Wikipedia

Suicide by cop

Suicide by cop in Florida, 2024(3:54)
An example of a suicide by cop in Florida in September 2024

Suicide by cop(abbreviated as: SbC[1]), also known assuicide by policeorlaw-enforcement-assisted suicide,[2]is asuicidemethod in which asuicidal individualdeliberately behaves in a threatening manner with intent to provoke a lethal response from a public safety orlaw enforcement officer[3]to end their own life.

Overview

edit

There are two broad categories of "suicide by cop". The first is when someone has committed a crime and is being pursued by the police and decides that they would rather die than be arrested. These people may not otherwise be suicidal but may simply decide that life is not worth living if they are incarcerated and thus will provoke police to kill them. The second version involves people who are already contemplating suicide and who decide to provoke law enforcement into killing them. These individuals may commit a crime with the specific intention of provoking a law enforcement response.[citation needed]

The idea of dying bysuicidein this manner is based on trained procedures of law enforcement officers, specifically the policy on the use ofdeadly force.In jurisdictions where officials are readily capable of deadly force, often bybeing equipped with firearms,there are usually set circumstances where they will predictably use deadly force against a threat to themselves or others. This form of suicide functions by exploiting this trained reaction. The most common scenario is pointing a firearm at a police officer or an innocent person, which would be expected to provoke an officer to fire on them. Many variants exist: for example, attacking with a knife or other hand weapon, trying to run an officer or other person over with a car, or trying to trigger a real or presumed explosive device.[citation needed]

This concept hinges on the person's state of mind, and their desire to end their own life, which can be difficult to determine post-mortem.[4]Some cases are obvious, such as pointing an unloaded or non-functioning gun, such as atoy gun,air gun,airsoft gun,orstarter's pistol,at officers, or the presence of asuicide note.Some suspects brazenly announce their intention to die before they act; however, many cases can be more difficult to determine, as some suspects with the desire to die will actually fire live ammunition and even kill people before being killed themselves. Many law enforcement training programs have added sections to specifically address handling these situations if officers suspect that the subject is attempting to goad them into using lethal force.[citation needed]

History

edit

Many modern cases that pre-date the formal recognition of the phenomenon have been identified or speculated by historians as matching the pattern now known as suicide by cop. According to authors Mark Lindsay and David Lester, Houston McCoy, one of the twoAustin Police Departmentofficers who shot and killedCharles Whitman,the "Texas Tower Sniper",believed that Whitman could have shot him and fellow officerRamiro Martinez,but "he was waiting for them, and wanted to be shot."[5]The 1976 death ofMal Evans,road manager, assistant, and a friend ofthe Beatles,who aimed an air gun at police and refused to put it down, was theorized as a possible example of this phenomenon.[6]Some historians believe thatGiuseppe Zangara,the man who killedChicagomayorAnton Cermakin a possible attempt to assassinate thenPresident-electFranklin D. Roosevelt,might have been attempting suicide by police.[7]

Recognition and research

edit

The phenomenon has been described in news accounts from 1981,[8]and scientific journals since 1985.[8]The phrase has appeared in news headlines since at least 1987.[9]It did not become common until the early 2000s. The phrase seems to have originated in the United States, but has also appeared in the UK, where a jury first determined someone died by suicide by cop in 2003.[10]

Some of the first research into suicide by cop was completed by Sgt. Rick Parent of theDelta Police Departmentin 2004. Parent's research of 843 police shootings determined that about 50% were victim-precipitated homicide. Police defined victim-precipitated homicide as "an incident in which an individual bent on self-destruction, engages in life threatening and criminal behavior to force law enforcement officers to kill them."[11]

The first formally labeled "Suicide by Cop" case in English legal history was a judgment made on May 9, 2003, by the Reverend Dr.William Dolman[10]while serving as a London coroner between 1993 and 2007.[12]It set a legal precedent and the judgment, as a cause of death, has been a part of English law since.

A 2009 study in the United States of the profiles of 268 people who died by suicide by cop found that[13]

  • 95% were male and 5% were female
  • the mean age was 35 for men
  • 41% of men were Caucasian, 26% Hispanic and 16% African American
  • 37% of men were single
  • 29% of men had children
  • 54% of men were unemployed
  • 29% of men did not have housing
  • 62% of men had confirmed or probable histories of mental health issues
  • 80% of men were armed – of these, 60% possessed firearms (of which 86% were loaded) and 26% possessed knives
  • 19% feigned or simulated weapon possession
  • 87% of individuals made suicidal communications prior to and/or during the incident
  • 36% were under the influence of alcohol.


