Political cartoon

Apolitical cartoon,also known as aneditorial cartoon,is acartoongraphic withcaricaturesof public figures, expressing the artist's opinion. An artist who writes and draws such images is known as aneditorial cartoonist.They typically combine artistic skill,hyperboleandsatirein order to either questionauthorityor draw attention tocorruption,political violenceand othersocial ills.^[1]^[2]

Developed in England in the latter part of the 18th century, the political cartoon was pioneered byJames Gillray,^[3]although his and others in the flourishing English industry were sold as individual prints in print shops. Founded in 1841, the British periodicalPunchappropriated the termcartoonto refer to its political cartoons, which led to the term's widespread use.^[4]

History

Origins

The pictorial satire has been credited as the precursor to the political cartoons in England: John J. Richetti, inThe Cambridge history of English literature, 1660–1780,states that "English graphic satire really begins with Hogarth'sEmblematical Print on the South Sea Scheme".^[7]^[8]William Hogarth's pictures combined social criticism with sequential artistic scenes. A frequent target of his satire was the corruption of early 18th century British politics. An early satirical work was anEmblematical Print on the South Sea Scheme(c. 1721), about the disastrous stock market crash of 1720 known as theSouth Sea Bubble,in which many English people lost a great deal of money.^[9]

His art often had a strong moralizing element to it, such as in his masterpiece of 1732–33,A Rake's Progress,engraved in 1734. It consisted of eight pictures that depicted the reckless life of Tom Rakewell, the son of a rich merchant, who spends all of his money on luxurious living, services from sex workers, and gambling—the character's life ultimately ends inBethlem Royal Hospital.^[10]

However, his work was only tangentially politicized and was primarily regarded on its artistic merits. George Townshend, 1st Marquess Townshend produced some of the first overtly political cartoons and caricatures in the 1750s.^[8]^[11]

Development

The medium began to develop in England in the latter part of the 18th century—especially around the time of theFrench Revolution—under the direction of its great exponents,James GillrayandThomas Rowlandson,both from London. Gillray explored the use of the medium for lampooning andcaricature,and has been referred to as the father of the political cartoon.^[3]Calling the king, prime ministers and generals to account, many of Gillray's satires were directed againstGeorge III,depicting him as a pretentious buffoon, while the bulk of his work was dedicated to ridiculing the ambitions of Revolutionary France andNapoleon.^[3]The times in which Gillray lived were peculiarly favourable to the growth of a great school of caricature. Party warfare was carried on with great vigour and not a little bitterness; and personalities were freely indulged in on both sides. Gillray's incomparable wit and humour, knowledge of life, fertility of resource, keen sense of the ludicrous, and beauty of execution, at once gave him the first place among caricaturists.^[13]

George Cruikshankbecame the leading cartoonist in the period following Gillray (1820s–40s). His early career was renowned for his social caricatures of English life for popular publications. He gained notoriety with his political prints that attacked the royal family and leading politicians and was bribed in 1820 "not to caricature His Majesty" (George IV) "in any immoral situation". His work included a personification of England namedJohn Bullwho was developed from about 1790 in conjunction with other British satirical artists such as Gillray and Rowlandson.^[14]

Cartoonist's magazines

The art of the editorial cartoon was further developed with the publication of the British periodicalPunchin 1841, founded byHenry Mayhewand engraverEbenezer Landells(an earlier magazine that published cartoons wasMonthly Sheet of Caricatures,printed from 1830 and an important influence onPunch).^[15]It was bought byBradbury and Evansin 1842, who capitalised on newly evolving mass printing technologies to turn the magazine into a preeminent national institution. The term "cartoon"to refer to comic drawings was coined by the magazine in 1843; the Houses of Parliament were to be decorated with murals, and" carttons "for the mural were displayed for the public; the term" cartoon "then meant a finished preliminary sketch on a large piece of cardboard, orcartonein Italian.Punchhumorously appropriated the term to refer to its political cartoons, and the popularity of thePunchcartoons led to the term's widespread use.^[4]

Artists who published inPunchduring the 1840s and 50s includedJohn Leech,Richard Doyle,John TennielandCharles Keene.This group became known as "ThePunchBrotherhood ", which also included Charles Dickens who joined Bradbury and Evans after leavingChapman and Hallin 1843.Punchauthors and artists also contributed to another Bradbury and Evans literary magazine calledOnce A Week(est.1859), created in response to Dickens' departure fromHousehold Words.^{[citation needed]}

