LGBT rights in Ecuador
LGBT rights in Ecuador | |
|---|---|
 | |
| Status | Legal since 1997 |
| Gender identity | Transgender people allowed to change legal gender |
| Military | Unknown |
| Discrimination protections | Sexual orientation and gender identity constitutional protections |
| Family rights | |
| Recognition of relationships | Civil unions since 2008 Same-sex marriage since 2019 |
| Adoption | Same-sex couples may not adopt. Single persons not restricted |
Lesbian, gay, bisexual, and transgender (LGBT) rights in Ecuador have evolved significantly in the past decades. Both male and female forms of same-sex sexual activity are legal inEcuadorand same-sex couples can enter intocivil unionsandsame-sex marriages.[1]
In 1998, Ecuador became one of the first countries in the world toconstitutionally bandiscrimination based onsexual orientation.Since 2008,civil unionswith all of the rights of marriage (except for adoption) have been available to same-sex couples. Additionally, transgender people under the 2016Gender Identity Lawmay change their legal gender solely based onself-determination,without undergoingsurgery.Ecuador is also one of the few countries in the world to have bannedconversion therapy.In 2023, there are still hundreds of clinics that promote conversion therapy.[2]
In 2013, gay activist Pamela Troya filed a lawsuit to strike down the country'ssame-sex marriageban. The lawsuit focused mostly on theInter-American Court of Human Rights' ruling inAtala Riffo and Daughters v. Chileand its 2018 opinion on same-sex marriage. TheAtalacase has caused bans on same-sex marriage inMexicoto be struck down andChilepledging to legalise same-sex marriage. Additionally, in January 2018, the Inter-American Court of Human Rights ruled that same-sex marriage is a human right protected by theAmerican Convention on Human Rights.[3]As a result, on 12 June 2019, theConstitutional Courtruled in a 5–4 vote in favor of same-sex marriage, legalising it in Ecuador.[4]
History
[edit]Conquest by theSpanishfrom the mid-16 century onwards introducedChristianity,specificallyRoman Catholicism,and religious mores condemning homosexuality as "sinful" and "immoral" to the region now known as Ecuador. As such, society has typically viewed homosexuality pejoratively. However, this is, or at least was, not the case for many of theindigenous peoples,including theShuar.While the Europeans and the West have typically regardedanal intercourseas a sign of effeminacy, the Shuar perceived it as a sign of trickery. The "passive" partner (chiminiamnijikratin) and the "active" partner (chiminiamnijitiai) were not regarded as feminine. A Shuar myth, known as the story of the fox and the jaguar, involves the fox deceiving the jaguar into having anal sex, but after having discovered the trickery the jaguar chases the fox and bites him.[5]
TheInca Empire's perception of homosexuality is unclear and is the subject of ongoing debate. Most modern-day documentation about the Incas stems from the SpanishInquisition.These reports suggest that male homosexuality was punished in the south and centre of the Inca Empire, possibly by death, but was tolerated in thenorth.According to certain sources, homosexuality and cross-dressing were tolerated "acts of worship", commonly practised in religious rituals and temples.Quariwarmiwere cross-dressingshamans,tasked with performing rituals in honour of Chuqui Hinchay, ajaguardual-gender god.[6]Effeminate men were calledhualmishcuorwarminchuby the Incas. Lesbian relationships seem to have been highly regarded by Inca society. Lesbians (known asholjoshta) enjoyed many privileges and could even participate in combats and were given the possibility of maintaining promiscuous relations between themselves.[7]
Law regarding same-sex sexual activity
[edit]Same-sex sexual activity has been legal in Ecuador since 1997 when theConstitutional Tribunal,inCase No. 111-97-TC,overturned the first paragraph of Article 516 of the Penal Code, which criminalized sexual activities between persons of the same sex.[8]In 2014, a new Organic Integral Penal Code (2014) entered into force, which did not include the criminalising provisions previously struck down by the Constitutional Court.[9]
Theage of consentin Ecuador is 14, regardless ofgenderorsexual orientation.[10]
Recognition of same-sex relationships
[edit]Article 67 of the Ecuadorian Constitution adopted in 2008 limited marriage to the union of a man and a woman.[11][12]However, article 68 provides thatsame-sex couplesin stable and monogamous unions shall enjoy the same rights and obligations as married couples, except for adoption.
