What do you think?
Rate this book
Orphan Train #1
With You Always
A Riveting Look at the Orphan Train from Historical Novelist Jody Hedlund
When a financial crisis in 1850s New York leaves three orphaned sisters nearly destitute, the oldest, Elise Neumann, knows she must take action. She's had experience as a seamstress, and the New York Children's Aid Society has established a special service: placing out seamstresses and trade girls. Even though Elise doesn't want to leave her sisters for a job in Illinois, she realizes this may be their last chance.
The son of one of New York City's wealthiest entrepreneurs, Thornton Quincy faces a dilemma. His father is dying, and in order to decide which of his sons will inherit everything, he is requiring them to do two things in six months: build a sustainable town along the Illinois Central Railroad, and get married. Thornton is tired of standing in his twin brother's shadow and is determined to win his father's challenge. He doesn't plan on meeting a feisty young woman on his way west, though.
When a financial crisis in 1850s New York leaves three orphaned sisters nearly destitute, the oldest, Elise Neumann, knows she must take action. She's had experience as a seamstress, and the New York Children's Aid Society has established a special service: placing out seamstresses and trade girls. Even though Elise doesn't want to leave her sisters for a job in Illinois, she realizes this may be their last chance.
The son of one of New York City's wealthiest entrepreneurs, Thornton Quincy faces a dilemma. His father is dying, and in order to decide which of his sons will inherit everything, he is requiring them to do two things in six months: build a sustainable town along the Illinois Central Railroad, and get married. Thornton is tired of standing in his twin brother's shadow and is determined to win his father's challenge. He doesn't plan on meeting a feisty young woman on his way west, though.
359 pages, Paperback
First published June 1, 2017
About the author
Jody Hedlund
72 books4,330 followersJody Hedlund is the best-selling author of over fifty books and is the winner of numerous awards. She writes sweet historical romances with plenty of sizzle. Find out more at jodyhedlund.com.
Jody lives in central Michigan with her husband, five busy children, and five spoiled cats. When she’s not penning another of her page-turning stories, she loves to spend her time reading, especially when it also involves consuming coffee and chocolate.
Jody lives in central Michigan with her husband, five busy children, and five spoiled cats. When she’s not penning another of her page-turning stories, she loves to spend her time reading, especially when it also involves consuming coffee and chocolate.
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 666 reviews
May 23, 2020
0.79 e-book https://amzn.to/2XnGy3X
(5/23/20)
The plot of this book is not quite what I expected- when I hear "orphan train" I picture the children from the city getting placed in families out West. The author instead focuses on an orphaned family being torn apart as unemployed women are sent on trains to help establish new towns where there are jobs waiting to be filled. Of course, my expectations of the quality of writing were met- I learned so much history, was immersed in the setting, and the characters came to life with emotion and feeling as they navigate complex relationship dynamics and uncertain and desperate circumstances. The main perspectives are Elise and Thorton as they embark on new ventures in Illinois, but we also see some scenes from Elise's family she had to leave behind in New York. While Elise is the strong and stalwart oldest sister who takes on the responsibility of her sisters and the young children they take under their wing, on her journey we see her vulnerability and innocence as well as her fortitude and spunk. Thorton is drawn to her and his protective feelings quickly develop into something more, despite his plan to court and marry a high society lady he believes his father would approve of. Elise challenges his town development methods and unequal treatment of the female employees, and grows to admire him as he meets her challenges and is changed through the experience. There are villains lurking and conflict arises as Thorton's deadline grows closer, and Elise's concern for her sisters is validated. They both struggle with faith but their trials prove to be a refiner's fire that strengthens them as they reconcile with the Lord and turn to Him for guidance. Highly recommend to fans of historical fiction!
(I received a complimentary copy of the book; all opinions in this review are my own)
(5/23/20)
The plot of this book is not quite what I expected- when I hear "orphan train" I picture the children from the city getting placed in families out West. The author instead focuses on an orphaned family being torn apart as unemployed women are sent on trains to help establish new towns where there are jobs waiting to be filled. Of course, my expectations of the quality of writing were met- I learned so much history, was immersed in the setting, and the characters came to life with emotion and feeling as they navigate complex relationship dynamics and uncertain and desperate circumstances. The main perspectives are Elise and Thorton as they embark on new ventures in Illinois, but we also see some scenes from Elise's family she had to leave behind in New York. While Elise is the strong and stalwart oldest sister who takes on the responsibility of her sisters and the young children they take under their wing, on her journey we see her vulnerability and innocence as well as her fortitude and spunk. Thorton is drawn to her and his protective feelings quickly develop into something more, despite his plan to court and marry a high society lady he believes his father would approve of. Elise challenges his town development methods and unequal treatment of the female employees, and grows to admire him as he meets her challenges and is changed through the experience. There are villains lurking and conflict arises as Thorton's deadline grows closer, and Elise's concern for her sisters is validated. They both struggle with faith but their trials prove to be a refiner's fire that strengthens them as they reconcile with the Lord and turn to Him for guidance. Highly recommend to fans of historical fiction!
(I received a complimentary copy of the book; all opinions in this review are my own)
June 20, 2017
I can quite honestly say that this story is one of Jody Hedlund's best to date. Elise is a vibrant character, with a keen sense of honor and a deep love for her family. Each bit of this story unfolded to show a woman brave in adversity, strong enough to put aside love for honor, and ready to make whatever sacrifices needed for her sisters' sake.
I deeply appreciated that there wasn't any smooshy "romance," but instead a true love, shown in a couple of kisses and also a strong regard for each other—as well as a challenge for each to become a better person. Elise is challenged in her faith; Thornton in his views toward humanity around him. Both characters start out nicely and grow through the course of the story into strong adults ready to face the world and change it for the better. What more can I ask?
I deeply appreciated that there wasn't any smooshy "romance," but instead a true love, shown in a couple of kisses and also a strong regard for each other—as well as a challenge for each to become a better person. Elise is challenged in her faith; Thornton in his views toward humanity around him. Both characters start out nicely and grow through the course of the story into strong adults ready to face the world and change it for the better. What more can I ask?
June 23, 2017
I’ve said this before in my reviews of several Hedlund novels, and it continues to be true here; she takes women from history and brings them to life in fresh ways, bringing the reader a romantic story, while also being true to the historical context and providing details that fascinate. In Elise Neumann’s story, it’s the orphan train, and though it presents a different facet of the orphan train that I was initially thinking, I loved this look into what it would be like for a woman who chooses to travel to a start-up town out west for work. For Elise, more than just her own well-being and future is at stake – her younger sisters and their adopted charges are first and foremost in her mind.
Though our characters Elise and Thornton are from different stations of society, they feel a connection with one another instantly, but fear not, it's not insta-love, but rather a mutual enjoyment of each other's company. They never expect to see each other again but hardship brings them together by way of the New York Children's Aid Society and Elise's desire to help her family. What I liked most is how they challenge each other and bring out different sides of their personalities. Their interactions in the beginning are especially bittersweet, as Thornton fights with himself over his desire to spend more time with her, knowing in the back of his mind that he has a challenge to win – a challenge that has no place for Elise Neumann. While at first it seemed like he was just ignoring the truth of his feelings, he is finally honest with himself - he knows that what he wants and the challenge set before him by his father are two different things. Instead of focusing on the challenge at hand, he finds himself challenged by Elise – to really put himself in his workers shoes, to really think about living life the way they have to do.
I know there were women like Elise who beseeched others to consider the plight of the poor and disregarded. I deeply appreciate the way that Hedlund sheds light on the plight of the poor in New York during this time period leading up to the orphan trains. While it is hard to fathom from today’s perspective either giving up your child, or leaving your family to work, for many back then, it was the only option. It really prompted me to remember not to cast judgement on the decisions of others and to remember to look at things from their perspective.
