What doyouthink?
Rate this book
Hagenheim#1
The Healer's Apprentice
Two Hearts. One Hope.
Rose has been appointed as a healer's apprentice at Hagenheim Castle, a rare opportunity for a woodcutter's daughter like her. While she often feels uneasy at the sight of blood, Rose is determined to prove herself capable. Failure will mean returning home to marry the aging bachelor her mother has chosen for her—a bloated, disgusting merchant who makes Rose feel ill.
When Lord Hamlin, the future duke, is injured, it is Rose who must tend to him. As she works to heal his wound, she begins to understand emotions she's never felt before and wonders if he feels the same. But falling in love is forbidden, as Lord Hamlin is betrothed to a mysterious young woman in hiding. As Rose's life spins toward confusion, she must take the first steps on a journey to discover her own destiny.
Rose has been appointed as a healer's apprentice at Hagenheim Castle, a rare opportunity for a woodcutter's daughter like her. While she often feels uneasy at the sight of blood, Rose is determined to prove herself capable. Failure will mean returning home to marry the aging bachelor her mother has chosen for her—a bloated, disgusting merchant who makes Rose feel ill.
When Lord Hamlin, the future duke, is injured, it is Rose who must tend to him. As she works to heal his wound, she begins to understand emotions she's never felt before and wonders if he feels the same. But falling in love is forbidden, as Lord Hamlin is betrothed to a mysterious young woman in hiding. As Rose's life spins toward confusion, she must take the first steps on a journey to discover her own destiny.
272 pages, Paperback
First published September 10, 2010
About the author
Melanie Dickerson
36books5,999followersMelanie Dickerson is the New York Times bestselling author of happily-ever-after romance. She believes in love, laughter, afternoon tea, and the power of story.
With a million books sold and numerous awards, including two Christy Awards, two Golden Quills, a National Readers Choice Award, Christian Retailing’s Best, and Book Buyers’ Best Awards, her books have hit #1 in her category on the New York Times bestseller list.
When she’s not writing, Melanie can be found watching Pride and Prejudice for the hundredth time, cozying up to her handsome hero husband, or shaking her head at her slightly unhinged Jack Russell terrier. She lives in the beautiful foothills of the Appalachians near Huntsville, Alabama.
With a million books sold and numerous awards, including two Christy Awards, two Golden Quills, a National Readers Choice Award, Christian Retailing’s Best, and Book Buyers’ Best Awards, her books have hit #1 in her category on the New York Times bestseller list.
When she’s not writing, Melanie can be found watching Pride and Prejudice for the hundredth time, cozying up to her handsome hero husband, or shaking her head at her slightly unhinged Jack Russell terrier. She lives in the beautiful foothills of the Appalachians near Huntsville, Alabama.
Ratings&Reviews
Friends&Following
Create a free accountto discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 2,469 reviews
January 30, 2011
So I did not realize going in thatThe Healer's Apprenticewas a Christian book, but after browsing through the shelves and seeing that many others had tagged it as such, I realized it would probably not be my cup of tea. I have nothing against Christian fiction, and I certainly understand why there is a market for it, considering that a lot of what is popular in YA fantasy and even most YA realistic fiction right now isn't exactly stuff that makes it easy to wear a WWJD bracelet while reading. Personally though, I like my fiction without an evangelical slant. I respect other's beliefs, but since Christian beliefs don't exactly mesh with my own (understatement of the century), I do find it hard to really get into a book that is constantly referencing stuff I don't believe in like "God's will", bible verses, etc.
However, I decided to continue with the book because I was intrigued by the twisted fairy tale aspect of the story, and was interested to see how on earth it bore any resemblance to Sleeping Beauty. The pleading to God and religious messages did quickly become tiresome, and once or twice I had the impulse to rate the book one star, but I decided not to dock the book any stars for its Christian slant. I didn't feel it would be fair to penalize it for being a Christian book, since it was really my own fault that I didn't do a bit more research beforehand into what kind of book it was.
That said, I do think it should be more clearly stated/marketed/advertised/whatever thatThe Healer's Apprenticeis religious fiction, so that people can make a more informed decision as to whether or not they want to read it. There was nothing on the cover, in the description on amazon or the blurb here on goodreads to indicate to me that this wasn't just a normal YA historical fantasy. I suppose the fact that it was published by Zondervan, apparently the world's largest bible publisher, could have been a hint, but if you're a pagan like me you've never heard of Zondervan before. So perhaps it was my own fault for not investigating more, but I did feel a little bit misled. You're a lot less likely to win anyone over to your beliefs when they feel that they've been misled or tricked into thinking this is just another light YA read, so it's better to just be upfront that there are Christian messages, perhaps stating so in the blurb or somewhere on the cover/back of the book, rather than waiting for the reader to get 50 pages in. Just saying.
Religion aside, it was a fairly mediocre, unmemorable read. It's pretty light on any actual history and heavy on deus ex machina, so I wouldn't consider it much more than fluff, but it did keep me entertained for a few hours. The writing was clean and smooth, with lots of cool vocabulary like "chewet" (German meat pie) and genuflection. Unfortunately, many aspects of the plot were too predictable. The hints were more like flashing alarm bells than subtle hints..I laughed out loud when Wilheim conveniently remembered "the ordinance" that allowed him to save Gunther - talk about deus ex machina. One second, the book was having a man killed on the whim of an arrogant ruler, with no regard for justice, and the next second it's having everyone obey some rarely-used, forgotten ordinance. I'm sure if said arrogant ruler really wanted to have the guy executed, he would have just ignored or changed the ordinance and done so. It seemed out of character and inconsistent for him to be ignoring justice and having a man killed, refusing to spare his life, mainly because he was in a bad mood, and then all of a sudden making nice with a law that forces him to spare the guy's life.
Some of the historical aspects did seem well-researched, such as the ball section, although I don't really know enough about 14th century german dancing and music to say for sure. I enjoyed the descriptions of the various gowns and outfit worn by characters. Rose's dresses sounded gorgeous and lush, so it was fun picturing them. I would have liked to see a lot more detail and plot centered around Rose being a healer's apprentice. Medieval medicine is an extremely interesting topic, so I was expecting that there would be a lot of focus on that aspect, considering the title of the book, but I was sorely disappointed. Aside from one stitching job, a few very brief mentions of herbs, one fevered death, and the occasional mention of her mentor bandaging a burn/wound, there was very little focus or elaboration on healing as an occupation. I was expecting deaths, broken bones, births and miscarriages and lots of cool tidbits about herbal remedies, etc.The Healer's Apprenticereally did not live up to its title. It was mainly a sappy romance with a wishy-washy heroine. Very little healing involved at all, unless you count the mending of broken hearts (awwwww!).
