments via credit card have a 3% fee for each transaction.[24]Some credit card providers may charge cash advance fees for Venmo payments.[25]If a user does not have enough funds in the account when making a transaction, it will automatically withdraw the necessary funds from the registered bank account or card.

When users first create an account, total transactions may not exceed $299.99 until the user's identity is verified.[26]After the identity has been verified, users may send up to $2,999.99 in each seven day period.[27]

Since 2008, cash transfers using Venmo have not beeninstantaneousand could be canceled after an initial transfer is sent. Like traditionalwire transfers,they can take one to three business days to become final.

In January 2018,[28]PayPal rolled out aninstant transferfeature on Venmo, allowing users to deposit funds to their debit cards typically within 30 minutes. A fee is deducted from the amount for each transfer; 1% or $10, whichever is less. The standard bank transfer (typically completed within three business days) is available for no fee.[29]

Venmo MasterCard

edit

In 2018, Venmo released a new physical debit card available for users.[30]The card runs on theMasterCardnetwork and offersATMaccess and overdraft protection. It can be used anywhere that accepts MasterCard, and it enables up to $400 in daily ATM withdrawals, though transactions at non-MoneyPassATMs come with at least $2.50 in withdrawal fees.[23]

In addition, the service offers a reload function, which, when enabled, takes money from a user's linked checking account in $10 increments if their Venmo balance drops too low to cover a purchase. Customers could be subject to fees or other consequences from their bank if they overdraft that account.[23]Card purchases show up in a user's Venmo transaction history, and the card can be canceled from within the app.[31]These features make the card similar to a traditional bank debit card, but adds the ability to directly track spending in-app.[23]

Social component and privacy

edit
Social feed of transactions on Venmo[32]

Venmo includessocial networkinginteraction; it was created so friends could quickly split bills, such as for movies, dinner, rent, or tickets. When a user makes a payment, the transaction details (excluding the payment amount) can be "shared", either publicly or with the user's network of friends, on the user's "news feed", like a social media feed.[33]

Venmo publishes a "world wide" public feed, a "friends only" feed, and a personal feed. By default, all Venmo transactions are shared publicly. Anyone who opens the app to the public feed, including those who do not use Venmo, can see these publicly shared transactions.[34]The user can make transactions private, but most users keep the default privacy settings.[35]Venmo encourages social interaction on the application through comments[36]using jokes,emojis,or likes.

Early on, Venmo required new users to sign up throughFacebook,which made it easy to find peers the user wanted to pay and provided Venmo with free marketing.[37]For users not friends on Facebook, the application allowed searching by username and phone number. Profiles are personalized with profile pictures, usernames, and Venmo transaction history. Venmo provides no protection for buyer or seller.[38]

On November 14, 2023, Venmo introduced a feature called Venmo Groups which implemented bill-splitting within the app,[39]competing with related expense-sharing apps such asSplitwise.[40][clarification needed:The beginning of this section said that splitting bills was the original purpose of Venmo. Why was this feature not introduced until 2024?]

Security

edit

Venmo has claimed that its security is "bank-grade".[41]However, journalists, security researchers, theCalifornia Department of Business Oversight(DBO) and theFederal Trade Commissionhave all disputed this claim.[42][43][44][45][46]

In February 2018, the FTC settled with Venmo, after an investigation uncovered false representations about "bank-grade" security and failures to comply with theGramm-Leach-BlileySafeguards Rule and Privacy Rule.[47][48]Under the settlement, Venmo would be required to undergo third-party audits every two years for the following ten years. The FTC also complained that Venmo "misled consumers about the extent to which they could control the privacy of their transactions" and misrepresented the availability of funds for withdrawal.[49]

Venmo states that customers need not worry about their security or privacy, and encourages users to set up aPINto increase security.[50]On July 17, 2018,The Guardian[51]published an article showing that Venmo is insecure because privacy protection is not set by default. According to the researcher who found this privacy issue, Venmo publishes all transactions along with names openly into theWorld Wide Web.