With You Always is another winning romantic historical by Jody Hedlund! Fans of her previous books will not be disappointed. While it doesn’t replace my favorite of her novels, I truly loved the look at the plight of orphans and women especially. It is great start to a new series, and a new Hedlund series is such a treat to look forward to. I’m eager to read Marianne and Sophie’s stories that are hopefully to come! Oh, and do read the ebook prequel novella if you get the chance - it's short, well-done story that sets up a nice backdrop to Elise's story. Also, can I just say that Bethany House hit it out of the park with this cover and the overall design of the book. It’s seriously lovely, and when the story inside is as lovely as the outside, it makes for a wonderful reading experience.
Though our characters Elise and Thornton are from different stations of society, they feel a connection with one another instantly, but fear not, it's not insta-love, but rather a mutual enjoyment of each other's company. They never expect to see each other again but hardship brings them together by way of the New York Children's Aid Society and Elise's desire to help her family. What I liked most is how they challenge each other and bring out different sides of their personalities. Their interactions in the beginning are especially bittersweet, as Thornton fights with himself over his desire to spend more time with her, knowing in the back of his mind that he has a challenge to win – a challenge that has no place for Elise Neumann. While at first it seemed like he was just ignoring the truth of his feelings, he is finally honest with himself - he knows that what he wants and the challenge set before him by his father are two different things. Instead of focusing on the challenge at hand, he finds himself challenged by Elise – to really put himself in his workers shoes, to really think about living life the way they have to do.
I know there were women like Elise who beseeched others to consider the plight of the poor and disregarded. I deeply appreciate the way that Hedlund sheds light on the plight of the poor in New York during this time period leading up to the orphan trains. While it is hard to fathom from today’s perspective either giving up your child, or leaving your family to work, for many back then, it was the only option. It really prompted me to remember not to cast judgement on the decisions of others and to remember to look at things from their perspective.
With You Always is another winning romantic historical by Jody Hedlund! Fans of her previous books will not be disappointed. While it doesn’t replace my favorite of her novels, I truly loved the look at the plight of orphans and women especially. It is great start to a new series, and a new Hedlund series is such a treat to look forward to. I’m eager to read Marianne and Sophie’s stories that are hopefully to come! Oh, and do read the ebook prequel novella if you get the chance - it's short, well-done story that sets up a nice backdrop to Elise's story. Also, can I just say that Bethany House hit it out of the park with this cover and the overall design of the book. It’s seriously lovely, and when the story inside is as lovely as the outside, it makes for a wonderful reading experience.
May 6, 2017
I had read a preview for this book in An Awakened Heart, which is a free preview kindle book on Amazon, https://www.amazon.com/Awakened-Heart..., and you will not be disappointed.
I was a page turning very quickly and this book is one that will linger with you, a very compelling read and enjoyable.
When we look back to the 1800’s in our country and look at a city like New York and its immigrant population, life was far from easy, and people tended to gather in areas from the same ethnicity.
The family we are following, and again I recommend you read the freebee, is from Germany, and although some are grown, they are orphans, and there are no jobs and they can’t afford any housing. Desperate, the oldest Elise heads out West hoping to earn enough to send for the others.
A chance meeting on the streets of NY and our Elise already knows a prospective employer whom she meets again on the train to Illinois, Thorton Quincy. You are in for a treat as you catch the banter that these two seem to enjoy.
What Elise doesn’t know is that Thorton and his twin brother have been challenged by their wealthy father to establish a self sustaining town and marry for love, and have all accomplished in six months. So while attracted to Elise, Thorton must marry well, or so he thinks.
A book filled with surprises, and not all to my liking, but a story that will keep you up late reading, and you won’t be disappointed.
I received this book through Net Galley and the Publisher Bethany House, and was not required to give a positive review.
I was a page turning very quickly and this book is one that will linger with you, a very compelling read and enjoyable.
When we look back to the 1800’s in our country and look at a city like New York and its immigrant population, life was far from easy, and people tended to gather in areas from the same ethnicity.
The family we are following, and again I recommend you read the freebee, is from Germany, and although some are grown, they are orphans, and there are no jobs and they can’t afford any housing. Desperate, the oldest Elise heads out West hoping to earn enough to send for the others.
A chance meeting on the streets of NY and our Elise already knows a prospective employer whom she meets again on the train to Illinois, Thorton Quincy. You are in for a treat as you catch the banter that these two seem to enjoy.
What Elise doesn’t know is that Thorton and his twin brother have been challenged by their wealthy father to establish a self sustaining town and marry for love, and have all accomplished in six months. So while attracted to Elise, Thorton must marry well, or so he thinks.
A book filled with surprises, and not all to my liking, but a story that will keep you up late reading, and you won’t be disappointed.
I received this book through Net Galley and the Publisher Bethany House, and was not required to give a positive review.
July 26, 2017
With You Always is a beautifully told story of the hardships of women and orphans in New York City in the mid 19th century. The book is about a young woman named Elise who is the oldest of three sisters trying to keep her orphaned family together. She reluctantly leaves to find work in central Illinois. She catches the eye of a very handsome man named Thornton. It turns out that he will be her employer. There is a lot of fun banter between them as well as a strong attraction between them both. This book shows the hardships of the times, but also shows hope. This story has a wonderful inspirational message as well as a sweet romance. This was a page turner for me. I really enjoyed it and I can't wait for the next book in the series.
*I was given a copy of this book by the publisher via netgalley and was not required to leave a review.
*I was given a copy of this book by the publisher via netgalley and was not required to leave a review.
July 13, 2020
Update: I have to admit, I was sure I had read one of Ms. Hedlund's books before. Oops . . . I haven't so this is a new author to me. Even though I have many of her books on my TBR list.
Once again Ms. Hedlund did not disappoint. I so enjoyed the story of Elise Neumann. From losing both parents and having to raise her two sisters, along with two additional orphans, on her own in a declining city with very little work. With the chance meeting of Thorton Quincy, her life could change in ways she never dreamed. Having to leave her sisters in New York City at a mission, while she travels to the wilds of Illinois, to the start of a new town that is anything but ideal. In a competition with his brother of who shall take over their father's company, Elise puts Thornton to the test of what it really means to be a boss.
This is a great start to this new trilogy and cannot wait to read on about Marianne and Sophie.
Once again Ms. Hedlund did not disappoint. I so enjoyed the story of Elise Neumann. From losing both parents and having to raise her two sisters, along with two additional orphans, on her own in a declining city with very little work. With the chance meeting of Thorton Quincy, her life could change in ways she never dreamed. Having to leave her sisters in New York City at a mission, while she travels to the wilds of Illinois, to the start of a new town that is anything but ideal. In a competition with his brother of who shall take over their father's company, Elise puts Thornton to the test of what it really means to be a boss.
This is a great start to this new trilogy and cannot wait to read on about Marianne and Sophie.
June 22, 2017
I was so excited to see a new series by Jody Hedlund. I remember growing up adoring the Joan Lowry Nixon Orphan Train books. And now to read more about that period of history by one of my favorite authors as an adult, well, let's just say that I was pretty much over the moon.
I knew that the Children's Aid Society placed children, orphans or not, in homes in the west. Yet I didn't know that they also found jobs for women. I also found the idea of building a town around the railroad fascinating.
I loved both Thornton and Elise. I loved how her suggestions were things that he actually took into consideration. I loved how he wanted to protect her and to provide for her. Watching them fight their feelings for each other was fun.
I am looking forward to the rest of this series. I am hoping for both Marianne's and Sophie's stories.
I received a copy of this book for free from the publisher. My thoughts and opinions are my own.
Recommended to fans of Jody Hedlund, Karen Witemeyer, historical fiction, orphan trains
Rating - 4 stars
I knew that the Children's Aid Society placed children, orphans or not, in homes in the west. Yet I didn't know that they also found jobs for women. I also found the idea of building a town around the railroad fascinating.
I loved both Thornton and Elise. I loved how her suggestions were things that he actually took into consideration. I loved how he wanted to protect her and to provide for her. Watching them fight their feelings for each other was fun.
I am looking forward to the rest of this series. I am hoping for both Marianne's and Sophie's stories.
