Jump to content

Hollow Moon

This is a good article. Click here for more information.
Page semi-protected
From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

TheHollow Moonand the closely relatedSpaceship Moonarepseudoscientifichypotheses that propose that Earth'sMoonis either wholly hollow or otherwise contains a substantial interior space. Noscientific evidenceexists to support the idea; seismic observations and other data collected since spacecraft began to orbit or land on the Moon indicate that it has a solid, differentiated interior, with a thincrust,extensivemantle,and a densecorewhich is significantly smaller (in relative terms) than Earth's.

While Hollow Moon hypotheses usually propose the hollow space as the result of natural processes, the related Spaceship Moon hypothesis[1][2]holds that the moon is an artifact created by an alien civilization;[1][2]this belief usually coincides with beliefs inUFOsorancient astronauts.[2]This idea dates from 1970, when two Soviet authors published a short piece in the popular press speculating that the Moon might be "the creation of alien intelligence"; since then, it has occasionally been endorsed by conspiracy theorists likeJim MarrsandDavid Icke.[3][4]

An at least partially hollow Moon has made many appearances inscience fiction,the earliest beingH. G. Wells' 1901 novelThe First Men in the Moon,[1][5]which borrowed from earlier works set in aHollow Earth,such asLudvig Holberg's 1741 novelNiels Klim's Underground Travels.[6][7]

Both the Hollow Moon and Hollow Earth theories are now universally considered to befringeorconspiracy theories.[1]

Claims and rebuttals

Density

The fact that the Moon is less dense than the Earth is advanced by conspiracy theorists as support for claims of a hollow Moon.[8]The Moon's meandensityis 3.3 g/cm3,whereas the Earth's is 5.5 g/cm3.[9]Mainstream science argues this difference is due to the fact that the Earth'supper mantleand crust are less dense than its heavy, iron core.[9][5][10]

The Moon rang like a bell

Between 1969 and 1977,seismometersinstalled on the Moon by theApollo missionsrecordedmoonquakes.The Moon was described as "ringing like a bell" during some of those quakes, specifically the shallow ones.[11]This phrase was brought to popular attention in March 1970[1]in an article inPopular Science.[12]

On November 20, 1969,Apollo 12deliberately crashed the Ascent Stage of itsLunar Moduleonto the Moon's surface; NASA reported that the Moon rang 'like a bell' for almost an hour, leading to arguments that it must be hollow like a bell.[1]Lunar seismology experiments since then have shown that the lunar body has shallow moonquakes that act differently from quakes on Earth, due to differences in texture, type and density of the planetary strata, but there is no evidence of any large empty space inside the body.[11]

Vasin-Shcherbakov "spaceship" conjecture

Speculative cutaway model of a Spaceship Moon

In 1970, Michael Vasin and Alexander Shcherbakov, of theSoviet Academy of Sciences,advanced a hypothesis that the Moon is a spaceship created by unknown beings.[2]The article was entitled "Is the Moon the Creation of Alien Intelligence?" and was published inSputnik,the Soviet equivalent ofReader's Digest.[1][13]The Vasin-Shcerbakov hypothesis was reported in the West that same year.[14]

The authors reference earlier speculation by astrophysicistIosif Shklovsky,who suggested that the Martian moonPhoboswas an artificial satellite and hollow;this has since been shown not to be the case.[15]Skeptical authorJason Colavitopoints out that all of their evidence is circumstantial, and that, in the 1960s, the atheistic Soviet Union promoted theancient astronautconcept in an attempt to undermine the West's faith in religion.[2]

"Perfect" solar eclipses

In 1965, authorIsaac Asimovobserved: "What makes a total eclipse so remarkable is the sheer astronomical accident that the Moon fits so snugly over the Sun. The Moon is just large enough to cover the Sun completely (at times) so that a temporary night falls and the stars spring out. [...] The Sun's greater distance makes up for its greater size and the result is that the Moon and the Sun appear to be equal in size. [...] There is no astronomical reason why Moon and Sun should fit so well. It is the sheerest of coincidence, and only the Earth among all the planets is blessed in this fashion."[16]

Since the 1970s, conspiracy theorists have cited Asimov's observations on solar eclipses as evidence of the Moon's artificiality.[17][18]Mainstream astronomers reject this interpretation. They note that the angular diameters of Sun and Moon vary by several percent over time and do not actually "perfectly" match during eclipses.[19]Nor is Earth the only planet with such a satellite: Saturn's moonPrometheushas roughly the same angular diameter as the Sun when viewed from Saturn.[19]

Some scholars have claimed that "the conditions required for perfect solar eclipses are the same conditions generally acknowledged to be necessary for intelligent life to emerge"; If so, the Moon's size and orbit might be best explained by theweak anthropic principle.[19][20][21]

Scientific perspective

Multiple lines of evidence demonstrate that the Moon is a solid body which formed from an impact between Earth and a planetoid.