The stable and monogamous union between two persons without any other marriage ties who have a common-law home, for the lapse of time and under the conditions and circumstances provided for by law, shall enjoy the same rights and obligations of those families bound by formal marriage ties.
Based on Article 68,civil unionsfor same-sex couples are legal in Ecuador.[13][14]In August 2014, PresidentRafael Correasigned a resolution to allow same-sex couples to register their unions. It also allows civil unions to be registered as a complementary data to marital status and created a special registry for these unions.[15]The order took effect on 15 September.[16]In April 2015, the National Assembly approved an amendment to the Civil Code that codified civil unions into statutory law and deleted the requirement of evidence of cohabitation for at least two years.[17]
2018 Inter-American Court of Human Rights advisory opinion
[edit]On 9 January 2018, theInter-American Court of Human Rights(IACHR) issued anadvisory opinionthat parties to theAmerican Convention on Human Rightsshould grant same-sex couples "accession to all existing domestic legal systems of family registration, including marriage, along with all rights that derive from marriage".[3]
Following the IACHR advisory opinion, which held that same-sex marriage is a human right, two same-sex couples went to the Civil Registry inCuenca,applying for marriage licenses. After both were rejected for not being a different-sex couple, they filed suit in court arguing that the refusal to recognise their marriage was discriminatory, unconstitutional and a violation of the American Convention on Human Rights. Relying on the IACHR advisory opinion, two family judges ruled in the couples' favour on 29 June 2018. The judges ordered the Civil Registry to immediately begin registering same-sex marriages. However, the Civil Registry appealed the decision to the Constitutional Court.[18]On 12 June 2019, the court ruled in favor of same-sex marriage, making it legal throughout the country.[4]
Adoption and parenting
[edit]Article 68 of the Ecuador Constitution states: "La adopción corresponderá sólo a parejas de distinto sexo".[19]An unofficial English language translation of this provision states: "Adoption shall only be permitted for different-sex couples."[12]The Constitution is silent about adoptions by single individuals.
Under Ecuadorian statutory law, however, a single person is allowed to adopt a child, although a legally constituted heterosexual couple has priority over the single person.[Note 2]
In May 2018, theConstitutional Court of Ecuadorordered the Civil Registry to register a seven-year-old girl as the daughter of a lesbian couple. The case, filed in September 2012, sought to have the daughter registered with the surnames of both her mothers.[20]The Court ruled that failing to register the daughter is a violation of children's rights.[21]The vote was 5 to 3, with one abstention.[20]
Discrimination protections
[edit]In 1998, Ecuador became the first country in theAmericas(and only the third worldwide afterSouth AfricaandFiji) to include sexual orientation as a protected category in its Constitution.[8]An unofficial English language translation of Article 11(2) states:
All persons are equal and shall enjoy the same rights, duties and opportunities. No one shall be discriminated against for reasons of ethnic belonging, place of birth, age, sex, gender identity, cultural identity, civil status, language, religion, ideology, political affiliation, legal record, socio-economic condition, migratory status, sexual orientation, health status, HIV carrier, disability, physical difference or any other distinguishing feature, whether personal or collective, temporary or permanent, which might be aimed at or result in the diminishment or annulment of recognition, enjoyment or exercise of rights. All forms of discrimination are punishable by law. The State shall adopt affirmative action measures that promote real equality for the benefit of the rights-bearers who are in a situation of inequality.[12]
In 2015, a labor law reform made it illegal for employers to discriminate against people due to their sexual orientation.[22]
In June 2018, the Justice Ministry approved a new policy concerning the rights of LGBT people. The policy aims to guarantee and strengthen their rights in relation to health, education, work, security, social protection and justice.[23]
Gender identity and expression
[edit]TheGender Identity Law(Spanish:Ley Orgánica de Gestión de la Identidad y Datos Civiles), approved in 2016, allows Ecuadorians to state their gender identity instead of the sex assigned at birth. The law distributes new legal ID cards to those wishing to change their gender and birth name.[24][25]
Conversion therapy
[edit]In November 2011, an Ecuadorean activist group, calledFundación Causana,began a petition onChange.orgto entreat the Ecuadorean Minister of Health to close down more than 200 "ex-gay clinics". The group claimed that the clinics abuse and torture patients in an effort to "cure homosexuality".