TheBetter Business Bureauhas reported that somescammersexploit the cancellation period to appear to pay, but ultimately avoid paying for an item.[52]

In November 2018,The Wall Street Journalreported that Venmo, in the first quarter of 2018, had suffered $40 million in operating losses, nearly 40% more than it had budgeted, due to "a wave of payments fraud".[53]

Criticism and controversies

edit

Privacy concerns

edit

A 2018 study analyzed over 200 million public transactions and found that Venmo "reveals a massive amount of private details about users' lives by default".[5]The same year, the company reached a settlement with the FTC after the FTC had accused Venmo of "misleading" users about the privacy settings changes required to make transactions completely private.[5]In 2019, another researcher downloaded and analyzed seven million transactions, concluding that although Venmo had made some very minor to no improvements limiting mass-scraping, the data still put users at risk for various forms ofcyber attacks.[54][4]

In 2019,Mozillaand theElectronic Frontier Foundationwrote an open letter "to express our deep concern about Venmo's disregard for the importance of user privacy, and to call on Venmo to make two critical changes to its privacy settings: make transactions private by default, and give users privacy settings for their friend lists".[4]

Venmo's social model has attracted attention from researchers. A research group from University of Washington observed[when?]that the social feed in Venmo differs from other social networks in that activity is driven by financial transactions. A user could make a trivial transaction to make a post (e.g., sending someone $0.01, or requesting $0.02), but only one participant in their studies reported ever doing this. Further, neither reading the feed nor sharing a transaction memo publicly or with friends is necessary to send or receive money.[citation needed]

On Venmo, people transact with both friends and businesses via the app. Analysis of public transactions identifies a spectrum of use patterns, from regular users who create transactions for a variety of expenses, to niche users who use Venmo with a small cluster of friends to pay for just a few things (e.g., bills among roommates).[55]

A May 2021 investigation byBuzzFeed Newsreportedly managed to find the Venmo account ofUnited States presidentJoe Bidenafter "less than 10 minutes of looking for it"; BuzzFeed News additionally states that the Venmo app "leaves everyone... in the world exposed" and states that it reveals a major privacy concern.[56][57][58][59]

In 2022, Dr. Rajat Tandon and Dr. Jelena Mirkovic from theUniversity of Southern California,along with their research collaborators, showcased that 2 in 5 Venmo users publicly reveal sensitive information. Their work, "I know what you did on Venmo: Discovering privacy leaks in mobile social payments",[60]which presents multiple findings from 389 million public transaction Venmo notes, highlights serious risks from a public-by-default policy for mobile social payments.

Consumer Financial Protection Bureau probe

edit

Venmo came under scrutiny from theConsumer Financial Protection Bureauin 2021 over the company's treatment of their customers owing money for transactions.PayPal,the company operating Venmo's platform, announced through aregulatory filingin February that it had received acivil investigative demandfrom the CFPB "related to Venmo's unauthorized funds transfers and collections processes, and related matters." Venmo has a history of using aggressive tactics to threaten debt-owing users, ranging from seizing the funds from the user's other PayPal accounts to sendingdebt collectorsafter users. Customer service emails showed the company notifying users it could involve a collection agency over debts from $3,000 to as low as $7 in 2019, in some instances even when the customer in question had been scammed. Such practices continued during theCOVID-19 pandemic.[61][62][63]

