Jump to content

Welsh republicanism

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

Welsh republicanism(Welsh:Gweriniaetholdeb Gymreig) orrepublicanism in Wales(Welsh:Gweriniaetholdeb yng Nghymru) is the political ideology that advocates forWalesto be governed by arepublicansystem, as opposed to themonarchy of the United Kingdom.

Typically, this ideology is suggested as an element of forming anindependent Wales,but can also be considered as part ofreforming the political systemof theUnited Kingdom,which could includeintroducing an elected official as head of state.It is not synonymous with Welsh independence, but one possible form of government, asWalesbefore English rule had native monarchies, and most of the prominent independence organisations do not explicitly support republicanism. While theWales Green Partysupports a republic and would support independencein a referendum.

Native monarchies in Wales[edit]

During theMiddle Agesand since theRoman Empireleft the island of Britain, Wales had many monarchical states most notably the kingdoms ofGwynedd,Powys,andDeuheubarth.The most significant Welsh royal house was theHouse of Gwyneddwhich started inc. 401and its cadet branches,Aberffraw,Dinefwr,andMathrafal.[1]

The legendaryKing Arthuris embedded in Welsh tradition and national stories through his battles for Celtic independence from the encroachment of Anglo-Saxon forces. Many Welsh leaders referencedKing Arthur's messianic returnto save the Welsh people and to lead rebellions against England.[citation needed]

Welsh unification fluctuated over time between different kingdoms, including the Anglo-Norman Kingdom of England which held land in southern Wales from the late 11th century.Llywelyn the Greatof Gwynedd formally united Wales at theCouncil of Aberdyfiin 1216 under the Principality of Wales with the title Prince of Wales.[2]The title ofPrince of Waleswas used not as one subservient to a king (as it is now), but to invoke the Roman Imperial title ofprinceps.[citation needed]

Some native Welsh nobles would continue to hold a few positions of power or status in Wales after English conquest.Owain Glyndŵras a member of the House of Mathrafal shortly reasserted Wales and an independent Principality of Wales 1400–1409. The WelshTudors of Penmynyddwere a prominent royal house which supported Glyndŵr, and would then become English monarchs afterHenry VIIwon theWar of the Roses.[3]

English monarchy rule in Wales[edit]

In the 13th century, the last Prince of Wales,Llywelyn the Lastwas forced into an agreement byEdward I of Englandthat saw Llywelyn withdraw his powers to Gwynedd only. In 1282 whilst attempting to gather support in Cilmeri near Builth Wells, Llywelyn was killed by one of Edward's soldiers. Llywelyn's brother,Dafydd ap Gruffyddbriefly led a force in Wales, but was captured and laterhanged, drawn and quarteredby Edward, thus ending Welsh independence.[4][5]

Since conquest, there have beenWelsh rebellions against English rule.The last, and the most significant revolt was theGlyndŵr Risingof 1400–1415, which briefly restored independence.Owain Glyndŵrheld the first Welsh parliament (Senedd) inMachynllethin 1404 where he was proclaimed Prince of Wales and a second parliament in 1405 inHarlech.Following the eventual defeat of the Glyndŵr rebellion and a brief period of independence, it wasn't until 1999 that a Welsh legislative body was re-established as the National Assembly of Wales which was renamedSenedd Cymru/Welsh Parliamentin 2020.[6][7]

In the 16th century, KingHenry VIIIof theTudor dynasty,(a royal house of Welsh origin) and theEnglish parliament,passed theLaws in Wales Acts,also referred to as the "Acts of Union", which incorporated Wales fully into theKingdom of England.[8]

History of republicanism in Wales[edit]

20th century[edit]

Cliff Bere, a founder of theWelsh Republican Movement,stated in the early 1950s, "The English Crown still forms an important part of the English machinery of domination, accusing politicians of all hues of being willing to avail themselves of the English crown's usefulness… as a means of maintaining domination upon the Celtic nations of Britain".[9]

The1969 investitureofCharles, Prince of Wales,saw strong opposition from Welsh nationalists, with the situation described before the investiture as "something close to open warfare between the Government's police and young people of Wales".[10]