I received a copy of this book for free from the publisher. My thoughts and opinions are my own.
Recommended to fans of Jody Hedlund, Karen Witemeyer, historical fiction, orphan trains
Rating - 4 stars
April 21, 2023
I always enjoy a good Jody Hedlund story. The story of the orphan trains in 19th Century America always fascinated me as a young child. Hence, I couldn't resist downloading the trilogy from Kindle Unlimited.
For this first book in the series, I based the story around the placing out of women that happened in 1857 as a result of a financial crisis and economic panic in the autumn of that year. Women laborers were already at a disadvantage with poor working conditions and low wages. In September of 1857, estimates of New York unemployment ran as high as forty percent. Author's Note
Our main protagonist, Elise Neumann is a German Immigrant in New York City. She and her sisters, Marianne and Sophie are now orphans. Both their parents died of illness and they are living at the mission house. When Elise has an opportunity to make more wages to support her family, she takes the train headed to Illinois. A meeting with the wealthy entrepreneur Thornton Quincy is not what Elise expected. But sparks do fly. When Elise becomes his employee, the young woman opens her employer's eyes to the working conditions of many of his employees and teaches him the lesson of working with his hands.
I am not going to deny that some of this romance was cheesy and predictable BUT I couldn't stop reading. Elise was a bit innocent and naïve for my liking but I am interested in continuing the trilogy.
Goodreads review published 21/04/23
For this first book in the series, I based the story around the placing out of women that happened in 1857 as a result of a financial crisis and economic panic in the autumn of that year. Women laborers were already at a disadvantage with poor working conditions and low wages. In September of 1857, estimates of New York unemployment ran as high as forty percent. Author's Note
Our main protagonist, Elise Neumann is a German Immigrant in New York City. She and her sisters, Marianne and Sophie are now orphans. Both their parents died of illness and they are living at the mission house. When Elise has an opportunity to make more wages to support her family, she takes the train headed to Illinois. A meeting with the wealthy entrepreneur Thornton Quincy is not what Elise expected. But sparks do fly. When Elise becomes his employee, the young woman opens her employer's eyes to the working conditions of many of his employees and teaches him the lesson of working with his hands.
I am not going to deny that some of this romance was cheesy and predictable BUT I couldn't stop reading. Elise was a bit innocent and naïve for my liking but I am interested in continuing the trilogy.
Goodreads review published 21/04/23
January 29, 2022
FTC Disclosure: I received a complimentary copy of this book. These are my honest thoughts.
This book held such an interesting premise: twin brothers competing in business and love in order to win an inheritance from their dying father. Who wouldn’t be intrigued by such a concept? For the most part, these aspects were very well written, although I would have loved getting to see how the second town was building up and getting to know that brother better. As it was, I didn’t feel like I got to know him much at all.
I struggled to understand why this book was part of a series titled “Orphan Train.” Like the prequel, this story did NOT feature an orphan train. At least this time such a train was mentioned—but only twice. Once at 42% in a single sentence, and again at 79% in perhaps a paragraph or two. In all 359 pages, these two extremely minor mentions of an orphan train did not really qualify the book to fit into a series entitled “Orphan Train.” This is the largest reason for my being done with this series right here. I’ve read two books, looking forward to reading about an orphan train, and twice I’ve been hugely disappointed at the misguidance the series title gave me.
Another struggle I had with this book, as with at least two previous Jody Hedlund books, was the carnal turn the romance took. The romance was chaste and sweet until the man suddenly ogled “every sweet, blessed curve of [the leading lady’s] body.” He didn’t stop at ogling, either. He took advantage of a situation to get physical with her. This physical aspect went on for at least a dozen paragraphs. The whole situation felt contrived for the sole purpose of forcing the romance to “progress.” What it actually did was ruin the reputations of both leads—though, of course, that didn’t factor into the storyline, as apparently no one in town cared if these leaders of the community suddenly acted in an unchaste manner in public, which I found unrealistic for an 1850s-era story. This one, long-lasting moment stripped all my respect for both characters but especially for the leading man, because he let his carnal desires take over rather than making sure the lady’s reputation was preserved.
In the first three fourths of the book, there was good, clean humor between Elise and Thornton. This was refreshing but was later distorted by the abovementioned issue.
I enjoyed how Elise encouraged Thornton to grow and mature in his perspective and actions in the story where the town-building was concerned. This part was superbly written, as was the town-building itself.
My heart ached for Elise and her siblings. Their story was almost enough to make me pick up the next book… but I’m going to assume all turns out fairly well by the end of the series, as I don’t care to continue reading it.
Content: prostitution mentioned, taverns, drunkenness, alcohol (including in food), rape inferred, replacement expletives, derogatory term
This book held such an interesting premise: twin brothers competing in business and love in order to win an inheritance from their dying father. Who wouldn’t be intrigued by such a concept? For the most part, these aspects were very well written, although I would have loved getting to see how the second town was building up and getting to know that brother better. As it was, I didn’t feel like I got to know him much at all.
I struggled to understand why this book was part of a series titled “Orphan Train.” Like the prequel, this story did NOT feature an orphan train. At least this time such a train was mentioned—but only twice. Once at 42% in a single sentence, and again at 79% in perhaps a paragraph or two. In all 359 pages, these two extremely minor mentions of an orphan train did not really qualify the book to fit into a series entitled “Orphan Train.” This is the largest reason for my being done with this series right here. I’ve read two books, looking forward to reading about an orphan train, and twice I’ve been hugely disappointed at the misguidance the series title gave me.
Another struggle I had with this book, as with at least two previous Jody Hedlund books, was the carnal turn the romance took. The romance was chaste and sweet until the man suddenly ogled “every sweet, blessed curve of [the leading lady’s] body.” He didn’t stop at ogling, either. He took advantage of a situation to get physical with her. This physical aspect went on for at least a dozen paragraphs. The whole situation felt contrived for the sole purpose of forcing the romance to “progress.” What it actually did was ruin the reputations of both leads—though, of course, that didn’t factor into the storyline, as apparently no one in town cared if these leaders of the community suddenly acted in an unchaste manner in public, which I found unrealistic for an 1850s-era story. This one, long-lasting moment stripped all my respect for both characters but especially for the leading man, because he let his carnal desires take over rather than making sure the lady’s reputation was preserved.
In the first three fourths of the book, there was good, clean humor between Elise and Thornton. This was refreshing but was later distorted by the abovementioned issue.
I enjoyed how Elise encouraged Thornton to grow and mature in his perspective and actions in the story where the town-building was concerned. This part was superbly written, as was the town-building itself.
My heart ached for Elise and her siblings. Their story was almost enough to make me pick up the next book… but I’m going to assume all turns out fairly well by the end of the series, as I don’t care to continue reading it.
Content: prostitution mentioned, taverns, drunkenness, alcohol (including in food), rape inferred, replacement expletives, derogatory term
June 5, 2017
"Are you sure?"
Elise Neumann has not been sure of anything since her parents died, leaving Elise and her two siblings penniless, and in dire need of safe housing and proper employment. Forced to flee a deplorable situation; Elise, her two younger sisters, and two orphans manage to find Seventh Street Mission, where a previous acquaintance offers a providential, albeit temporary, respite from their desperation. When New York City becomes plagued with riots and rampant bankruptcies, Elise makes the bold decision to leave the city for employment further west, determined to send her earnings back home, never imagining that a chance encounter with a handsome stranger would follow her all the way to Illinois.
Thornton Quincy is in a competition against his twin brother; their dying father having thrown down the gauntlet to determine which of his sons will continue his economic dynasty. Thornton and Bradford have six short months to develop a prosperous community along their west bound rail line; in addition, they must marry for love before Christmas Day. Although sensibly entertained with a beautiful socialite, Thornton finds that his heart is pulling him towards another; one who certainly won't gain him an empire, but who has already made him a better man.
Jody Hedlund never disappoints, and "With You Always" tenderly unwraps an intriguing portion of our nation's history, carrying a poignant reminder that though we may "walk through the valley of the shadow of death" in this life, our gracious Lord is only a hand hold away.
