Conspiracy theories

While you here do snoring lie, Open-eyed conspiracy His time doth take.
If of life you keep a care, Shake off slumber, and beware: Awake, awake! ~William Shakespeare,

The transformation of America's civic culture from the Founders' hard-nosed realism about elite political intrigue to today's blanket condemnation of conspiracy beliefs as ludicrous by definition... did not occur spontaneously; it was planned and orchestrated by the government itself. ~ Lance deHaven-Smith

Employ propaganda assets to... refute the attacks of the critics. ~ Declassified CIA Document 1035-960

It is easy to sneer at stupid conspiracy theories and mock the thinking processes of those who advocate them. But in doing so academics and journalists are contaminating the good theories with the bad, lumping together secret state research and David Icke’s reptilian delusions as ‘conspiracy theories’. Which is, of course, what the state wants us to do. ~Robin Ramsay

Conspiracy theoriesare explanations of events or situations that invokes aconspiracyby powerful actors, often political in motivation. Conspiracy theories once limited to fringe audiences have become commonplace online, emerging as a cultural phenomenon of the early21st centuries.

Quotes

(arranged chronologically)

• While you here do snoring lie, Open-eyed conspiracy His time doth take.
  If of life you keep a care, Shake off slumber, and beware: Awake, awake!
  • William Shakespeare,The Tempest(c. 1610-1612), Act II, scene 1. Song, line 295.

• The truth is that the State is a conspiracy designed not only to exploit, but above all to corrupt its citizens… Henceforth, I shall never serve any government anywhere.
  • Leo Tolstoy(~1890) quoted inTolstoyby A. N. Wilson, p. 146 (1988)

• The individual is handicapped by coming face-to-face with a conspiracy so monstrous he cannot believe it exists. The American mind simply has not come to a realization of the evil which has been introduced into our midst. It rejects even the assumption that human creatures could espouse aphilosophywhich must ultimately destroy all that is good and decent.
  • J. Edgar Hoover,as quoted inThe Elks Magazine(August 1956).

• Conspiracy theories have frequently thrown suspicion on our organization, for example by falsely alleging thatLee Harvey Oswaldworked for us.... Addresses are requested... to employ propaganda assets to... refute the attacks of the critics.... Our ploy should point out, as applicable, that the critics are (I) wedded to theories adopted before the evidence was in, (II) politically interested, (III) financially interested, (IV) hasty and inaccurate in their research, or (V) infatuated with their own theories.
  • Central Intelligence Agency,CIA Document 1035-960 "Concerning Criticism of the Warren Report",(1967)

• The paranoid spokesman sees the fate ofconspiracyin apocalyptic terms—he traffics in the birth and death of whole worlds, whole political orders, whole systems of human values. He is always manning the barricades ofcivilization.He constantly lives at a turning point. Like religious millennialists he expresses the anxiety of those who are living through the last days and he is sometimes disposed to set a date fort theapocalypse... As a member of theavant-gardewho is capable of perceiving the conspiracy before it is fully obvious to an as yet unaroused public, the paranoid is a militant leader. He does not see social conflict as something to be mediated and compromised.. Since what is at stake is always a conflict between absolute good and absolute evil, what is necessary is not compromise but the will to fight things out to a finish... Unlike the rest of us, the enemy is not caught in the toils of the vast mechanism of history, himself a victim of his past, his desires, his limitations.
  • Richard HofstadterinThe Paranoid Style in American Politics,Harper Magazine,(November 1964)

• Very few notions generate as much intellectual resistance, hostility, and derision within academic circles as a belief in the historical importance or efficacy of political conspiracies. Even when this belief is expressed in a very cautious manner, limited to specific and restricted contexts, supported by reliable evidence, and hedged about with all sort of qualifications, it still manages to transcend the boundaries of acceptable discourse and violate unspoken academic taboos.
  • Conspiracy Theories' and Clandestine Politics,Lobster#29 (Jun 1995)