The clinics primarily targetedlesbiansand operated under the guise of being drug rehabilitation centers.[26][27]At least one pair of parents discovered the abuse and asked for the clinic to release their daughter, Paola Ziritti, but were denied. Ziritti was eventually released after two years of confinement and was the first to press a formal complaint against the clinics.[27]
Activists consequently called on the Government to close down the clinics, but by August 2011, only 27 had been closed, while a reported 207 clinics remained open.[28]On 23 January 2012, the Change.org petition was closed and marked as a success with 113,761 international signatures. The petition also was updated with a statement fromFundacion Causanareading,
After ten years of outcry, the nation of Ecuador – through the Ministry of Public Health – has entered into a commitment with civic organizations and society in general to deconstruct the belief that homosexuality is an illness and root out the use of torture in these clinics. We extend our thanks to all the men and women who signed our petition. It has been invaluable to have this support in starting to change this reality.
Minister of HealthCarina Vance Maflaordered shortly thereafter three clinics to be raided in the vicinity of Quito and rescued dozens of women.[29]
Consequently, Article 151 of the Penal Code was changed in 2014 to prohibit conversion therapy, equating it to torture. People who undertake thepseudoscientificpractice are punished with seven to ten years imprisonment.[30]
Living conditions
[edit]
A fairly large gay scene has developed inQuitoandGuayaquil.[31]The first gay pride in Ecuador took place in Quito in 1998, following the Constitutional Court ruling that overturned the law which prohibited sexual acts between people of the same sex.[32]Nevertheless, Ecuador has a conservative andmachoculture, and homosexuality tends to be viewed negatively by society.[31]
Since the last decade, many gay pride marches have been organized in all major cities, with the authorization of authorities and police protection, in addition to their participation. In Guayaquil's gay pride march of 2011, for instance, among those present wereGuayas Province's Vice Prefect Luzmila Nicolaide, Guayaquil City Council member Gino Molinari, and member of the National AssemblyGina Godoy,while the police band played traditional songs.[33][34]
There have also been LGBT film festivals organized in the major cities.[35]
TheU.S. Department of State's 2011 Human Rights Report found that,
The constitution includes the principle of nondiscrimination and establishes choice of sexual orientation as a right. Although the law prohibits discrimination based on sexual orientation, gay, lesbian, and transgender persons continued to suffer discrimination from both public and private bodies. LGBT organizations reported that transgender persons suffered more discrimination because they were more visible. LGBT groups claimed that police and prosecutors did not thoroughly investigate deaths of LGBT individuals, including when there was suspicion that the killing was because of sexual orientation or gender identity. LGBT organizations and credible media sources reported that LGBT persons were interned against their will in private treatment centers to "cure" or "dehomosexualize" them, although such treatment is illegal. The clinics reportedly used cruel treatments, including rape, in an attempt to change LGBT persons' sexual orientation. In August[,] the government reported that it closed 30 such centers, but LGBT organizations reported that other illegal clinics continued to operate. Members of the LGBT community continued to report that their right of equal access to formal education was frequently violated. The LGBT population involved in the commercial sex trade reported abusive situations, extortion, and mistreatment by security forces.[36]
In 2012, PresidentRafael CorreaappointedCarina Vance Mafla,a lesbian activist, as the country's Health Minister.[37]
In 2017, approximately 20,000 people marched in the Guayaquil Gay Pride parade. For the first time, the municipality of Guayaquil agreed to light up the Bolivar and San Martin Monument with the colors of the rainbow in support of LGBT rights.[38]In June 2017, the Presidential House was illuminated in rainbow colors.[39]In 2018, more than 18,000 people participated in the Quito Pride march.[40]
