Florence (Lefty) MacIntosh's Reviews > A Monster Calls
A Monster Calls
by
by
Florence (Lefty) MacIntosh's review
bookshelves: ya, realistic-fiction, magical-realism, 2014, dark, family, reviewed, favs-recent
Sep 28, 2013
bookshelves: ya, realistic-fiction, magical-realism, 2014, dark, family, reviewed, favs-recent
Minute I saw Jim Kay’s cover illustration I knew I’d read this. Edgy, his use of rapid, almost angry slashing strokes and a palette of grey capturing the tone that permeates this novel to perfection. Young adult but read it anyway, only takes a few hours and does what the best fables do, speaks to all ages. It never lets up from this hook of an opening line “The monster showed up just after midnight. As they do.” In the category of contemporary fairy tales I’m putting this right up there with Coraline– and I’m nuts about Neil Gaimen.
I envied Conor his monsters; how useful it would be to distill your fears into something palatable that you could then face head on. While this story deals with bullying and Conor’s terror of losing his mother, just insert your own personal demons. We all wrestle with accepting things beyond our control, maybe Conor’s monsters can teach you a few tricks. It’s dark but it’s also hopeful - he comes out the other side.
I’ll never outgrow fairytales, especially those with a lesson or a moral. “There is not always a good guy. Nor is there always a bad one. Most people are somewhere in between.” Admire their clarity – sometimes need the obvious spelt out. In this one the monster tells three tales, each is ponder worthy:) Good twist that the fourth is left for Conor to tell.
Cons: I dislike having my guts wrenched, thought the author went a little overboard pulling the old heartstrings. Unfair I know considering the tough subjects it tackles. So I’m knocking off a 1/2 a star and rounding it to 5. It's worthy.
“You do not write your life with words” the monster said. “You write it with actions. What you think is not important. It is only important what you do.”
I envied Conor his monsters; how useful it would be to distill your fears into something palatable that you could then face head on. While this story deals with bullying and Conor’s terror of losing his mother, just insert your own personal demons. We all wrestle with accepting things beyond our control, maybe Conor’s monsters can teach you a few tricks. It’s dark but it’s also hopeful - he comes out the other side.
I’ll never outgrow fairytales, especially those with a lesson or a moral. “There is not always a good guy. Nor is there always a bad one. Most people are somewhere in between.” Admire their clarity – sometimes need the obvious spelt out. In this one the monster tells three tales, each is ponder worthy:) Good twist that the fourth is left for Conor to tell.
Cons: I dislike having my guts wrenched, thought the author went a little overboard pulling the old heartstrings. Unfair I know considering the tough subjects it tackles. So I’m knocking off a 1/2 a star and rounding it to 5. It's worthy.
“You do not write your life with words” the monster said. “You write it with actions. What you think is not important. It is only important what you do.”
Sign into Goodreads to see if any of your friends have read
A Monster Calls.
Sign In »
Reading Progress
September 28, 2013
– Shelved
February 3, 2014
–
Started Reading
February 4, 2014
–
Finished Reading
Comments Showing 1-50 of 59 (59 new)
message 1:
by
Shaun
(new)
-
rated it 5 stars
Feb 05, 2014 08:55AM
Florence, I loved, loved this. I cried and cried and cried...and then I really cried. I love the imagery and symbolism in this book and thought the illustrations/cover art were spectacular. Hope you've got a box (big box) of tissues close by.
reply
|
flag
I've read so many great reviews about this book that I went out and purchased it. It's going to be on my reading list for this year. Looking forward to it.
Gosh, what a stunning review.
This is on one of my teetering t-r lists, but obviously I need to move it up the pile.
And wow, that last quote was toughie....
This is on one of my teetering t-r lists, but obviously I need to move it up the pile.
And wow, that last quote was toughie....
Great review! I LOVE that first line. And also, you know how I feel about Coraline, so I may just have to read this. Not sure if I can handle having my heart wrenched at the moment - just finished a book that knocked me for a loop...
Very, very good and thorough review! My feelings exactly!!!!! Could you imagine Gaiman and this author doing a book together? Fabulous!
Lynda wrote: "I've read so many great reviews about this book that I went out and purchased it. It's going to be on my reading list for this year. Looking forward to it."
The writing is simplistic, hope it doesn't disappoint but don't think it will though Lynda. Look forward to your review.
The writing is simplistic, hope it doesn't disappoint but don't think it will though Lynda. Look forward to your review.
Caroline wrote: "Gosh, what a stunning review.
This is on one of my teetering t-r lists, but obviously I need to move it up the pile.
And wow, that last quote was toughie...."
Caroline, thank you! Yeh, that last line resonates doesn't it:)
This is on one of my teetering t-r lists, but obviously I need to move it up the pile.
And wow, that last quote was toughie...."
