Unknowability

Inphilosophy,unknowabilityis the possibility of inherently unaccessibleknowledge.It addresses theepistemologyof that which wecannotknow. Some related concepts include thehalting problem,the limits of knowledge, theunknown unknowns,andchaos theory.

Nicholas Rescherprovides the most recent focused scholarship for this area inUnknowability: An Inquiry into the Limits of Knowledge,^[1]where he offered three high level categories, logical unknowability, conceptual unknowability, and in-principle unknowability.

Background

Speculation about what is knowable and unknowable has been part of the philosophical tradition since the inception of philosophy. In particular,Baruch Spinoza's Theory of Attributes^[2]argues that a human's finite mind cannot understand infinite substance; accordingly, infinite substance, as it is in itself, is in-principle unknowable to the finite mind.

Immanuel Kantbrought focus to unknowability theory in his use of thenoumenonconcept. He postulated that, while we can know the noumenal exists, it is not itself sensible and must therefore remain unknowable.

Modern inquiry encompassesundecidable problemsand questions such as the halting problem, which in their very nature cannot be possibly answered. This area of study has a long and somewhat diffuse history as the challenge arises in many areas of scholarly and practical investigations.

Rescher's categories of unknowability

Rescher organizes unknowability in three major categories:

logical unknowability — arising from abstract considerations of epistemic logic.
conceptual unknowability — analytically demonstrable of unknowability based on concepts and involved.
in-principle unknowability — based on fundamental principles.

In-principle unknowability may also be due to a need for more energy and matter than is available in the universe to answer a question, or due to fundamental reasons associated with the quantum nature of matter. In the physics ofspecialandgeneral relativity,thelight conemarks the boundary of physically knowable events.^[3]^[4]

The halting problem

The halting problem – namely, the problem of determining if arbitrary computer programs will ever finish running – is a prominent example of an unknowability associated with the established mathematical field ofcomputability theory.In 1936,Alan Turingproved that the halting problem is undecidable. This means that there is no algorithm that can take as input a program and determine whether it will halt. In 1970,Yuri Matiyasevichproved that the Diophantine problem (closely related toHilbert's tenth problem) is also undecidable by reducing it to the halting problem.^[5]This means that there is no algorithm that can take as input a Diophantine equation and always determine whether it has a solution in integers.

The undecidability of the halting problem and the Diophantine problem has a number of implications for mathematics and computer science. For example, it means that there is no general algorithm for proving that a given mathematical statement is true or false. It also means that there is no general algorithm for finding solutions to Diophantine equations.

In principle, many problems can be reduced to the halting problem. See thelist of undecidable problems.

Gödel's incompleteness theoremsdemonstrate the implicit in-principle unknowability of methods to prove consistency and completeness of foundation mathematical systems.

Related concepts

There are various graduations of unknowability associated with frameworks of discussion. For example:

unknowability to particular individual humans (due to individual limitations);
unknowability to humans at a particular time (due to lack of appropriate tools);
unknowability to humans due to limits of matter and energy in the universe that might be required to conduct the appropriate experiments or conduct the calculations required;
unknowability to any processes, organism, or artifact.

Treatment ofknowledgehas been wide and diverse.Wikipediaitself is an initiate to capture and record knowledge using contemporary technological tools. Earlier attempts to capture and record knowledge include writing deep tracts on specific topics as well as the use ofencyclopediasto organize and summarize entire fields or event the entirety of human knowledge.

Limits of knowledge

An associated topic that comes up frequently is that of Limits of Knowledge.

Examples of scholarly discussions involvinglimits of knowledgeinclude:

John Horgan'sEnd of science: facing the limits of knowledge in the twilight of the scientific age.^[6]

Tavel Morton'sContemporary physics and the limits of knowledge.^[7]

Christopher Cherniak'sLimits for knowledge.^[8]

Ignoramus et ignorabimus,a Latin maxim meaning "we do not know and will not know", popularized byEmil du Bois-Reymond.Bois-Reymond'signorabimusproclamation was viewed byDavid Hilbertas unsatisfactory, and motivated Hilbert to declare in 1900International Congress of Mathematiciansthat answers to problems of mathematics are possible with human effort. He declared, "in mathematics there is noignorabimus",^[9].The halting problem and the Diophantine Problem eventually were answered demonstrating in-principle unknowability of answers to some foundational mathematical questions, meaning Bois-Reymond's assertion was in fact correct.

Gregory Chaitindiscusses unknowability in many of his works.

Categories of unknowns

Popular discussion of unknowability grew with the use of the phraseThere are unknown unknownsbyUnited States Secretary of Defense Donald Rumsfeldat a news briefing on February 12, 2002. In addition to unknown unknowns there are known unknowns and unknown knowns. These category labels appeared in discussion of identification of chemical substances.^[10]^[11]^[12]

Chaos theory

Chaos theoryis a theory of dynamics that argues that, for sufficiently complex systems, even if we know initial conditions fairly well, measurement errors and computational limitations render fully correct long-term prediction impossible, hence guaranteeing ultimate unknowability of physical system behaviors.

References

^Rescher, Nicholas. Unknowability: an inquiry into the limits of knowledge. Le xing ton Books, 2009.https:// worldcat.org/title/298538038
^"Spinoza's Theory of Attributes".The Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy.Metaphysics Research Lab, Stanford University. 2018.
^ Hilary Putnam, Time and Physical Geometry, The Journal of Philosophy, Vol. 64, No. 8 (Apr. 27, 1967), pp. 240–247https:// jstor.org/stable/2024493 https://doi.org/10.2307/2024493
^John M. Myers, F. Hadi Madjid, "Logical synchronization: how evidence and hypotheses steer atomic clocks," Proc. SPIE 9123, Quantum Information and Computation XII, 91230T (22 May 2014);https://doi.org/10.1117/12.2054945
^Matii︠a︡sevich I︠U︡. V. Hilbert's Tenth Problem. MIT Press 1993.https:// worldcat.org/title/28424180
^ Horgan, John. The End of Science: Facing the Limits of Knowledge in the Twilight of the Scientific Age. Addison-Wesley Pub 1996.https:// worldcat.org/title/34076685
^ Tavel, Morton. Contemporary Physics and the Limits of Knowledge. Rutgers University Press 2002.https:// worldcat.org/title/47838409
^Cherniak, Christopher. "Limits for knowledge." Philosophical Studies: An International Journal for Philosophy in the Analytic Tradition 49.1 (1986): 1–18.https:// jstor.org/stable/4319805
^Hilbert, David (1902)."Mathematical Problems: Lecture Delivered before the International Congress of Mathematicians at Paris in 1900".Bulletin of the American Mathematical Society.8:437–79.doi:10.1090/S0002-9904-1902-00923-3.MR 1557926.
^Little, James L. (2011)."Identification of" known unknowns "utilizing accurate mass data and ChemSpider"(PDF).Journal of the American Society for Mass Spectrometry.23(1): 179–185.doi:10.1007/s13361-011-0265-y.PMID 22069037.
^McEachran, Andrew D.; Sobus, Jon R.; Williams, Antony J. (2016). "Identifying known unknowns using the US EPA's CompTox Chemistry Dashboard".Analytical and Bioanalytical Chemistry.409(7): 1729–1735.doi:10.1007/s00216-016-0139-z.PMID 27987027.S2CID 31754962.
^Schymanski, Emma L.;Williams, Antony J. (2017)."Open Science for Identifying" Known Unknown "Chemicals".Environmental Science and Technology.51(10): 5357–5359.Bibcode:2017EnST...51.5357S.doi:10.1021/acs.est.7b01908.PMC6260822.PMID 28475325.