2013 election homophobic remarks
[edit]
After the2013 Ecuadorian general election,Nelson Zavala, an evangelical preacher and the presidential candidate who finished last out of the eight candidates, was sentenced by an election court to pay more than $3,000 in fines for his homophobic remarks. The court also prohibited him for a year from standing as a candidate or from affiliating himself or being involved with a political party or movement. During the campaign, he called gay people "sinners" and "immoral" and said they suffered from "severe deviation of conduct." LGBT activists applauded the ruling as "landmark".[41][42]Zavala appealed the verdict, but the ruling was ratified in the last instance on 19 March 2013.[43]
LGBTI candidacy
[edit]In the 2013 elections, LGBTI activistDiane Marie Rodríguez Zambranoof the Silueta X Association (Asociación Silueta X) became the first openly transgender candidate to run for public office.[44][45][46]At the conclusion of her candidacy, Ecuadorian President Rafael Correa Delgado declared his respect and admiration for Rodriquez on Twitter.[47][48][49]Months later, Rodriguez was invited to change the Presidential Guard.[50]In December 2013, she led the first LGBTI group meeting with President Rafael Correa.[51]The meeting concluded with several agreements.[52]In 2017, she was elected to theNational Assembly,becoming the country's first transgender lawmaker.[53]
Summary table
[edit]| Same-sex sexual activity legal |  (Since 1997)
|
| Equal age of consent (14) | (Since 1997)
|
| Anti-discrimination laws in employment only | (Since 1998)
|
| Anti-discrimination laws in the provision of goods and services | (Since 1998)
|
| Anti-discrimination laws in all other areas (incl. indirect discrimination, hate speech) | (Since 1998)
|
| Same-sex marriages | (Since 2019)[54]
|
| Recognition of same-sex couples | (Since 2008)
|
| Adoption for single people regardless of sexual orientation |
|
| Stepchild adoption by same-sex couples | 
|
| Joint adoption by same-sex couples | (Constitutional ban since 2008)
|
| LGBT people allowed to serve openly in the military | (Since 2009)[55]
|
| Right to change legal gender |
|
| Gender identity recognition in identity cards | (Since 2016)[25]
|
| Automatic parenthood for both spouses after birth | (Since 2018)
|
| Access to IVF for lesbians | 
|
| Conversion therapybanned | (Since 2014)
|
| Commercial surrogacy for gay male couples |
|
| MSMsallowed to donate blood | [citation needed]
|
See also
[edit]
- Case No. 111-97-TC
- LGBT rights in the Americas
- Same-sex marriage in Ecuador
- Decriminalization of homosexuality in Ecuador
- Bar Abanicos police raid
- LGBT literature in Ecuador
- Timeline of LGBT history in Ecuador
Notes
[edit]- ^In Spanish, the official version of Article 68 reads as follows:
La unión estable y monogámica entre dos personas libres de vínculo matrimonial que formen un hogar de hecho, por el lapso y bajo las condiciones y circunstancias que señale la ley, generará los mismos derechos y obligaciones que tienen las familias constituidas mediante matrimonio.Article 68, Constitución de la República del Ecuador
- ^"Código de la Niñez y Adolescencia"(in Spanish). 3 January 2003. Archived fromthe originalon 10 January 2015.Retrieved9 April2021.
priorizará la adopción por parte de parejas heterosexuales constituidas legalmente, sobre la adopción por parte de personas solas
References
[edit]- ^"The 203 Worst (& Safest) Countries for LGBTQ+ Travel in 2023".Asher & Lyric.5 June 2023.Retrieved20 August2023.
- ^"Secuestros, abusos y torturas: así funcionan las horrorosas clínicas de deshomosexualización en Ecuador".Infobae(in Spanish). 7 May 2023.
- ^ab"Inter-American Court endorses same-sex marriage".Agence France-Presse.Yahoo7.9 January 2018. Archived fromthe originalon 9 January 2018.Retrieved9 January2018.
- ^abCrittenton, Anya (4 June 2019)."Ecuador high court delays ruling on same-sex marriage".Gay Star News.Archived fromthe originalon 20 June 2019.Retrieved13 June2019.
- ^Cova, Victor (2018)."Nicole, reina de Macas: el impacto del trabajo asalariado sobre el activismo trans en la Amazonia ecuatoriana".Academia.edu.
- ^Horswell, Michael J. (2006).Transculturating Tropes of Sexuality,Tinkuy,and Third Gender in the Andes,introduction to "Decolonizing the Sodomite: Queer Tropes of Sexuality in Colonial Andean Culture".ISBN0-292-71267-7.Article online.
