Comparative anatomy

Comparative anatomyis the study of similarities and differences in theanatomyof differentspecies.It is closely related toevolutionary biologyandphylogeny^[1](theevolutionof species).

The science began in theclassical era,continuing in theearly modern periodwith work byPierre Belonwho noted the similarities of the skeletons of birds and humans.

Comparative anatomy has providedevidence of common descent,and has assisted in the classification of animals.^[2]

History

The first specifically anatomical investigation separate from a surgical or medical procedure is associated by

.^[3]Leonardo da Vincimade notes for a planned anatomical treatise in which he intended to compare the hands of various animals including bears.^[4]Pierre Belon,a French naturalist born in 1517, conducted research and held discussions ondolphinembryos as well as the comparisons between the skeletons of birds to the skeletons of humans. His research led to modern comparative anatomy.^[5]

Around the same time,Andreas Vesaliuswas also making some strides of his own. A young anatomist of Flemish descent made famous by a penchant for amazing charts, he was systematically investigating and correcting the anatomical knowledge of the Greek physician Galen. He noticed that many of Galen's observations were not even based on actual humans. Instead, they were based on other animals such as non-humanapes,monkeys,andoxen.^[6]In fact, he entreated his students to do the following, in substitution for human skeletons, as cited by Edward Tyson: "If you can't happen to see any of these, dissect an Ape, carefully view each Bone, &c...." Then he advises what sort of Apes to make choice of, as most resembling a Man: And conclude "One ought to know the Structure of all the Bones either in a Humane Body, or in an Apes; 'tis best in both; and then to go to the Anatomy of the Muscles."^[7]Up until that point, Galen and his teachings had been the authority on human anatomy. The irony is that Galen himself had emphasized the fact that one should make one's own observations instead of using those of another, but this advice was lost during the numerous translations of his work. AsVesaliusbegan to uncover these mistakes, other physicians of the time began to trust their own observations more than those of Galen. An interesting observation made by some of these physicians was the presence of homologous structures in a wide variety of animals which included humans. These observations were later used byDarwinas he formed his theory ofNatural Selection.^[8]

Edward Tysonis regarded as the founder of modern comparative anatomy. He is credited with determining thatwhalesanddolphinsare, in fact, mammals. Also, he concluded thatchimpanzeesare more similar to humans than tomonkeysbecause of their arms.Marco Aurelio Severinoalso compared various animals, including birds, in hisZootomia democritaea,one of the first works of comparative anatomy. In the 18th and 19th century, great anatomists likeGeorge Cuvier,Richard OwenandThomas Henry Huxleyrevolutionized our understanding of the basic build andsystematicsofvertebrates,laying the foundation forCharles Darwin's work onevolution.An example of a 20th-century comparative anatomist isVictor Negus,who worked on the structure and evolution of the larynx. Until the advent of genetic techniques likeDNA sequencing,comparative anatomy together withembryologywere the primary tools for understandingphylogeny,as exemplified by the work ofAlfred Romer.^{[citation needed]}

Concepts

A drawing by Edward Tyson — A drawing byEdward Tyson

Two major concepts of comparative anatomy are:

Homologous structures- structures (body parts/anatomy) which are similar in different species because the species havecommon descentand have evolved, usually divergently, from a shared ancestor. They may or may not perform the same function. An example is the forelimb structure shared bycatsandwhales.
Analogous structures- structures similar in different organisms because, inconvergent evolution,they evolved in asimilar environment,rather than were inherited from a recent common ancestor. They usually serve the same or similar purposes. An example is the streamlined torpedo body shape ofporpoisesandsharks.So even though they evolved from different ancestors, porpoises and sharks developed analogous structures as a result of their evolution in the same aquatic environment. This is known as ahomoplasy.^[9]

Uses

Comparative anatomy has long served asevidence for evolution,now joined in that role bycomparative genomics;^[10]it indicates that organisms share a common ancestor.