Caroline, thank you! Yeh, that last line resonates doesn't it:)
"Just insert your own personal demons" I could use some help wrestling with mine as well. Loved this review Florence. Still not sure I'll read it but very tempted.
Jonathan wrote: "Right up with Coraline? Quite a recommendation."
Yes, I know! Quite a bit different though Jonathan, I know you're a Gaiman fan as well. This one targeted more to teens, leaning more towards realistic-fiction. Patrick Ness did a fine job genre blending.
Yes, I know! Quite a bit different though Jonathan, I know you're a Gaiman fan as well. This one targeted more to teens, leaning more towards realistic-fiction. Patrick Ness did a fine job genre blending.
Mary wrote: "Great review! I LOVE that first line. And also, you know how I feel about Coraline, so I may just have to read this. Not sure if I can handle having my heart wrenched at the moment - just finished ..."
Love a great opening line, and thanks! What book? Hope you do read this Mary but DEFINITELY take a break between, something featuring sexy men in kilts would work:)
Love a great opening line, and thanks! What book? Hope you do read this Mary but DEFINITELY take a break between, something featuring sexy men in kilts would work:)
Florence (Lefty) wrote: "Mary wrote: "Great review! I LOVE that first line. And also, you know how I feel about Coraline, so I may just have to read this. Not sure if I can handle having my heart wrenched at the moment - j..."
Just finished I Shall Be Near To You. It was powerful and heart-wrenching, and I haven't been able to pick up anything else for the last two days. Might just read it again right away. It was that good. (Haven't written a review yet, but I will once I can get my thoughts straight).
Just finished I Shall Be Near To You. It was powerful and heart-wrenching, and I haven't been able to pick up anything else for the last two days. Might just read it again right away. It was that good. (Haven't written a review yet, but I will once I can get my thoughts straight).
I agree, this is a fairy tale for adults. And he did pull and tug on the old heartstrings. I literally sat at my kitchen table and cried while reading the last third of the book. No sooner had I got it together than another passage had me reaching for the Kleenex. Usually that bothers me...but this just had so much more I couldn't help but fall for this one, hook, line, and sinker.
I loved the monster imagery and the illustrations. This is truly a work of art on many levels.
I loved the monster imagery and the illustrations. This is truly a work of art on many levels.
Mary wrote: "Florence (Lefty) wrote: "Mary wrote: "Great review! I LOVE that first line. And also, you know how I feel about Coraline, so I may just have to read this. Not sure if I can handle having my heart w..."
I've never picked up a book and re-read it immediately - good on you.
I've never picked up a book and re-read it immediately - good on you.
Doug wrote: "I'm a sucker for these. Guess I'll have to read it. Thanks for the great review"
I love that you're a sucker for books like this Doug - and thank YOU.
I love that you're a sucker for books like this Doug - and thank YOU.
Shaun wrote: "I agree, this is a fairy tale for adults. And he did pull and tug on the old heartstrings. I literally sat at my kitchen table and cried while reading the last third of the book. No sooner had I go..."
Exactly Shaun, it was a work of art. I was imagining a young person going through the loss of a parent reading this. Wondering if it would be helpful/healing or just to much... I've decided the former. Quite the book.
Exactly Shaun, it was a work of art. I was imagining a young person going through the loss of a parent reading this. Wondering if it would be helpful/healing or just to much... I've decided the former. Quite the book.
Florence (Lefty) wrote: "Mary wrote: "Florence (Lefty) wrote: "Mary wrote: "Great review! I LOVE that first line. And also, you know how I feel about Coraline, so I may just have to read this. Not sure if I can handle havi..."
I've only ever done that with The Sea Captain's Wife, but I have a few others where I've listened to the audio immediately after reading: Outlander and White Rose Rebel.
I've only ever done that with The Sea Captain's Wife, but I have a few others where I've listened to the audio immediately after reading: Outlander and White Rose Rebel.
Mary wrote: "Florence (Lefty) wrote: "Mary wrote: "Florence (Lefty) wrote: "Mary wrote: "Great review! I LOVE that first line. And also, you know how I feel about Coraline, so I may just have to read this. Not ..."
I wish I had the patience to do that Mary, just don't - always on to the next book. Should learn to slow down and savour...
I wish I had the patience to do that Mary, just don't - always on to the next book. Should learn to slow down and savour...
Caroline wrote: "I always love your reviewing style, Florence. Glad to hear this one is a winner!"
Caroline, lovely thing to say. Thankyou!
Caroline, lovely thing to say. Thankyou!
Alejandro wrote: "Wonderful review, Florence! :) Truly glad that you enjoyed the book as much as me ;)"
Alejandro, I'm SO glad I finally read it. Glad my friends have such good taste (and I pay attention to them:))or I'd never have read this. Thankyou for the pat on the back, you're to kind - I like it:)
Alejandro, I'm SO glad I finally read it. Glad my friends have such good taste (and I pay attention to them:))or I'd never have read this. Thankyou for the pat on the back, you're to kind - I like it:)
Florence (Lefty) wrote: "Alejandro wrote: "Wonderful review, Florence! :) Truly glad that you enjoyed the book as much as me ;)"
Alejandro, I'm SO glad I finally read it. Glad my friends have such good taste (and I pay a..."
