Code-talker paradox

Acode-talker paradoxis a situation in which alanguageprevents communication. As an issue inlinguistics,theparadoxraises questions about the fundamental nature of languages. As such, the paradox is a problem inphilosophy of language.

The term code-talker paradox was coined in 2001 byMark Bakerto describe the Navajo code talking used duringWorld War II.Code talkersare able to create a languagemutually intelligibleto each other but completely unintelligible to everyone who does not know the code. This causes a conflict of interests without actually causing any conflict at all. In the case of Navajo code-talkers,cryptanalystswere unable to decode messages inNavajo,even when using the most sophisticated methods available. At the same time, the code talkers were able to encrypt and decrypt messages quickly and easily by translating them into and from Navajo. Thus the code talker paradox refers to how human languages can be so similar and different at once: so similar that one can learn them both and gain the ability to translate from one to the other, yet so different that if someone knows one language but does not know another, it is not always possible to derive the meaning of a text by analyzing it or infer it from the other language.

See also

• Drift (linguistics)
• List of paradoxes
• Plato's Problem
• The Analysis of Verbal Behavior
• Philip Johnston

References

• Baker, Mark C.The Atoms of Language: The Mind's Hidden Rules of Grammar.Basic Books, 2001.