It also assists scientists in classifying organisms based on similar characteristics of their anatomical structures. A common example of comparative anatomy is the similar bone structures in forelimbs of cats, whales, bats, and humans. All of these appendages consist of the same basic parts; yet, they serve completely different functions. The skeletal parts which form a structure used for swimming, such as a fin, would not be ideal to form a wing, which is better-suited for flight. One explanation for the forelimbs' similar composition is descent with modification. Through random mutations and natural selection, each organism's anatomical structures gradually adapted to suit their respective habitats.^[11]The rules for development ofspecialcharacteristics which differ significantly from generalhomologywere listed byKarl Ernst von Baerasthe laws now named after him.

References

^Gaucher EA, Kratzer JT, Randall RN (January 2010)."Deep phylogeny--how a tree can help characterize early life on Earth".Cold Spring Harbor Perspectives in Biology.2(1): a002238.doi:10.1101/cshperspect.a002238.PMC2827910.PMID 20182607.
^National Academy of Sciences (US) (22 April 1999).Science and Creationism.doi:10.17226/6024.ISBN 978-0-309-06406-4.PMID 25101403.
^Blits KC (April 1999). "Aristotle: form, function, and comparative anatomy".The Anatomical Record.257(2): 58–63.doi:10.1002/(SICI)1097-0185(19990415)257:2<58::AID-AR6>3.0.CO;2-I.PMID 10321433.S2CID 38940794.
^Bean, Jacob; Stampfle, Felice (1965).Drawings from New York Collections I: The Italian Renaissance.Greenwich, CT: Metropolitan Museum of Art. p. 28.
^Gudger EW (1934). "The Five Great Naturalists of the Sixteenth Century: Belon, Rondelet, Salviani, Gesner and Aldrovandi: A Chapter in the History of Ichthyology".Isis.22(1): 21–40.doi:10.1086/346870.S2CID 143961902.
^Mesquita ET, Souza Júnior CV, Ferreira TR (March 2015)."Andreas Vesalius 500 years--A Renaissance that revolutionized cardiovascular knowledge".Revista Brasileira de Cirurgia Cardiovascular.30(2): 260–5.doi:10.5935/1678-9741.20150024.PMC4462973.PMID 26107459.
^Edward Tyson, Orang-Outang..., 1699, p. 59.
^Caldwell R (2006)."Comparative Anatomy: Andreas Vesalius".University of California Museum of Paleontology. Archived fromthe originalon 23 November 2010.Retrieved17 February2011.
^Kardong KV (2015).Vertebrates: Comparative Anatomy, Function, Evolution.New York: McGraw-Hill Education. pp. 15–16.ISBN 978-0-07-802302-6.
^Hardison RC (November 2003)."Comparative genomics".PLOS Biology.1(2): E58.doi:10.1371/journal.pbio.0000058.PMC261895.PMID 14624258.
^Campbell NA, Reece JB (February 2002).Biology(6th ed.). San Francisco, CA:Benjamin Cummings.pp.438–439.ISBN 978-0-8053-6624-2.OCLC 1053072597.

External links

[1] Gaucher EA, Kratzer JT, Randall RN (January 2010)."Deep phylogeny--how a tree can help characterize early life on Earth".Cold Spring Harbor Perspectives in Biology.2(1): a002238.doi:10.1101/cshperspect.a002238.PMC2827910.PMID 20182607.

[2] National Academy of Sciences (US) (22 April 1999).Science and Creationism.doi:10.17226/6024.ISBN 978-0-309-06406-4.PMID 25101403.

[Blits_1999-3] Blits KC (April 1999). "Aristotle: form, function, and comparative anatomy".The Anatomical Record.257(2): 58–63.doi:10.1002/(SICI)1097-0185(19990415)257:2<58::AID-AR6>3.0.CO;2-I.PMID 10321433.S2CID 38940794.