References

edit
  1. ^Bommer, William H.; Rana, Shailesh; Milevoj, Emil (April 25, 2022)."A meta-analysis of eWallet adoption using the UTAUT model".International Journal of Bank Marketing.40(4): 791–819.doi:10.1108/IJBM-06-2021-0258.ISSN0265-2323.S2CID247427504.
  2. ^"Venmo Revenue and Usage Statistics (2022)".Business of Apps. May 4, 2022.RetrievedMay 27,2022.
  3. ^"What Is Venmo: How It Works".Money.RetrievedJanuary 24,2024.
  4. ^abcdCole, Samantha (August 28, 2019)."Venmo Is Still Exposing Your Connections to Everyone You. Know".Vice.RetrievedFebruary 12,2020.
  5. ^abcdPaul, Kari (July 22, 2018)."The scary reasons you should make your Venmo account private".MarketWatch.RetrievedFebruary 12,2020.
  6. ^Elgar, Tyler (October 2, 2017)."Venmo. The wallet of the future".Medium.
  7. ^abGillette, Felix (November 20, 2014)."Cash Is for Losers!".Bloomberg Businessweek.
  8. ^Hadi Attarbashi, Brian."Andrew Kortina: How An Accident Inspired a Mobile Payment App".AI Bees.
  9. ^Schonfeld, Erick (September 16, 2010)."Social Payment Startup Venmo Raised $1.2 Million And Has A New iPhone App".TechCrunch.
  10. ^"Braintree Acquires Mobile Payments Platform Venmo"(Press release).Business Wire.August 17, 2012.
  11. ^Wortham, Jenna (August 16, 2012)."Braintree, a Payments Company, Buys Venmo for $26.2 Million".The New York Times.
  12. ^Lardinois, Frederic (August 16, 2012)."Online Payments Service Braintree Acquires Venmo for $26.2M".TechCrunch.
  13. ^"eBay Inc. Completes Acquisition of Global Payments Innovator Braintree"(Press release). Business Wire. December 19, 2013.
  14. ^Rao, Leena; Perez, Sarah (September 26, 2013)."Ebay's Paypal Acquires Payment Gateway Braintree For $800M In Cash".TechCrunch.
  15. ^Rao, Leena (January 27, 2016)."You Can Now Use PayPal's Venmo to Pay Merchants".Fortune.
  16. ^Toplin, Jaime (May 1, 2017)."Venmo makes moves to monetize".Business Insider.
  17. ^"Payment Methods: Venmo".Braintree Support Articles.Archived fromthe originalon May 14, 2018.RetrievedMay 14,2018.
  18. ^Chester, Ken (May 10, 2018)."Can China's 'WeChat Diaspora' Pioneer Mobile Payment in the US?".Sixth Tone.RetrievedMay 14,2018.
  19. ^Irrera, Anna (October 21, 2020)."PayPal to allow cryptocurrency buying, selling and shopping on its network".Reuters.RetrievedNovember 2,2020.
  20. ^"PayPal and Venmo will offer and accept cryptocurrency for all online payments".The Verge.October 21, 2020.RetrievedNovember 2,2020.
  21. ^Perez, Sarah (April 20, 2021)."Venmo adds support for buying, holding and selling cryptocurrencies".TechCrunch.RetrievedApril 20,2021.
  22. ^Lyles, Taylor (April 20, 2021)."Venmo is adding support for users to buy, store, and sell cryptocurrency".The Verge.RetrievedApril 20,2021.
  23. ^abcd"PayPal's Venmo now offering physical credit cards aimed at millennials".ameinfo.com.July 2, 2018.RetrievedJuly 3,2018.
  24. ^"Pricing".Venmo.RetrievedJanuary 10,2022.
  25. ^"Fees & Venmo".Venmo.RetrievedJanuary 10,2022.
  26. ^Allan, Patrick (January 11, 2016)."Money Transfer Showdown: Square Cash vs. Venmo vs. PayPal".
  27. ^"Payment Limits".Venmo.September 6, 2023.
  28. ^Garun, Natt (January 26, 2018)."Venmo can now instantly transfer money to your debit card for 25 cents".The Verge.RetrievedSeptember 8,2018.
  29. ^"Instant Transfers FAQ".help.venmo.com.Venmo. November 19, 2018.RetrievedNovember 19,2018.
  30. ^Welch, Chris (June 25, 2018)."Venmo is officially launching its physical debit card".The Verge.RetrievedDecember 13,2018.
  31. ^Bonnington, Christina (June 25, 2018)."Everything you need to know about the new Venmo card".The Daily Dot.RetrievedDecember 13,2018.
  32. ^"Venmo-Braintree".Braintree.
  33. ^Moorthy, Neelesh (March 25, 2015)."Cash, credit or mobile app: the rise of Venmo".The Chronicle.Archived fromthe originalon August 15, 2015.RetrievedApril 18,2015.
  34. ^"Who Can View Your Venmo Profile and Post?".sacmav. November 7, 2022.
  35. ^Wener-Fligner, Zach (March 20, 2015)."The emoji of Venmo: food, booze, partying, and, occasionally, rent".Quartz.RetrievedApril 18,2015.
  36. ^Jain, Ashish."Venmo Captions".Mybestcaptions.RetrievedJanuary 17,2020.