TheWelsh Socialist Republican Movementwas a short lived political group that emerged following the1979 devolution referendumwhich campaigned for anindependentand socialist Welsh independent republic.[11]

The song "Charles Windsor" by the English indie pop bandMcCarthywas covered by the Welsh rock bandManic Street Preacherson their 1994 EPLife Becoming a Landslide.It includes lyrics describing the deposing of Charles.[12]

21st century[edit]

Wales' largest pro-independence party,Plaid CymruandGwlad,both have a neutral position and propose a referendum after independence on the future status of the monarchy in Wales. Plaid Cymru has a number of republican members and supporters, including former party leaderLeanne Wood.[13][14]

Bethan SayedMS argued in 2019 that Senedd members should not have to swear an oath of allegiance to the queen, and instead should be allowed to swear an oath of allegiance, loyalty and service to the people of Wales.[15]

In September 2021, the pressure groupRepubliccrowdfunded billboards across Britain calling for the abolition of the monarchy, with billboards appearing in Wales in Aberdare, Swansea and Cardiff declaring in bothWelshandEnglishthat "Wales doesn't need a prince", referring to Charles.[16][17]

TheWales Green Partysupport a Welsh republic in the event that Wales becomes independent.[18]The party has stated that if a referendum were to be held on the matter of Welsh independence then it would support Welsh independence.[19]

PropelandSovereign Walesdo not hold a position on the monarchy or a future Head of State in an independent Wales,[20][21]whilstSocialist Party Walesadvocate a 'socialist Wales as part of a socialist federation of Wales, England, Scotland and Ireland'.[22]

2022[edit]

First minister of Wales,Mark Drakefordhas stated that there will be future discussions about an elected head of state in Wales, but "not this week" during the period of mourning for the Queen.[23]

A minority of crowd of protesters opposed to the British monarch attended events in Cardiff that proclaimed the accession ofCharles III.[24]Upon Charles' visit toCardiff Castle,a silent protest against the monarchy will be held by trade unions,Labour for an Independent Walesand equality campaigners, led byBethan Sayed.[25]

CNNdescribed Wales as the most 'hostile' country to Charles' visit. One man said: "While we struggle to heat our homes, we have to pay for your parade." King Charles sighed, saying "oh" and turned away. The man then said "We pay £100 million a year for you, and for what?". Protestors outsideCardiff Castleheld banners including the phrases "Abolish the Monarchy", "Citizen not subject", "Democracy now".[26]

Senedd member forMid and West Wales region,[27]Cefin Campbellasked in the current "more inclusive" and "egalitarian" society, whether "we need a monarchy at all".[28]

Laura McAllister,Welsh academic, formerinternational footballerand senior sports administrator has said of the monarchy, "I'm a republican but, if I'm honest, it's pretty low on my own list of priorities. A hereditary sovereign most definitely isn't the representation of my nation that I'd choose, but I care more about poverty, education and climate change than I do about this particular debate."[29]

Prince of Wales[edit]

ThePrince Charles's 1969 investiturewas "largely welcomed" in Wales,[30]but protests also took place in the days leading up to the ceremony.[31][32]Multiple Welsh organisations and individuals were against the event, includingDafydd Iwan,[33]Edward Millward,[34]Cofia 1282 ('Remember 1282'),[35]and theWelsh Language Society.[36]On the day of the investiture, a few protesters were arrested.[37]

Since then, further prominent organisations and figures in Wales have called for an end to the titlePrince of Wales.This includesPlaid CymruMP,Adam Price,who called in 2006 for a referendum to end thePrince of Walestitle.[38]Welsh actorMichael Sheenreturned hisOBEin 2017, so he could campaign to end the title.[39]

FollowingCharles III's accession to the throne on 8 September 2022, LordDafydd Elis-Thomassuggested to the media that the Prince of Wales title had "no meaning to it in the constitution" and could be discontinued.[40]When the title was passed toPrince Williamwithin a few days, further opposition was voiced.[41]The campaign group,Republic,raised £25,000 to put up billboards declaring "Wales doesn't need a prince".[42]A petition was launched calling for the abolition of the title 'Prince of Wales', which had received over 35,000 signatures.[43]First MinisterMark Drakeford,[44]Adam Price MS,[45]Jane DoddsMS,[46]andYesCymru[47]acknowledged a potential for a debate or have suggested potential for Welsh decision. On the 6 October,Gwynedd Council,the local authority where Charles was invested, voted to declare opposition to the title of 'Prince of Wales' and against holding another investiture in Wales.[48]

