Talk:uter

Latest comment:10 years agoby Darth Newdar in topicUter

Uter

edit

Just a quick note to point out that I'm fairly confidentuteris masculine in gender,although it declines like a third declension neuter noun.See the following:

Are you sure it declines like a neuter noun? I can find lots of citations for "utres", but no more than one for "utria".Mr. Granger(talk)16:51, 19 November 2013 (UTC)Reply
I think you're right. According to thisonline Latin Dictionary"neutr. collat. form of plur. utria, Liv. And. ap. Non. p. 231, 31; gen. plur. utrium, Sall. J. 91, 1)". All the abbreviations make it hard to understand, but I think it means "[alternative] neutral collateral form of pluralutria",i.e. the word is normally third declension masculine, with an unusual neuter variation also existing. Should there be a note of this on the page?
A further note: I have rather amusingly discovered a reference to the utres/utria confusion in the work of Arnobius (an early Christian writer during the 300s). Thefull Latin textis available, but there's alsoa translation.To quote: "Does not one of you make the plural of uter, utria? another utres?" So there you go - we wrestle with an ancient problem!
Huh. And Arnobius even lists a bunch of words that have this strange phenomenon. I'm going to add that quote as a citation, and put a usage note aboututria.Mr. Granger(talk)21:25, 19 November 2013 (UTC)Reply
Done. Feel free to change what I've added if you think it could be presented better.Mr. Granger(talk)21:45, 19 November 2013 (UTC)Reply
That's great - thanks!Darth Newdar(talk)11:31, 21 November 2013 (UTC)Reply