Jump to content

Symmetry

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
(Redirected fromSymmetrical)
Symmetry (left) andasymmetry(right)
A sphericalsymmetry groupwithoctahedral symmetry.The yellow region shows thefundamental domain.
Afractal-like shape that hasreflectional symmetry,rotational symmetryandself-similarity,three forms of symmetry. This shape is obtained by afinite subdivision rule.

Symmetry(fromAncient Greekσυμμετρία(summetría)'agreement in dimensions, due proportion, arrangement')[1]in everyday life refers to a sense of harmonious and beautiful proportion and balance.[2][3][a]Inmathematics,the term has a more precise definition and is usually used to refer to an object that isinvariantunder sometransformations,such astranslation,reflection,rotation,orscaling.Although these two meanings of the word can sometimes be told apart, they are intricately related, and hence are discussed together in this article.

Mathematical symmetry may be observed with respect to the passage oftime;as aspatial relationship;throughgeometric transformations;through other kinds of functional transformations; and as an aspect ofabstract objects,includingtheoretic models,language,andmusic.[4][b]

This article describes symmetry from three perspectives: inmathematics,includinggeometry,the most familiar type of symmetry for many people; inscienceandnature;and in the arts, coveringarchitecture,art,and music.

The opposite of symmetry isasymmetry,which refers to the absence of symmetry.

In mathematics

[edit]

In geometry

[edit]
Thetriskelionhas 3-fold rotational symmetry.

A geometric shape or object is symmetric if it can be divided into two or more identical pieces that are arranged in an organized fashion.[5]This means that an object is symmetric if there is a transformation that moves individual pieces of the object, but doesn't change the overall shape. The type of symmetry is determined by the way the pieces are organized, or by the type of transformation:

  • An object hasreflectional symmetry(line or mirror symmetry) if there is a line (or in3Da plane) going through it which divides it into two pieces that are mirror images of each other.[6]
  • An object hasrotational symmetryif the object can be rotated about a fixed point (or in 3D about a line) without changing the overall shape.[7]
  • An object hastranslational symmetryif it can betranslated(moving every point of the object by the same distance) without changing its overall shape.[8]
  • An object hashelical symmetryif it can be simultaneously translated and rotated in three-dimensional space along a line known as ascrew axis.[9]
  • An object hasscale symmetryif it does not change shape when it is expanded or contracted.[10]Fractalsalso exhibit a form of scale symmetry, where smaller portions of the fractal aresimilarin shape to larger portions.[11]
  • Other symmetries includeglide reflectionsymmetry (a reflection followed by a translation) androtoreflectionsymmetry (a combination of a rotation and a reflection[12]).

In logic

[edit]

Adyadic relationR=S×Sis symmetric if for all elementsa,binS,whenever it is true thatRab,it is also true thatRba.[13]Thus, the relation "is the same age as" is symmetric, for if Paul is the same age as Mary, then Mary is the same age as Paul.

In propositional logic, symmetric binarylogical connectivesincludeand(∧, or &),or(∨, or |) andif and only if(↔), while the connectiveif(→) is not symmetric.[14]Other symmetric logical connectives includenand(not-and, or ⊼),xor(not-biconditional, or ⊻), andnor(not-or, or ⊽).

Other areas of mathematics

[edit]

Generalizing from geometrical symmetry in the previous section, one can say that amathematical objectissymmetricwith respect to a givenmathematical operation,if, when applied to the object, this operation preserves some property of the object.[15]The set of operations that preserve a given property of the object form agroup.

In general, every kind of structure in mathematics will have its own kind of symmetry. Examples includeeven and odd functionsincalculus,symmetric groupsinabstract algebra,symmetric matricesinlinear algebra,andGalois groupsinGalois theory.Instatistics,symmetry also manifests assymmetric probability distributions,and asskewness—the asymmetry of distributions.[16]

In science and nature

[edit]

In physics

[edit]

Symmetry in physics has been generalized to meaninvariance—that is, lack of change—under any kind of transformation, for examplearbitrary coordinate transformations.[17]This concept has become one of the most powerful tools oftheoretical physics,as it has become evident that practically all laws of nature originate in symmetries. In fact, this role inspired the Nobel laureatePW Andersonto write in his widely read 1972 articleMore is Differentthat "it is only slightly overstating the case to say that physics is the study of symmetry."[18]SeeNoether's theorem(which, in greatly simplified form, states that for every continuous mathematical symmetry, there is a corresponding conserved quantity such as energy or momentum; a conserved current, in Noether's original language);[19]and also,Wigner's classification,which says that the symmetries of the laws of physics determine the properties of the particles found in nature.[20]

Important symmetries in physics includecontinuous symmetriesanddiscrete symmetriesofspacetime;internal symmetriesof particles; andsupersymmetryof physical theories.