Truly appreciated, Florence ;)
Alejandro, I'm SO glad I finally read it. Glad my friends have such good taste (and I pay a..."
Truly appreciated, Florence ;)
Judith wrote: "Great review...and I, too, love CORALINE!"
Thanks Judith! So hope you enjoy it. Don't want to mislead, it's alot different from Coraline (includes a strong dollop of realistic-fiction) but I thought it was just great.
Thanks Judith! So hope you enjoy it. Don't want to mislead, it's alot different from Coraline (includes a strong dollop of realistic-fiction) but I thought it was just great.
LeeAnne wrote: "I love your reviews Florence! I'm adding this one to my "to read" list!"
So glad you enjoy reading them, thankyou. Hope you love it too LeeAnne, the monster is quite wise:)
So glad you enjoy reading them, thankyou. Hope you love it too LeeAnne, the monster is quite wise:)
Kelly wrote: "Ooohhhhhh!! This sounds good!!"
So happy you're going to read it Kelly, think it's right up your alley and would love to hear your thoughts on it.
So happy you're going to read it Kelly, think it's right up your alley and would love to hear your thoughts on it.
Michael wrote: "Lovely review with just the right hooks for me, saying it is the equal of Coraline."
Young adult fiction is SO much better now than when I was a teenager - pretty amazing little book Michael.
Young adult fiction is SO much better now than when I was a teenager - pretty amazing little book Michael.
Delee wrote: "Great review Florence! I have had this on my list to read for awhile."
Thankyou Delee! Sat on my TBR for ages - glad I got to it, hope you do as well!
Thankyou Delee! Sat on my TBR for ages - glad I got to it, hope you do as well!
Florence (Lefty) wrote: "Michael wrote: "Lovely review with just the right hooks for me, saying it is the equal of Coraline."
Young adult fiction is SO much better now than when I was a teenager - pretty amazing little bo..."
I always have thought that books shouldn't have "age" or "sexual genre", meant to be read by readers of any age or sexual genre, but I know what you meant ;) Hehehe. yes, definitely YA books nowadays are really good.
Young adult fiction is SO much better now than when I was a teenager - pretty amazing little bo..."
I always have thought that books shouldn't have "age" or "sexual genre", meant to be read by readers of any age or sexual genre, but I know what you meant ;) Hehehe. yes, definitely YA books nowadays are really good.
Alejandro wrote: "Florence (Lefty) wrote: "Michael wrote: "Lovely review with just the right hooks for me, saying it is the equal of Coraline."
Young adult fiction is SO much better now than when I was a teenager -..."
I know what you're saying and agree Alejandro, old habits die hard:) Just saying Nancy Drew never did it for me.
Young adult fiction is SO much better now than when I was a teenager -..."
I know what you're saying and agree Alejandro, old habits die hard:) Just saying Nancy Drew never did it for me.
Florence (Lefty) wrote: "Alejandro wrote: "Florence (Lefty) wrote: "Michael wrote: "Lovely review with just the right hooks for me, saying it is the equal of Coraline."
Young adult fiction is SO much better now than when ..."
Well, I never had the chance of reading Nancy Drew :P And even that I knew that the book series isn't the pinacle of literature about detectives, I still want to read some novels from this series eventually ;)
Hehehe, not always I read books looking for top rating options ;)
Young adult fiction is SO much better now than when ..."
Well, I never had the chance of reading Nancy Drew :P And even that I knew that the book series isn't the pinacle of literature about detectives, I still want to read some novels from this series eventually ;)
Hehehe, not always I read books looking for top rating options ;)
Florence (Lefty) wrote: "Kelly wrote: "Ooohhhhhh!! This sounds good!!"
So happy you're going to read it Kelly, think it's right up your alley and would love to hear your thoughts on it."
I'm next on the list for the kindle edition at the library!
So happy you're going to read it Kelly, think it's right up your alley and would love to hear your thoughts on it."
I'm next on the list for the kindle edition at the library!
Kelly wrote: "Florence (Lefty) wrote: "Kelly wrote: "Ooohhhhhh!! This sounds good!!"
So happy you're going to read it Kelly, think it's right up your alley and would love to hear your thoughts on it."
I'm next..."
Most excellent Kelly, I almost wish we could read this as a group read - but historical fiction it ain't...oh well.
So happy you're going to read it Kelly, think it's right up your alley and would love to hear your thoughts on it."
I'm next..."
Most excellent Kelly, I almost wish we could read this as a group read - but historical fiction it ain't...oh well.