Jump to content

Robert V. Bruce

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
Robert Vance Bruce
Born(1923-12-19)December 19, 1923
Malden, Massachusetts,United States
DiedJanuary 15, 2008(2008-01-15)(aged 84)
Alma materUniversity of New Hampshire(B.S.)
Boston University(M.A.,PhD.)
AwardsGuggenheim Fellow(1957)
Huntington LibraryFellow (1966)
President of the Lincoln Group of Boston (1969–74)
Fellow of the Society of American Historians (1974)
R. Gerald McMurtry Lecturer on Abraham Lincoln (1981)
Pulitzer Prize for History(1988)
Fortenbaugh Lecturer atGettysburg College(1989)
Scientific career
FieldsHistory(American Civil War)
InstitutionsUniversity of Bridgeport
Lawrence Academy at Groton
Boston University
University of Wisconsin
Notes

Robert Vance Bruce(December 19, 1923 inMalden, Massachusetts– January 15, 2008 inOlympia, Washington)[1][6]was an American historian specializing in theAmerican Civil War,who won the 1988Pulitzer Prize for Historyfor his bookThe Launching of Modern American Science, 1846–1876(1987).[5]After serving in the Army duringWorld War II,Bruce graduated from theUniversity of New Hampshire,where he earned hisBachelor of Scienceinmechanical engineering.He received hisMaster of Artsin history and hisDoctor of PhilosophyfromBoston University,where he was later a professor.[3][4][6]He also taught at theUniversity of Bridgeport,Lawrence Academy at Groton,and theUniversity of Wisconsin.[6]Bruce was also a lecturer at the Fortenbaugh Lecture atGettysburg College.[7]

Plagiarism controversy

[edit]

In April 1998, Bruce accused Scottish historianJames A. Mackayof plagiarizing his bookBell: Alexander Graham Bell and The Conquest of Solitude,even as Mackay acknowledged Bruce on page 12 of his book.[3][8]Accusations also appeared in the review of Mackay's book byThe Washington Post.[9]By Bruce's own count, 285 pages of Mackay's 297-page bookAlexander Graham Bell: A Lifecontained plagiarisms from his book, including Mackay's acknowledging theNational Geographic Societyand other organizations that had not heard of Mackay. Eventually,John Wiley & Sonstook the book out of print and destroyed any remaining copies at Mackay's expense in exchange for Bruce's promise not to sue.[10]Mackay also later apologized to Bruce.[11]TheAmerican Historical Associationlater found that Mackay had violated itsStatement on Standards of Professional Conduct.[12]

Bibliography

[edit]

Bruce wrote multiple works:[1]

  • Lincoln and the Tools of War(1956)ISBN978-0252060908
  • 1877: Year of Violence(1959)ISBN978-0929587059
  • Two Roads to Plenty: An Analysis of American History(1964)
  • Alexander Graham Bell and the Conquest of Solitude(1973)ISBN9780316112512
  • Alexander Graham Bell: Teacher of the Deaf(1974)
  • Lincoln and the Riddle of Death(1981)
  • The Launching of Modern American Science, 1846–1876(1987)ISBN9780394553948(Pulitzer Prize for History winner)[5]
  • Bruce, Robert;Boritt, Gabor(1988).The Historian's Lincoln: Rebuttals: What the University Press Would Not Print.Gettysburg College.OCLC21762068.
  • The Shadow of A Coming War(1989)
  • Lincoln, the War President: The Gettysburg Lectures(1992) (withGabor Boritt)ISBN9780195078916

References

[edit]
  1. ^abc"Bruce, Robert V. (WorldCat Identities)".OCLC Online Computer Library Center, Inc. 2010.Retrieved2011-09-23.
  2. ^"Obituary Daily Times Results: robert vance bruce".Obituary Times.RootsWeb.Retrieved2011-09-24.
  3. ^abcBlumenthal, Ralph; Sarah Lyall (September 21, 1999)."Repeat Accusations Of Plagiarism Taint Prolific Biographer".The New York Times.Retrieved2011-09-23.
  4. ^abMazzari, Louis (2000)."Literary Sleuthing".University of New HampshireAlumni Association. Archived fromthe originalon 2011-09-25.Retrieved2011-09-23.
  5. ^abc"The Pulitzer Prizes - History".The Pulitzer Prizes. September 2011.Retrieved2011-09-23.
  6. ^abcdFuneral Alternatives of Washington, Inc. (2011)."Funeral Alternatives of Washington - Planning & Services".Funeral Alternatives of Washington, Inc. Archived fromthe originalon 2012-04-02.Retrieved2011-09-24.
  7. ^"Gettysburg College - Past Fortenbaugh Speakers".Gettysburg College.2010.Retrieved2011-09-23.
  8. ^Carvajal, Doreen (June 22, 1998)."Media Talk; Pulitzer-Winning Writer Cries Foul Over a Bell Biography".The New York Times.Retrieved2011-09-23.
  9. ^Shulevitz, Judith (June 11, 1998)."The Bell Curve".Slate.Retrieved2011-09-23.
  10. ^Bruce, Robert V. (July 8, 2002)."Scotching Plagiarism".History News Network.Retrieved2011-09-23.
  11. ^Curran, Jeanne; Takata, Susan R. (1999-09-21)."Plagiarism: A Case of Not Avoiding It".California State University, Dominguez Hills.Retrieved2011-09-24.
  12. ^American Historical Association(March 2001)."Council Decides on Complaint Filed with the Professional Division".Perspectives.39(3). American Historical Association.