In biology

[edit]
Many animals are approximately mirror-symmetric, though internal organs are often arranged asymmetrically.

In biology, the notion of symmetry is mostly used explicitly to describe body shapes.Bilateral animals,including humans, are more or less symmetric with respect to thesagittal planewhich divides the body into left and right halves.[21]Animals that move in one direction necessarily have upper and lower sides, head and tail ends, and therefore a left and a right. Thehead becomes specializedwith a mouth and sense organs, and the body becomes bilaterally symmetric for the purpose of movement, with symmetrical pairs of muscles and skeletal elements, though internal organs often remain asymmetric.[22]

Plants and sessile (attached) animals such assea anemonesoften have radial orrotational symmetry,which suits them because food or threats may arrive from any direction. Fivefold symmetry is found in theechinoderms,the group that includesstarfish,sea urchins,andsea lilies.[23]

In biology, the notion of symmetry is also used as in physics, that is to say to describe the properties of the objects studied, including their interactions. A remarkable property of biological evolution is the changes of symmetry corresponding to the appearance of new parts and dynamics.[24][25]

In chemistry

[edit]

Symmetry is important tochemistrybecause it undergirds essentially allspecificinteractions between molecules in nature (i.e., via the interaction of natural and human-madechiralmolecules with inherently chiral biological systems). The control of thesymmetryof molecules produced in modernchemical synthesiscontributes to the ability of scientists to offertherapeuticinterventions with minimalside effects.A rigorous understanding of symmetry explains fundamental observations inquantum chemistry,and in the applied areas ofspectroscopyandcrystallography.The theory and application of symmetry to these areas ofphysical sciencedraws heavily on the mathematical area ofgroup theory.[26]

In psychology and neuroscience

[edit]

For a human observer, some symmetry types are more salient than others, in particular the most salient is a reflection with a vertical axis, like that present in the human face.Ernst Machmade this observation in his book "The analysis of sensations" (1897),[27]and this implies that perception of symmetry is not a general response to all types of regularities. Both behavioural and neurophysiological studies have confirmed the special sensitivity to reflection symmetry in humans and also in other animals.[28]Early studies within theGestalttradition suggested that bilateral symmetry was one of the key factors in perceptualgrouping.This is known as theLaw of Symmetry.The role of symmetry in grouping and figure/ground organization has been confirmed in many studies. For instance, detection of reflectional symmetry is faster when this is a property of a single object.[29]Studies of human perception and psychophysics have shown that detection of symmetry is fast, efficient and robust to perturbations. For example, symmetry can be detected with presentations between 100 and 150 milliseconds.[30]

More recent neuroimaging studies have documented which brain regions are active during perception of symmetry. Sasaki et al.[31]used functional magnetic resonance imaging (fMRI) to compare responses for patterns with symmetrical or random dots. A strong activity was present in extrastriate regions of the occipital cortex but not in the primary visual cortex. The extrastriate regions included V3A, V4, V7, and the lateral occipital complex (LOC). Electrophysiological studies have found a late posterior negativity that originates from the same areas.[32]In general, a large part of the visual system seems to be involved in processing visual symmetry, and these areas involve similar networks to those responsible for detecting and recognising objects.[33]

In social interactions

[edit]

People observe the symmetrical nature, often including asymmetrical balance, of social interactions in a variety of contexts. These include assessments ofreciprocity,empathy,sympathy,apology,dialogue,respect,justice,andrevenge. Reflective equilibriumis the balance that may be attained through deliberative mutual adjustment among general principles and specificjudgments.[34] Symmetrical interactions send themoralmessage "we are all the same" while asymmetrical interactions may send the message "I am special; better than you." Peer relationships, such as can be governed by theGolden Rule,are based on symmetry, whereas power relationships are based on asymmetry.[35]Symmetrical relationships can to some degree be maintained by simple (game theory) strategies seen insymmetric gamessuch astit for tat.[36]

In the arts

[edit]

There exists a list of journals and newsletters known to deal, at least in part, with symmetry and the arts.[37]

In architecture

[edit]
Seen from the side, theTaj Mahalhas bilateral symmetry; from the top (in plan), it has fourfold symmetry.