The most prolific and influential cartoonist of the 1850s and 60s wasJohn Tenniel,chief cartoon artist forPunch,who perfected the art of physical caricature and representation to a point that has changed little up to the present day. For over five decades he was a steadfast social witness to the sweeping national changes that occurred during this period alongside his fellow cartoonistJohn Leech.The magazine loyally captured the general public mood; in 1857, following theIndian Rebellionand the public outrage that followed,Punchpublished vengeful illustrations such as Tenniel'sJusticeandThe British Lion's Vengeance on the Bengal Tiger.^{[citation needed]}

Maturation

By the mid-19th century, major political newspapers in many countries featured cartoons designed to express the publisher's opinion on the politics of the day. One of the most successful wasThomas Nastin New York City, who imported realistic German drawing techniques to major political issues in the era of the Civil War and Reconstruction. Nast was most famous for his 160 editorial cartoons attacking the criminal characteristics ofBoss Tweed's political machine in New York City. American art historianAlbert Boimeargues that:

As a political cartoonist, Thomas Nast wielded more influence than any other artist of the 19th century. He not only enthralled a vast audience with boldness and wit, but swayed it time and again to his personal position on the strength of his visual imagination. Both Lincoln and Grant acknowledged his effectiveness in their behalf, and as a crusading civil reformer he helped destroy the corrupt Tweed Ring that swindled New York City of millions of dollars. Indeed, his impact on American public life was formidable enough to profoundly affect the outcome of every presidential election during the period 1864 to 1884.^[16]

Notable editorial cartoons includeBenjamin Franklin'sJoin, or Die(1754), on the need for unity in the American colonies;The Thinkers Club(1819), a response to the surveillance and censorship of universities in Germany under theCarlsbad Decrees;andE. H. Shepard'sThe Goose-Step(1936), on therearmament of GermanyunderAdolf Hitler.The Goose-Stepis one of a number of notable cartoons first published in the BritishPunchmagazine.^{[citation needed]}

Recognition

Institutions which archive and document editorial cartoons include theCenter for the Study of Political Graphicsin the United States,^[17]and theBritish Cartoon Archivein the United Kingdom.^[18]

Editorial cartoons andeditorial cartoonistsare recognised by a number of awards, for example thePulitzer Prize for Editorial Cartooning(for US cartoonists, since 1922) and theBritish Press Awards' "Cartoonist of the Year".^{[citation needed]}

Modern political cartoons

Political cartoons can usually be found on theeditorial pageof many newspapers, although a few (such asGarry Trudeau'sDoonesbury) are sometimes placed on the regularcomic strippage. Most cartoonists use visual metaphors and caricatures to address complicated political situations, and thus sum up a current event with a humorous or emotional picture.^{[citation needed]}

Yaakov Kirschen, creator of the Israeli comic stripDry Bones,says his cartoons are designed to make people laugh, which makes them drop their guard and see things the way he does. In an interview, he defined his objective as a cartoonist as an attempt to "seduce rather than to offend."^[19]

Modern political cartooning can be built around traditional visual metaphors and symbols such asUncle Sam,theDemocratic donkeyand theRepublican elephant.One alternative approach is to emphasize the text or the story line, as seen inDoonesburywhich tells a linear story in comic strip format.^{[citation needed]}

Cartoons have a great potential to political communication capable of enhancing political comprehension and reconceptualization of events, through specific frames of understanding. Mateus' analysis "seems to indicate that the double standard thesis can be actually applied to trans-national contexts. This means that the framing of politics and business may not be limited to one country but may reflect a political world-view occurring in contemporary societies. From the double standard standpoint, there are no fundamental differences in the way Canadian political cartoonists and Portuguese political cartoons assess politics and business life". The paper does not tell that all political cartoons are based on this kind of double standard, but suggests that the double standard thesis in Political Cartoons may be a frequent frame among possible others.^[20]

A political cartoon commonly draws on two unrelated events and brings them together incongruously for humorous effect. The humour can reduce people's political anger and so serves a useful purpose. Such a cartoon also reflects real life and politics, where a deal is often done on unrelated proposals beyond public scrutiny.^{[citation needed]}