Welsh republicans[edit]

Politics[edit]

Arts[edit]

Activists[edit]

Public opinion[edit]

In 2019, a Focaldata poll commissioned byUnHerdrevealed that support for theBritish royal familyin Wales ( "I am a strong supporter of the continued reign of the Royal Family" ) was lowest inSwansea Eastat 40% (21% opposed) and highest inMontgomeryshireat 61% (18% opposed), with no overall figures for Wales available.[68]

The latest poll byYouGovwas held in March 2022. The poll asked 3,041 people in Wales for their views on the monarchy which showed that 55% support the monarchy whilst 28% would prefer an elected head of state (66.3% versus 33.7% excluding don't knows/ambivalent).[69]

An opinion poll by Omnisis in February 2022 showed 52% in favour of the monarchy and 48% against.[70]An opinion poll by Omnisis in May 2022 showed 57% supporting the monarchy and 43% against in Wales, but only had 42 people in Wales in the sample.[70][71][72]

Graphical summary[edit]

Table of public opinion in Wales on theMonarchy
Polling date Polling organisation and client Sample size Support the
monarchy
Support an
elected
head of state
Do not know Lead
3–15 March 2023 Lord Ashcroft[73] 659 54% 23% 23% 31%
17–23 February 2023 YouGov / WalesOnline[74] 1,083 52% 28% 11% 25%
March 2022 YouGov / Cardiff University[69] 3,041 55% 28% 17% 27%
November 2019 Focaldata / Unherd[75] 21,119 (UK)

(Wales not specified)

48% 25% 28% 23%
7–23 February 2019 ICM Unlimited / BBC Wales[76] 1,000 62% 18% 2% 44%
May 2018 DeltaPoll / Policy Exchange[77][78] 513 49% 18% 6% 31%
12–24 June 2009 Beaufort Research / BBC[79][80] 922 59% 29% - 30%
1999 Beaufort Research / BBC[81] 1,000 62% - - -

By age (2023)[74][edit]

Age group Support the
monarchy
Support an
elected
head of state
Do not know Lead
16–24 28% 20%
25–49 43% 28% 15%
50–64 61%
65+ 69% 20% 49%

Opinion polls on the title Prince of Wales in Wales[edit]

Date(s) conducted Polling organisation and client Sample size Support Oppose Undecided Other Lead Note
15–23 March 2023 Lord Ashcroft[73] 659 51% 32% 17% 19% "Some argue that the Prince and Princess of Wales have no real connection to Wales, and that the titles should be abolished. Others think it is a valuable"
20–22 September 2022[82] YouGov / Barn Cymru 1,014 66% 22% 12% 44% Non-standard question:Do you support or oppose Prince William being titled Prince of Wales?
June 2022[83] YouGov / ITV 46% 31% 23% 15%
2019[84][85] ICM / BBC Wales 50% 22% 28% 28%
2018[86] YouGov / ITV Wales 57% 22% 16% Neither: 5% 35%
12–24 June 2009[79][80] BBC 922 58% 26% 42% 32%
1999[81] Beaufort Research / BBC Wales 73% 27% 46% Opposition and don't knows not specified.

Non-standard sample:onlyWelsh speakersasked.

See also[edit]

Wales[edit]

Other[edit]

References[edit]