Symmetry finds its ways into architecture at every scale, from the overall external views of buildings such as GothiccathedralsandThe White House,through the layout of the individualfloor plans,and down to the design of individual building elements such astile mosaics.Islamicbuildings such as theTaj Mahaland theLotfollah mosquemake elaborate use of symmetry both in their structure and in their ornamentation.[38][39]Moorish buildings like theAlhambraare ornamented with complex patterns made using translational and reflection symmetries as well as rotations.[40]

It has been said that only bad architects rely on a "symmetrical layout of blocks, masses and structures";[41]Modernist architecture,starting withInternational style,relies instead on "wings and balance of masses".[41]

In pottery and metal vessels

[edit]
Clay pots thrown on apottery wheelacquire rotational symmetry.

Since the earliest uses ofpottery wheelsto help shape clay vessels, pottery has had a strong relationship to symmetry. Pottery created using a wheel acquires full rotational symmetry in its cross-section, while allowing substantial freedom of shape in the vertical direction. Upon this inherently symmetrical starting point, potters from ancient times onwards have added patterns that modify the rotational symmetry to achieve visual objectives.

Cast metal vessels lacked the inherent rotational symmetry of wheel-made pottery, but otherwise provided a similar opportunity to decorate their surfaces with patterns pleasing to those who used them. The ancientChinese,for example, used symmetrical patterns in their bronze castings as early as the 17th century BC. Bronze vessels exhibited both a bilateral main motif and a repetitive translated border design.[42]

In carpets and rugs

[edit]
Persian rug with rectangular symmetry

A long tradition of the use of symmetry incarpetand rug patterns spans a variety of cultures. AmericanNavajoIndians used bold diagonals and rectangular motifs. ManyOriental rugshave intricate reflected centers and borders that translate a pattern. Not surprisingly, rectangular rugs have typically the symmetries of arectangle—that is,motifsthat are reflected across both the horizontal and vertical axes (seeKlein four-group § Geometry).[43][44]

In quilts

[edit]
Kitchenkaleidoscopequiltblock

Asquiltsare made from square blocks (usually 9, 16, or 25 pieces to a block) with each smaller piece usually consisting of fabric triangles, the craft lends itself readily to the application of symmetry.[45]

In other arts and crafts

[edit]

Symmetries appear in the design of objects of all kinds. Examples includebeadwork,furniture,sand paintings,knotwork,masks,andmusical instruments.Symmetries are central to the art ofM.C. Escherand the many applications oftessellationin art and craft forms such aswallpaper,ceramic tilework such as inIslamic geometric decoration,batik,ikat,carpet-making, and many kinds oftextileandembroiderypatterns.[46]

Symmetry is also used in designing logos.[47]By creating a logo on a grid and using the theory of symmetry, designers can organize their work, create a symmetric or asymmetrical design, determine the space between letters, determine how much negative space is required in the design, and how to accentuate parts of the logo to make it stand out.

In music

[edit]
Major and minortriads on the white piano keys are symmetrical to the D.

Symmetry is not restricted to the visual arts. Its role in the history ofmusictouches many aspects of the creation and perception of music.

Musical form

[edit]

Symmetry has been used as aformalconstraint by many composers, such as thearch (swell) form(ABCBA) used bySteve Reich,Béla Bartók,andJames Tenney.In classical music,Johann Sebastian Bachused the symmetry concepts of permutation and invariance.[48]

Pitch structures

[edit]

Symmetry is also an important consideration in the formation ofscalesandchords,traditional ortonalmusic being made up of non-symmetrical groups ofpitches,such as thediatonic scaleor themajor chord.Symmetrical scalesor chords, such as thewhole tone scale,augmented chord,or diminishedseventh chord(diminished-diminished seventh), are said to lack direction or a sense of forward motion, areambiguousas to thekeyor tonal center, and have a less specificdiatonic functionality.However, composers such asAlban Berg,Béla Bartók,andGeorge Perlehave used axes of symmetry and/orinterval cyclesin an analogous way tokeysor non-tonaltonalcenters.[49]George Perle explains that "C–E, D–F♯, [and] Eb–G, are different instances of the sameinterval…the other kind of identity.… has to do with axes of symmetry. C–E belongs to a family of symmetrically related dyads as follows: "[49]

