Edmund Morgan (historian)

Edmund Sears Morgan
Born	(1916-01-17)January 17, 1916 Minneapolis,Minnesota,U.S.
Died	July 8, 2013(2013-07-08)(aged 97) New Haven, Connecticut,U.S.
Alma mater	Harvard University(BA,PhD) London School of Economics
Scientific career
Institutions	University of Chicago Brown University Yale University
Doctoral advisor	Perry Miller
Doctoral students	Joseph Ellis Christine Leigh Heyrman Bruce H. Mann

Edmund Sears Morgan(January 17, 1916 – July 8, 2013) was an American historian and an authority on earlyAmerican history.He was theSterling Professorof History atYale University,where he taught from 1955 to 1986.He specialized inAmerican colonial history,with some attention toEnglish history.Thomas S. Kidd says he was noted for his incisive writing style, "simply one of the best academic prose stylists America has ever produced."He covered many topics, includingPuritanism,political ideas, theAmerican Revolution,slavery,historiography,family life, and numerous notables such asBenjamin Franklin.

Early life and education

Morgan was born inMinneapolis,Minnesota,the second child of Edmund Morris Morgan and Elsie Smith Morgan.His mother was from aYankeefamily that practicedChristian Science,though she distanced herself from that faith. His father, descended fromWelshcoal miners, taught law at theUniversity of Minnesota.His sister wasRoberta Mary Morgan (later Wohlstetter),also a historian and, like Edmund, a winner of theBancroft Prize.

In 1925, the family moved fromWashington, D.C.,toArlington, Massachusetts,when their father was appointed a professor atHarvard Law School.

Morgan attendedBelmont Hill SchoolinBelmont, Massachusetts,and then enrolled atHarvard College,where he initially intended to study English history and literature. But after taking a course in American literature withF. O. Matthiessen,he switched to the new major of American civilization (history and literature), withPerry Milleras his tutor. He received his bachelor's degree from Harvard in 1937. Then, at the urging of the jurist and family friendFelix Frankfurter,Morgan began attending lectures at theLondon School of Economics.

In 1942, Morgan earned hisPh.D.in the History of American Civilization fromHarvard Universitywith Miller as his adviser.

Military service

Although a pacifist, Morgan became convinced after thefall of Francein June 1940 that only military force could stopHitler,and he withdrew his application for conscientious objector status. DuringWorld War II,he trained as a machinist at theMIT Radiation Laboratory,where he turned out parts for radar installations.

Personal life and death

In 1939, he married Helen Theresa Mayer, who died in 1982.

Morgan died inNew Haven, Connecticuton July 8, 2013, at the age of 97. His cause of death waspneumonia.He was survived by two daughters—Penelope Aubin and Pamela Packard—from his first marriage; his second wife, Marie (née Carpenter) Caskey Morgan, a historian; six grandchildren; and seven great-grandchildren.

Career

In 1946–55, Morgan taught history atBrown UniversityinProvidence, Rhode Islandbefore becoming a professor atYale University,where he directed some 60PhDdissertations in colonial history before retiring in 1986.

As an undergraduate at Harvard, Morgan was profoundly influenced by historianPerry Miller,who became a lifelong friend. Although both were atheists, they had a deep understanding and respect forPuritan religion.From Miller, Morgan learned to appreciate:

The intellectual rigor and elegance of a system of ideas that made sense of human life in a way no longer palatable to most of us. Certainly not palatable to me... He left me with a habit of taking what people have said at face value unless I find compelling reasons to discount it... What Americans said from the beginning abouttaxationand just government deserved to be taken as seriously as the Puritans' ideas about God and man.

Morgan's many books and articles covered a range of topics in the history of the colonial and Revolutionary periods, using intellectual,social history,biographical, and political history approaches. Two of his early books,The Birth of the Republic(1956) andThe Puritan Dilemma(1958), have for decades been required reading in many undergraduate history courses. His works includeAmerican Slavery, American Freedom(1975), which won theSociety of American Historians'Francis Parkman Prize,theSouthern Historical Association's Charles S. Sydnor Prize and theAmerican Historical Association'sAlbert J. Beveridge Award,andInventing the People: The Rise of Popular Sovereignty inEnglandand America(1988), which won Columbia University'sBancroft Prizein American History in 1989. Morgan has written a biography of Benjamin Franklin of which he made extensive use ofThe Papers of Benjamin Franklinand has written about at length.He has also written biographies onEzra StilesandRoger Williams.

