Middle managementis the intermediatemanagementlevel of ahierarchical organizationthat is subordinate to theexecutive managementand responsible for "team leading"line managersand/or "specialist" line managers. Middle management is indirectly (through line management) responsible for junior staff performance and productivity.[1]
Unlikeline management,middle management is considered to be a senior (orsemi-executive) position as middle managers are authorised to speak and act on behalf of the organisation to line managers, junior staff and customers. Included in this level of management are division, plant and department managers.[2]
A 2023 study in theAmerican Journal of Sociologyfound that middle management has increased over time and that the role of middle management increasingly revolves around the task of collaboration rather than supervision.[3]
Role in an organization
editFunctions of a middle manager
editA middle manager is a link between thesenior managementand the lower (junior) levels of the organization. Due to involvement into day-to-day running of a business, middle managers have the opportunity to report valuable information and suggestions from the inside of an organization.[4]They are in charge of putting into practice guidelines established previously in the strategic plans by top level managers.[2]Moreover, the middle manager is a channel of communication within the organization, as they pass on major decisions of executives and the main goals of an organization to lower levels of employees. This contributes to better coordination between workers and makes a company more united.[5]
The primary responsibility of a middle manager is to implement a strategy, created by the executive level, in the most efficient way possible. In order to reach the target goals, a manager may adjust and interpret the initial plan.[6]Other functions can be divided into three main categories:[7]
- Technical
Middle managers are responsible for facilitating any necessary changes within an organization and creating an effective working environment. They oversee daily routines, monitor performance, and ensure that everything is done in compliance with the organization's needs.[8]
- Human resources
One of the most important functions of a middle manager is motivating, leading and inspiring their subordinates. This also includes building a team and supporting any team member when necessary.
- Strategic
Strategic functions involve analyzing a subordinate group in terms of productivity and financial effectiveness, creating a strategy of improving the current situation and reporting to the executive management in the form of attending a boardroom meeting or a discussion.
Competencies
editA number of competencies are critical to become an effective middle manager.
- Leadership.The most important competency that consists of many skills. As an inherent leader, middle managers have to possess sense-making and persuading skills. They must be able to motivate, influence and guide their subordinates, become a role model for them, demonstrate the quality and the level of work contribution necessary for the organization and engage in continuous self-development and learning.[8][9]
- Decision-making.Ability to quickly solve the problems, make decisions under pressure and take responsibility for the outcome.
- Creativity & Visioning.Managers should have a clear vision of the strategy implementation and be creative in overcoming the possible difficulties.[7]
- Performance management.Involves managing the performance of subordinates and, specifically, the line managers, effectively, by setting clear and measurable objectives for them and provide coaching. Middle managers must be also skilled in presenting, persuading and influencing people.[citation needed]
Middle manager vs. line manager
editA middle management position is often mistakenly described as a similar to theline managementone. However, there are some differences:[7]
- Middle manager is a semi-executive position– line managers are promoted to become middle managers. Thus, middle managers enjoy greater salary, benefits and a closer position to a boardroom.
- System of subordination– line managers are subordinate to middle managers. Middle managers are responsible for large teams and are unable to control performance of every single individual. Thus, direct or line manager measures the team performance and reports to the middle manager.
- Set of duties– unlike line managers, who have a clear procedure of work and set of duties, middle managers have only target goals. The way of achieving those goals is decided by the manager independently.
Criticism
editThe role of middle management is subject to a number of criticisms. This position is often seen as unnecessary, and middle managers are blamed for holding the organization back from achieving its full potential and using their influence for their own purposes.
Influence
editMiddle management is often accused of possessing too much influence. Their central position in an organization allows them to influence strategy and actions in "both upward and downward direction".[6]When supplying information to the executive level, middle managers interpret it subjectively and may insinuate it with their own opinion and evaluation.[10]Further, proximity to the boardroom makes it easy for the manager to promote their own interests, by "synthesizing" the information and presenting data from a certain strategic perspective.[11]The same level of influence can be exploited by a middle manager towards the lower staff.[12]
Resistance
editMiddle managers' reluctance to lose control in their teams and satisfaction with a settled situation could lead to their resistance in any changes in the strategy or direction of an organization. Usually, the resistance does not take an aggressive form such as refusal to carry out tasks or unconcealed confrontation, but result in a lack of support and eagerness to convey only those tasks, impact of which is clearly visible to the top management.[13]This creates barriers to a growth of a company and lags the overall working process.