- ^"La homosexualidad en las culturas antiguas"(in Spanish). 23 February 2015. Archived fromthe originalon 17 March 2015.
- ^abFetterhoff, Christina (28 November 2011)."Shutting Down Clinics that 'Cure Homosexuality' in Ecuador".The Human Rights Brief.Archived fromthe originalon 2 January 2013.Retrieved9 April2021.
- ^{{Cite web|url=https://database.ilga.org/criminalisation-consensual-same-sex-sexual-acts
- ^"Codigo Penal Ecuador"(PDF).Archived fromthe original(PDF)on 17 May 2004.Retrieved9 April2021.
- ^Küffner, Joshua Partlow and Stephan (29 September 2008)."Voters in Ecuador Approve Constitution"– via washingtonpost.
- ^abcd"Ecuador: 2008 Constitution in English".pdba.georgetown.edu.
- ^"Apoyo al matrimonio entre personas del mismo sexo en América Latina"(PDF).Perspectivas desde el Barómetro de las Américas.44.2010. Archived fromthe original(PDF)on 20 August 2013.Retrieved9 April2021.
- ^"Ecuador Approves New Constitution Including Same-Sex Civil Unions".30 September 2008.
- ^Civil, Registro."REGISTRO DE UNIONES DE HECHO".Retrieved26 June2016.
- ^"Desde el 15 de septiembre se reconocerán las uniones de hecho como un estado civil – ANDES".Retrieved26 June2016.
- ^"Ecuador reconoce la Unión de Hecho Homosexual como un estado civil".ILGA LAC.22 April 2015. Archived fromthe originalon 7 May 2019.Retrieved9 April2021.
- ^"In historic move, court rules Ecuador's same-sex marriage ban is illegal".Gay Star News.4 July 2018. Archived fromthe originalon 1 April 2019.Retrieved9 April2021.
- ^"Ecuador: Constitution, 2008".pdba.georgetown.edu.
- ^abVillagomez, Cristina; Vidal, Laura (21 June 2018)."In Ecuador, a Young Girl Wins the Right to Have the Surnames of Both Her Mothers".Global Voices.Retrieved9 April2021.
- ^Smith, Lydia (31 May 2018)."Gay family recognised by state in Ecuador in historic decision".PinkNews.Retrieved9 April2021.
- ^"LEY ORGÁNICA PARA LA JUSTICIA LABORAL Y RECONOCIMIENTO DEL TRABAJO EN EL HOGAR"(PDF).
- ^"Gobierno Nacional presenta la política pública para la garantía de derechos de las personas LGBTI".Ministerio de Justicia, Derechos Humanos y Cultos(in Spanish). Archived fromthe originalon 7 May 2019.Retrieved9 April2021.
- ^"Change of 'gender' in identity card will require two witnesses – EcuadorTimes.net – Breaking News, Ecuador News, World, Sports, Entertainment".Archived fromthe originalon 9 June 2016.Retrieved26 June2016.
- ^ab"LEY ORGÁNICA DE GESTIÓN DE LA IDENTIDAD Y DATOS CIVILES"(PDF).
- ^"Lesbian Torture Clinics in Ecuador- Claiming to" Cure "Them".Hispanically Speaking News.Hispanically Speaking News.5 November 2011. Archived fromthe originalon 12 December 2011.Retrieved17 January2013.
- ^ab"Why 200 Lesbian Torture Clinics Are Still Operating in Ecuador".The Huffington Post.11 November 2011.Retrieved17 January2013.
- ^"Lesbians Escape From Ecuador's" Ex-Gay "Torture Centers".The Advocate.The Advocate.7 October 2011.Retrieved17 January2013.
- ^"Rights groups hail Ecuador's crackdown on lesbian 'torture clinics'".MSNBC. 25 January 2012. Archived fromthe originalon 10 June 2012.
- ^"Código Orgánico Integral Penal"(PDF).Archived fromthe original(PDF)on 19 February 2018.Retrieved11 August2018.
- ^ab"Gay Ecuador".Gay Guide.Gay Times.Archived fromthe originalon 19 October 2012.Retrieved26 December2012.
- ^"El GLBTI, colectivo que gana espacios".El Universo(in Spanish). 21 April 2013.Retrieved9 April2021.