[4] Bean, Jacob; Stampfle, Felice (1965).Drawings from New York Collections I: The Italian Renaissance.Greenwich, CT: Metropolitan Museum of Art. p. 28.

[5] Gudger EW (1934). "The Five Great Naturalists of the Sixteenth Century: Belon, Rondelet, Salviani, Gesner and Aldrovandi: A Chapter in the History of Ichthyology".Isis.22(1): 21–40.doi:10.1086/346870.S2CID 143961902.

[6] Mesquita ET, Souza Júnior CV, Ferreira TR (March 2015)."Andreas Vesalius 500 years--A Renaissance that revolutionized cardiovascular knowledge".Revista Brasileira de Cirurgia Cardiovascular.30(2): 260–5.doi:10.5935/1678-9741.20150024.PMC4462973.PMID 26107459.

[7] Edward Tyson, Orang-Outang..., 1699, p. 59.

[Caldwell2006-8] Caldwell R (2006)."Comparative Anatomy: Andreas Vesalius".University of California Museum of Paleontology. Archived fromthe originalon 23 November 2010.Retrieved17 February2011.

[9] Kardong KV (2015).Vertebrates: Comparative Anatomy, Function, Evolution.New York: McGraw-Hill Education. pp. 15–16.ISBN 978-0-07-802302-6.

[10] Hardison RC (November 2003)."Comparative genomics".PLOS Biology.1(2): E58.doi:10.1371/journal.pbio.0000058.PMC261895.PMID 14624258.

[11] Campbell NA, Reece JB (February 2002).Biology(6th ed.). San Francisco, CA:Benjamin Cummings.pp.438–439.ISBN 978-0-8053-6624-2.OCLC 1053072597.

[1]

[2]

[3]

[4]

[5]

[6]

[7]

[8]

[9]

[10]

[11]

v t e Anatomyandmorphology
Fields	Gross anatomy Superficial anatomy Neuroanatomy brain morphometry Comparative anatomy Microscopic anatomy histology molecular Morphometrics
Bacteria and fungi	Bacterial cell structure cellular morphologies morphological plasticity Colonial morphology Lichen morphology
Protists	Structures
Plants	Plant anatomy fruit Plant habit Plant life-form Plant morphology reproductive Soil morphology
Invertebrates	Decapod anatomy Gastropod anatomy Insect morphology Diptera Odonata Spider anatomy Arthropod cuticle
Mammals	Human anatomy Neanderthal anatomy Cat anatomy Dog anatomy Horse anatomy Elephant anatomy Giraffe anatomy
Other vertebrates	Amphibian anatomy Bird anatomy Fish anatomy Shark anatomy
Glossaries	Anatomical terminology Anatomical terms of location Glossary of dinosaur anatomy Glossary of plant morphology leaf morphology
Related topics	Allometry Anatomical variation Anatomical plane Body plan Form classification Gracility Hertwig rule History of anatomy 19th century Physiognomy Standard anatomical position Transcendental anatomy
Category Portal Index of anatomy articles

v t e Fins,limbsandwings
Fins	Aquatic locomotion Cephalopod fin Fish locomotion Fin and flipper locomotion Caudal fin Dorsal fin Fish fin Flipper Lobe-finned fish Ray-finned fish Pectoral fins Pelvic fin
Limbs	Limb development Limb morphology digitigrade plantigrade unguligrade uniped biped facultative biped triped quadruped Arthropod Cephalopod Tetrapod dactyly Digit Webbed foot
Wings	Flying and gliding animals Bat wing Bird wing keel skeleton feathers Insect wing Pterosaur wing Wingspan
Evolution	Evolution of fish Evolution of tetrapods Evolution of birds Origin of birds Origin of avian flight Evolution of cetaceans Comparative anatomy Convergent evolution Analogous structures Homologous structures
Related	Animal locomotion Gait Robot locomotion Samara Terrestrial locomotion Tradeoffs for locomotion in air and water Rotating locomotion Undulatory locomotion