• I say this to the militias and all others who believe that the greatest threat to freedom comes from theGovernmentinstead of from those who would take away ourfreedom:If you sayviolenceis an acceptable way to make change, you are wrong. If you say that Government is in a conspiracy to take your freedom away, you are just plain wrong. If you treatlaw enforcementofficers who put their lives on the line for your safety every day like some kind of enemy army to be suspected, derided, and if they should enforce the law against you, to be shot, you are wrong. If you appropriate our sacred symbols for paranoid purposes and compare yourselves tocolonial militiaswho fought for the democracy you now rail against, you are wrong. How dare you suggest that we in the freest nation onEarthlive in tyranny! How dare you call yourselves patriots and heroes!
  • Bill Clinton,Remarks at the Michigan State University Commencement Ceremony in East Lansing, Michigan (May 5, 1995), quoted inPublic Papers of the Presidents of the United States: William J. Clinton, Book 1—January 1 to June 30, 1995(1996), pp. 644–645

• Oh, there’s no high quite like getting the focused attention of powerful enemies. Nothing is better guaranteed to make you feel important in the world, which may be why conspiracy theories are so popular among frustrated underachievers.
  • David Brin,Kiln People(2002), Chapter 42(ISBN 0-765-34261-8,p. 400)

• It’s almost comical. Nobody knew anything, but everybody took that as proof of the hypothesis.
  • Adam-Troy Castro,Emissaries from the Dead(2008),ISBN 978-0-06-144372-5,p. 378

• Hofstadter’s essay linked an interest in conspiracies or conspiracy theories with paranoia and with the loonyradical Right.Hofstadter thus helped to contaminate the subjects for the liberal-left which then – and now – is unwilling to be associated with almost anything on or of theRight.For ‘serious’ people –academics,journalists,politicians– large areas of political inquiry have been contaminated ever since by an association with conspiracy theories. Hofstadter’s essay appeared just when questions were being asked about theassassination of JFKand his essay helped to shore up the ‘lone assassin’ verdict offered by theWarren Commission.
  • Robin Ramsay,Politics and Paranoia,(2008)

• We should strive to be aware of what we are doing when labelling others as paranoid or reporting that they believe in “conspiracy theories” given that one of the effects of such a move is to undermine the legitimacy of others’ views and to implicitly position our own views as legitimate.
  • David Harper,The Politics of Paranoia: Paranoid Positioning and Conspiratorial Narratives in the Surveillance Society,University of East London(January 2008)

• In the wake of theSeptember 11 2001 attacksmany conspiracy theories have developed, for example thatthe Pentagonwas hit by a missile, not aplane... that the attacks were an “inside job”... or that theWorld Trade Centre buildingswere brought down by pre-planned controlled explosions... These theories have gained ground – Gillan... reports that a recent poll found that 36% of Americans believed it “very likely” or “somewhat likely” that theirgovernmentwas involved in allowing the attacks or had carried them out itself. In a time of increased skepticism of official accounts, the tendency forbureaucraciesto cover-up their errors and mistakes can appear to be evidence for conspiracy. AsRobin Ramsay,editor ofLobster magazineputs it “in situations where the shit is flying bureaucracies go into cover-up mode automatically”.
  • David Harper,The Politics of Paranoia: Paranoid Positioning and Conspiratorial Narratives in the Surveillance Society,University of East London(January 2008)

• These unofficial narratives have become so widespread that theUS State departmenthas developed guidance aboutmisinformationwhich includes post 9/11internetconspiracy theories (State department, 2005), the media have published detailed rebuttals of claims about the attacks (Popular Mechanics, 2005) and evenGeorge Bushfelt the need to rebut them only two months after the attacks:Let us never tolerate outrageous conspiracy theories concerning the attacks of September the 11th; malicious lies that attempt to shift the blame away from the terrorists themselves, away from the guilty.(Bush, 2001)
  • David Harper,The Politics of Paranoia: Paranoid Positioning and Conspiratorial Narratives in the Surveillance Society,University of East London(January 2008)
• Setbacks and defeats become part of such stories, rather than challenges to their truth. If the faithful have suffered, that is because of the plots and conspiracies of their enemies. ForHitler,of course, that meant theJews.They had startedWorld War Iand created theBolshevik Revolution,and they had ensured thatGermanysuffered under theTreaty of Versailles.He had warned them, Hitler said repeatedly, that if they dared to start another war he would destroy them, “the vermin ofEurope.”World War IIwas the fault of the Jews, and the time had come to deal with them once and for all. If any one person was responsible for that war, it was Hitler himself, butlogicand reason do not enter into closed systems of viewing the world. In 1991, theAmericantelevisionevangelistPat Robertsonwarned thatBush Senior's victory overIraqwas not what it appeared. It was paving the way not for peace but for the triumph of evil. It was all so clear to Robertson. Ever since the Bolshevik Revolution of 1917, a secret conspiracy had been pushing the world towardsocialismand the triumph of theAnti-Christ.TheEuropean Unionwas clearly part of the plot and so was theUnited Nations.TheGulf Warand the missiles thatSaddam Husseinhad fired onIsraelwere yet more steps toward the final reckoning.
  • Margaret MacMillan,The Uses and Abuses of History(2008), pp. 66-67