I received a copy of this book from the author. The opinions stated above are entirely my own.
Elise Neumann has not been sure of anything since her parents died, leaving Elise and her two siblings penniless, and in dire need of safe housing and proper employment. Forced to flee a deplorable situation; Elise, her two younger sisters, and two orphans manage to find Seventh Street Mission, where a previous acquaintance offers a providential, albeit temporary, respite from their desperation. When New York City becomes plagued with riots and rampant bankruptcies, Elise makes the bold decision to leave the city for employment further west, determined to send her earnings back home, never imagining that a chance encounter with a handsome stranger would follow her all the way to Illinois.
Thornton Quincy is in a competition against his twin brother; their dying father having thrown down the gauntlet to determine which of his sons will continue his economic dynasty. Thornton and Bradford have six short months to develop a prosperous community along their west bound rail line; in addition, they must marry for love before Christmas Day. Although sensibly entertained with a beautiful socialite, Thornton finds that his heart is pulling him towards another; one who certainly won't gain him an empire, but who has already made him a better man.
Jody Hedlund never disappoints, and "With You Always" tenderly unwraps an intriguing portion of our nation's history, carrying a poignant reminder that though we may "walk through the valley of the shadow of death" in this life, our gracious Lord is only a hand hold away.
I received a copy of this book from the author. The opinions stated above are entirely my own.
March 3, 2023
Unfortunately, With You Always was a sour experience for me because of the hero and the romance.
Although I was sympathetic to Thornton in the beginning, he definitely lost his shine as a hero as the story progressed. He's not forthcoming to Elise about his identity or his intentions/relationship with another woman as they travel west to Illinois, and he strings her along. Later, he apologizes for leading Elise on, but the sentiment is hollow and there's no real change in his character. Regardless of the friend label he puts on Elise, he still expresses keen romantic interest in her that it's absolutely unfair to both women involved, especially considering that he isn't forthcoming about his relationship to each of them. Furthermore, he was never truthful by choice when it came to both women - the truth only coming out by him being exposed, which only made me see him as a coward.
Consequently, the romance was unbearable for me, especially considering that the weight of Thornton's actions was ignored, pushed aside, and not fully addressed. Instead Thornton is presented to the audience as an honorable man, a statement that I wholeheartedly disagree with. Ultimately, I found Thornton to be untrue and his actions eclipsed and tainted the romance entirely for me.
In the end, this book just wasn't for me.
Although I was sympathetic to Thornton in the beginning, he definitely lost his shine as a hero as the story progressed. He's not forthcoming to Elise about his identity or his intentions/relationship with another woman as they travel west to Illinois, and he strings her along. Later, he apologizes for leading Elise on, but the sentiment is hollow and there's no real change in his character. Regardless of the friend label he puts on Elise, he still expresses keen romantic interest in her that it's absolutely unfair to both women involved, especially considering that he isn't forthcoming about his relationship to each of them. Furthermore, he was never truthful by choice when it came to both women - the truth only coming out by him being exposed, which only made me see him as a coward.
Consequently, the romance was unbearable for me, especially considering that the weight of Thornton's actions was ignored, pushed aside, and not fully addressed. Instead Thornton is presented to the audience as an honorable man, a statement that I wholeheartedly disagree with. Ultimately, I found Thornton to be untrue and his actions eclipsed and tainted the romance entirely for me.
In the end, this book just wasn't for me.
July 28, 2017
Loved this book! Great start to a new series. I can't wait to read about the rest of the sisters! More detailed review to follow.
*Thanks to the author & publisher for a complimentary copy of this book. I was not paid or required to write a positive review and all opinions stated are my own.*
*Thanks to the author & publisher for a complimentary copy of this book. I was not paid or required to write a positive review and all opinions stated are my own.*
June 27, 2018
At 40% percent: I'm having a hard time with this one. I don't find either MC all that likable. The H is in a competition with his brother to fall in love with and marry someone, already has a specific person in mind and has been wooing her. However, he's attracted to h instead and starts taking her out to dinner, paying her compliments, and basically wooing her too, all while hiding his real identity from her. He strings her along, knowing all the while that his father would never approve of her, and his shame and self loathing dont't come soon enough.
Upon finishing, my initial reaction stands. Added to my thoughts above, the h turned into a self sacrificing martyr. Er. I enjoyed the historical aspect of this story, as heartbreaking as it was. It was well developed, interesting, and inspired a deep level of gratitude in me. The two stars I give are for the enjoyable storytelling (multiple povs told in the third person), the historical context, and the message of this story. Unfortunately, the MCs left much to be desired. They were complex and developing, but they weren't very likable.
Upon finishing, my initial reaction stands. Added to my thoughts above, the h turned into a self sacrificing martyr. Er. I enjoyed the historical aspect of this story, as heartbreaking as it was. It was well developed, interesting, and inspired a deep level of gratitude in me. The two stars I give are for the enjoyable storytelling (multiple povs told in the third person), the historical context, and the message of this story. Unfortunately, the MCs left much to be desired. They were complex and developing, but they weren't very likable.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
June 28, 2017
Full review on Faithfully Bookish http://wp.me/p7ngfE-10x
The danger, destitution, and desperation of New York City's poor immigrants during this period is vividly portrayed and contrasted against the abundant work opportunities available across the fresh, wide open expanses of central Illinois farmland. Elise Neumann and her younger sisters are literally fighting for survival while struggling to care for a pair of young orphans.
Thornton Quincy has the potential to become a great leader. Despite his ignorance of the hardships endured by the working class, his moral compass is true. Thornton has a lot to learn about the cost of a hard day's work and he needs to weigh what he discovers against his father's expectations for his business and future.
This story touched my heart and had me looking up old railroad maps from the time period. I'm eagerly anticipating each new story in this series and highly recommend this book!
I requested the opportunity to read this book through the publisher. The opinions expressed are my own.
The danger, destitution, and desperation of New York City's poor immigrants during this period is vividly portrayed and contrasted against the abundant work opportunities available across the fresh, wide open expanses of central Illinois farmland. Elise Neumann and her younger sisters are literally fighting for survival while struggling to care for a pair of young orphans.
Thornton Quincy has the potential to become a great leader. Despite his ignorance of the hardships endured by the working class, his moral compass is true. Thornton has a lot to learn about the cost of a hard day's work and he needs to weigh what he discovers against his father's expectations for his business and future.
This story touched my heart and had me looking up old railroad maps from the time period. I'm eagerly anticipating each new story in this series and highly recommend this book!
I requested the opportunity to read this book through the publisher. The opinions expressed are my own.
July 31, 2017
I've not yet read a Jody Hedlund novel I don't enjoy.
In With You Always, Hedlund focuses on the plight of women in 1857 New York. I love the way she takes little known information about women from history and makes it the backdrop for a novel.
This author is a gem. I look forward to continuing the Orphan Train Series.
In With You Always, Hedlund focuses on the plight of women in 1857 New York. I love the way she takes little known information about women from history and makes it the backdrop for a novel.
This author is a gem. I look forward to continuing the Orphan Train Series.
March 6, 2018
With You Always by Jody Hedlund is a delightful Christian historical romance. It is the first book in the Orphan Train series which promises to be fabulous. Fact blends with fiction to produce yet another charming feel-good tale.
The novel explores being true to ourselves. We need to be the person God created us to be. It is no good trying to work to be someone else. One size does not fit all. We are all unique.
Poverty was terrible in New York City in 1857. Lack of work, overcrowded tenements and gang warfare made life precarious. Women went west in search of work to avoid falling into the trap of prostitution to feed their families. It was an era of exploration as well as exploitation.
Good leaders are hard to come by. Good leaders must be small enough to serve before they are big enough to lead. They need to know what their workers are doing by experience and walking in their shoes. Good leaders do not just happen, they are made with respect.
Life and all its burdens can make us bitter if we do not practice a heart that forgives. Carrying guilt will always weigh us down. We need to forgive ourselves as well as others.