Pocket cartoons

A pocket cartoon is a form of cartoon which generally consists of a topical political gag/joke and appears as a single-panel single-column drawing. It was introduced byOsbert Lancasterin 1939 at theDaily Express.^[21]A 2005 obituary byThe Guardianof its pocket cartoonistDavid Austinsaid "Newspaper readers instinctively look to the pocket cartoon to reassure them that the disasters and afflictions besetting them each morning are not final. By taking a sideways look at the news and bringing out the absurd in it, the pocket cartoonist provides, if not exactly a silver lining, then at least a ray of hope."^[22]

Controversies related to cartoons

Editorial cartoons sometimes cause controversies.^[23]Examples include theJyllands-PostenMuhammad cartoons controversyandCharlie Hebdo shooting(stemming from the publication of cartoons related toIslam) and the2007 Bangladesh cartoon controversy.^{[citation needed]}

Libel lawsuits have been rare. In Britain, the first successful lawsuit against a cartoonist in over a century came in 1921 whenJ.H. Thomas,the leader of theNational Union of Railwaymen(NUR), initiated libel proceedings against the magazine of theBritish Communist Party.Thomas claimed defamation in the form of cartoons and words depicting the events of "Black Friday" —when he allegedly betrayed the locked-out Miners' Federation. Thomas won his lawsuit, and restored his reputation.^[24]

References

^Sterling, Christopher (2009).Encyclopedia of Journalism.Thousand Oaks: Sage Publications, Inc. pp. 253–261.ISBN 978-0-7619-2957-4.
^Shelton, Mitchell."Editorial Cartoons: An Introduction | HTI".hti.osu.edu.Retrieved13 March2024.
^^a ^b ^c"Satire, sewers and statesmen: why James Gillray was king of the cartoon".The Guardian. 16 June 2015.
^^a ^bAppelbaum & Kelly 1981,p. 15.
^J. B. Nichols, 1833 p. 192"PLATE VIII.... Britannia 1763"
^J. B. Nichols, 1833 p. 193"Retouched by the Author, 1763"
^Richetti, John J. (2005).The Cambridge history of English literature, 1660–1780.Cambridge University Press.ISBN 0-521-78144-2.,p. 85.
^^a ^bCharles Press (1981).The Political Cartoon.Fairleigh Dickinson University Press. p. 34.ISBN 9780838619018.
^See Ronald Paulson,Hogarth's Graphic Works(3rd edition, London 1989), no. 43.
^"A Rake's Progress".Sir John Soane's Museum.2012.Retrieved13 December2013.
^Chris Upton."Birth of England's pocket cartoon".Birmingham Post & Mail– via The Free Library.
^Martin Rowson,speaking on The Secret of Drawing, presented byAndrew Graham Dixon,BBCTV
^"James Gillray: The Scourge of Napoleon".HistoryToday.
^Gatrell, Vic.City of Laughter: Sex and Satire in Eighteenth-Century London.New York: Walker & Co., 2006
^"Caricature and cartoon".Encyclopædia Britannica.
^Albert Boime,"Thomas Nast and French Art",American Art Journal(1972) 4#1 pp. 43–65
^"Collection | political-graphics".CSPG.Retrieved28 June2017.
^"British Cartoon Archive at University of Kent".Culture24.Archived fromthe originalon 11 March 2020.Retrieved28 June2017.
^Davis, Barry (31 May 2011)."'Dry Bones': Row shows clash of civilizations, Jerusalem Post ".The Jerusalem Post.Retrieved16 May2014.
^Mateus, Samuel; University, Madeira (2016)."Political Cartoons as communicative weapons – the hypothesis of the" Double Standard Thesis "in three Portuguese cartoons".Estudos em Comunicação(23): 195–221.doi:10.20287/ec.n23.a09.hdl:10400.13/2921.ISSN 1646-4974.
^David Smith,The Observer,23 November 2008,Timeless appeal of the classic joke
^Nicola Jennings and Patrick Barkham,The Guardian,21 November 2005,David Austin: Guardian pocket cartoonist with a sceptically humanist view of the news
^Navasky, Victor S. (12 November 2011)."Why Are Political Cartoons Incendiary?".The New York Times.
^Samuel S. Hyde, "'Please, Sir, he called me" Jimmy!' Political Cartooning before the Law: 'Black Friday,' J.H. Thomas, and the Communist Libel Trial of 1921 ",Contemporary British History(2011) 25#4 pp 521–550