• I didn’t know much about Conspiracy, but I did know that its theorists were mostly paranoid and tended to value conviction above evidence.
  • Jasper Fforde,One of Our Thursdays is Missing(2011),ISBN 978-0-670-02252-6,pp. 46-47

• The title of the project, Conspiracy and Democracy, (began in January 2013 atCambridge University) might suggest that it is going to deal with the issue of how conspiracy as a practice undermines or impacts upondemocracy.It might, for example, examine all the state conspiracies which now exist within this society; and since thearmed forces,police,security and intelligence services(and the bigcorporations) are almost entirely unaccountable, such research would be entirely apt. It would be only a slight exaggeration to say that theBritish state– almost any modern state – is a set of interlinked conspiracies, competing for money (taxes) and power.
  • Robin Ramsay,Conspiracy and DemocracyLobster#68 (pdf)(Winter 2014)

• John Naughton’s comment that ‘sometimes governments and organisations do conspire’ is the place to start. If ‘sometimes’ is in fact frequently, perhaps routinely – and in my view it is – then ‘conspiracy theorising’ is not per se the irrational activity the project assumes it to be. Many conspiracy theoriests are incompetent and many of the theories proposed are false butSturgeon’s lawapplies here: if 90% of conspiracy theories are crap, so is 90% of everything. It is easy to sneer at stupid conspiracy theories and mock the thinking processes of those who advocate them. But in doing so academics and journalists are contaminating the good theories with the bad, lumping together secret state research andDavid Icke’s reptilian delusions as ‘conspiracy theories’. Which is, of course, what the state wants us to do.
  (Footnote: John Naughton, one of the three directors of the project, tweeted: ‘The minute you get into theJFKstuff and the minute you sniff at the 9/11 stuff you begin to lose the will to live’. Seehttp://www.conspiracyanddemocracy.org/blog/category/jfk/.Yes, both subjects are full of crappy thinking and writing; and, yes, both subjects are now enormous and enormously complex. But tough shit: you cannot just pass on events of this size and expect to be taken seriously.Sturgeon’s law page on Wikipedia)
  • Robin Ramsay,Conspiracy and DemocracyLobster#68 (pdf)(Winter 2014)

• Most Americans will be shocked to learn that the conspiracy-theory label was popularized as a pejorative term by theCentral Intelligence Agency(CIA) in apropagandaprogram initiated in 1967. This program was directed at criticisms of theWarren Commission'sreport. The propaganda campaign called on media corporations and journalists to criticize "conspiracy theorists" and raise questions about their motives and judgments.
  • Lance deHaven-Smith,Conspiracy Theory in America(University of Texas Press:2014), p. 21

• Conspiracy Theory in Americais about the transformation of America's civic culture from theFounders' hard-nosed realism aboutelitepolitical intrigue to today's blanket condemnation of conspiracy beliefs as ludicrous by definition. This cultural reversal did not occur spontaneously; it was planned and orchestrated by the government itself.
  • Lance deHaven-Smith,Conspiracy Theory in America(University of Texas Press:2014), p. 21

• Young people who question the government or media may be “extremists”,UK authorities have declared, as the full-scaleOrwellisationof our society continues apace. The leaflet, handed to parents inLondon,says the danger signs of so-called radicalisation include “showing a mistrust ofmainstream mediareports and belief in conspiracy theories” and “appearing angry about government policies, especiallyforeign policy”.Numbed slack-jawed conformists gawping apathetically at the TV set are, presumably, the ideal non-extremist citizens of tomorrow.
  • The Acorn #19, (full text online)(December 22, 2015)