The romance was far too clean for my tastes. I realize that while for me "clean" may be a complaint, for others it is something to praise, and that's fine. I just personally need a bit more spice and sexiness for me to enjoy a romance. I really can't get heated up when there's a big fuss made about something as dull as holding hands (how scandalous!) and the most that happens is a lukewarm kiss. That brings me to what bugged me most about the plot - the obsession with female virtue. Virginity is cool, whether you choose to keep it or lose it, either decision is equally valid. However, idealizing female purity to such absurd levels only serves to objectify women, as it did when Gunther had to "defend Hildy's honour", as if she was an object to be won and fought over, not to mention that it also serves to perpetuate cycles of violence. Again, if these views on purity/virtue are your beliefs, then you'll probably enjoy the book, but if you're more like me, it will likely just annoy you.
Although I've been rather critical, it ultimately wasn't a bad book, but the themes and content weren't really to my personal taste. I'm sure others who are better-suited to the story will really enjoy it as a fun, lighter read. I would recommendPrincess of the Midnight Ball,another sweet, light fairytale retelling with a German setting, for those who want the fluff without the overt morality.
However, I decided to continue with the book because I was intrigued by the twisted fairy tale aspect of the story, and was interested to see how on earth it bore any resemblance to Sleeping Beauty. The pleading to God and religious messages did quickly become tiresome, and once or twice I had the impulse to rate the book one star, but I decided not to dock the book any stars for its Christian slant. I didn't feel it would be fair to penalize it for being a Christian book, since it was really my own fault that I didn't do a bit more research beforehand into what kind of book it was.
That said, I do think it should be more clearly stated/marketed/advertised/whatever thatThe Healer's Apprenticeis religious fiction, so that people can make a more informed decision as to whether or not they want to read it. There was nothing on the cover, in the description on amazon or the blurb here on goodreads to indicate to me that this wasn't just a normal YA historical fantasy. I suppose the fact that it was published by Zondervan, apparently the world's largest bible publisher, could have been a hint, but if you're a pagan like me you've never heard of Zondervan before. So perhaps it was my own fault for not investigating more, but I did feel a little bit misled. You're a lot less likely to win anyone over to your beliefs when they feel that they've been misled or tricked into thinking this is just another light YA read, so it's better to just be upfront that there are Christian messages, perhaps stating so in the blurb or somewhere on the cover/back of the book, rather than waiting for the reader to get 50 pages in. Just saying.
Religion aside, it was a fairly mediocre, unmemorable read. It's pretty light on any actual history and heavy on deus ex machina, so I wouldn't consider it much more than fluff, but it did keep me entertained for a few hours. The writing was clean and smooth, with lots of cool vocabulary like "chewet" (German meat pie) and genuflection. Unfortunately, many aspects of the plot were too predictable. The hints were more like flashing alarm bells than subtle hints..I laughed out loud when Wilheim conveniently remembered "the ordinance" that allowed him to save Gunther - talk about deus ex machina. One second, the book was having a man killed on the whim of an arrogant ruler, with no regard for justice, and the next second it's having everyone obey some rarely-used, forgotten ordinance. I'm sure if said arrogant ruler really wanted to have the guy executed, he would have just ignored or changed the ordinance and done so. It seemed out of character and inconsistent for him to be ignoring justice and having a man killed, refusing to spare his life, mainly because he was in a bad mood, and then all of a sudden making nice with a law that forces him to spare the guy's life.
Some of the historical aspects did seem well-researched, such as the ball section, although I don't really know enough about 14th century german dancing and music to say for sure. I enjoyed the descriptions of the various gowns and outfit worn by characters. Rose's dresses sounded gorgeous and lush, so it was fun picturing them. I would have liked to see a lot more detail and plot centered around Rose being a healer's apprentice. Medieval medicine is an extremely interesting topic, so I was expecting that there would be a lot of focus on that aspect, considering the title of the book, but I was sorely disappointed. Aside from one stitching job, a few very brief mentions of herbs, one fevered death, and the occasional mention of her mentor bandaging a burn/wound, there was very little focus or elaboration on healing as an occupation. I was expecting deaths, broken bones, births and miscarriages and lots of cool tidbits about herbal remedies, etc.The Healer's Apprenticereally did not live up to its title. It was mainly a sappy romance with a wishy-washy heroine. Very little healing involved at all, unless you count the mending of broken hearts (awwwww!).
The romance was far too clean for my tastes. I realize that while for me "clean" may be a complaint, for others it is something to praise, and that's fine. I just personally need a bit more spice and sexiness for me to enjoy a romance. I really can't get heated up when there's a big fuss made about something as dull as holding hands (how scandalous!) and the most that happens is a lukewarm kiss. That brings me to what bugged me most about the plot - the obsession with female virtue. Virginity is cool, whether you choose to keep it or lose it, either decision is equally valid. However, idealizing female purity to such absurd levels only serves to objectify women, as it did when Gunther had to "defend Hildy's honour", as if she was an object to be won and fought over, not to mention that it also serves to perpetuate cycles of violence. Again, if these views on purity/virtue are your beliefs, then you'll probably enjoy the book, but if you're more like me, it will likely just annoy you.
Although I've been rather critical, it ultimately wasn't a bad book, but the themes and content weren't really to my personal taste. I'm sure others who are better-suited to the story will really enjoy it as a fun, lighter read. I would recommendPrincess of the Midnight Ball,another sweet, light fairytale retelling with a German setting, for those who want the fluff without the overt morality.
Read
July 1, 2010My book! It releases in September with Zondervan, a YA romance loosely based on the Sleeping Beauty fairy tale. Check it out!!!
November 20, 2010
I do so love a good clean romance novel. And this book was a perfect example. It was beautiful and romantic, a perfect Christian love story. I really like books set in medievalish times, and this book was brilliantly researched and written. It was pretty predictable, I knew who Rose was nearly from the beginning, but that didn't take away the joy I had of reading Wilhelm and Rose find this out for themselves. I also liked how it was based loosley on Sleeping Beauty, and the true love's kiss..sigh. So perfect.