D D♯ E F F♯ G G♯
D C♯ C B A♯ A G♯

Thus in addition to being part of the interval-4 family, C–E is also a part of the sum-4 family (with C equal to 0).[49]

+ 2 3 4 5 6 7 8
2 1 0 11 10 9 8
4 4 4 4 4 4 4

Interval cycles are symmetrical and thus non-diatonic. However, a seven pitch segment of C5 (the cycle of fifths, which areenharmonicwith the cycle of fourths) will produce the diatonic major scale. Cyclic tonalprogressionsin the works ofRomanticcomposers such asGustav MahlerandRichard Wagnerform a link with the cyclic pitch successions in the atonal music of Modernists such as Bartók,Alexander Scriabin,Edgard Varèse,and the Vienna school. At the same time, these progressions signal the end of tonality.[49][50]

The first extended composition consistently based on symmetrical pitch relations was probably Alban Berg'sQuartet,Op. 3(1910).[50]

Equivalency

[edit]

Tone rowsorpitch classsetswhich areinvariantunderretrogradeare horizontally symmetrical, underinversionvertically. See alsoAsymmetric rhythm.

In aesthetics

[edit]

The relationship of symmetry toaestheticsis complex. Humans findbilateral symmetryin faces physically attractive;[51]it indicates health and genetic fitness.[52][53]Opposed to this is the tendency for excessive symmetry to be perceived as boring or uninteresting. Rudolf Arnheim suggested that people prefer shapes that have some symmetry, and enough complexity to make them interesting.[54]

In literature

[edit]

Symmetry can be found in various forms inliterature,a simple example being thepalindromewhere a brief text reads the same forwards or backwards. Stories may have a symmetrical structure, such as the rise and fall pattern ofBeowulf.[55]

See also

[edit]

Explanatory notes

[edit]
  1. ^For example,Aristotleascribed spherical shape to the heavenly bodies, attributing this formally defined geometric measure of symmetry to the natural order and perfection of the cosmos.
  2. ^Symmetric objects can be material, such as a person,crystal,quilt,floor tiles,ormolecule,or it can be anabstractstructure such as amathematical equationor a series of tones (music).