Necessity
editThe overall necessity of middle managers in an organization is questioned. They are said to be too costly, non-effective and constantly under-performing employees. It has been stated[by whom?]that middle managers do not carry out their main duties of linking the organization and reporting effectively, which leads to a block of communication between different levels of staff.[14]Thus, as rapid growth of globalization put pressures on businesses in terms of cost effectiveness and speed of information flow within the organization, middle management make companies less flexible and competitive.[15]
Future
editThe development ofinformation technologyhas enabled an increase in the span of control and reduced the need for middle management. Moreover, an increasing number of modern organizations are becoming flatter and downsized in pursuit of flexibility, higher competitiveness, and innovation. According to David Williams, flat organizations promote greater intercommunication and efficiency among workers.[16]As a result, many organizations are being restructured, middle management is being reduced, and their roles are considered outdated and unnecessary.
At the same time, there is still a need in a middle manager as an employee and they continue playing a significant role in organizations, specifically in setting an overall strategy and targets.[17]Changes in the global market forced them to become more flexible, stress-resistant, acquire new skills.
References
edit- ^Dance, Anthony (2019).Pragmatic Introduction to Middle Management.Amazon: eBookit. pp. 8–14.ASINB07L4D3QB9.
- ^abBusiness / O. C. Ferrell, Geoffrey A. Hirt, Linda Ferrell(6e ed.). New York, NY: McGraw-Hill. 2019.ISBN978-1-259-92945-8.
- ^Zhang, Letian (2023)."The Changing Role of Managers".American Journal of Sociology.129(2): 439–484.doi:10.1086/727145.ISSN0002-9602.
- ^Likert, R (1961).New Patterns of Management.New-York: McGraw-Hill.
- ^Barnard, Chester I. (1973).The Functions of the Executive.London: Oxford University Press.
- ^abFloyd, S. W.; Wooldridge, B. (1992). "Middle management involvement in strategy and its association with strategic type: A research note".Strategic Management Journal.13(S1): 153–167.doi:10.1002/smj.4250131012.
- ^abcDance, Anthony (2011)."The ambiguity of the middle management role"(PDF).managerperformance.co.uk.Manager Performance. Archived fromthe original(PDF)on 26 November 2013.Retrieved21 October2014.
- ^abZhang, Ann Yan; Tsui, Anne S.; Song, Lynda Jiwen; Li, Chaoping; Jia, Liangding (2008). "How do I trust thee? The employee‐organization relationship, supervisory support, and middle manager trust in the organization".Human Resource Management.47(1): 111–132.doi:10.1002/hrm.20200.
- ^Rouleau, L.; Balogun, J. (2011)."Middle managers, strategic sensemaking, and discursive competence"(PDF).Journal of Management Studies.48(5): 953–983.doi:10.1111/j.1467-6486.2010.00941.x.S2CID145090455.
- ^Ranson, S.; Hinings, B.; Greenwood, R. (1980). "The structuring of organizational structures".Administrative Science Quarterly.25(1): 1–17.doi:10.2307/2392223.JSTOR2392223.
- ^Dutton, J. E.; Duncan, R. B. (1987). "The influence of the strategic planning process on strategic change".Strategic Management Journal.8(2): 103–116.doi:10.1002/smj.4250080202.
- ^Floyd, Steven W.; Wooldridge, Bill (1997). "Middle management's strategic influence and organizational performance".Journal of Management Studies.3(34): 466–482.doi:10.1111/1467-6486.00059.
- ^Connors, J. L.; Rom berg, T. A. (1991). "Middle management and quality control: Strategies for obstructionism".Human Organization.50:61–65.doi:10.17730/humo.50.1.2w81h2l600260704.
- ^Scarbrough, H.;Burrell, G.(1996). Clegg, S.; Palmer, G. (eds.). "The Axeman Cometh: the changing role and knowledge of middle managers".The Politics of Management Knowledge.
- ^Dopson, S.; Stewart, R. (1993). "Information technology, organizational restructuring and the future of middle management".New Technology, Work and Employment.1(8): 10–20.doi:10.1111/j.1468-005X.1993.tb00030.x.
- ^Williams, David."The End Of Middle Managers (And Why They'll Never Be Missed)".forbes.Retrieved26 October2014.
- ^Balogun, J (2003). "From Blaming the Middle to Harnessing its Potential: Creating Change Intermediaries".British Journal of Management.14(1): 69–83.doi:10.1111/1467-8551.00266.
External links
edit- Melissa Korn (5 August 2013)."What It's Like Being a Middle Manager Today".The Wall Street Journal.
- Freek Hermkens (3 June 2020)Middle managers are key for lean change in financial services