March 23, 2018
So many inaccuracies! RTC. It will be rather ranty.
February 2, 2016
I wasn't impressed. It isn't bad by any means but it's not that good.
Woah, hold up there, Hamlin. You can't go around issuing unrealistic decrees that you break no less than two pages later, that everybody breaks with no consequences at the ball, and that apparently no longer matter till it's necessary for the story again. Thisreallyannoys me. Majorly. You don't mention something that seems important and then have it no longer pertain in any way no less thantwo pages later.He breaks it, Rupert breaks it, Gunther breaks it, I'm betting all the boys of this town break this rule that Hamlin imposed "for love of Rose" but that apparently doesn't matter in the slightest.
SHODDY/FRUSTRATING WRITING DOES NOT MAKE A HAPPY READER.
And the romance? I'm so sick of Insta-love, honestly. And the constant mooning did not only cause heavy eye-rolling, there was even actual facepalms.
Rose: Oh my gosh, he's so masculine but he also is really nice and a noble and pays attention to me and...and he is really good looking.
Hamlin: She occupies my thoughts at all times. I must stop thinking of her beauty and grace because I cannot ever have her, but I can't.
And then all that (x14) is added to Rose semi turning her affections over to Rupert. Why?? No one knows. He's a lecherous jerk. But then switch back over to Hamlin. *rolls eyes*
Oh, and so stick one element fromSleeping Beautyand you can call it a retelling?? How does that work? Just because he has to kiss her to wake her up from the "demonic spirits" (Oh, I have more on that later) doesn't automatically make it a retelling.
On to the villain -
Sooo no motivations beyond "demonic voices tell me I've got to ruin her life"??? That is just not acceptable. And so Rose is forced to drink this potion, which gives her "evil spirits"? Firstly, she would have had to be open to all that jazz for the spirits to be able to take over so that doesn't work. And guess what Hamlin's approach to all this is?
Not even kidding. It doesn'tquitework that way. But apparently it does. And why does the kiss wake her up?? At least in the fairytale, and remember that these were notorious fornotmaking sense, it made sense cause of the curse.
The Christian aspect, while admirable, was not that well done. It pays to be subtle. No one wants the heavy handed SHE'S CHRISTIAN. DO YOU SEE? CHRISTIAN. SHE MENTIONED GOD 24 TIMES THIS CHAPTER AND SHE PRAYED A LOT. CHRISTIAN. CHRISTIAN!!!!!!!!!
Let their examples and minimal prayer (Heck, throw in a "She's Christian" ) lead us to that conclusion. Don't shove it in our faces. Hopefully, we'll be smart enough to deduce that.
There are far better fairytale retlellings out there (
Princess of the Midnight Ball,Sun and Moon, Ice and Snow,Cinder,The Storyteller's Daughter,Waking Roseto name a few) that you'd be better off reading.
Woah, hold up there, Hamlin. You can't go around issuing unrealistic decrees that you break no less than two pages later, that everybody breaks with no consequences at the ball, and that apparently no longer matter till it's necessary for the story again. Thisreallyannoys me. Majorly. You don't mention something that seems important and then have it no longer pertain in any way no less thantwo pages later.He breaks it, Rupert breaks it, Gunther breaks it, I'm betting all the boys of this town break this rule that Hamlin imposed "for love of Rose" but that apparently doesn't matter in the slightest.
SHODDY/FRUSTRATING WRITING DOES NOT MAKE A HAPPY READER.
And the romance? I'm so sick of Insta-love, honestly. And the constant mooning did not only cause heavy eye-rolling, there was even actual facepalms.
Rose: Oh my gosh, he's so masculine but he also is really nice and a noble and pays attention to me and...and he is really good looking.
Hamlin: She occupies my thoughts at all times. I must stop thinking of her beauty and grace because I cannot ever have her, but I can't.
And then all that (x14) is added to Rose semi turning her affections over to Rupert. Why?? No one knows. He's a lecherous jerk. But then switch back over to Hamlin. *rolls eyes*
Oh, and so stick one element fromSleeping Beautyand you can call it a retelling?? How does that work? Just because he has to kiss her to wake her up from the "demonic spirits" (Oh, I have more on that later) doesn't automatically make it a retelling.
On to the villain -
Sooo no motivations beyond "demonic voices tell me I've got to ruin her life"??? That is just not acceptable. And so Rose is forced to drink this potion, which gives her "evil spirits"? Firstly, she would have had to be open to all that jazz for the spirits to be able to take over so that doesn't work. And guess what Hamlin's approach to all this is?
Not even kidding. It doesn'tquitework that way. But apparently it does. And why does the kiss wake her up?? At least in the fairytale, and remember that these were notorious fornotmaking sense, it made sense cause of the curse.
The Christian aspect, while admirable, was not that well done. It pays to be subtle. No one wants the heavy handed SHE'S CHRISTIAN. DO YOU SEE? CHRISTIAN. SHE MENTIONED GOD 24 TIMES THIS CHAPTER AND SHE PRAYED A LOT. CHRISTIAN. CHRISTIAN!!!!!!!!!
Let their examples and minimal prayer (Heck, throw in a "She's Christian" ) lead us to that conclusion. Don't shove it in our faces. Hopefully, we'll be smart enough to deduce that.
There are far better fairytale retlellings out there (
Princess of the Midnight Ball,Sun and Moon, Ice and Snow,Cinder,The Storyteller's Daughter,Waking Roseto name a few) that you'd be better off reading.
June 26, 2017
LOVED LOVED LOVED this!
A story of persevering love; importance of honour, keeping your word and family, personal calling, along with true chivalry, makes a lasting impression on your mind and heart.
Rose is a beautiful and tender character. I related to her very much. She just wants to do what is right and have a loving family... is that too much to ask for? And Wilhem is the perfect gentleman. I had a feeling of who the evil snake was - yuck! Great plot twists and turns making it a fast read:D
The first in her Medieval Retelling Series, which catapulted us into her superb writing, touching stories that are clean and truly wonderful!
A must-must-must read for anyone who loves classic fairytale stories!!
A story of persevering love; importance of honour, keeping your word and family, personal calling, along with true chivalry, makes a lasting impression on your mind and heart.
Rose is a beautiful and tender character. I related to her very much. She just wants to do what is right and have a loving family... is that too much to ask for? And Wilhem is the perfect gentleman. I had a feeling of who the evil snake was - yuck! Great plot twists and turns making it a fast read:D
The first in her Medieval Retelling Series, which catapulted us into her superb writing, touching stories that are clean and truly wonderful!