• Any analysis which involves anything smacking of “conspiracy” is almost taboo in certain radical circles, for some reason. But scornfully muttering the words “conspiracy theory” does not magically stop real conspiracies from existing…
  • The Acorn,(December 22, 2015)

• A dull-witted right-wing conspiracy theorist might get stuck at the level of mere specifics and come to the facile conclusion that the people responsible for such-and-such wrongdoing must also be responsible for all wrong-doing, everywhere and throughout history.
  But anyone endowed with the powers of reason will understand that this is not the case and that there is also a bigger picture. AsRamsaysays, there is a difference between “theories about conspiracies” and an all-embracing “Conspiracy Theory” which seeks to explain everything in one neat little package, at the expense of any deeper understanding.
  • The Acorn,(11 January 2016)

• If anti-capitalists refuse to protest against theBilderbergmeetings of global capitalist leaders because they might find themselves rubbing shoulders with right-wing conspiracy nutters, then opposition to the Bilderberg gatherings can easily be presented as borderline insanity.
  • The Acorn,(11 January 2016)

• Nobody trusts anyone in authority today. It is one of the main features of our age. Wherever you look there are lyingpoliticians,crookedbankers,corrupt police officers,cheating journalists and double-dealing media barons, sinister children’s entertainers, rotten and greedy energy companies and out-of-control security services. And what makes the suspicion worse is that practically no-one ever gets prosecuted for the scandals. Certainly nobody at the top.
  • Adam Curtis,inHypernormalisation,BBC,(11 October 2016)

• Conspiracy theory: a theory that explains an event or situation as the result of a secret plan by usually powerful people or groups.
  Conspiracy: a secret plan made by two or more people to do something that is harmful or illegal
  Theory: 1. An idea or set of ideas that is intended to explain facts or events.
  • Merriam-Webster, Learner's Dictionary(2019)

• Conspiracy: a secret plan made by two or more people to do something bad, illegal, or against someone’s wishes
  Theory:something suggested as a reasonable explanation for facts, a condition, or an event, esp. a systematic or scientific explanation
  Conspiracy theory: a belief that an event or situation is the result of a secret plan made by powerful people
  • Cambridge Dictionary, Cambridge University Press(2019)

• Russell Muirhead and Nancy L. Rosenblum... write at the beginning of “A Lot of People Are Saying: The New Conspiracism and the Assault on Democracy”... it’s been out-of-power groups that have been drawn to tales of secret plots. Today, it’s those in power who insist the game is rigged, and no one more insistently than the so-called leader of the free world... As government agencies “lose competence and capacity, they will come to look more and more illegitimate to more and more people,”
  The Internet revolution “has displaced the gatekeepers, the producers, editors, and scholars who decided what was worthy of dissemination,” Is it possible to make a rigorous study of conspiracy theories?...Research into conspiracy theories “has been hampered by a lack of long-term systematic data,” Uscinski and Parent, political scientists at the University of Miami and theUniversity of Notre Dame,respectively, write in “American Conspiracy Theories.” Fortunately, “methods are now available to better scrutinize what we think we know.”
  • Elizabeth Kolbert,What’s New About Conspiracy Theories? The New Yorker(15 April 2019)

• The reality is that the US has been a nation gripped by conspiracy for a long time. The Kennedy assassination has been hotly debated for years. Thefeministandantiwar movementsof the1960swere, for a time, believed by a not-inconsiderable number of Americans to be part of acommunistplot to weaken the country. A majority have believed for decades that the government is hiding what it knows aboutextraterrestrials...
  There is a perpetual tug between conspiracy theorists and actual conspiracies, between things that are genuinely not believable and truths that are so outlandish they can be hard, at first, to believe.
  But while conspiracy theories are as old as the US itself, there is something new at work... historically, times of tumult and social upheaval tend to lead to a parallel surge in conspiracy thinking... our increasingly rigid class structure, one that leaves many people feeling locked into their circumstances... Together, these elements helped create a society in which many Americans see millions of snares, laid by a menacing group of enemies, all the more alarming for how difficult they are to identify and pin down.
  • Why we are addicted to conspiracy theories, The Guardian,Anna Merlan,(2 May 2019) [edited extract fromRepublic of Lies: American Conspiracy Theorists and Their Surprising Rise to Powerby Anna Merlan]