  37. ^Bird, John (November 4, 2015)."How Venmo Won In One Of The Most Crowded Spaces In Tech".RetrievedJune 23,2017.
  38. ^"Venmo Security".Venmo.
  39. ^"Introducing Venmo Groups"(Press release).Venmo.November 14, 2023.
  40. ^Peterson, Jake (November 14, 2023)."Venmo May Have Just Killed Splitwise".Lifehacker.RetrievedJuly 22,2024.
  41. ^"FTC Proposes Settlement over Venmo Disclosures, Claims of 'Bank-Grade' Security".ABA Banking Journal.February 28, 2018.RetrievedSeptember 11,2022.
  42. ^Griswold, Alison (February 1, 2015)."Venmo security: it's not as strong as the company wants you to think".Slate.RetrievedOctober 23,2015.
  43. ^"Security research of a social payment app"(PDF).MIT CSAIL.May 14, 2014.RetrievedOctober 23,2015.
  44. ^"Venmo App: Users Raise Questions About the Security of Peer-to-Peer Money Transfer Service".ABC News.March 18, 2015.RetrievedOctober 13,2024.
  45. ^Demos, Telis (July 12, 2018)."You Accidentally Sent $149 to a Stranger on Venmo? Good Luck Getting It Back".The Wall Street Journal.RetrievedFebruary 11,2020.
  46. ^"Episode 922: The Cost Of Getting Your Money Back".Planet Money.National Public Radio.June 26, 2019.RetrievedFebruary 11,2020.
  47. ^"PayPal Settles FTC Charges that Venmo Failed to Disclose Information to Consumers About the Ability to Transfer Funds and Privacy Settings; Violated Gramm-Leach-Bliley Act"(Press release). Federal Trade Commission. February 27, 2018.
  48. ^Fair, Lesley (February 27, 2018)."FTC Venmo Settlement addresses availability of funds, privacy practices and GLB".Federal Trade Commission Business Blog.RetrievedApril 7,2018.
  49. ^"Before the Federal Trade Commission: In the Matter of Paypal, Inc., a corporation (FTC Complaint against Venmo)"(PDF).Federal Trade Commission. 2017. Archived fromthe original(PDF)on April 8, 2018.
  50. ^Nath, Trevir (March 24, 2015)."How Safe is Venmo and Why is it Free?".Investopedia.RetrievedFebruary 23,2018.
  51. ^Solon, Olivia."Venmo: how the payment app exposes our private lives".The Guardian.London.RetrievedJuly 19,2018.
  52. ^"Scammers Use Venmo to Fool Sellers".Better Business Bureau. Archived fromthe originalon October 22, 2016.RetrievedOctober 24,2016.
  53. ^Rudegeair, Peter (November 24, 2018)."Venmo Caught Off Guard by Fraudsters; A spike in fraudulent activity earlier this year led to higher losses than the payments company had expected".The Wall Street Journal.RetrievedMay 5,2020.
  54. ^Salmon, Dan (June 26, 2019)."I Scraped Millions of Venmo Payments. Your Data Is at Risk".Wired.ISSN1059-1028.RetrievedFebruary 12,2020.
  55. ^Xinyi, Zhang (2017)."Cold Hard E-Cash: Friends and Vendors in the Venmo Digital Payments System"(PDF).Proceedings of the International AAAI Conference on Web and Social Media (ICWSM 2017).
  56. ^Mac, Ryan; Notopoulos, Katie; Brooks, Ryan; McDonald, Logan (May 14, 2021)."We Found Joe Biden's Secret Venmo. Here's Why That's A Privacy Nightmare For Everyone".BuzzFeed News.RetrievedMay 15,2021.
  57. ^Peters, Jay (May 14, 2021)."Venmo shows who you're friends with even if you're Joe Biden".The Verge.RetrievedMay 15,2021.
  58. ^Relchert, Corinne (May 14, 2021)."Biden's Venmo account was reportedly tracked down within minutes".CNET.RetrievedMay 15,2021.
  59. ^Pengelly, Martin (May 15, 2021)."Joe Biden's Venmo account discovered in 'less than 10 minutes' – report".The Guardian.RetrievedMay 15,2021.
  60. ^Tandon, Rajat (July 15, 2022)."I know what you did on Venmo: Discovering privacy leaks in mobile social payments"(PDF).Privacy Enhancing Technologies.RetrievedMarch 11,2022.
  61. ^McCaffrey, Peter Rudegeair and Orla (February 5, 2021)."Venmo's Debt-Collection Practices Probed by CFPB".Wall Street Journal.ISSN0099-9660.RetrievedFebruary 6,2021.
  62. ^Rudegeair, Peter (March 25, 2019)."Venmo to Users: If You Owe Us Money, We're Coming for It".Wall Street Journal.ISSN0099-9660.RetrievedFebruary 6,2021.
  63. ^Rudegeair, Peter (September 24, 2020)."Even in a Pandemic, Venmo Tells Conned Customers to Pay Up".Wall Street Journal.ISSN0099-9660.RetrievedFebruary 6,2021.
edit
Retrieved from "https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Venmo&oldid=1252042801"