A must-must-must read for anyone who loves classic fairytale stories!!
May 18, 2021
Imaginative and colorful.
June 14, 2023
This was such a fun and exciting book!!! Though not my favorite in the series, I do still love seeing Rose and Wilhelm's romance and returning to Hagenheim. Medieval Germany is such an intriguing setting and works perfectly for this book. I also loved how Dickerson twisted the Sleeping Beauty elements into the story. There's enough that you can see similarities to the fairytale, but it's not a scene-by-scene retelling so you feel like you're getting something new! A perfect read for fans of Christian historical romance!!!
March 20, 2018
Sweet. Historical. Romantic. Christian. Epic.
February 12, 2016
Yet another that has made it my absolute faves shelf.
I have never read anything like this. A christian fairy tale/historical fiction but I mean, wow.
I adored this world and found myself really excited to get back to the audiobook. It had me tearing up and beaming.
This book received a fair bit of criticism from other Goodreads members because of it's strong emphasis on Christianity and although I can see why that just isn't some people's cup if tea, it didn't bother me at all and in fact, it was fitting to the time period any way. It was also nice for it be ROMANCE and LOVE not lust or purely sexual attraction. I will definitely be carrying on with the series asap.
There was also a really strong ship in this book and I haven't shipped anyone that hard for a long time.
I very captivating, satisfying story.
I have never read anything like this. A christian fairy tale/historical fiction but I mean, wow.
I adored this world and found myself really excited to get back to the audiobook. It had me tearing up and beaming.
This book received a fair bit of criticism from other Goodreads members because of it's strong emphasis on Christianity and although I can see why that just isn't some people's cup if tea, it didn't bother me at all and in fact, it was fitting to the time period any way. It was also nice for it be ROMANCE and LOVE not lust or purely sexual attraction. I will definitely be carrying on with the series asap.
There was also a really strong ship in this book and I haven't shipped anyone that hard for a long time.
I very captivating, satisfying story.
October 24, 2022
I have mixed feelings about this book. Out of my entire Melanie Dickerson collection, this is my absolute least favorite, hence why I have only read it twice. Once when I received it and now so I could write a review.
On one hand, Dickerson is not afraid to include faith, for which I respect her. Dickerson is also well-versed in writing and knows how to convey a story that grabs attention. She is also masterful at settings and conveying the characters' struggles.
This book has received a lot of disgruntlement and flack for including so much faith. Ms. Dickerson, kudos to you for being unafraid to share your faith. So to those of you who dislike Christian fiction and like to whine and snarl and condemn it, don't read this book.
Can we take a moment to appreciate that cover? It. Is. Gorgeous.
Of the characters, Wilhelm was my favorite. So burdened to do rightly by his people and family. He'll make a good duke. The healer (her name is too complicated for me to spell) is good as well. I liked her meddlesome ways.
This book would garner a three-star if not for a disturbing issue. Before I tackle that, the other elements I wasn't fond of are:
The typical gorgeous heroine that makes everyone stop and stare at her. Not every woman is beautiful. Can we please have a man fall in love with a woman due to her personality?
Rose sneaking to meet Rupert. He obviously was a shyster, and her intuition about him, apparently, fell flat. I didn't approve of how clandestine it was. Especially in that day and age, a woman would not do that--sneak off to meet a man who *may* be interested in her. I will say good for Rose for not ultimately and wholly succumbing to his charms. It was an annoying journey to that point, though.
Okay, the reason I'm giving this book a two stars (please keep in mind this book does have many good elements) is because a character, aChristiancharacter
There are points I liked about this book and there are those I heavily disliked. While I appreciate Ms. Dickerson's inclusion of the rest of the faith elements (and I truly, honestly do appreciate it; a lot of "Christian" authors are straying from the faith and Dickerson is not one of them), all I can say is when you reach a certain section, proceed at your own risk.
We cannot idly accept incorrect doctrine which is why I rated this book a two stars. A shame that section had to be included, becauseThe Healer's Apprenticecould be a solid three without it.
On one hand, Dickerson is not afraid to include faith, for which I respect her. Dickerson is also well-versed in writing and knows how to convey a story that grabs attention. She is also masterful at settings and conveying the characters' struggles.
This book has received a lot of disgruntlement and flack for including so much faith. Ms. Dickerson, kudos to you for being unafraid to share your faith. So to those of you who dislike Christian fiction and like to whine and snarl and condemn it, don't read this book.
Can we take a moment to appreciate that cover? It. Is. Gorgeous.
Of the characters, Wilhelm was my favorite. So burdened to do rightly by his people and family. He'll make a good duke. The healer (her name is too complicated for me to spell) is good as well. I liked her meddlesome ways.
This book would garner a three-star if not for a disturbing issue. Before I tackle that, the other elements I wasn't fond of are:
The typical gorgeous heroine that makes everyone stop and stare at her. Not every woman is beautiful. Can we please have a man fall in love with a woman due to her personality?
Rose sneaking to meet Rupert. He obviously was a shyster, and her intuition about him, apparently, fell flat. I didn't approve of how clandestine it was. Especially in that day and age, a woman would not do that--sneak off to meet a man who *may* be interested in her. I will say good for Rose for not ultimately and wholly succumbing to his charms. It was an annoying journey to that point, though.
Okay, the reason I'm giving this book a two stars (please keep in mind this book does have many good elements) is because a character, aChristiancharacter
There are points I liked about this book and there are those I heavily disliked. While I appreciate Ms. Dickerson's inclusion of the rest of the faith elements (and I truly, honestly do appreciate it; a lot of "Christian" authors are straying from the faith and Dickerson is not one of them), all I can say is when you reach a certain section, proceed at your own risk.
We cannot idly accept incorrect doctrine which is why I rated this book a two stars. A shame that section had to be included, becauseThe Healer's Apprenticecould be a solid three without it.
August 27, 2018
This book was just as good as the first time I read it!! If you have not already, I HIGHLY recommend reading this series or just any Melanie Dickerson books. Her books are the BEST!!!!!!!
Here is a link to a more in-depth review on my blog:https://bookslifeandchrist.wordpress....
Here is a link to a more in-depth review on my blog:https://bookslifeandchrist.wordpress....