In our hurt and pain we may pull away from God and erect walls to keep Him out. She "wished she could draw confidence in God... but a wall stood in the way." God does not cause our troubles but walks alongside us in them. He longs for us to return to Him, until we do, we will not know peace. "God's been there waiting for me."
God is a good Father. We do not have to earn His love, we already have it. He contrasts sharply with some fathers who seem to make their offspring earn their love. Achievement appears to equal love. God's love is freely available to all.
Once again Jody Hedlund has drawn marvellous characters. The two leading characters spar with each other to the amusement of the reader. Poverty of possessions does not equal poverty of love. There are many riches within the story.
I adore all Jody Hedlund's novels. They leave me with a warm heart and a smile on my face.
Absolutely wonderful.
I received this book for free. A favourable review was not required and all views expressed are my own.
The novel explores being true to ourselves. We need to be the person God created us to be. It is no good trying to work to be someone else. One size does not fit all. We are all unique.
Poverty was terrible in New York City in 1857. Lack of work, overcrowded tenements and gang warfare made life precarious. Women went west in search of work to avoid falling into the trap of prostitution to feed their families. It was an era of exploration as well as exploitation.
Good leaders are hard to come by. Good leaders must be small enough to serve before they are big enough to lead. They need to know what their workers are doing by experience and walking in their shoes. Good leaders do not just happen, they are made with respect.
Life and all its burdens can make us bitter if we do not practice a heart that forgives. Carrying guilt will always weigh us down. We need to forgive ourselves as well as others.
In our hurt and pain we may pull away from God and erect walls to keep Him out. She "wished she could draw confidence in God... but a wall stood in the way." God does not cause our troubles but walks alongside us in them. He longs for us to return to Him, until we do, we will not know peace. "God's been there waiting for me."
God is a good Father. We do not have to earn His love, we already have it. He contrasts sharply with some fathers who seem to make their offspring earn their love. Achievement appears to equal love. God's love is freely available to all.
Once again Jody Hedlund has drawn marvellous characters. The two leading characters spar with each other to the amusement of the reader. Poverty of possessions does not equal poverty of love. There are many riches within the story.
I adore all Jody Hedlund's novels. They leave me with a warm heart and a smile on my face.
Absolutely wonderful.
I received this book for free. A favourable review was not required and all views expressed are my own.
June 13, 2017
With You Always was such a wonderful novel! I’d been introduced to some of the characters in the free ebook, An Awakened Heart, so I was happy to connect with them again, and to meet some new ones, too. I believe that With You Always could possibly be read without reading the prequel, but I personally recommend reading the prequel because it does such a good job of setting the stage for this novel. The stories in both of these books seamlessly continue from the prequel to book one.
I liked Elise and Thornton so much! Even though they came from extremely different circumstances, they really were made for each other. I loved watching them fall for each other, even as I wondered how anything could ever work out for them to be together.
I loved the setting of the new town of Quincy, Illinois that was being built along the railroad. How hard it must have been for those women and men who had to leave behind their families for the chance of making a living far away from those they loved.
This is a book I enjoyed from start to finish. I am really looking forward to the next novel in the series.
I received a complimentary copy of this book. All opinions are my own.
You can read this review on my blog at:
https://brittreadsfiction.wordpress.c...
I liked Elise and Thornton so much! Even though they came from extremely different circumstances, they really were made for each other. I loved watching them fall for each other, even as I wondered how anything could ever work out for them to be together.
I loved the setting of the new town of Quincy, Illinois that was being built along the railroad. How hard it must have been for those women and men who had to leave behind their families for the chance of making a living far away from those they loved.
This is a book I enjoyed from start to finish. I am really looking forward to the next novel in the series.
I received a complimentary copy of this book. All opinions are my own.
You can read this review on my blog at:
https://brittreadsfiction.wordpress.c...
June 5, 2017
This book brings to light another amazing woman who is a lost part of history. One of the many things I love about Hedlund's novels.
This book really reached my heart. I began putting myself in the places of some of the women. What would I do in their shoes? How would I act to keep my loved ones alive...to keep them from starving?? The fact that different aspects of this book keep one thinking when the book is closed...is the reason for the five stars. I don't give out many.
I loved the plot as it was different than any other orphan story I've read, the characters are real and believable, and I'm really looking forward to more books in this series.
Many of the other reasons I enjoyed it would be spoilers...so you will just have to read it yourself. However, the brilliant idea of a lowly cook to a wealthy man of what he should do to better understand....and his response was one of my favorite parts of this novel!
" ' I won't let you go.' This time the whisper was God's, and it came from deep in her soul..."
I received this book from the publisher. All opinions are my own.
This book really reached my heart. I began putting myself in the places of some of the women. What would I do in their shoes? How would I act to keep my loved ones alive...to keep them from starving?? The fact that different aspects of this book keep one thinking when the book is closed...is the reason for the five stars. I don't give out many.
I loved the plot as it was different than any other orphan story I've read, the characters are real and believable, and I'm really looking forward to more books in this series.
Many of the other reasons I enjoyed it would be spoilers...so you will just have to read it yourself. However, the brilliant idea of a lowly cook to a wealthy man of what he should do to better understand....and his response was one of my favorite parts of this novel!
" ' I won't let you go.' This time the whisper was God's, and it came from deep in her soul..."
I received this book from the publisher. All opinions are my own.
March 4, 2019
"The Force will be with you...always." -- Obi-Wan Kenobi
(Sorry; the geek in me couldn't resist.)
Seriously, though: This was a very inspiring and engaging historical novel; I found the writing to be crisp and the plot to be gripping.
(Sorry; the geek in me couldn't resist.)
Seriously, though: This was a very inspiring and engaging historical novel; I found the writing to be crisp and the plot to be gripping.
June 3, 2018
This was my first time reading one of Jody Hedlund books. EXCELLENT!!! I can't wait to read the rest of the Orphan Train series!
June 7, 2017
I specially saved this review for today. Do you know why? Well, today is this book’s birthday! You officially can buy it on Amazon and other places like that.
I had the pleasure of being an influencer for this book. So one of the coolest things about being an influencer is you get the book early!
I really enjoyed this story. It was a wonderful historical romance. I mean, some authors cannot pull of adding history into the story without seeing too historical. But, Jody is not one of those authors. She is wonderful at adding history to the story.
I really liked this cover. It immediately set the mood for the book. Before even reading the back synopsis, I knew the basic setting of the story. I am going to give it 5 stars.
I am going to give the book 4 stars because of one thing. The contest was kind of unrealistic. I mean, the father wanting his sons to marry for love in six months was not very smart. Some people don’t fall head over heels in just six months. That was the only thing I didn’t really like about the story. Other than that, I would definitely recommend this book to any fan of the historical romance genre! I am totally looking forward to the next book in the Orphan Train series!
Title: With You Always
Author: Jody Hedlund
Author’s Website: http://jodyhedlund.com/
This review is written in my own opinions and words.
I had the pleasure of being an influencer for this book. So one of the coolest things about being an influencer is you get the book early!
I really enjoyed this story. It was a wonderful historical romance. I mean, some authors cannot pull of adding history into the story without seeing too historical. But, Jody is not one of those authors. She is wonderful at adding history to the story.
I really liked this cover. It immediately set the mood for the book. Before even reading the back synopsis, I knew the basic setting of the story. I am going to give it 5 stars.
I am going to give the book 4 stars because of one thing. The contest was kind of unrealistic. I mean, the father wanting his sons to marry for love in six months was not very smart. Some people don’t fall head over heels in just six months. That was the only thing I didn’t really like about the story. Other than that, I would definitely recommend this book to any fan of the historical romance genre! I am totally looking forward to the next book in the Orphan Train series!
Title: With You Always
Author: Jody Hedlund
Author’s Website: http://jodyhedlund.com/
This review is written in my own opinions and words.
July 28, 2017
This book is the exact reason I love historical fiction. In it I am able to learn about events in history through characters that I can connect to. Yes, the characters are fictional, but they represent the people of that time- their feelings, their struggles and their triumphs.