  1. ^Price, Huw (2010).The Acts of Welsh Rulers, 1120-1283.University of Wales Press.ISBN978-0-7083-2387-8.
  2. ^"BBC Wales - History - Themes - Chapter 7: The Emergence of the Principality of Wales".www.bbc.co.uk.Retrieved8 December2023.
  3. ^"Tudor Family Origins in North Wales".tudorhistory.org.Retrieved8 December2023.
  4. ^"Kings and Princes of Wales".Historic UK.Retrieved8 February2022.
  5. ^"BBC Wales - History - Themes - Chapter 8: The end of Welsh independence".www.bbc.co.uk.Retrieved6 July2022.
  6. ^"OwainGlyndwr - Parliaments".www.owain-glyndwr.wales.Retrieved8 February2022.
  7. ^"Welsh assembly renamed Senedd Cymru/Welsh Parliament".BBC News.6 May 2020.Retrieved13 June2022.
  8. ^"Wales under the Tudors".History.UK: BBC. 15 October 2010.Retrieved29 December2010.
  9. ^Wiliam, Mari Elin (2022)."Monarchy and National Identity: Wales and the 1953 Coronation".Cultural and Social History.19(3): 301–322.doi:10.1080/14780038.2022.2060903.ISSN1478-0038.
  10. ^Deacon, Thomas (24 February 2019)."Prince Charles, the investiture and the bombs: How Welsh nationalists tried to stop it".Wales Online.Retrieved24 September2022.
  11. ^Jones, Douglas (15 October 2017).The Communist Party of Great Britain and the National Question in Wales, 1920-1991.University of Wales Press. p. 258.ISBN978-1-78683-132-3.
  12. ^"When a young Charles was crowned Prince of Wales — and spoke in Welsh".Washington Post.ISSN0190-8286.Retrieved6 October2022.
  13. ^Wyn Jones, Richard (14 May 2018)."Severn bridge shows Plaid should embrace republicanism".WalesOnline.
  14. ^"[:cy]Maniffesto[:en]Manifesto[:]".
  15. ^"Call for alternative to Welsh Assembly oath to Queen".BBC News.27 April 2019.Retrieved21 February2022.
  16. ^"'Wales doesn't need a prince': Anti-monarchy billboards spark backlash ".Sky News.16 September 2021.Retrieved21 February2022.
  17. ^Harrison, Rhodri (14 September 2021)."Prince Charles appears on billboards with slogan 'Wales doesn't need a prince'".WalesOnline.Retrieved21 February2022.
  18. ^"Public Administration".policy.greenparty.org.uk.
  19. ^Wales Green Party [@WalesGreenParty] (24 October 2020)."Today, Wales Green Party has committed to campaigning in favour of an Independent Wales in the event of a referendum. A huge thanks to all those who helped create and pass this motion!"(Tweet).Retrieved24 October2020– viaTwitter.
  20. ^"The WNP Statement".Archived fromthe originalon 29 November 2020.Retrieved23 November2021.
  21. ^"Manifesto – Cymru Sovereign".Archived fromthe originalon 6 May 2021.Retrieved23 November2021.
  22. ^Thraves, Alec."What We Stand For".Socialist Party Wales.
  23. ^"Drakeford: 'There's no rush' for an investiture for new Prince of Wales".ITV News.12 September 2022.Retrieved14 September2022.
  24. ^PA (11 September 2022)."Anti-royalist demonstrators at Scotland, Wales events".RTÉ.
  25. ^"King Charles III: Public invited to greet monarch in Cardiff".BBC News.15 September 2022.Retrieved15 September2022.
  26. ^"Watch: Protestor challenges King Charles over cost of monarchy as CNN describes Wales as most 'hostile' country".Nation.Cymru.16 September 2022.Retrieved14 September2022.
  27. ^Hotchin, Becky (8 May 2021)."Senedd Election: Regional seats announced".South Wales Guardian.Retrieved8 May2021.
  28. ^"Prince of Wales announcement was divisive, says senior Plaid politician".BBC News.22 September 2022.Retrieved24 September2022.
  29. ^McAllister, Laura (1 October 2022)."The future of the monarchy merits proper debate".WalesOnline.Retrieved14 October2022.
  30. ^Berry-Waite, Lisa (22 May 2022)."The Investiture of the Prince of Wales".The National Archives blog.