External links

History of CartoonHistory of Cartoon fromToons Mag
American Association of Editorial CartoonistsPolitical cartoons by the members of the American Association of Editorial Cartoonists
TED Talk:The power of cartoons
About: Political Cartoons Archived28 January 2017 at theWayback MachineComprehensive guide to political editorial cartoons on the Web
Globe Cartoon:archived editorial cartoons, searchable by themes and keywords
Using editorial cartoons in the classroomSources, analysis, interpretation (mostly English with some German)
Gettysburg College Civil War Era Digital CollectionContains over 300 Civil War Era political cartoons
The Role ofPuck'sCartoons in Gilded Age Politicsfrom American Studies at the University of Virginia
CartoonMovement: Political Cartoons and Comics Journalism from around the world
"Cartoons in American History" guide to websites
John Tinney McCutcheon Editorial Cartoon Collectionat the University of Missouri
Caricature Maps of World War I Archived11 April 2023 at theWayback Machineby Gayle Olson-Raymer

[Sterling-1] Sterling, Christopher (2009).Encyclopedia of Journalism.Thousand Oaks: Sage Publications, Inc. pp. 253–261.ISBN 978-0-7619-2957-4.

[2] Shelton, Mitchell."Editorial Cartoons: An Introduction | HTI".hti.osu.edu.Retrieved13 March2024.

[Guardian-3] "Satire, sewers and statesmen: why James Gillray was king of the cartoon".The Guardian. 16 June 2015.

[FOOTNOTEAppelbaumKelly198115-4] Appelbaum & Kelly 1981,p. 15.

[5] J. B. Nichols, 1833 p. 192"PLATE VIII.... Britannia 1763"

[6] J. B. Nichols, 1833 p. 193"Retouched by the Author, 1763"

[7] Richetti, John J. (2005).The Cambridge history of English literature, 1660–1780.Cambridge University Press.ISBN 0-521-78144-2.,p. 85.

[Press-8] Charles Press (1981).The Political Cartoon.Fairleigh Dickinson University Press. p. 34.ISBN 9780838619018.

[9] See Ronald Paulson,Hogarth's Graphic Works(3rd edition, London 1989), no. 43.

[10] "A Rake's Progress".Sir John Soane's Museum.2012.Retrieved13 December2013.

[11] Chris Upton."Birth of England's pocket cartoon".Birmingham Post & Mail– via The Free Library.

[12] Martin Rowson,speaking on The Secret of Drawing, presented byAndrew Graham Dixon,BBCTV

[13] "James Gillray: The Scourge of Napoleon".HistoryToday.

[14] Gatrell, Vic.City of Laughter: Sex and Satire in Eighteenth-Century London.New York: Walker & Co., 2006

[15] "Caricature and cartoon".Encyclopædia Britannica.

[16] Albert Boime,"Thomas Nast and French Art",American Art Journal(1972) 4#1 pp. 43–65

[17] "Collection | political-graphics".CSPG.Retrieved28 June2017.

[18] "British Cartoon Archive at University of Kent".Culture24.Archived fromthe originalon 11 March 2020.Retrieved28 June2017.

[19] Davis, Barry (31 May 2011)."'Dry Bones': Row shows clash of civilizations, Jerusalem Post ".The Jerusalem Post.Retrieved16 May2014.

[20] Mateus, Samuel; University, Madeira (2016)."Political Cartoons as communicative weapons – the hypothesis of the" Double Standard Thesis "in three Portuguese cartoons".Estudos em Comunicação(23): 195–221.doi:10.20287/ec.n23.a09.hdl:10400.13/2921.ISSN 1646-4974.

[21] David Smith,The Observer,23 November 2008,Timeless appeal of the classic joke

[22] Nicola Jennings and Patrick Barkham,The Guardian,21 November 2005,David Austin: Guardian pocket cartoonist with a sceptically humanist view of the news

[23] Navasky, Victor S. (12 November 2011)."Why Are Political Cartoons Incendiary?".The New York Times.

[24] Samuel S. Hyde, "'Please, Sir, he called me" Jimmy!' Political Cartooning before the Law: 'Black Friday,' J.H. Thomas, and the Communist Libel Trial of 1921 ",Contemporary British History(2011) 25#4 pp 521–550

[1]

[2]

[3]

[4]

[5]

[6]

[7]

[8]

[9]

[10]

[11]

[12]

[13]

[14]

[15]

[16]

[17]

[18]

[19]

[20]

[21]

[22]

[23]

[24]