Puritans

Morgan's trioThe Puritan Family: Religion and Domestic Relations in 17th-Century New England(1944),The Puritan Dilemma(1958), andVisible Saints: The History of a Puritan Idea(1963) restored the intellectual respectability of thePuritans,and exposed their appetite for healthy sex, causing a renaissance in Puritan studies, partly because both Morgan and his mentor Miller wereIvy Leagueatheist professors, which added to their credibility.Visible Saints,dedicated to Miller, was a reinterpretation of the Puritan ideal of the "Church of the Elect." Morgan argued that the criterion for church membership was not fixed in England. Soon after their arrival, the Puritans changed membership to a gathered church composed exclusively of tested Saints.

Morgan's 1958 bookThe Puritan Dilemmaraised his notability, and the book became the most assigned textbook in U.S. history survey courses, documenting the change in understanding among Puritans of what it means to be a member of a church. Morgan described the Puritan as "doing right in a world that does wrong...Caught between the ideals of God's Law and the practical needs of the people,John Winthropwalked a line few could tread. "

American Revolution

InThe Stamp Act Crisis(1953) andThe Birth of the Republic(1956) Morgan rejected theProgressiveinterpretation of theAmerican Revolutionand its assumption that the rhetoric of the Patriots was mere claptrap. Instead Morgan returned to the interpretation first set out byGeorge Bancrofta century before that the patriots were deeply motivated by a commitment to liberty. Historian Mark Egnal argues that:

The leading neo-Whig historians, Edmund Morgan andBernard Bailyn,underscore this dedication to whiggish principles, although with variant readings. For Morgan, the development of the patriots' beliefs was a rational, clearly defined process.

Slavery

In his 1975 bookAmerican Slavery, American Freedom,Morgan explored "the American paradox, the marriage of slavery and freedom":

Human relations among us still suffer from the former enslavement of a large portion of our predecessors. The freedom of the free, the growth of freedom experienced in the American Revolution depended more than we like to admit on the enslavement of more than 20 percent of us at that time. How republican freedom came to be supported, at least in large part, by its opposite, slavery, is the subject of this book.

Morgan claimed that largeVirginia plantationowners exerted an outsized influence on poorer white Virginians and their attitude toward theracial divide (color line)which made it possible for Virginian white men as a group to become more politically equal: ( "Aristocrats could more safely preach equality in a slave society than in a free one" ).

In a controversial passage, Morgan suggestsVirginia's poor whites felt no racial superiority to poor blacks. He does this by providing evidence that, in 17th-century Virginia, poor white indentured servants and black slaves frequently cooperated with each other and worked together. Morgan cites the 1676Bacon's Rebellionas evidence of a surprising racial egalitarianism among the poor, since Bacon incorporated runaway black slaves into his army.

Despite the assertions of such writers as Michelle Alexander,however, Morgan does not state that Bacon's Rebellion was the reason that rich landowners stopped purchasing whiteindentured servantsand started increasing their purchase of black slaves; rather, regional changes in labor economics was the reason black slaves began to replace white servants: during the early 1600s, white servants cost less per unit labor than black slaves did; but by the latter 1600s, the situation reversed itself, and black slaves became the more economical investment.And, as Morgan states, "The planters who bought slaves instead of servants did not do so with any apparent consciousness of the social stability to be gained thereby. Indeed, insofar as Virginians expressed themselves on the subject of slavery, they feared that it would magnify the danger of insurrection in the colony."As events evolved, however, the rising number of black slaves and the virtual end to the importation of indentured servants did stabilize Virginia society. And as time went on, according to Morgan, Virginia politicians learned to further pacify poor whites by fostering a sense of white superiority."Racism made it possible for white Virginians to develop a devotion to the equality that English republicans had declared to be the soul ofliberty."That is, according to Morgan, white men in Virginia were able to become much more politically equal and cohesive than would have been possible without a population of low-status black slaves.

Anthony S. Parent commented: "American historians of our generation admire Edmund Morgan'sAmerican Slavery, American Freedommore than any other monograph. Morgan resuscitated American history by placing black slavery and white freedom as its central paradox. "

In 2002 Morgan published a surpriseNew York TimesBestseller,Benjamin Franklin,which dispels the myth of "a comfortable old gentleman staring out at the world over his half-glasses with benevolent comprehension of everything in it", revealing his true mental makeup.

With a wisdom about himself that comes only to the great of heart, Franklin knew how to value himself and what he did without mistaking himself for something more than one man among many. His special brand ofself-respectrequired him to honor his fellow men and women no less than himself.