December 19, 2010
Disclaimer: I received this book through Goodread's FirstReads program, so I'd like to thank them and Zondervan for my copy. No compensation was received and the opinions expressed are my own.
"The Healer's Apprentice" by Melanie Dickerson is my first Goodread's FirstReads win --a book I've been "dying" to read ever since I saw the book cover months before its release. I am SO glad to see Zondervan coming out with teen medieval historical fiction (that's a mouthful, haha) and I thoroughly enjoyed Melanie Dickerson's medieval “Sleeping Beauty” inspired tale. Speaking as a huge Christian Medieval/Fantasy fan, I hope Zondervan and other publishers will take notice of this wonderful new author.
As a college-aged student, I'm a bit older than the target audience, but I simply adored this book, finishing it in about three hours and promptly re-reading it twice over the weekend. Since there are already so many well written summaries about this book, I will refrain from trying to come up with my own and instead focus on my own thoughts of this novel. In general, I thought the writing was very well done for a first time author. One time when I was reading a novel set in the 1700's, a character used the word "okay," which really jarred me out of the story, since I thought that language was too modern. As far as I remember, the characters used appropriate, "medieval sounding" language and I felt that this and the attention to historical detail presented in this novel enhances the story greatly.
In contrast to some of the reviews here, I loved the character of Rose –perhaps because I found myself relating to her in many ways. While I consider myself romantic at heart: getting my hands on all the Christian romance fiction (that won't scare my parents) and vigorously “shipping” character pairings from my favorite books and t.v. shows, when it comes to my real life, my “love life” --I am extremely logical or realistic, maybe too much or maybe just recognizing crushes when I see them.
I think the main reason why it's hard for some to relate to the main characters is because we live in such a different time. Only two hundred years ago, in Jane Austen's 19th century Regency Era, the issues of class, how much money you or your family had, etc. factored very highly into who you could marry. These issues were very much alive in the medieval age. Rose's thoughts of “why should/could Lord Hamlin be interested in me when I'm just a woodcutter's daughter” is a valid question. Just as for the Bennett girls in “Pride and Prejudice,” marrying “well” was one of the only ways to be financially secure for a woman. Though I'm not sure about the historical accurateness of Rose's apprenticeship, there were some trades (such as being a governess) that would be an “acceptable” job for a woman, but other than that, marriage was the answer to her life's security (food, shelter, clothing, etc.). In both eras, since marriage was such a high priority for many women, having a good reputation was imperative for a “good” marriage. Think of the fiasco that Lydia Bennett caused when she went away with her “dear Mr. Wickham” --not only that, but her sisters' reputations were also sullied even after Lydia's marriage because of the scandalous rumors surrounding her and her husband before the wedding ( “Did they? Didn't they?” ). However for wealthy men like Lord Hamlin or Mr. Darcy, it would be easier for them to marry a woman even if from a “lower class” because of their financial security, though even they could suffer repercussions for not marrying someone within their class (as Mr. Darcy's aunt Lady Catherine hinted at regarding Elizabeth).
Because of this probable historical background, I think that it was interesting to see that medieval healer's apprentice Rose didn't want to marry the “old rich bachelors” her mother tries to set her up with (which would be what most women did), but wants to be self-sufficient. I suppose there were women who felt that way back then, but I imagine that they weren't very common. Even though it might have been a more “modern” sensibility, I felt that it was extremely believable and I liked that aspect very much.
I loved the growing relationship between the hero and Rose. Very cute and sweet (and can I say hot?) I think the best way to describe it is “romance with restraint.” A lot of this was from their sense of responsibilities and obligations but “OMG,” yes you most definitely can feel the chemistry and tension between them! Of course they struggled with their growing attraction and I feel that was realistically portrayed and endeared me to the characters. The mature, responsible way they handled their feelings is something I'd love to have in a relationship one day. As one of my friends would say, “Any guy can give in to his desires, but what's really sexy is if he has those feelings and can control himself.” The library scene near the end is one of my favorite romance scenes. Speaking of romance, unless you count a “real” kiss or two as “mushy,” it doesn't go farther than that description-wise. As I mentioned, there is romantic chemistry, but it was very appropriate, tasteful, pure (or whatever you would like to call it). However, with issues such as mistresses and (though not graphically described) a girl attacked by a man at night, I would say parents should come to their own decision on whether to let their elementary aged children read this novel (it is aimed at teens), though I'd let someone who's bordering the tween/teen years read this.
My only dislike was the conclusion to the Moncore storyline. It was a let down to me --I felt like Lord Hamlin should have had a greater role in regards to Moncore instead of a knight. I felt like a big duel or something between the two would have been cool (after all, he's been searching for that man for over five years), but I'm a sucker for sword fights. Yes, I also suspected the ending, but it's a historical romance novel, not a mystery/suspense book, so I didn't mind that too much.
The Christian aspect of the novel was well done and not “preachy” like some other Christian authors I've read and the historical aspect of the novel helped in this area as most Europeans at that time were “practicing Christians” at the least. Good messages such as not relying entirely on your feelings or emotions when it comes to love and the willingness of the characters to do the right or responsible thing, despite personal sacrifices can be taken for all audiences, but I was encouraged specifically by the main characters striving to live by faith and trusting in God –in Him and His plan for them.
My first reaction on seeing my book copy was, “Oh, my gosh, it looks so short.” Granted, the book looks about 1.5'' thick, but the print is smaller than average for a paperback about 7'' tall (the print seems to be the size of mass market paperback “pocket books” ), but my fears were assuaged as I didn't feel like it was “short” --in other words, the story arc was full, lush, and then came to a logical conclusion. In the future, I (and my eyes) would appreciate a more traditional-sized type for the size of this paperback. However, the cover art is even more gorgeous in real life and the “healer's cabinet” concept on the back cover is lovely as well.
In conclusion, “The Healer's Apprentice” is one of the most well written debut from a first time author I've read in a long time, and I hope much more medieval fiction is to come. I'm recommending this to all my friends, especially teen girls. I've put Melanie Dickerson on my “favorite authors” list and can't wait for her next novel! (Thank you for reading and I apologize for the length of this review.)
"The Healer's Apprentice" by Melanie Dickerson is my first Goodread's FirstReads win --a book I've been "dying" to read ever since I saw the book cover months before its release. I am SO glad to see Zondervan coming out with teen medieval historical fiction (that's a mouthful, haha) and I thoroughly enjoyed Melanie Dickerson's medieval “Sleeping Beauty” inspired tale. Speaking as a huge Christian Medieval/Fantasy fan, I hope Zondervan and other publishers will take notice of this wonderful new author.