A study of five years (2010-2015) ofLAPDdata on 419 attempted suicides by cop found that officers used lethal force seven times, killing five of the subjects.Less-lethalforce was used 71 times. No force was used the other 341 times, or 81 percent. LAPD’s Mental Evaluation Unit has specially trained officers to handle such incidents and tracked, paired with mental health clinicians, who are on call 24 hours a day.[14]

In the US, thePolice Executive Research Forumdeveloped a protocol for dealing with incidents, in which officers do not aim their weapon at the person, move a safe distance away and engage the person in conversation rather than shouting commands at them.[14]

Examples

edit
  • According to theBeatlesresearcherKenneth Womack,the death of band's roadieMal Evansin 1976 was a suicide by cop, as Evans had written a will the night before.[15]
  • In theAramoana massacre,aspree shootingthat occurred on 13 November 1990 inNew Zealand,police shot the suspect dead as he came out of a house firing from the hip and screaming "Kill me!"[16]
  • On 5 May 2005,Peggy Jo Tallas,a bank robber, engaged in a shootout while armed with a toy pistol.[17]
  • In December 2008, 15-year-oldTyler Cassidywas shot and killed by threeVictoria Policeofficers after he threatened them with two large knives and ordered them to shoot him.[18]
  • During March 2011, Chilean businessman and organized criminalItalo Nolliwas shot and killed by police after shooting dead two investigative police detectives and hurting another five. He had previously stated to his wife and son that he believed dying in a police shootout would be "dignifying" and that he "would not return to prison".[19]
  • Myron May,a 31-year-old man believing he was a victim of government covertelectronic harassmenton the line ofCold WareraMKUltraandCOINTELPROclandestine US government programs, died by suicide by cop on 20 November 2014 after recording his intentions on tape.[20]
  • On 4 January 2015, a 32-year-old San Francisco man, Matthew Hoffman, staged a standoff with police in the parking lot of an SFPD station. When he brandished the gun, two officers shot him a total of three times. He left a message for the officers on his cell phone, saying: "You did nothing wrong. You ended the life of a man who was too much of a coward to do it himself... I provoked you. I threatened your life as well as the lives of those around me."[21]
  • In June 2015, 21-year-old Trepierre Hummons, a known gangster with a history of weapons violations, posted his intent to die by suicide by cop onFacebookon the same day that a sex offense had been reported against him. He called9-1-1and reported he had seen a man acting erratically with a gun. He then shot the responding officer multiple times, mortally wounding him. The next officer to arrive on the scene shot Hummons. Both Hummons and the wounded policeman later died in the hospital.[22]
  • On 22 October 2015, Anton Lundin Pettersson, the perpetrator of theTrollhättan school stabbing,wrote a message to an online friend an hour before the attack, where he states “I hope those fucking cops aim straight, because I really don't want to survive my rampage.". He also wrote that he expected to be dead within one or two hours and that he hated himself. Pettersson had a history of mental illness, and a book about the attack with interviews of many people around him states that "during the period before the attack, he wavered between several options; to seek professional help, to kill himself 'normally' or to attack people around him to get killed."[23]
  • On 28 May 2017, a man namedWillie Godboltin Mississippi who murdered seven of his family members and a police officer told a journalist that by shooting towards police, "Suicide by cop was my intention. I ain't fit to live. Not after what I've done."[24]
  • On 15 September 2017, a 15-year-old Virginia boy, Ruben Urbina, called police and was shot twice after threatening an officer with a crowbar. After calling 911, he made threats of a bomb, hostages, knives and guns, none of which were real. "I called the police… so they can kill me."[25]
  • On August 30, 2018, American actressVanessa Marquezpleaded with police officers to kill her while pointing a replica gun at them. Officers were unaware the gun was a replica, and they shot her to death in self-defense.[26][27]
  • In 2018, Alek Minassian, the perpetrator of theToronto van attack,claimed to have attempted suicide by cop when apprehended by police after his attack, requesting to be killed and claiming he was armed with a gun, a declaration which was false.[28]

In literary fiction

edit

InTo Kill a Mockingbird,Tom Robinson, a despondent black man who is imprisoned for a rape he did not commit, is shot 17 times and killed while trying to escape from prison in front of the prison guards.[29]

InThe Outsiders,Dallas Winston, a juvenile delinquent, aims an unloaded handgun at police officers with the intent of them shooting him; he is shot dead.