This particular book is set in the midst of the immigrants to America in the 1850's and their struggle to sustain life. How awful it must have been to leave your home country in search of a better life only to find it worse than the one you left.
I loved this story. It was told in a way that connected to my heart. I could so easily visualize everything that was happening- the places and the people. My heart hurt for the struggles of Elise and her family. Thornton's journey of self awareness, compassion and understanding were so satisfying. So, so good.
I cannot wait to read the next book in this series. This book sets things up perfectly for a continuation but still left me utterly satisfied. That's how I like a series to be.
Content: Clean, mild romance, some kissing. A situation of abuse with no details, just the aftermath. Mild peril.
- I received a copy of this book from the publisher via NetGalley. A positive review was not required and all opinions expressed are my own.
This particular book is set in the midst of the immigrants to America in the 1850's and their struggle to sustain life. How awful it must have been to leave your home country in search of a better life only to find it worse than the one you left.
I loved this story. It was told in a way that connected to my heart. I could so easily visualize everything that was happening- the places and the people. My heart hurt for the struggles of Elise and her family. Thornton's journey of self awareness, compassion and understanding were so satisfying. So, so good.
I cannot wait to read the next book in this series. This book sets things up perfectly for a continuation but still left me utterly satisfied. That's how I like a series to be.
Content: Clean, mild romance, some kissing. A situation of abuse with no details, just the aftermath. Mild peril.
- I received a copy of this book from the publisher via NetGalley. A positive review was not required and all opinions expressed are my own.
August 9, 2018
3.5
I had been looking forward to reading this for a LONG time (as in, as soon as I sped-read the prequel An Awakened Heart), and I did enjoy it...although there were a few points that took me by surprise.
First, the novel is the first in the Orphan Train series...but it didn't focus on the historical orphan trains! Instead, it follows Elise Neumann's journey to find work out west with the caravans of women who were relocated out of New York by the Children's Aid Society during the economic downturn between 1854 and 1929. While I was surprised by this focus, I enjoyed getting to read about the women's experiences finding work along the railroad--and I especially loved that Elise's fiery spirit highlighted the plights of women that received unfair wages (and sometimes abusive treatment) simply because they were women. Fanny's story particularly broke my heart, especially because I know that her story was (and still is) not unique. I was glad that Hedlund brought it into the light.
Second, I wasn't expecting to have the POV switch from Thornton/Elise to Marianne. While Marianne's story captivated me and left me wanting to read her novel, it was a bit jarring to go back and forth between Illinois and New York--especially when both stories were not equally represented. Perhaps this is just a pet peeve of mine, though! I always get a bit frustrated when books have unequal POVs because it throws the story off for me.
That being said, I really did enjoy this book. I look forward to reading Together Forever!
I had been looking forward to reading this for a LONG time (as in, as soon as I sped-read the prequel An Awakened Heart), and I did enjoy it...although there were a few points that took me by surprise.
First, the novel is the first in the Orphan Train series...but it didn't focus on the historical orphan trains! Instead, it follows Elise Neumann's journey to find work out west with the caravans of women who were relocated out of New York by the Children's Aid Society during the economic downturn between 1854 and 1929. While I was surprised by this focus, I enjoyed getting to read about the women's experiences finding work along the railroad--and I especially loved that Elise's fiery spirit highlighted the plights of women that received unfair wages (and sometimes abusive treatment) simply because they were women. Fanny's story particularly broke my heart, especially because I know that her story was (and still is) not unique. I was glad that Hedlund brought it into the light.
Second, I wasn't expecting to have the POV switch from Thornton/Elise to Marianne. While Marianne's story captivated me and left me wanting to read her novel, it was a bit jarring to go back and forth between Illinois and New York--especially when both stories were not equally represented. Perhaps this is just a pet peeve of mine, though! I always get a bit frustrated when books have unequal POVs because it throws the story off for me.
That being said, I really did enjoy this book. I look forward to reading Together Forever!
May 5, 2022
3.5 stars. This is probably my favorite Jody Hedlund book I've read so far. I was eager to pick it up each time and find out what was unfolding in the plot. I have a lot of critiques though, and that's the reason for the lower rating.
I had mixed feelings about both our hero and heroine. Elise is smart, witty, determined, caring, and hardworking. I understood her drive to take care of her younger sisters and admired her determination to keep them fed and safe despite all odds. I especially liked her realtionship with Isaiah and Mrs. Gray. However, her sarcasm often borders on rudeness, especially towards the other women in the mission. She's quite bitter for a lot of the book. I'm glad we see her finally come to trust in God, but it didn't feel like enough of a pivotal moment.
Then we have Thornton. I liked his bantering with Elise. I liked how he pitches in to help build up his town, and how he gives his brother the benefit of the doubt. I had a food feeling when he stayed to help defend the mission in the beginning. But then we see him start down a path of dishonesty with Elise. It starts to get really old. He strings her along as well as a socialite back home. He isn't truthful with either of them, even though it wouldn't have been that difficult. I didn't understand why he didn't just pursue Elise from the beginning. The deal was to have a love match, not a social one.
I really like the side characters in this book. I want a book about Miss Pendleton and the Pastor. They were really interesting. Fanny could definitely have a book too. Reinhold was a highlight. I actually kind of preferred him to Thornton, so I'm glad to see he's returning in the 3rd novel.
Here's just a few random things that bugged me throughout the story.
The picnic that Thornton plans for Elise seems to border on impropriety. A respectable woman of the day probably wouldn't have gone on a picnic alone with a practical stranger, much less layed down on a blanket.
Elise and Thornton also get pretty physical for the time period. Neck kisses? Seems a little raunchy to me.
At one point, Thornton thinks "Wow, I could do that again." I could be wrong, but I don't think they said wow in the late 1800s.
This is a super small pet peeve, but I hate when characters moan while they eat. And that happens several times in this book, given that Elise likes to cook and bake.
Thornton's thought life: At one point he admires how "every sweet blessed curve of her body was outlined "
I'm so confused about why Marianne invents a pregnancy. If she was so desperate, she should have just stayed at the mission. This weird little rabbit trail doesn't really contribute to the story and it's just confusing. Especially since when Elise finds Marianne she doesn't seem surprised that she isn't actually pregnant.
Then, when Elise finally finds Marianne, she's described as being despondent. Then, just a few minutes later, she's laughing and teasing Thornton and Elise at news of their engagement. It seemed really abrupt.
Despite all these little things, I enjoyed the book. I'm invested now. I need to find out what happens to Sophie and Marianne.
I had mixed feelings about both our hero and heroine. Elise is smart, witty, determined, caring, and hardworking. I understood her drive to take care of her younger sisters and admired her determination to keep them fed and safe despite all odds. I especially liked her realtionship with Isaiah and Mrs. Gray. However, her sarcasm often borders on rudeness, especially towards the other women in the mission. She's quite bitter for a lot of the book. I'm glad we see her finally come to trust in God, but it didn't feel like enough of a pivotal moment.
Then we have Thornton. I liked his bantering with Elise. I liked how he pitches in to help build up his town, and how he gives his brother the benefit of the doubt. I had a food feeling when he stayed to help defend the mission in the beginning. But then we see him start down a path of dishonesty with Elise. It starts to get really old. He strings her along as well as a socialite back home. He isn't truthful with either of them, even though it wouldn't have been that difficult. I didn't understand why he didn't just pursue Elise from the beginning. The deal was to have a love match, not a social one.
I really like the side characters in this book. I want a book about Miss Pendleton and the Pastor. They were really interesting. Fanny could definitely have a book too. Reinhold was a highlight. I actually kind of preferred him to Thornton, so I'm glad to see he's returning in the 3rd novel.
Here's just a few random things that bugged me throughout the story.
The picnic that Thornton plans for Elise seems to border on impropriety. A respectable woman of the day probably wouldn't have gone on a picnic alone with a practical stranger, much less layed down on a blanket.
