Talk:Tudor period

old comments

Hi I made a change from the reading on the English Reformation. Henry VIII wanted an annulment and not a divorce, this may seem pedantic but its actually important legally and ecclesiastically. (annulment says the marriage never took place).— Precedingunsignedcomment added by67.175.134.196(talk)15:57, 30 July 2012 (UTC)

I'm sorry but this reads like it was written by a child paraphrasing from a playschool textbook. Shouldn't we try overhauling it? I'm definitely willing to give it a go

-- I agree. Is this article a piss-take??— Precedingunsignedcomment added by82.43.197.231(talk) 17:23, May 12, 2007

Particuarly poor is the bit about health. It seems to conflate life expectancy at birth with how long an adult could expect to live. Wilhelm Ritter23:30, 19 July 2007 (UTC)

I am interested to find more information about how the poor lived during this time. We've all seen grand tudor mansions. What were the poor likely to live in? Unfinished stone? Finished stone? Wood? Adobe?;) Thatched roof? Shingles?

By its very nature the way of life of the poor is not well substantiated in any period. It can only be generalised at best, through its remaining plain artefacts which were in everyday use, and which tend to resemble those of the poor from other periods more closely than they do the fashionable objects of the rich of their own period. The property of the poor was rarely traced and recorded, nor preserved by the very reason of their ordinariness, whereas the objects in the great houses of the nobility, etc., would always be more closely guarded and maintained for posterity.

The fashions of clothes do vary with time, of course, if slashed shirts and doublets were in fashion then clothes similar in cut but made of far coarser materials would be worn by the poor, which again can only very generally be described, while those of nobility would be written about and even painted by the artists of the day.

The way of life of the illiterate poor would be passed down through oral traditions rather than the literary records left behind by the educated rich of any period.

It is for these reasons, that the lives of the poor during the Tudor period might resemble the lives of the poor of other periods, and could only be generalised in their descripton. A poor Tudor family would probably resemble a poor family from Dickens's times rather than that of a rich Tudor family. The lives of the poor of any periods can only be described in the most generalised terms.

The architecture of the Tudor cottage which was the dwelling of the commoners does reflect that of the trends of the time, which I copied fromTudor Style architecture:

Tudor style buildings have six distinctive features -

• Decorative half-timbering
• Steeply pitched roof
• Prominent cross gables
• Tall, narrow windows
• Small window panes
• Large chimneys, often topped with decorative chimney pots

I am not sure whether any Wikipedia article gives details of what the wages a working person in Tudor times were, at any rate I wasn't able to find anything to that effect.

I do hope it does give you some idea of the difficulties of hunting down details pertaining to the common people of the Tudor period.Dieter Simon00:13, 31 July 2006

(UTC)

The article conflates the Tudor Period with the Elizabethan Period which is distinct. i suggest cutting out all the Elibethan info.—Precedingunsignedcomment added by12.193.84.162(talk)17:41, 8 July 2008 (UTC)

So, were they all gay?

Why on earth were grown men sending all that love to each other in letters? Has anybody ever studied why these lads, "loving servants", were sending letters giving "wings of affection" to other grown men? Just what was really going on in Tudor England? Where'sPeter Tatchellwhen you need him?86.42.98.32(talk)20:44, 12 December 2007 (UTC)

First opera

The comment about opera in the "Pastimes" section is not really for the general reader, but for Wikipedia editors. Browsing this subject I could not find any reference about Tudor period opera being popular. If anyone can source opera during this period, please re-enter with citing sources.Dieter Simon(talk)22:22, 20 April 2008 (UTC)

Will have a lookNk.sheridanTalk22:42, 1 May 2008 (UTC)

Overhaul of Article and Expansion of Article

I've begun an overhaul of article. Please help if you can. I did the same toStuart period (England).References are always good:)Nk.sheridanTalk22:42, 1 May 2008 (UTC)

I've added a couple of sections to the significant events section but there's lots more to add! Some ideas;

• Perhaps a mention on Henry VIII, roots of thereformationin Pope Clement VII's refusal to grant him a divorce etc.?
• Henry VIII beheading of his wives?
• Entering the slave trade
• colonization of Ulster
• John Knox1559

It's a long period so there is plenty to do. Cheers,Nk.sheridanTalk22:32, 2 May 2008 (UTC)

Review

This article needs to have someone define its scope a bit more clearly. There already is an articleTudor dynasty,which covers the major historical developments of the period. But that still leaves a lot of material not covered there. My best guess, and it is a weak one, might be to place all the politically important developments in the Tudor dynasty article, and maybe retitle this one something like "Everyday life in the Tudor era." A separate series of articles on that theme over the history of the country might not be a bad idea, and it would allow for ready access to that content.John Carter(talk)18:36, 3 June 2008 (UTC)

lead section sounds a bit silly

it says 'England was economically healthier, more expansive, and more optimistic under the Tudors "than at any time in a hundred years.' does anyone else find this statement a bit strange, considering the Tudor period lasted 115 years and 100 years isn't a very long time in that context. It would be like saying 'England was more optimsitic in the 1960s than at any time in ten years' which wouldn't be saying much and does not deserve to be treated as an incredibly dramatic and grandiose statement as presented here.— Precedingunsignedcomment added by2a00:23c7:2b88:5700:1ccc:ee4a:344b:943b(talk)08:43, 5 August 2020 (UTC)