See also

edit

References

edit
  1. ^"Suicide By Cop".policeforum.org.Retrieved14 November2023.
  2. ^Hutson, H. R.; Anglin, D.; Yarbrough, J.; Hardaway, K.; Russell, M.; Strote, J.; Canter, M.; Blum, B. (12 December 1998)."Suicide by cop".Annals of Emergency Medicine.32(6): 665–669.doi:10.1016/s0196-0644(98)70064-2.PMID9832661– via PubMed.
  3. ^Stincelli, Rebecca A. (2004).Suicide by police: victims from both sides of the badge.Folsom, Calif: Interviews & Interrogations Institute.ISBN0-9749987-0-2.
  4. ^Pinizzotto, Anthony J.; Davis, Edward F.; Miller III, Charles E. (February 2005). "Suicide by Cop."FBI Law Enforcement Bulletin.74(2):8–20
  5. ^Linsday, Mark; Lester, David (2004).Suicide by Cop: Committing Suicide by Provoking Police to Shoot You.Amityville, New York: Baywood Publishing. p. 45.ISBN978-0-89503-290-4.Archivedfrom the original on 14 June 2020.Retrieved22 June2010.
  6. ^"FindArticles | CBSi".findarticles.Archivedfrom the original on 14 March 2020.Retrieved3 July2019.
  7. ^"Giuseppe Zangara".Executedtoday. 22 March 1933.Archivedfrom the original on 28 September 2020.Retrieved9 January2010.
  8. ^abZandt, Clinton R. "Suicide by CopArchived25 April 2012 at theWayback Machine."National Center for the Analysis of Violent Crime.
  9. ^CBC News, "Suicide by cop, a growing phenomenon?".27 February 2013. For example: "Apparent Suicide By Cop on LIRR," Newsday, 11 April 1987.
  10. ^abAllison, Rebecca (10 May 2003)."UK's first 'suicide by cop' ruling".The Guardian.Archivedfrom the original on 22 October 2019.Retrieved16 December2016.
  11. ^Parent, Richard 2004. "Aspects of Police Use of Deadly Force In North America – The Phenomenon of Victim-Precipitated Homicide," Ph.D. thesis,Simon Fraser University.
  12. ^"Suicide by cop" coroner retiresArchived2009-01-25 at theWayback Machine,a brief bio of Dolman, December 2007.
  13. ^Mohandie, Kris; Meloy, J. Reid; Collins, Peter I. (March 2009)."Suicide by Cop Among Officer-Involved Shooting Cases".Journal of Forensic Sciences.54(2): 456–462.doi:10.1111/j.1556-4029.2008.00981.x.PMID19220654.S2CID13881748.Archivedfrom the original on 30 April 2022.Retrieved12 September2020.
  14. ^abJackman, Tom (31 October 2019)."Police chiefs propose ways to reduce 'suicide by cop'".Washington Post.ISSN0190-8286.Retrieved6 July2024.
  15. ^Sheffield, Rob(10 December 2023)."The High Life and Shocking Death of Beatles Sidekick Mal Evans".Rolling Stone.Retrieved19 June2024.
  16. ^"World Notes New Zealand".Time.24 June 2001.Archivedfrom the original on 20 September 2020.Retrieved21 June2015.
  17. ^Skip Hollandsworth(November 2005),"The Last Ride of Cowboy Bob",Texas Monthly
  18. ^"Tyler Cassidy's death 'suicide by cop', coroner told".CourierMail.Archivedfrom the original on 30 April 2022.Retrieved15 March2016.
  19. ^"Mi vida como un Nolli".Revista Qué Pasa.20 March 2014.Retrieved4 October2023.
  20. ^McPhate, Mike (10 June 2016)."United States of Paranoia: They See Gangs of Stalkers".The New York Times.Archivedfrom the original on 13 June 2020.Retrieved3 March2017.
  21. ^"The Untold Motives behind Suicide-by-Cop".Officer.Archivedfrom the original on 2 September 2017.Retrieved26 May2017.
  22. ^Brumfield, Ben (21 June 2015)."Police: Cincinnati man calls 911 on self, kills responding officer".CNN.Archivedfrom the original on 25 November 2020.Retrieved2 March2016.
  23. ^Röstlund, Lisa (27 September 2017)."Mördarens sista meddelande: 'Jag fucking hatar mig själv'".Dagens Nyheter(in Swedish).Archivedfrom the original on 11 November 2020.Retrieved14 September2018.
  24. ^"Exclusive: Suspect confesses to C-L reporter; 8 dead, including deputy".The Clarion Ledger.Archivedfrom the original on 30 April 2022.Retrieved17 June2019.
  25. ^"The teen couldn't bear life anymore. So he called police with a chilling threat. - Washington Post".The Washington Post.30 March 2023. Archived from the original on 30 March 2023.Retrieved17 July2023.{{cite news}}:CS1 maint: bot: original URL status unknown (link)
  26. ^Lacey, Jackie (25 February 2020)."Officer Involved Shooting of Vanessa Marquez South Pasadena Police Department"(PDF).District Attorney County of Los Angeles.Archived(PDF)from the original on 4 April 2023.Retrieved14 December2023.
  27. ^Lacey, Jackie (5 February 2020)."Los Angeles County District Attorney's Office Report".District Attorney County of Los Angeles.Archivedfrom the original on 4 April 2023.Retrieved14 December2023.
  28. ^"Toronto police officer hailed as hero for arresting suspect without firing shot".the Guardian.24 April 2018.Archivedfrom the original on 26 March 2022.Retrieved26 March2022.
  29. ^Temple, Kathryn (Spring 2014)."What's Old Is New Again: William Blackstone's Theory of Happiness Comes to America".The Eighteenth Century: Theory and Interpretation.55(1): 129–134.doi:10.1353/ecy.2014.0006.ISSN1935-0201.S2CID145016032.Retrieved26 July2022.Tom Robinson, the black man falsely charged with rape, commits what some call 'suicide by cop,' attempting to escape from prison under circumstances that assure his death. p. 131

Further reading

edit
edit

Retrieved from "https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Suicide_by_cop&oldid=1257284210"