Origin of the Moon

Main article:Origin of the Moon

Historically, it was theorized that the Moon originated when a rapidly-spinning Earth expelled a piece of its mass.[22]This was proposed byGeorge Darwin(son of the famous biologistCharles Darwin) in 1879[23]and retained some popularity until Apollo.[22]The Austrian geologistOtto Ampfererin 1925 also suggested the emerging of the Moon as cause forcontinental drift.[24]A second hypothesis argued the Earth and the Moon formed together as a double system from the primordialaccretion diskof theSolar System.[25][26]Finally, a third hypothesis suggested that the Moon may have been a planetoid captured by Earth's gravity.[22][27][28]

The modern explanation for theorigin of the Moonis usually thegiant-impact hypothesis,which argues aMars-sized body struck theEarth,making a debris ring that eventually collected into a singlenatural satellite,theMoon.[29][30]The giant-impact hypothesis is currently the favored scientifichypothesisfor theformation of the Moon.[31]

Internal structure

Schematic cross-section of theinternal structure of the Moon

Multiple lines of evidence disprove that the Moon is hollow.[1][32]One involvesmoment of inertia parameters;the other involvesseismic observations.[1][32]The moment of inertia parameters indicate that the core of the Moon is both dense and small, with the rest of the Moon consisting of material with nearly-constant density. Seismic observations have been made, constraining the thickness of the Moon's crust, mantle and core, demonstrating it could not be hollow.[33]

Mainstream scientific opinion on theinternal structure of the Moonoverwhelmingly supports a solid internal structure with a thin crust, an extensive mantle and a small denser core.[34][35]

Moment of inertia factor

Body Moment
of inertia
factor
Hollow Sphere 0.67
Uniform Sphere 0.4
Denser at Core < 0.4
Moon 0.39
Earth 0.33
All Mass at Core 0.0

Themoment of inertia factoris a number, ranging from 0 to.67, that represents the distribution of mass in a spherical body. A moment of inertia factor of 0 represents a body with all its mass concentrated at its central core, while a factor of.67 represents a perfectly hollow sphere.[36]A moment of inertia factor of 0.4 corresponds to a sphere of uniform density, while factors less than 0.4 represent bodies with cores that are more dense than their surfaces.[37]The Earth, with its dense inner core, has a moment of inertia factor of 0.3307[37]

In 1965, astronomerWallace John Eckertattempted to calculate the lunar moment of inertia factor using a novel analysis of the Moon'sperigeeandnode.[38]His calculations suggested the Moon might be hollow, a result Eckert rejected as absurd.[39]Subsequent analysis revealed Eckert had failed to account for nonuniformity of Earth's rotation in the orbital theory of the Moon.[40]By 1968, other methods had allowed the Moon's moment of inertia factor to be accurately calculated at its accepted value.[41]

From 1969 to 1973,fiveretroreflectorswere installed on the Moon during theApollo program(11,14,and15) andLunokhod 1 and 2 missions.[42]These reflectors made it possible to measurethe distancebetween the surfaces of theEarthand theMoonusing extremely preciselaser ranging.True (physical)librationof the Moon measured viaLunar laser rangingconstrains the moment of inertia factor to 0.394 ± 0.002.[43]This is very close to the value for asolid object with radially constant density,which would be 0.4.[43]

Seismic activity

Main article:Lunar seismology

From 1969 through 1972, Apollo astronauts installed severalseismographicmeasuring systems on the Moon and their data made available to scientists (such as those from theApollo Lunar Surface Experiments Package). The Apollo 11 instrument functioned through August of the landing year. The instruments placed by theApollo 12,14,15,and16missions were functional until they were switched off in 1977.[44][45]

The existence of moonquakes was an unexpected discovery from seismometers. Analysis of lunar seismic data has helped constrain the thickness of the crust (~45 km)[35][46]and mantle, as well as the core radius (~330 km).[34]

Doppler Gravity Experiment

A visualization of the lunar gravity field based onLunar Prospectordata.