Legacy and impact

After examining his writings,University of North Floridahistorian wrote David T. Courtwright wrote that:

They are based on exhaustive research in primary sources; emphasize human agency as against historicist forces; and are written in precise and graceful prose. This combination of rigor, empathy, and lucidity is intended for, and has succeeded in capturing, a broad audience. Morgan is read by secondary school students, undergraduates, and graduate students, as well as by his specialist peers – some sixty of whom were trained in his seminars.

Massachusetts Institute of TechnologyAmerican history professorPauline Maierwrote:

As a historian of colonial and revolutionary America, he was one of the giants of his generation, and a writer who could well have commanded a larger nonacademic audience than I suspect he received. He characteristically took on big issues and had a knack for conveying complex, sophisticated truths in a way that made them seem, if not simple, at least easily understandable.

Brooklyn Collegehistory professor Benjamin L. Carp describes Morgan as "one of the great historians of early America, with a formidable influence on academic and popular audiences."Jill Leporecalled Morgan "one of the most influential American historians of the 20th century."According toJoseph Ellis,Morgan was "revered" by other members of the profession.

Historian and authorWilliam Hogeland affirmsMorgan's success in enshrining a "consensus approach" to U.S. history, where colonists' ideas, rather than their possible economic interests, were worthy of inspection by 20th century historians."He was out to define something essential in the American character and thereby create a new master narrative, and to achieve that end, he concocted a false portrayal of the colonists’ petitions," Hogeland wrote.

The essayistTa-Nehisi Coatescredits Morgan with greatly influencing his own views about race in American history.

Awards and honors

Morgan was elected to theAmerican Philosophical Societyin 1964and theAmerican Academy of Arts and Sciencesin 1966.In 1971 Morgan was awarded the Yale chapter ofPhi Beta Kappa's William Clyde DeVane Medal for outstanding teaching andscholarship,considered one of the most prestigious teaching prizes for Yale faculty. In 1971–1972 Morgan served as president of theOrganization of American Historians.In 1972, he became the first recipient of theDouglass AdairMemorial Award for scholarship in early American history, and in 1986 he received the Distinguished Scholar Award of the American Historical Association. He has also won numerous fellowships and garnered a number of honorary degrees and named lectureships. In 1965 he became aSterling Professor,one of Yale's highest distinctions. Morgan was awarded the 2000National Humanities Medalby U.S. PresidentBill Clintonat a ceremony for "extraordinary contributions to American cultural life and thought." In 2006 he received aspecial Pulitzer Prize"for a creative and deeply influential body of work as an American historian that spans the last half century."In 2008 theAmerican Academy of Arts and Lettershonored him with agold medalfor lifetime achievement.

Books

• The Puritan Family: Religion and Domestic Relations in 17th-Century New England(1944)read online
• Virginians at Home: Family Life in the Eighteenth Century(1952)
• The Stamp Act Crisis: Prologue to Revolution(1953), withHelen M. Morgan
• The Birth of the Republic, 1763–89(1956; 4th ed. 2012)read online
• The Puritan Dilemma: The Story of John Winthrop(1958)read online
• The American Revolution: A Review of Changing Interpretations(1958)
• The Mirror of the Indian(1958)
• Editor,Prologue to the Revolution: Sources and Documents on the Stamp Act Crisis, 1764–1766(1959)
• The Gentle Puritan: A Life of Ezra Stiles, 1727–1795(1962)read online
• The National Experience: A History of the United States(1963) coauthor of textbook; several editions
• Visible Saints: The History of a Puritan Idea(1963)
• Editor,The Founding of Massachusetts: Historians and the Sources(1964)
• The American Revolution: Two Centuries of Interpretation(1965)
• Puritan Political Ideas, 1558–1794(1965)read online
• The Diary of Michael Wigglesworth, 1653–1657: The Conscience of a Puritan(1965)
• The Puritan Family([1944] 1966)
• Roger Williams: The Church and the State(1967)read online
• So What About History?(1969)
• American Slavery, American Freedom: The Ordeal of Colonial Virginia(1975)
• The Meaning of Independence: John Adams, George Washington, and Thomas Jefferson(1976, reprint with new foreword, 2004)
• The Genius of George Washington(1980)
• Inventing the People: The Rise of Popular Sovereignty in England and America(1988)
• Benjamin Franklin(Yale University Press, 2002)read online
• The Genuine Article: A Historian Looks at Early America(2004), selected review essays fromNew York Review of Booksread online
• American Heroes: Profiles of Men and Women Who Shaped Early America(2009), biographical essaysread online