• Conspiracy theories tend to flourish especially at times of rapid social change, when we are re-evaluating ourselves and, perhaps, facing uncomfortable questions in the process... Frank Donner wrote that conspiracism reveals a fundamental insecurity about who Americans want to be versus who they are. “Especially in times of stress, exaggerated febrile explanations of unwelcome reality come to the surface of American life and attract support,” he wrote. The continual resurgence of conspiracy movements, he claimed, “illuminate[s] a striking contrast between our claims to superiority, indeed our mission as a redeemer nation to bring a new world order, and the extraordinary fragility of our confidence in our institutions”. That contrast, he said, “has led some observers to conclude that we are, subconsciously, quite insecure about the value and permanence of our society”.
  • Why we are addicted to conspiracy theories, The Guardian,Anna Merlan,(2 May 2019) [edited extract fromRepublic of Lies: American Conspiracy Theorists and Their Surprising Rise to Powerby Anna Merlan]

• Medical conspiracy theories are startlingly widespread. In a study published in 2014,University of Chicagopolitical scientists Eric Oliver and Thomas Wood surveyed 1,351 American adults and found that 37% believe the USFood and Drug Administrationis “intentionally suppressing natural cures forcancerbecause of drug company pressure”. Meanwhile, 20% agreed thatcorporationsare preventing public health officials from releasing data linking mobile phones to cancer, and another 20% that doctors still want to vaccinate children “even though they know suchvaccinesto be dangerous”.... Subscribing to those conspiracy theories is linked to specifichealthbehaviours: believers are less likely to get flu jabs or wear sunscreen and more likely to seek alternative treatments. (In a more harmless vein, they are also more likely to buy organic vegetables and avoid GMOs.) They are also less inclined to consult a family doctor...
  • Why we are addicted to conspiracy theories, The Guardian,Anna Merlan,(2 May 2019) [edited extract fromRepublic of Lies: American Conspiracy Theorists and Their Surprising Rise to Powerby Anna Merlan]

• 1. Conspiracy to turn the world into a giant marketplace for the benefit of the wealthy elite...
  2. Conspiracy bytransnational corporationsto turn billions of people intoaddicts...
  3. Conspiracy to plunder the Global South for the benefit of the Global North...
  4. Conspiracy tohide the effects of climate breakdownfor corporateprofit...
  5. Conspiracy to grow theglobal economyindefinitely, whilekilling most of lifeonEarthand risking thecollapse of civilization....
  So who, in this case, are the conspirators? If you’re living a normal life in an affluent country, you don’t need to look further than the mirror.... So, the next time someone tells you to “do your research” on their new conspiracy theory, please point them to the real conspiracies that are threatening life on this beautiful but troubled planet. The good news is that, since they’re real conspiracies, there is something we can do about them. We can vote in politicians that promise to peel back theneoliberalnightmare; advocate for curbs on predatory corporate activities; support the Global South in changing the terms of international trade; declare aClimate Emergencyin our community to turn aroundcarbon emissions;and become active in the movement to transform our global society to an Ecological Civilization—one that is based on life-affirming principles rather than accumulatingwealth.
  • Jeremy LentinThe Five Real Conspiracies You Need to Know About,Opendemocracy(1 October 2020)

• In his book, Rahul Roushan writes, “This is why conspiracy theories are so popular in theMuslim world-9/11 was an inside job,ISISwas created by the US,Mumbai terror attackswere carried out by theRSS,thePulwama terror attackwas done by theGovernment of India,the Godhra train carnage was an accident, no Muslim mob ever attackeddoctorsorpolicemenduring thecoronavirus lockdown—you name a conspiracy theory, and it has an audience.”....
  Explaining the ‘perpetual victimhood’ displayed by the Muslims, Rahul Roushan writes, “An average Muslim is perpetually in victimhood mode due to this. Such theories convince him that everyone else is conspiring to giveMuslimsandIslama bad name. Such conspiracy theories not only get support from the Right-wing groups among the Muslim community but from seemingly neutral and erudite intellectuals of the society too. Ironically, theIslamistsprivately celebrate or take pride in each of these incidents, but with active support from theleftistsandliberals,they publicly deny it. And the common person is left confused about what reality is and what is fiction.”
  • Rahul Roushan in his book “Sanghi Who Never Went To A Sangha"[1]

See Also

• Conspiracy