In 1998, the United States launched theLunar Prospector,which hosted the Doppler Gravity Experiment (DGE) -- the first polar, low-altitude mapping of the lunar gravity field. TheProspectorDGE obtained data constituted the "first truly operational gravity map of the Moon".[47]The purpose of theLunar ProspectorDGE was to learn about the surface and internal mass distribution of the Moon.[47]This was accomplished by measuring theDoppler shiftin theS-bandtracking signal as it reaches Earth, which can be converted to spacecraft accelerations.[47]The accelerations can be processed to provide estimates of the lunar gravity field. Estimates of the surface and internal mass distribution give information on the crust, lithosphere, andinternal structure of the Moon.[47]

In popular culture

Fiction

Conspiracy theory

  • Don Wilson,Our Mysterious Spaceship Moon(1975) andSecrets of Our Spaceship Moon(1979), inspired by Vasin-Shcherbakov, Wilson popularized the Spaceship Moon hypothesis.[54]
  • George H. Leonard,Somebody Else Is On The Moon(1976) Argues the Moon is inhabited by an Alien race, but NASA has covered up this fact.[55]
  • Fred Steckling,We Discovered Alien Bases on the Moon(1981)[56][55]
  • Jim MarrsAlien Agenda(1997) Long-time JFK conspiracy theorist Marrs embraced the Spaceship Moon conspiracy theory[57]
  • Christopher Knight& Alan Butler,Who Built the Moon?(2005). They suggest humans from the future traveled into the past to build the Moon in order to safeguard human evolution.[58]
  • David Icke,Human Race Get off Your Knees – The Lion Sleeps No More(2010). Icke suggests that the Moon is in fact a space station from whichReptiliansmanipulate human thought.[59]