- ^"Comunidad Glbti del Ecuador celebró Día del Orgullo Gay".El Universo.2 July 2011.
- ^"Desfile del orgullo 2011 en Guayaquil".Gay Ecuador(in Spanish). Archived fromthe originalon 23 December 2011.Retrieved9 April2021.
- ^"Es Ecuador sede de festival de cine LGBT en Latinoamérica - Es Ecuador sede de festival de cine LGBT en Latinoamérica Miércoles, 12 de Octubre de 2011 15:12 Rolo. Toro Hits: 443 Para conmemorar la".Archived fromthe originalon 3 August 2012.
- ^"2011 Country Reports on Human Rights Practices: Ecuador,Bureau of Democracy, Human Rights and Labor, U.S. Department of State, p. 25 "(PDF).
- ^"Ecuador Lesbian Activist Appointed to Presidential Cabinet".advocate.24 January 2012.
- ^"Matrimonio igualitario y registro de niños: pedidos ciudadanos en la marcha del Orgullo LGTBI".EMG(in Spanish). 5 July 2017.Retrieved9 April2021.
- ^ECU, Presidencia (28 June 2017)."El Palacio de #Carondelet se ilumina al recordar el Día Internacional del Orgullo LGBTIpic.twitter /HMwYzNLNoA".
- ^Power, Shannon (4 July 2018)."18,000 people hit the streets to celebrate Pride in Ecuador".Gay Star News.Archived fromthe originalon 15 July 2018.Retrieved6 July2018.
- ^"Ecuador sentence for homophobia".BBC News.12 March 2013.
- ^Ramos, Zuania (12 March 2013)."Preacher Sentenced For Homophobic Comments".HuffPost.
- ^"TCE ratifica sentencia contra excandidato presidencial Nelson Zavala - MAR. 19, 2013 - 16:46 - Política - Noticias de Ecuador y del mundo | El Universo".eluniverso.19 March 2013.
- ^"Diane Rodriguez: primera transexual en postularse a asambleista en Ecuador".YouTube(in Spanish). Canal Ecuavisa. 15 November 2012.Archivedfrom the original on 13 December 2021.Retrieved9 April2021.
- ^"Ruptura impulsa una candidata transexual en Guayas".El Comercio(in Spanish). 14 November 2012. Archived fromthe originalon 24 April 2014.Retrieved9 April2021.
- ^"¡Superó el discrimen y ahora lucha por la inclusión social!".Extra(in Spanish). Archived fromthe originalon 24 April 2014.Retrieved9 April2021.
- ^Rafael Correa (19 March 2013)."DianeRodriguezZ Estimada Diane: sólo quería decirle que la admiro y respeto profundamente, aunque no comparta todos sus postulados".Twitter(in Spanish).Retrieved9 April2021.
- ^"DianeRodriguezZ Estimada Diane: sólo quería decirle que la admiro y respeto profundamente, aunque no comparta todos sus postulados".Twitter(in Spanish). 19 March 2013. Archived fromthe originalon 12 May 2014.Retrieved9 April2021.
- ^"Un Espacio para el Debate de los Gais".El Comercio(in Spanish). 27 March 2013. Archived fromthe originalon 12 May 2014.
- ^Gender Studies Network – In SpanishArchived26 June 2020 at theWayback MachinePresident Rafael Correa invites presidential change of guard transsexual activist Diane Rodriguez. Retrieved 11 August 2013.
- ^"Historic meeting between the President of Ecuador and the GLBTI community to allow moving forward in claiming rights".Andes.16 December 2013. Archived fromthe originalon 12 May 2014.Retrieved9 April2021.
- ^"15 asesinatos de GLBTI investigara el Gobierno".El Universo(in Spanish). 18 December 2013.Retrieved9 April2021.
- ^Isaad, Virginia (2 April 2019)."11 Transgender Latinas Empowering the LGBTQIA Community".Hiplatina.Retrieved9 April2021.
- ^"La Corte Constitucional de Ecuador aprueba el matrimonio gay".el Nuevo Herald(in Spanish). 12 June 2019. Archived fromthe originalon 16 June 2019.Retrieved12 June2019.
- ^El camino hacia la inclusión. La homosexualidad en el ejército.Enfoque.Retrieved on November 8, 2021.