Elise and Thornton also get pretty physical for the time period. Neck kisses? Seems a little raunchy to me.
At one point, Thornton thinks "Wow, I could do that again." I could be wrong, but I don't think they said wow in the late 1800s.
This is a super small pet peeve, but I hate when characters moan while they eat. And that happens several times in this book, given that Elise likes to cook and bake.
Thornton's thought life: At one point he admires how "every sweet blessed curve of her body was outlined "
I'm so confused about why Marianne invents a pregnancy. If she was so desperate, she should have just stayed at the mission. This weird little rabbit trail doesn't really contribute to the story and it's just confusing. Especially since when Elise finds Marianne she doesn't seem surprised that she isn't actually pregnant.
Then, when Elise finally finds Marianne, she's described as being despondent. Then, just a few minutes later, she's laughing and teasing Thornton and Elise at news of their engagement. It seemed really abrupt.
Despite all these little things, I enjoyed the book. I'm invested now. I need to find out what happens to Sophie and Marianne.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
October 20, 2018
I've tried to read one other book by Hedlund and put it to the side because I just could't get into the story. This one seemed so intriguing that I decided to give her another try. I'm so glad I did! This story is set during the 1850's. After the Neumann Girl's parents die they are on their own in New York City. Elise is the oldest and decides to travel west to a new start up town to hopefully be able to earn enough money to support her sisters and their two charges. Along the way she meets Thornton Quincy. From different backgrounds they are able to form a friendship and help each other in ways they didn't know they would.
This was the perfect book to pick up after a long week. This was a page turner! I mean I can't remember the last time I stayed up until 3 am to finish a book! I look forward to finishing this series and seeing what happens to the other two Neumann sisters.
This was the perfect book to pick up after a long week. This was a page turner! I mean I can't remember the last time I stayed up until 3 am to finish a book! I look forward to finishing this series and seeing what happens to the other two Neumann sisters.
May 18, 2017
This story takes place in 1870’s following a
financial crises. The setting is in New York City
where many immigrants settled looking for a
better life in this country.
But what they find in this time period is a jobless
city, people living in the street, starvation, women
having to turn to prostitution, gangs fighting in
the street. A time of poverty and discontent.
In this story, the reader will learn about " The
Orphan Train ". This concept was developed to
help keep children clothed and feed plus housed
in return for their labor out West. Yet this train
broke up many families apart.
One German immigrant family consisting of
three daughters found themselves in the street
accompanied by two other orphaned children.
Seeking refuse at a Mission, they found shelter
and food in their rudimentary environment.
The older sister, Elise Neumann was able to work
there as seamstress until the mission closes then
she has to take advantage of the Children's Aide
Society. She boards a train to head West to an
undisclosed location.
While on the train she reacquaints with a man,
she had literally collided with on a New York street.
The man is Thornton Quincy. Thornton is a twin
from a very wealthy family. Elise does not know
anything about his wealthy status.
Thornton is in a competition with his twin brother,
Bradford. His father challenged each of his sons
to establish separate towns along the Illinois Central
Railroad within a six month period. Plus each sons
must marry for love.
Thornton arranges to have Elise assigned to his
town, Quincy with her knowledge.
There was undeniable chemistry shared between
the main characters throughout the story.
Descriptions are deftly woven into the story taking
the reader right into the midst of the story.
The author incorporates historical details into
the everyday happenings making the story vividly
realistic.
Riveting storyline. A well written historical fiction
combined with romance, well defined, realistic
and dimensional characters.
Jody Hedlund brings history to life in this amazing
time period inspiring the reader with the constant
reminder that the light of God shines on His
steady followers bringing relief in small ways.
I highly recommend this book.
I volunteered to read With You Always. Thanks to
the author and the Influencers via Net Gallery for
the opportunity. My opinion is my own.
financial crises. The setting is in New York City
where many immigrants settled looking for a
better life in this country.
But what they find in this time period is a jobless
city, people living in the street, starvation, women
having to turn to prostitution, gangs fighting in
the street. A time of poverty and discontent.
In this story, the reader will learn about " The
Orphan Train ". This concept was developed to
help keep children clothed and feed plus housed
in return for their labor out West. Yet this train
broke up many families apart.
One German immigrant family consisting of
three daughters found themselves in the street
accompanied by two other orphaned children.
Seeking refuse at a Mission, they found shelter
and food in their rudimentary environment.
The older sister, Elise Neumann was able to work
there as seamstress until the mission closes then
she has to take advantage of the Children's Aide
Society. She boards a train to head West to an
undisclosed location.
While on the train she reacquaints with a man,
she had literally collided with on a New York street.
The man is Thornton Quincy. Thornton is a twin
from a very wealthy family. Elise does not know
anything about his wealthy status.
Thornton is in a competition with his twin brother,
Bradford. His father challenged each of his sons
to establish separate towns along the Illinois Central
Railroad within a six month period. Plus each sons
must marry for love.
Thornton arranges to have Elise assigned to his
town, Quincy with her knowledge.
There was undeniable chemistry shared between
the main characters throughout the story.
Descriptions are deftly woven into the story taking
the reader right into the midst of the story.
The author incorporates historical details into
the everyday happenings making the story vividly
realistic.
Riveting storyline. A well written historical fiction
combined with romance, well defined, realistic
and dimensional characters.
Jody Hedlund brings history to life in this amazing
time period inspiring the reader with the constant
reminder that the light of God shines on His
steady followers bringing relief in small ways.
I highly recommend this book.
I volunteered to read With You Always. Thanks to
the author and the Influencers via Net Gallery for
the opportunity. My opinion is my own.
May 24, 2017
Jody Hedlund has provided her readers with another wonderful story of the men and women who helped to settle the American Midwest of the mid-1800's. These men and women left difficult situations, showing great strength of character to build a better life in the American frontier. Hedlund especially shows the reader the plight of the immigrant women and children.
Elise and her sisters have been left orphaned. Through several twists of fate, Elise decides that she should venture west to gain employment through the Children's Aid Society in one of the many towns that were being built along the railroad. She hopes to raise the money to send for her sisters after she has settled. She meets Thornton, unaware that he is in charge of the development of one of these towns. Thornton's father is dying, and in order to decide which of his sons will inherit everything, he is requiring them to do two things in six months: build a sustainable town along the Illinois Central Railroad, and get married. Most importantly, Thornton desires his father's approval.
Jody Hedlund creates inspirational characters. The reader sees the flaws, but also the strength of the human spirit. Elise's unbeatable spirit grabbed me immediately. She would not be defeated. She also had the incredible ability to bring out the best in others. I felt her pain as she kept thinking God did not care what happened to her. Her journey to learn that God is with her always- through the good and bad- made me feel so many emotions, wanting to laugh and weep with her. But mostly to cheer her on, hoping I can show the same strength and fortitude of spirit in my life.
I believe this is one of Hedlund's best novels yet. The next book in this series cannot come soon enough. I hope we get to read Marianne and Sophie's stories.
I voluntarily reviewed a complimentary copy of this book which I received from the author/publisher. I was not required to write a review. All opinions expressed are my own.
Elise and her sisters have been left orphaned. Through several twists of fate, Elise decides that she should venture west to gain employment through the Children's Aid Society in one of the many towns that were being built along the railroad. She hopes to raise the money to send for her sisters after she has settled. She meets Thornton, unaware that he is in charge of the development of one of these towns. Thornton's father is dying, and in order to decide which of his sons will inherit everything, he is requiring them to do two things in six months: build a sustainable town along the Illinois Central Railroad, and get married. Most importantly, Thornton desires his father's approval.
Jody Hedlund creates inspirational characters. The reader sees the flaws, but also the strength of the human spirit. Elise's unbeatable spirit grabbed me immediately. She would not be defeated. She also had the incredible ability to bring out the best in others. I felt her pain as she kept thinking God did not care what happened to her. Her journey to learn that God is with her always- through the good and bad- made me feel so many emotions, wanting to laugh and weep with her. But mostly to cheer her on, hoping I can show the same strength and fortitude of spirit in my life.
