aleo's Reviews > Twilight

9.7/10

HI I love this book.
Disclaimer: I am FULL of unpopular opinions about Warrior Cats, especially The New Prophecy.

I love character drama and I found myself smiling like the entire time I was reading. I read it in school; sitting in the hallway with my headphones in, it was really nice. My only gripe is Chapter 20, I wrote more on it here. Basically, I don't really like how Crowfeather & Leafpool running away was handled. Like I do agree they should've come back (obviously) but I just think it's really rushed. Also that story in itself is so sad... The last chapter, the badger attack was really hard for me to read because everyone's just suffering and everything's being destroyed.

Random tidbits:
- Birchkit/paw is cute and it's funny how he's just an innocent victim in Squirrelflight & Brambleclaw's fights lol
- I kinda? like Crowfeather more in Starlight because I like his angst/whatever.
But I've actually read this book many times that I'm kind of used to the scenes in Twilight
- Sootfur's death is actually worse than Cinderpelt's imo because it's actually, the badgers break both of his back legs and then he's trying to climb up a ledge, only to fall back down. Then he gets slashed again and dies.

may 2022 ~ wc re-read retrospective

MY FAVORITE WC BOOK!! probably my favorite book, period. no one does forbidden romance grumpy-sunshine like bluestar's proph :))

warrior cats: favorites
(in rank order, best to worst)
1. Super Edition ⇢ bluestar's prophecy
2. OotS, #3 ⇢ night whispers
3. TNP, #5 ⇢ twilight
4. OoTS, #2 ⇢ fading echoes
5. TNP, #2 ⇢ midnight
6. Super Edition ⇢ crowfeather's trial
7. Po3, #5 ⇢ long shadows
8. Po3, #6 ⇢ sunrise
++ nav