As a college-aged student, I'm a bit older than the target audience, but I simply adored this book, finishing it in about three hours and promptly re-reading it twice over the weekend. Since there are already so many well written summaries about this book, I will refrain from trying to come up with my own and instead focus on my own thoughts of this novel. In general, I thought the writing was very well done for a first time author. One time when I was reading a novel set in the 1700's, a character used the word "okay," which really jarred me out of the story, since I thought that language was too modern. As far as I remember, the characters used appropriate, "medieval sounding" language and I felt that this and the attention to historical detail presented in this novel enhances the story greatly.
In contrast to some of the reviews here, I loved the character of Rose –perhaps because I found myself relating to her in many ways. While I consider myself romantic at heart: getting my hands on all the Christian romance fiction (that won't scare my parents) and vigorously “shipping” character pairings from my favorite books and t.v. shows, when it comes to my real life, my “love life” --I am extremely logical or realistic, maybe too much or maybe just recognizing crushes when I see them.
I think the main reason why it's hard for some to relate to the main characters is because we live in such a different time. Only two hundred years ago, in Jane Austen's 19th century Regency Era, the issues of class, how much money you or your family had, etc. factored very highly into who you could marry. These issues were very much alive in the medieval age. Rose's thoughts of “why should/could Lord Hamlin be interested in me when I'm just a woodcutter's daughter” is a valid question. Just as for the Bennett girls in “Pride and Prejudice,” marrying “well” was one of the only ways to be financially secure for a woman. Though I'm not sure about the historical accurateness of Rose's apprenticeship, there were some trades (such as being a governess) that would be an “acceptable” job for a woman, but other than that, marriage was the answer to her life's security (food, shelter, clothing, etc.). In both eras, since marriage was such a high priority for many women, having a good reputation was imperative for a “good” marriage. Think of the fiasco that Lydia Bennett caused when she went away with her “dear Mr. Wickham” --not only that, but her sisters' reputations were also sullied even after Lydia's marriage because of the scandalous rumors surrounding her and her husband before the wedding ( “Did they? Didn't they?” ). However for wealthy men like Lord Hamlin or Mr. Darcy, it would be easier for them to marry a woman even if from a “lower class” because of their financial security, though even they could suffer repercussions for not marrying someone within their class (as Mr. Darcy's aunt Lady Catherine hinted at regarding Elizabeth).
Because of this probable historical background, I think that it was interesting to see that medieval healer's apprentice Rose didn't want to marry the “old rich bachelors” her mother tries to set her up with (which would be what most women did), but wants to be self-sufficient. I suppose there were women who felt that way back then, but I imagine that they weren't very common. Even though it might have been a more “modern” sensibility, I felt that it was extremely believable and I liked that aspect very much.
I loved the growing relationship between the hero and Rose. Very cute and sweet (and can I say hot?) I think the best way to describe it is “romance with restraint.” A lot of this was from their sense of responsibilities and obligations but “OMG,” yes you most definitely can feel the chemistry and tension between them! Of course they struggled with their growing attraction and I feel that was realistically portrayed and endeared me to the characters. The mature, responsible way they handled their feelings is something I'd love to have in a relationship one day. As one of my friends would say, “Any guy can give in to his desires, but what's really sexy is if he has those feelings and can control himself.” The library scene near the end is one of my favorite romance scenes. Speaking of romance, unless you count a “real” kiss or two as “mushy,” it doesn't go farther than that description-wise. As I mentioned, there is romantic chemistry, but it was very appropriate, tasteful, pure (or whatever you would like to call it). However, with issues such as mistresses and (though not graphically described) a girl attacked by a man at night, I would say parents should come to their own decision on whether to let their elementary aged children read this novel (it is aimed at teens), though I'd let someone who's bordering the tween/teen years read this.
My only dislike was the conclusion to the Moncore storyline. It was a let down to me --I felt like Lord Hamlin should have had a greater role in regards to Moncore instead of a knight. I felt like a big duel or something between the two would have been cool (after all, he's been searching for that man for over five years), but I'm a sucker for sword fights. Yes, I also suspected the ending, but it's a historical romance novel, not a mystery/suspense book, so I didn't mind that too much.
The Christian aspect of the novel was well done and not “preachy” like some other Christian authors I've read and the historical aspect of the novel helped in this area as most Europeans at that time were “practicing Christians” at the least. Good messages such as not relying entirely on your feelings or emotions when it comes to love and the willingness of the characters to do the right or responsible thing, despite personal sacrifices can be taken for all audiences, but I was encouraged specifically by the main characters striving to live by faith and trusting in God –in Him and His plan for them.
My first reaction on seeing my book copy was, “Oh, my gosh, it looks so short.” Granted, the book looks about 1.5'' thick, but the print is smaller than average for a paperback about 7'' tall (the print seems to be the size of mass market paperback “pocket books” ), but my fears were assuaged as I didn't feel like it was “short” --in other words, the story arc was full, lush, and then came to a logical conclusion. In the future, I (and my eyes) would appreciate a more traditional-sized type for the size of this paperback. However, the cover art is even more gorgeous in real life and the “healer's cabinet” concept on the back cover is lovely as well.
In conclusion, “The Healer's Apprentice” is one of the most well written debut from a first time author I've read in a long time, and I hope much more medieval fiction is to come. I'm recommending this to all my friends, especially teen girls. I've put Melanie Dickerson on my “favorite authors” list and can't wait for her next novel! (Thank you for reading and I apologize for the length of this review.)
February 6, 2016
About this book:
“Two Hearts. One Hope.
Rose has been appointed as a healer's apprentice at Hagenheim Castle, a rare opportunity for a woodcutter's daughter like her. While she often feels uneasy at the sight of blood, Rose is determined to prove herself capable. Failure will mean returning home to marry the aging bachelor her mother has chosen for her—a bloated, disgusting merchant who makes Rose feel ill.
When Lord Hamlin, the future duke, is injured, it is Rose who must tend to him. As she works to heal his wound, she begins to understand emotions she's never felt before and wonders if he feels the same. But falling in love is forbidden, as Lord Hamlin is betrothed to a mysterious young woman in hiding. As Rose's life spins toward confusion, she must take the first steps on a journey to discover her own destiny.”