  31. ^Ellis, John Stephen (2008).Investiture: Royal Ceremony and National Identity in Wales, 1911-1969.University of Wales Press. p. 207.ISBN978-0-7083-2000-6.
  32. ^"50 years since the Investiture".National Library of Wales Blog.1 July 2019.Retrieved11 September2022.
  33. ^Jones, Craig Owen (Summer 2013).""Songs of Malice and Spite"?: Wales, Prince Charles, and an Anti-Investiture Ballad of Dafydd Iwan ".Music and Politics.7(2).doi:10.3998/mp.9460447.0007.203.hdl:2027/spo.9460447.0007.203.ISSN1938-7687.
  34. ^"Prince Charles' Wales Investiture Was As Controversial As 'The Crown' Shows".Bustle.Retrieved8 September2022.
  35. ^"50 years since the Investiture".National Library of Wales Blog.1 July 2019.Retrieved8 September2022.
  36. ^Ellis, John Stephen (2008).Investiture: Royal Ceremony and National Identity in Wales, 1911-1969.University of Wales Press. p. 206.ISBN978-0-7083-2000-6.
  37. ^Stephen), Ellis, John S. (John (2008).Investiture: royal ceremony and national identity in Wales, 1911-1969.University of Wales Press. p. 235.OCLC647632453.{{cite book}}:CS1 maint: multiple names: authors list (link)
  38. ^"Plaid Cymru objections to Prince of Wales".Western Mail.8 August 2006.Retrieved18 October2022.
  39. ^"Michael Sheen returned OBE to air views on royal family".the Guardian.29 December 2020.Retrieved8 September2022.
  40. ^"'Devolved, democratic' Wales doesn't 'need' a Prince of Wales any more says Lord Elis-Thomas ".Nation.Cymru.8 September 2022.Retrieved8 September2022.
  41. ^"Declaring a new Prince of Wales with no discussion with the people of Wales wasn't right".Nation.Cymru.10 September 2022.Retrieved10 September2022.
  42. ^"'Wales doesn't need a prince': Anti-monarchy billboards spark backlash ".Sky News.Retrieved21 February2022.
  43. ^"Prince and Princess of Wales 'quell concerns' over investiture".27 September 2022.
  44. ^Hayward, Will (16 September 2022)."Mark Drakeford says 'We need to have a debate about the Prince of Wales'".WalesOnline.Retrieved6 October2022.
  45. ^Owen, Cathy (13 September 2022)."Plaid leader wants vote on William's investiture as Prince of Wales".WalesOnline.Retrieved6 October2022.
  46. ^"Prince William will be the last Prince of Wales, historian predicts".ITV News.22 September 2022.Retrieved24 September2022.
  47. ^"YesCymru statement - Prince of Wales".YesCymru EN.13 September 2022.Retrieved21 September2022.
  48. ^"Gwynedd says no to new Prince of Wales - authority votes against another investiture, says title should be abolished".Nation.Cymru.6 October 2022.Retrieved6 October2022.
  49. ^"Mark Drakeford on drugs, the monarchy and his vision for Wales, as he launches his manifesto".ITV News.12 November 2018.Retrieved8 May2019.
  50. ^Wheeler, Brian (24 September 2014)."Secret life of Labour's republicans".BBC News.Retrieved8 May2019.
  51. ^abcd"Our Supporters Include..."Republic.Archived fromthe originalon 26 September 2009.
  52. ^Bodden, Tom (4 June 2011)."Plaid Cymru AMs to snub Queen's official opening of Welsh Assembly".North Wales Live.Retrieved12 September2022.
  53. ^WalesOnline (30 October 2022)."'Westminster could learn something from the Royals about how to treat Wales'".WalesOnline.Retrieved6 December2022.
  54. ^"'I'm a republican' says Ken Skates as he defends 'Prince of Wales Bridge' name change ".Nation.Cymru.16 May 2018.Retrieved12 September2022.
  55. ^"Who is Leanne Wood? A profile of the Plaid Cymru leader".29 May 2017 – via www.bbc.co.uk.
  56. ^Wintour, Patrick (4 March 1996). "Blair dogged by monarchy debate".The Guardian.ProQuest187860918.
  57. ^Kingsley Martin,The Crown and the Establishment.London, Hutchinson (p.137-39)