References

  1. ^abcdefghi"Is the Moon Hollow?".Armagh Planetarium.22 May 2015.Archivedfrom the original on 11 April 2019.Retrieved26 August2016.
  2. ^abcde""Spaceship Moon" and Soviet Scientific Politics ".JasonColavito.23 September 2012.
  3. ^"Taking tea with David Icke, the world's best-known conspiracy theorist".The Sydney Morning Herald.16 July 2016.
  4. ^"Mocked prophet: what is David Icke's appeal?".New Humanist.10 December 2014.
  5. ^abcd"Hollow Moon".Solar System Exploration Research Virtual Institute.2 February 2009.
  6. ^Jerome Hamilton Buckley, ed. (1975).The Worlds of Victorian Fiction.Harvard University Press.p. 412, n. 27.ISBN978-0-674-96205-7.
  7. ^"An Account of the cause of the Change of the Variation of the Magnetic Needle; with an Hypothesis of the Structure of the Internal Pardnerrts of the Earth".Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society of London.III(195). pp. 470–78, esp. p. 475. 1683–1694.doi:10.1098/rstl.1686.0107.
  8. ^"The Strange Origin of the Hollow Moon Conspiracy Theory".18 October 2022.
  9. ^abCain, Fraser (3 November 2008)."Density of the Moon".Universe Today.Retrieved21 November2016.
  10. ^"Why Do We Have a Two-Faced Moon?".Bad Astronomer.1 July 2014.
  11. ^ab"Moonquakes".NASA.15 March 2006. Archived fromthe originalon 18 February 2022.Retrieved29 August2016.
  12. ^Wernher von Braun(March 1970)."How APOLLO 13 Will Probe The Moon's Interior".Popular Science.
  13. ^Dominic Phelan, ed. (2013).Cold War Space Sleuths.Springer-Praxis.p. 34.ISBN978-1-4614-3052-0.
  14. ^"14 Sep 1970, 4 – The Expositor at Newspapers".Newspapers.
  15. ^Öpik, Ernst Julius (March 1963). "News and Comments: Phobos, Nature of Acceleration".Irish Astronomical Journal.6:40.Bibcode:1963IrAJ....6R..40.
  16. ^Isaac Asimov,Of Time And Space 4.The Heavenly Zoo
  17. ^Wilson, Don (March 2, 1979).Secrets of Our Spaceship Moon.Dell.ISBN978-0-440-16550-7– via Google Books.
  18. ^Marrs, Jim (March 22, 2000).Alien Agenda: Investigating the Extraterrestrial Presence Among Us.Harper Collins.ISBN978-0-06-095536-6– via Google Books.
  19. ^abc"23 Jun 1999, 16 – The Daily Telegraph at Newspapers".Newspapers.
  20. ^Gonzalez, G. (1999)."Wonderful eclipses".Astronomy & Geophysics.40(3): 3.18–3.20.doi:10.1093/astrog/40.3.3.18.
  21. ^Gonzalez, Guillermo; Richards, Jay W. (March 1, 2004).The Privileged Planet: How Our Place in the Cosmos Is Designed for Discovery.Simon and Schuster.ISBN978-1-59698-707-4– via Google Books.
  22. ^abc"Lunar Origin. JNot a valid reference must be a Scientifi publication".Archivedfrom the original on 2018-03-23.Retrieved2018-03-23.
  23. ^Wise, D. U. (1966). "Origin of the Moon by Fission". In Marsden, B. G.; Cameron, A. G. W. (eds.).The Earth-Moon System.Boston, MA: Springer. pp. 213–223.doi:10.1007/978-1-4684-8401-4_14.ISBN978-1-4684-8403-8.
  24. ^Ampferer, O. (July 1925). "Über Kontinentverschiebungen".Naturwissenschaften(in German).13(31): 669–675.Bibcode:1925NW.....13..669A.doi:10.1007/BF01558835.S2CID40767867.Fulltextpage 672.
  25. ^The Formation of the Moonburro.cwru.edu
  26. ^"BBC Earth | Home".Bbcearth.
  27. ^"14 Jan 1968, Page 124 – The Philadelphia Inquirer at Newspapers".Newspapers.
  28. ^Cummings, Warren D. (25 September 2019).Evolving Theories on the Origin of the Moon.Springer.ISBN9783030291198.
  29. ^"NASA – NASA Lunar Scientists Develop New Theory on Earth and Moon Formation".Nasa.gov.Archived fromthe originalon 2019-02-23.Retrieved2022-03-02.
  30. ^Staff (September 7, 2014)."Revisiting the Moon".The New York Times.RetrievedSeptember 8,2014.
  31. ^Canup, R.;Asphaug, E. (2001)."Origin of the Moon in a giant impact near the end of the Earth's formation"(PDF).Nature.412(6848): 708–712.Bibcode:2001Natur.412..708C.doi:10.1038/35089010.PMID11507633.S2CID4413525.Archived fromthe original(PDF)on 2010-07-30.Retrieved2011-12-10.
  32. ^ab"About the Ask an Astronomer Team".Ask an Astronomer.Cornell University.14 November 2011. Archived from the original on 4 February 2015.{{cite web}}:CS1 maint: bot: original URL status unknown (link)
  33. ^"Can we prove that the Moon isn't hollow?".Ask an Astronomer.Cornell University. October 2007. Archived from the original on 2008-04-22.{{cite web}}:CS1 maint: bot: original URL status unknown (link)