Series: It’s connected to Melanie Dickerson’s other books,“The Fairest Beauty”and“The Captive Maiden”and should be read in this order for the least amount of spoilers.
Spiritual Content- The sign of the Cross is done when talking about the dead;“Glory to God”is said; a goddess is mentioned; Prayers; Scriptures are quoted; Talks about God, His Will & casting out demons in His Name.
Negative Content- Minor cussing including: two ‘stupid’s, six items are called “cursed”, a curse is said but not written; Blood (semi-detailed); Black magic & demons are a large part of the story; a mention of how a dog died; People eat peacock (Yes, really! (Semi-detailed)); Wine drinking and hints about those who have had too much; Talks of hanging people (one person almost gets hanged but he doesn’t and it works out okay).
Sexual Content- three ‘wench’s; Studying each other (just the face); Flirting; Rose says that the blacksmith’s son wants one thing form her and it’s not marriage; Rose says she developed curves at age 13; She also says she doesn’t need attention, as“she knew a few maidens who had need it and ended up with child—and without a husband.”;Punishments for touching a women is the stocks and compromising her is death by hanging; Wilhelm says his brother, Rupert, is”always happy when there’s a party to go to or a women to seduce.”Mentions of children out of wedlock & what happens to the mother; Romantic songs are sung and written; Girls gets attacked but only get hurt (semi—detailed); *Spoiler* A man asks Rose to be his mistress, she, of course, says no. *End of Spoiler*; Many hand kisses (highest being a semi that has shivers); a semi-detailed kiss and a detailed kiss; Love, falling in love & warm from touches.
-Rose
-Wilhelm
P.O.V. switches between them.
Set in 1386 {Medieval}
257 pages
~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*
Pre Teens- One Star
New Teens- One Star (and a half)
Early High School Teens- Two Stars
Older High School Teens- Three Stars
My personal Rating- Three Stars
“Sleeping Beauty”(A.k.a. Briar Rose) was my favorite Disney princess when I was growing up, but I called her “Iknow”, because of the song..?{ “I know you, I walked with you once upon a dream….” }So when I heard about a Christian version I knew I had to read it. So, I got all of Melanie Dickerson’s four books from the library, but I read them out of order! I did“The Fairest Beauty”(number 3) first then once I realized that they were connecting, I read this one,“The Healer’s Apprentice”(number 1). Book #2,“The Merchant’s Daughter”,is another series which will be added to with her new book“The Princess Spy”,coming in November. I enjoyed this take on my precious Sleepy Beauty story and was shocked at how things played out.
Link to review:
http://booksforchristiangirls.blogspo...
*BFCG may (Read the review to see) recommend this book by this author. It does not mean I recommend all the books by this author.
“Two Hearts. One Hope.
Rose has been appointed as a healer's apprentice at Hagenheim Castle, a rare opportunity for a woodcutter's daughter like her. While she often feels uneasy at the sight of blood, Rose is determined to prove herself capable. Failure will mean returning home to marry the aging bachelor her mother has chosen for her—a bloated, disgusting merchant who makes Rose feel ill.
When Lord Hamlin, the future duke, is injured, it is Rose who must tend to him. As she works to heal his wound, she begins to understand emotions she's never felt before and wonders if he feels the same. But falling in love is forbidden, as Lord Hamlin is betrothed to a mysterious young woman in hiding. As Rose's life spins toward confusion, she must take the first steps on a journey to discover her own destiny.”
Series: It’s connected to Melanie Dickerson’s other books,“The Fairest Beauty”and“The Captive Maiden”and should be read in this order for the least amount of spoilers.
Spiritual Content- The sign of the Cross is done when talking about the dead;“Glory to God”is said; a goddess is mentioned; Prayers; Scriptures are quoted; Talks about God, His Will & casting out demons in His Name.
Negative Content- Minor cussing including: two ‘stupid’s, six items are called “cursed”, a curse is said but not written; Blood (semi-detailed); Black magic & demons are a large part of the story; a mention of how a dog died; People eat peacock (Yes, really! (Semi-detailed)); Wine drinking and hints about those who have had too much; Talks of hanging people (one person almost gets hanged but he doesn’t and it works out okay).
Sexual Content- three ‘wench’s; Studying each other (just the face); Flirting; Rose says that the blacksmith’s son wants one thing form her and it’s not marriage; Rose says she developed curves at age 13; She also says she doesn’t need attention, as“she knew a few maidens who had need it and ended up with child—and without a husband.”;Punishments for touching a women is the stocks and compromising her is death by hanging; Wilhelm says his brother, Rupert, is”always happy when there’s a party to go to or a women to seduce.”Mentions of children out of wedlock & what happens to the mother; Romantic songs are sung and written; Girls gets attacked but only get hurt (semi—detailed); *Spoiler* A man asks Rose to be his mistress, she, of course, says no. *End of Spoiler*; Many hand kisses (highest being a semi that has shivers); a semi-detailed kiss and a detailed kiss; Love, falling in love & warm from touches.
-Rose
-Wilhelm
P.O.V. switches between them.
Set in 1386 {Medieval}
257 pages
~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*
Pre Teens- One Star
New Teens- One Star (and a half)
Early High School Teens- Two Stars
Older High School Teens- Three Stars
My personal Rating- Three Stars
“Sleeping Beauty”(A.k.a. Briar Rose) was my favorite Disney princess when I was growing up, but I called her “Iknow”, because of the song..?{ “I know you, I walked with you once upon a dream….” }So when I heard about a Christian version I knew I had to read it. So, I got all of Melanie Dickerson’s four books from the library, but I read them out of order! I did“The Fairest Beauty”(number 3) first then once I realized that they were connecting, I read this one,“The Healer’s Apprentice”(number 1). Book #2,“The Merchant’s Daughter”,is another series which will be added to with her new book“The Princess Spy”,coming in November. I enjoyed this take on my precious Sleepy Beauty story and was shocked at how things played out.
Link to review:
http://booksforchristiangirls.blogspo...
*BFCG may (Read the review to see) recommend this book by this author. It does not mean I recommend all the books by this author.