  58. ^McAllister, Laura (1 October 2022)."The future of the monarchy merits proper debate".WalesOnline.Retrieved3 October2022.
  59. ^Richardson, Jay."Lloyd Langford: Old Fashioned: Reviews 2014: Chortle: The UK Comedy Guide".www.chortle.co.uk.Retrieved13 June2019.
  60. ^Ballin, Malcolm (2013).Welsh periodicals in English, 1882-2012.Cardiff: University of Wales Press.ISBN978-1783165612.
  61. ^Moore, Dylan (7 June 2022)."Coronation Everest: A Welsh republican at the summit of monarchy and imperial adventure".The National (Wales).Archived fromthe originalon 31 December 2022.Retrieved12 September2022.Writing to mark the fiftieth anniversary of the expedition in 2003, Morris wryly observes that her role in reporting the successful ascent was "very improbabl[e], for I am a lifelong republican", nevertheless describing the coincidence of the queen's coronation and the breaking news of Everest's conquest as 'a happy conjunction'.
  62. ^Gwyn A. Williams, Review ofThe Enchanted Glassby Tom Nairn. Marxism Today, July 1988. (p. 43)
  63. ^"Republicans to protest at royal visit".Wales Online.25 April 2012.Retrieved13 June2019.
  64. ^Foster, Charles Robert (1980).Nations without a State: ethnic minorities in Western Europe.Michigan: Praeger.ISBN0030568072.
  65. ^"Laochra Uladh: Meanwhile in Wales -" Timeline of Welsh Events, 1946-1956 "".Laochra Uladh.2 June 2013.
  66. ^Luain, Cathal Ó."Rare Film Footage of Max and Welsh at 1916 Rising Fiftieth Anniversary".Agence Bretagne Presse(in French).Retrieved13 June2019.
  67. ^Gossedge, Rob; Morra, Irene, eds. (2016).The new Elizabethan age: culture, society and national identity after World War II.I.B.Tauris.ISBN978-0857728678.
  68. ^"Support for Royals lower across west Wales and valleys, poll shows".Nation.Cymru.21 November 2019.Retrieved21 February2022.
  69. ^ab"Platinum Jubilee: How strong is Wales' bond with the monarchy?".BBC News.31 May 2022.Retrieved2 June2022.
  70. ^abBright, Sam (1 June 2022)."A Nation Split on the Monarchy".Byline Times.Retrieved3 June2022.
  71. ^"Support for elected head of state highest in Wales and Scotland, poll suggests".Nation.Cymru.3 June 2022.Retrieved3 June2022.
  72. ^"Jubilee".Omnisis Ltd.Retrieved3 June2022.
  73. ^ab"Lord Ashcroft Polls: Majority of Welsh Voters Back the Monarchy Ahead of Coronation".PR Newswire(Press release). UK. 3 May 2023.
  74. ^abSummer, Ben (2 March 2023)."Poll shows King Charles has support in Wales but the future is less certain".WalesOnline.Retrieved4 March2023.
  75. ^Clements, Laura (22 November 2019)."The areas of Wales that love the Royal Family the most (and the least)".WalesOnline.Retrieved3 June2022.
  76. ^"BBC Wales: St. David's Day Poll 2019"(PDF).
  77. ^Monarchy & Union Poll(PDF).DeltaPoll. 2018.
  78. ^"Support for the Union and the Monarchy (Wales)".Deltapoll.22 May 2018.Retrieved10 November2022.
  79. ^ab"Poll shows support for monarchy".BBC News Online.30 June 2009.Retrieved18 September2022.
  80. ^ab"Monarchy backed by 59% in Wales".30 June 2009.Retrieved19 September2022.
  81. ^ab"Wales backs Charles for king".BBC News Online.25 June 1999.Retrieved18 September2022.
  82. ^"YouGov / Barn Cymru Survey Results"(PDF).YouGov.22 September 2022.
  83. ^"Only 46% want another Prince of Wales after Charles, poll suggests".Nation.Cymru.22 June 2022.Retrieved18 September2022.
  84. ^"Buckingham Palace event marks Prince of Wales' 50 years".BBC News.7 March 2019.Retrieved18 September2022.
  85. ^Jackson, Gregor (7 March 2019)."BBC Wales - St. David's Day Poll 2019 (2)".icmunlimited.Retrieved18 September2022.
  86. ^"ITV News Poll: Should Charles be the last Prince of Wales?".ITV News.ITV. 6 July 2018.Retrieved18 September2022.