  34. ^ab"NASA Research Team Reveals Moon Has Earth-Like Core".NASA.6 January 2011. Archived fromthe originalon 11 January 2012.Retrieved7 January2011.
  35. ^abMark Wieczorek and 15 coauthors (2006)."The constitution and structure of the lunar interior"(PDF).Reviews in Mineralogy and Geochemistry.60(1): 221–364.Bibcode:2006RvMG...60..221W.doi:10.2138/rmg.2006.60.3.Archived fromthe original(PDF)on 2014-12-21.{{cite journal}}:CS1 maint: numeric names: authors list (link)
  36. ^Miriam Riner (December 2008).Compositional Variations in the Inner Solar System(Ph.D.).Arizona State University.p. 3.
  37. ^abWilliams, James G. (1994)."Contributions to the Earth's obliquity rate, precession, and nutation".The Astronomical Journal.108:711.Bibcode:1994AJ....108..711W.doi:10.1086/117108.ISSN0004-6256.S2CID122370108.
  38. ^Eckert, W. J. (1965)."1965AJ.....70..787E Page 788".The Astronomical Journal.70:787.Bibcode:1965AJ.....70..787E.doi:10.1086/109818.
  39. ^"18 Apr 1965, Page 1 – Colorado Springs Gazette-Telegraph at Newspapers".Newspapers.
  40. ^Meshcheryakov, G. A.; Zazulyak, P. M.; Kirichuk, V. V. (1976)."1976SvA....20..351M Page 351".Soviet Astronomy.20:351.Bibcode:1976SvA....20..351M.
  41. ^Solomon, Sean C.; Toksöz, M. Nafi (December 1, 1968)."On the density distribution in the moon".Physics of the Earth and Planetary Interiors.1(7): 475–484.Bibcode:1968PEPI....1..475S.doi:10.1016/0031-9201(68)90016-2– via ScienceDirect.
  42. ^Chapront, J.; Chapront-Touzé, M.; Francou, G. (1999). "Determination of the lunar orbital and rotational parameters and of the ecliptic reference system orientation from LLR measurements and IERS data".Astronomy and Astrophysics.343:624–633.Bibcode:1999A&A...343..624C.
  43. ^abAS Konopliv; AB Binder; LL Hood; AB Kucinskas; WL Sjogren; JG Williams (1998). "Improved Gravity Field of the Moon from Lunar Prospector".Science.281(5382): 1476–80.Bibcode:1998Sci...281.1476K.doi:10.1126/science.281.5382.1476.PMID9727968.
  44. ^Nunn, C.; et al. (July 3, 2020)."Lunar Seismology: A Data and Instrumentation Review".Space Science Reviews.216(5): 89.Bibcode:2020SSRv..216...89N.doi:10.1007/s11214-020-00709-3.hdl:20.500.11850/425940.
  45. ^Goins, N. R.; et al. (June 10, 1981). "Lunar seismology – The internal structure of the moon".Journal of Geophysical Research.86:5061.Bibcode:1981JGR....86.5061G.doi:10.1029/JB086iB06p05061.hdl:2060/19790009611.
  46. ^A. Khan; K. Mosegaard (2002)."An inquiry into the lunar interior: A nonlinear inversion of the Apollo lunar seismic data"(PDF).Journal of Geophysical Research.107(E6): 5036.Bibcode:2002JGRE..107.5036K.doi:10.1029/2001JE001658.ISSN0148-0227.
  47. ^abcd"Doppler Gravity Experiment Results".NASA. Archived fromthe originalon July 12, 2008.RetrievedJuly 14,2008.
  48. ^H.G. Wells(1901).The First Men in The Moon.George Newnes Ltd.pp. 285–88.
  49. ^Edgar Rice Burroughs(1926)."2".The Moon Maid.A. C. McClurg.
  50. ^Maria Nikolajeva(2000).From Mythic to Linear: Time in Children's Literature.The Scarecrow Press, Inc.p. 74.ISBN978-0-8108-4952-5.
  51. ^Donald E. Palumbo (2016).An Asimov Companion.McFarland & Company.p. 123.ISBN978-0-7864-9823-9.
  52. ^"David Weber takes readers on a tour Off Armageddon Reef and discusses writing, religion and responsibility".Sci Fi Weekly.7 May 2007. Archived fromthe originalon 29 January 2008.
  53. ^"CAPTURING A COLOSSAL CLOSE ENCOUNTER OF THE LUNAR KIND IN MOONFALL".VFX Voice Magazine.2022-01-10.Retrieved2022-02-21.
  54. ^"2 Nov 1975, Page 62 – Detroit Free Press".Newspapers.Retrieved21 March2022.
  55. ^abDiscussed in Milton Cooper's 1991 conspiracy workBehold a Pale Horse
  56. ^Steckling, Fred (1981).We Discovered Alien Bases on the Moon.F. Steckling.ISBN978-0-942176-00-1.
  57. ^Marrs, Jim (1997).Alien Agenda: Investigating the Extraterrestrial Presence Among Us.HarperCollinsPublishers.ISBN978-0-06-018642-5.
  58. ^"Peer review: Who Built the Moon?".The Guardian.1 September 2005.
  59. ^David G. Robertson (2016).UFOs, Conspiracy Theories and the New Age: Millennial Conspiracism.Bloomsbury Academic.p. 148.ISBN978-1-4742-5322-2.
Retrieved from "https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Hollow_Moon&oldid=1229645242"