Selected articles

• Morgan, Edmund S. (1937). "The Case against Anne Hutchinson".The New England Quarterly.10(4): 635–649.doi:10.2307/359929.JSTOR359929.
• Morgan, Edmund S. (1942). "The Puritans and Sex".The New England Quarterly.15(4): 591–607.doi:10.2307/361501.JSTOR361501.
• Morgan, Edmund S. (1948). "Colonial Ideas of Parliamentary Power 1764-1766".The William and Mary Quarterly.5(3): 311–341.doi:10.2307/1923462.JSTOR1923462.
• Morgan, Edmund S. (1948). "Thomas Hutchinson and the Stamp Act".The New England Quarterly.21(4): 459–492.doi:10.2307/361566.JSTOR361566.
• Morgan, Edmund S. (1950). "The Postponement of the Stamp Act".The William and Mary Quarterly.7(3): 353–392.doi:10.2307/1917228.JSTOR1917228.
• Morgan, Edmund S. (1954). "Ezra Stiles: The Education of a Yale Man, 1742-1746".Huntington Library Quarterly.17(3): 251–268.doi:10.2307/3816428.JSTOR3816428.
• Morgan, Edmund S. (1957). "The American Revolution: Revisions in Need of Revising".The William and Mary Quarterly.14(1): 3–15.doi:10.2307/1917368.JSTOR1917368.
• Morgan, Edmund S. (1957). "Ezra Stiles and Timothy Dwight".Proceedings of the Massachusetts Historical Society.72:101–117.JSTOR25080517.
• Morgan, Edmund S. (1967). "The Puritan Ethic and the American Revolution".The William and Mary Quarterly.24(1): 4–43.doi:10.2307/1920560.JSTOR1920560.
• Morgan, Edmund S. (1971). "The First American Boom: Virginia 1618 to 1630".The William and Mary Quarterly.28(2): 170–198.doi:10.2307/1917308.JSTOR1917308.
• Morgan, Edmund S. (1971). "The Labor Problem at Jamestown, 1607-18".The American Historical Review.76(3): 595–611.doi:10.2307/1851619.JSTOR1851619.
• Morgan, Edmund S. (1972). "Slavery and Freedom: The American Paradox".The Journal of American History.59(1): 5–29.doi:10.2307/1888384.JSTOR1888384.
• Morgan, Edmund S. (1983). "The World and William Penn".Proceedings of the American Philosophical Society.127(5): 291–315.JSTOR986499.
• Morgan, Edmund S. (1986). "Safety in Numbers: Madison, Hume, and the Tenth 'Federalist'".Huntington Library Quarterly.49(2): 95–112.doi:10.2307/3817178.JSTOR3817178.
• Morgan, Edmund S. (1987). "John Winthrop's 'Modell of Christian Charity' in a Wider Context".Huntington Library Quarterly.50(2): 145–151.doi:10.2307/3817255.JSTOR3817255.

Further reading

• Carp, Benjamin L. "Edmund S. Morgan and the Urgency of Good Leadership."Reviews in American History44.1 (2016): 1–18.
• Courtwright, David T. (1987). "Fifty Years of American History: An Interview with Edmund S. Morgan".The William and Mary Quarterly.44(2): 336–369.doi:10.2307/1939669.JSTOR1939669.
• Liddle, William D. "Edmund S. Morgan (1916– )" in Clyde N. Wilson, ed.,Twentieth-Century American Historians(Dictionary of Literary Biography, vol. XVII) (Detroit, 1983), pp 285–95.
• Middlekauff, Robert. “In Memoriam: Edmund S. Morgan 1916-2013.”New England Quarterly96#4 (2013), pp. 685–687.online.
• Murrin, John M. "Edmund S. Morgan," in Robert Allen Rutland, ed.Clio's Favorites: Leading Historians of the United States, 1945–2000U of Missouri Press. (2000) pp 126–137
• Nawotka, Edward (December 2002). "Edmund Morgan: The Historian's Historian".Publishers Weekly.249(49): 57.
• Grimes, William (9 July 2013)."Edmund S. Morgan, Historian Who Shed Light on Puritans, Dies at 97".The New York Times.
• Washington Post obituary
• Boston Globe obituary
• American Historical Association obituary
• Obituary by Thomas Kidd
• Obituary by Jill Lepore

External links

• Morgan Bio at Yale
• Morgan bio on History News Network
• Morgan author page and archivefromThe New York Review of Books
• AppearancesonC-SPAN