References

[edit]
  1. ^Harper, Douglas."symmetry".Online Etymology Dictionary.
  2. ^Zee, A. (2007).Fearful Symmetry.Princeton, New Jersey:Princeton University Press.ISBN978-0-691-13482-6.
  3. ^Hill, C. T.;Lederman, L. M.(2005).Symmetry and the Beautiful Universe.Prometheus Books.
  4. ^Mainzer, Klaus (2005).Symmetry and Complexity: The Spirit and Beauty of Nonlinear Science.World Scientific.ISBN981-256-192-7.
  5. ^E. H. Lockwood, R. H. Macmillan,Geometric Symmetry,London: Cambridge Press, 1978
  6. ^Weyl, Hermann(1982) [1952].Symmetry.Princeton: Princeton University Press.ISBN0-691-02374-3.
  7. ^Singer, David A. (1998).Geometry: Plane and Fancy.Springer Science & Business Media.
  8. ^Stenger, Victor J. (2000) and Mahou Shiro (2007).Timeless Reality.Prometheus Books. Especially chapter 12. Nontechnical.
  9. ^Bottema, O, and B. Roth,Theoretical Kinematics,Dover Publications (September 1990)
  10. ^Tian Yu CaoConceptual Foundations of Quantum Field TheoryCambridge University Press p.154-155
  11. ^Gouyet, Jean-François (1996).Physics and fractal structures.Paris/New York: Masson Springer.ISBN978-0-387-94153-0.
  12. ^"Rotoreflection Axis".TheFreeDictionary.Retrieved2019-11-12.
  13. ^Josiah Royce, Ignas K. Skrupskelis (2005)The Basic Writings of Josiah Royce: Logic, loyalty, and community (Google eBook)Fordham Univ Press, p. 790
  14. ^Gao, Alice (2019)."Propositional Logic: Introduction and Syntax"(PDF).University of Waterloo — School of Computer Science.Retrieved2019-11-12.
  15. ^Christopher G. Morris (1992)Academic Press Dictionary of Science and TechnologyGulf Professional Publishing
  16. ^Petitjean, M. (2003)."Chirality and Symmetry Measures: A Transdisciplinary Review".Entropy.5(3): 271–312 (see section 2.9).Bibcode:2003Entrp...5..271P.doi:10.3390/e5030271.
  17. ^Costa, Giovanni; Fogli, Gianluigi (2012).Symmetries and Group Theory in Particle Physics: An Introduction to Space-Time and Internal Symmetries.Springer Science & Business Media. p. 112.
  18. ^Anderson, P.W. (1972)."More is Different"(PDF).Science.177(4047): 393–396.Bibcode:1972Sci...177..393A.doi:10.1126/science.177.4047.393.PMID17796623.S2CID34548824.
  19. ^Kosmann-Schwarzbach, Yvette(2010).The Noether theorems: Invariance and conservation laws in the twentieth century.Sources and Studies in the History of Mathematics and Physical Sciences.Springer-Verlag.ISBN978-0-387-87867-6.
  20. ^Wigner, E. P.(1939), "On unitary representations of the inhomogeneous Lorentz group",Annals of Mathematics,40(1): 149–204,Bibcode:1939AnMat..40..149W,doi:10.2307/1968551,JSTOR1968551,MR1503456,S2CID121773411
  21. ^Valentine, James W."Bilateria".AccessScience. Archived fromthe originalon 18 January 2008.Retrieved29 May2013.
  22. ^Hickman, Cleveland P.; Roberts, Larry S.; Larson, Allan (2002)."Animal Diversity (Third Edition)"(PDF).Chapter 8: Acoelomate Bilateral Animals.McGraw-Hill. p. 139. Archived fromthe original(PDF)on May 17, 2016.RetrievedOctober 25,2012.
  23. ^Stewart, Ian (2001).What Shape is a Snowflake? Magical Numbers in Nature.Weidenfeld & Nicolson. pp. 64–65.
  24. ^Longo, Giuseppe; Montévil, Maël (2016).Perspectives on Organisms: Biological time, Symmetries and Singularities.Springer.ISBN978-3-662-51229-6.
  25. ^Montévil, Maël; Mossio, Matteo; Pocheville, Arnaud; Longo, Giuseppe (2016)."Theoretical principles for biology: Variation".Progress in Biophysics and Molecular Biology.From the Century of the Genome to the Century of the Organism: New Theoretical Approaches.122(1): 36–50.doi:10.1016/j.pbiomolbio.2016.08.005.PMID27530930.S2CID3671068.
  26. ^Lowe, John P; Peterson, Kirk (2005).Quantum Chemistry(Third ed.). Academic Press.ISBN0-12-457551-X.
  27. ^Mach, Ernst (1897).Symmetries and Group Theory in Particle Physics: An Introduction to Space-Time and Internal Symmetries.Open Court Publishing House.
  28. ^Wagemans, J. (1997)."Characteristics and models of human symmetry detection".Trends in Cognitive Sciences.1(9): 346–352.doi:10.1016/S1364-6613(97)01105-4.PMID21223945.S2CID2143353.
  29. ^Bertamini, M. (2010). "Sensitivity to reflection and translation is modulated by objectness".Perception.39(1): 27–40.doi:10.1068/p6393.PMID20301844.S2CID22451173.