I believe this is one of Hedlund's best novels yet. The next book in this series cannot come soon enough. I hope we get to read Marianne and Sophie's stories.
I voluntarily reviewed a complimentary copy of this book which I received from the author/publisher. I was not required to write a review. All opinions expressed are my own.
June 7, 2017
I ALWAYS love it when a novel shines light on a lesser-known historical fact, era, or event. Often, there is nothing more fascinating that real life. In this case, the time period is 1850s New York to Illinois, during a challenging economic downturn. This was especially hard on immigrant families, and subsequently children AND women were sent west to find a better life, on what is now known as the Orphan Train. With You Always by Jody Hedlund tells a fictional story based on the journeys many women took to provide a better life for their families.
Author Jody Hedlund dependably pens characters with well-established personalities. I loved the nurturing tendencies of Elise and the gentlemanly determination of Thornton. It *did* take me a few chapters to really settle into the plot and the direction the story was taking, but I empathized with the characters immediately, especially concerning the plight of Elise and her family.
I liked that the challenges both Elise and Thornton face are not only tactile and physical but also challenges to their very hearts. Elise, for instance, faces finding a place for her family AND coming to terms with her faith that God is constant, and for her. Thornton deals with the manner of proving himself; whether choosing to set aside his pride is worth a greater, selfless task he can accomplish in the wake of his dreams.
Through the ups and downs of Elise and Thornton's intersecting journeys, a sweetly natural romance emerges. Jody handles this with her signature style (read: era-appropriate swooniness) and realistic conflicts. The romance combines with the threads of faith, a story of finding a "true home", and the belonging found with friends in a close community to make With You Always a rich story AND a lovely introduction to a new series.
Thank you to Bethany House Publishers for the complimentary review copy of this book. This review is my honest opinion.
Author Jody Hedlund dependably pens characters with well-established personalities. I loved the nurturing tendencies of Elise and the gentlemanly determination of Thornton. It *did* take me a few chapters to really settle into the plot and the direction the story was taking, but I empathized with the characters immediately, especially concerning the plight of Elise and her family.
I liked that the challenges both Elise and Thornton face are not only tactile and physical but also challenges to their very hearts. Elise, for instance, faces finding a place for her family AND coming to terms with her faith that God is constant, and for her. Thornton deals with the manner of proving himself; whether choosing to set aside his pride is worth a greater, selfless task he can accomplish in the wake of his dreams.
Through the ups and downs of Elise and Thornton's intersecting journeys, a sweetly natural romance emerges. Jody handles this with her signature style (read: era-appropriate swooniness) and realistic conflicts. The romance combines with the threads of faith, a story of finding a "true home", and the belonging found with friends in a close community to make With You Always a rich story AND a lovely introduction to a new series.
Thank you to Bethany House Publishers for the complimentary review copy of this book. This review is my honest opinion.
June 16, 2017
One of the things I absolutely love about Jody Hedlund's novels is the way she brings to life some of the lesser known aspects in history -- particularly issues that affected women. And that's exactly what she delivers in With You Always. Of course, I've heard of the Orphan Trains but I had no idea that women were also sent west with that program. Or that it broke up families and left desperate women torn between staying with their children or finding work far away in order to keep their children alive.
And that's the predicament Elise finds herself in. After her parents death, she struggles to keep what's left of the family together. Heartache and sorrow dog her heels as she tries to make a life in the crowded, impoverished slums of New York City. Until the day fate throws Thornton Quincy into her path.
He comes from a life of privilege and, while he's kind and compassionate, he can't grasp the harsh circumstances the immigrants endure. Or how his business endeavors can help or harm hundreds of desperate workers. This contrast between these two lifestyles is sheer brilliance and makes for a riveting read.,,and a complicated romance!
Though Elise isn't his social equal, she's not cowed by Thornton's power and wealth. And she's not afraid to speak her mind and challenge his preconceived ideas. She's good for him and he knows it. He just isn't sure what to do with that knowledge. There's angst and confusion and a piercing sweetness as an impossible love begins to flourish.
A plot filled with the unexpected -- even a hint of intrigue -- and the freeing hope that comes from placing your trust in Jesus even in the most difficult times, makes this first book in the Orphan Train series a stunning success.
Book provided courtesy of Baker Publishing Group and Graf-Martin Communications.
And that's the predicament Elise finds herself in. After her parents death, she struggles to keep what's left of the family together. Heartache and sorrow dog her heels as she tries to make a life in the crowded, impoverished slums of New York City. Until the day fate throws Thornton Quincy into her path.
He comes from a life of privilege and, while he's kind and compassionate, he can't grasp the harsh circumstances the immigrants endure. Or how his business endeavors can help or harm hundreds of desperate workers. This contrast between these two lifestyles is sheer brilliance and makes for a riveting read.,,and a complicated romance!
Though Elise isn't his social equal, she's not cowed by Thornton's power and wealth. And she's not afraid to speak her mind and challenge his preconceived ideas. She's good for him and he knows it. He just isn't sure what to do with that knowledge. There's angst and confusion and a piercing sweetness as an impossible love begins to flourish.
A plot filled with the unexpected -- even a hint of intrigue -- and the freeing hope that comes from placing your trust in Jesus even in the most difficult times, makes this first book in the Orphan Train series a stunning success.
Book provided courtesy of Baker Publishing Group and Graf-Martin Communications.
January 23, 2018
DNF
I had a hard time with this one. Somehow, in spite of the setting and the backdrop of historical events, it didn't really feel historical to me. Maybe my perception is tainted by all the period (as in, written-in-the-period) books I've read? The way that near-strangers would just talk offhand about any and all subjects while seemingly not giving a thought to the presence or lack of any kind of social proprieties just didn't ring true for me. And for some reason, even though I felt sympathy for their situations, I couldn't make myself really care about the characters.
The romance was very noticing, tingling, turning to mush at a look or a touch, which isn't my favorite. I also felt like the characters acted very unwisely in certain instances. She's afraid her reputation will be hurt if she's seen in public with him, so she accepts several invitations to meet him in private? At that time especially, she'd have done much worse damage to her reputation if anyone found out they had been alone together. Also, the fact that they got as far as an uncomfortably (for me) passionate kiss without any kind of formal or even implied courtship and no promises beyond "I'll see you again"? That bothered me quite a bit.
The other issue, and the one that finally tipped the scales, was how openly and bluntly the former "profession" of some of the girls was discussed. It didn't feel right for the time period, for one thing, and while calling something by a nicer name doesn't make it any less sinful, there are reasons euphemisms have been created over the years. That sort of life may be a reality for some, but I was uncomfortable having it shoved in my face quite so often and blatantly.
I had a hard time with this one. Somehow, in spite of the setting and the backdrop of historical events, it didn't really feel historical to me. Maybe my perception is tainted by all the period (as in, written-in-the-period) books I've read? The way that near-strangers would just talk offhand about any and all subjects while seemingly not giving a thought to the presence or lack of any kind of social proprieties just didn't ring true for me. And for some reason, even though I felt sympathy for their situations, I couldn't make myself really care about the characters.
The romance was very noticing, tingling, turning to mush at a look or a touch, which isn't my favorite. I also felt like the characters acted very unwisely in certain instances. She's afraid her reputation will be hurt if she's seen in public with him, so she accepts several invitations to meet him in private? At that time especially, she'd have done much worse damage to her reputation if anyone found out they had been alone together. Also, the fact that they got as far as an uncomfortably (for me) passionate kiss without any kind of formal or even implied courtship and no promises beyond "I'll see you again"? That bothered me quite a bit.
The other issue, and the one that finally tipped the scales, was how openly and bluntly the former "profession" of some of the girls was discussed. It didn't feel right for the time period, for one thing, and while calling something by a nicer name doesn't make it any less sinful, there are reasons euphemisms have been created over the years. That sort of life may be a reality for some, but I was uncomfortable having it shoved in my face quite so often and blatantly.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 666 reviews