  30. ^Barlow, H.B.; Reeves, B.C. (1979). "The versatility and absolute efficiency of detecting mirror symmetry in random dot displays".Vision Research.19(7): 783–793.doi:10.1016/0042-6989(79)90154-8.PMID483597.S2CID41530752.
  31. ^Sasaki, Y.; Vanduffel, W.; Knutsen, T.; Tyler, C.W.; Tootell, R. (2005)."Symmetry activates extrastriate visual cortex in human and nonhuman primates".Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the USA.102(8): 3159–3163.Bibcode:2005PNAS..102.3159S.doi:10.1073/pnas.0500319102.PMC549500.PMID15710884.
  32. ^Makin, A.D.J.; Rampone, G.; Pecchinenda, A.; Bertamini, M. (2013). "Electrophysiological responses to visuospatial regularity".Psychophysiology.50(10): 1045–1055.doi:10.1111/psyp.12082.PMID23941638.
  33. ^Bertamini, M.; Silvanto, J.; Norcia, A.M.; Makin, A.D.J.; Wagemans, J. (2018)."The neural basis of visual symmetry and its role in middle and high-level visual processing".Annals of the New York Academy of Sciences.132(1): 280–293.Bibcode:2018NYASA1426..111B.doi:10.1111/nyas.13667.hdl:11577/3289328.PMID29604083.
  34. ^Daniels, Norman(2003-04-28)."Reflective Equilibrium".InZalta, Edward N.(ed.).Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy.
  35. ^Emotional Competency:Symmetry
  36. ^Lutus, P. (2008)."The Symmetry Principle".Retrieved28 September2015.
  37. ^Bouissou, C.; Petitjean, M. (2018)."Asymmetric Exchanges".Journal of Interdisciplinary Methodologies and Issues in Science.4:1–18.doi:10.18713/JIMIS-230718-4-1.(see appendix 1)
  38. ^Williams: Symmetry in Architecture.Members.tripod (1998-12-31). Retrieved on 2013-04-16.
  39. ^Aslaksen: Mathematics in Art and Architecture.Math.nus.edu.sg. Retrieved on 2013-04-16.
  40. ^Derry, Gregory N. (2002).What Science Is and How It Works.Princeton University Press. pp. 269–.ISBN978-1-4008-2311-6.
  41. ^abDunlap, David W. (31 July 2009)."Behind the Scenes: Edgar Martins Speaks".New York Times.Retrieved11 November2014."My starting point for this construction was a simple statement which I once read (and which does not necessarily reflect my personal views): 'Only a bad architect relies on symmetry; instead of symmetrical layout of blocks, masses and structures, Modernist architecture relies on wings and balance of masses.'
  42. ^The Art of Chinese BronzesArchived2003-12-11 at theWayback Machine.Chinavoc (2007-11-19). Retrieved on 2013-04-16.
  43. ^Marla Mallett Textiles & Tribal Oriental Rugs.The Metropolitan Museum of Art, New York.
  44. ^Dilucchio: Navajo Rugs.Navajocentral.org (2003-10-26). Retrieved on 2013-04-16.
  45. ^Quate: Exploring Geometry Through QuiltsArchived2003-12-31 at theWayback Machine.Its.guilford.k12.nc.us. Retrieved on 2013-04-16.
  46. ^Cucker, Felipe(2013).Manifold Mirrors: The Crossing Paths of the Arts and Mathematics.Cambridge University Press. pp. 77–78, 83, 89, 103.ISBN978-0-521-72876-8.
  47. ^"How to Design a Perfect Logo with Grid and Symmetry".
  48. ^see ( "Fugue No. 21,"pdfArchived2005-09-13 at theWayback MachineorShockwaveArchived2005-10-26 at theWayback Machine)
  49. ^abcdPerle, George(1992). "Symmetry, the twelve-tone scale, and tonality".Contemporary Music Review.6(2): 81–96.doi:10.1080/07494469200640151.
  50. ^abPerle, George(1990).The Listening Composer.University of California Press. p.21.ISBN978-0-520-06991-6.
  51. ^Grammer, K.; Thornhill, R. (1994). "Human (Homo sapiens) facial attractiveness and sexual selection: the role of symmetry and averageness".Journal of Comparative Psychology.108(3). Washington, D.C.: 233–42.doi:10.1037/0735-7036.108.3.233.PMID7924253.S2CID1205083.
  52. ^Rhodes, Gillian;Zebrowitz, Leslie A.(2002).Facial Attractiveness: Evolutionary, Cognitive, and Social Perspectives.Ablex.ISBN1-56750-636-4.
  53. ^Jones, B. C., Little, A. C., Tiddeman, B. P., Burt, D. M., & Perrett, D. I. (2001). Facial symmetry and judgements of apparent health Support for a “‘ good genes ’” explanation of the attractiveness – symmetry relationship, 22, 417–429.
  54. ^Arnheim, Rudolf (1969).Visual Thinking.University of California Press.
  55. ^Jenny Lea Bowman (2009)."Symmetrical Aesthetics of Beowulf".University of Tennessee, Knoxville.

Further reading

[edit]
[edit]