February 24, 2017
While I still enjoyed this for the most part, there were a few things I didn’t like about it…I felt like some of the characters like Rose could be a little careless at times and put themselves in unnecessary danger for certain situations. I was also spoiled for a major thing that happened in this book—which could definitely be a reason why I was aggravated by some of the character’s actions sometimes…Since I saw everything at a different perspective, I don’t think I can judge this book too harshly. So don’t let my minor complaints dissuade you from reading this book. Even with being spoiled, I still enjoyed this story. It was pretty cute in the end and I am definitely going to continue on with the rest of this series! (Especially since I already own all seven of the books in the series XD lol)
September 13, 2016
3.5 stars -- I enjoyed this book from Melanie Dickerson. Fun and fresh play on a classic fairy tale, though I was itching to edit some sections (it's hard for a writer to make me forget my editorial bent). I look forward to watching Melanie develop as a writer; she has a solid start here. Recommended for the 12 and up Christian YA reading crowd.
February 26, 2019
OKAY, THIS BOOK WAS REALLY GOOD.
first off, I had no idea what this was supposed to be a retelling of?? I THOUGHT I had figured out that it was the Princess and the Pea but then now I realize I was wrong (Plus, I didn't do such a great job remembering that fairytale). Anyway, now I know it was supposed to be Sleeping Beauty. It's been a while since I read that fairytale, so this doesn't have as many parallels as I thought. I don't know. I'm rambling. This was good. That is all. I enjoyed it.
first off, I had no idea what this was supposed to be a retelling of?? I THOUGHT I had figured out that it was the Princess and the Pea but then now I realize I was wrong (Plus, I didn't do such a great job remembering that fairytale). Anyway, now I know it was supposed to be Sleeping Beauty. It's been a while since I read that fairytale, so this doesn't have as many parallels as I thought. I don't know. I'm rambling. This was good. That is all. I enjoyed it.
November 13, 2019
Possible rtc
April 21, 2016
Set in Medieval Germany, “The Healer’s Apprentice” by Melanie Dickerson follows the titular character, a young woman named Rose, and young Lord Hamlin. They first meet when Lord Hamlin is injured and Rose is forced to tend to him on her own. They soon begin to fall in love. Problem is, Lord Hamlin has been betrothed since childhood to the mysterious Lady Salomea, whom he has never met because she is in hiding from the evil, self-proclaimed sorcerer, Moncore.
I’ve never read anything by Melanie Dickerson before “The Healer’s Apprentice”, and therefore didn’t know what to expect. I knew from the synopsis that it was loosely based on the Sleeping Beauty story, and from the tags here on Goodreads that it was Christian fiction, which were the things that attracted me to the book in the first place, but other than that, I had no idea what the writing style would be like, what the story would be like, or anything.
This book is a romance, beginning to end, but as a Christian fiction story, it is very clean, which was very much appreciated by me. It was nice to be able to enjoy the sweetness and romance of the relationships without things getting too smexy for my tastes. I also appreciated how the two main characters consciously made the effort to behave in a way that honored God and each other, even when it was hard for them because of how attracted they were to each other.
That said, the first third, or maybe even half of the book was mainly about developing the relationships. Sure, we got little hints about Lord Hamlin’s hunt for Moncore, but there wasn’t much in the way of “action” outside of feasts, dances and relationship drama. Around page 110 I started to wonder if anything REALLY dramatic was ever going to happen, or if it was going to be more like Jane Austen’s stories where the relationship drama is as dramatic as it gets. (Just so we’re clear, I like Jane Austen, so that wouldn’t have been a bad thing. I just wanted to know what to expect.) But then, only a few pages later, something dramatic did happen, and the more mysterious, exciting part of the story began.
The mystery here was predictable, and I admit that as soon as the action-y thing happened, I formed a theory as to who certain people were and what was going on and I turned out to be right about all of it. But I enjoy trying to guess plot points before they happen, so that didn’t bother me much and just had me excited to see if I was right. It did help, though, that the characters weren’t oblivious to the clues being put forth either and started to guess at these things themselves, but because there was still a reasonable doubt, they and the reader weren’t able to know for sure until the end whether or not they were right.
More things that I liked:
The historical authenticity. The author obviously did her research on medieval Germany, and according to the author interview in the back of the book, has actually been to Germany herself, which is where she fell in love with medieval architecture. This made the setting feel very realistic, and I enjoyed seeing the German names for some things, and the ye olde foods and culture.
And that ending. Guh. So much romance. So much sweetness. So much happy. *melts into a puddle with hearts floating up from it* It couldn’t have been more satisfying, IMHO.
Now, before I conclude, I do want to address one last thing, about the villain specifically, for the sake of younger readers, or those wondering if this book would be good for younger readers. But this section may be a little spoilery, so I’ll leave a little space here if anyone wants to skip it:
.
.
.
.SPOILER SPACE
.
.
.
.
While the villain of this story, Moncore, doesn’t feature prominently in most of the story, we do get some scenes from his perspective close to the end. We already knew he was evil and vengeful, but through these scenes, we find out the he is also N-U-T-S, NUTS! He has voices in his head, which are suggested to be demonic, and as such, they tell him to do very bad things, such as kill and/or demonize those people on whom he wants revenge. He does actually try to do these things, and the result of his attempts to terrorize a certain character with demons could be scary to younger or sensitive readers. I was personally glad I got to that section of the story during the daytime, because had I been reading it right before bedtime, I might have gotten creeped out myself!
But of course, the end of the story is happy, so Moncore’s plans eventually get thwarted and Moncore himself is killed. His demise, while well-deserved, is a tad icky: He is stabbed through the chest with a sword, and there was a brief description of blood as he died I could have gone without, but otherwise, his death is not drawn-out, and once he’s gone, he’s gone, and we don’t have to think about him again.
.
.
.
.
.END OF SPOILERS
.
.
.
.
.
Overall, I loved this book even more than I thought I would when I started it. It’s a sweet, clean, well-written, romance, and I liked the tie-ins to the Sleeping Beauty story as well. Now that I’ve discovered Melanie Dickerson, I’ll definitely be reading more books by her, particularly the rest of her series of fairy tale retellings, which will be going on my want-to-read list as soon as I finish this review.
This book gets 5 stars.
I’ve never read anything by Melanie Dickerson before “The Healer’s Apprentice”, and therefore didn’t know what to expect. I knew from the synopsis that it was loosely based on the Sleeping Beauty story, and from the tags here on Goodreads that it was Christian fiction, which were the things that attracted me to the book in the first place, but other than that, I had no idea what the writing style would be like, what the story would be like, or anything.
This book is a romance, beginning to end, but as a Christian fiction story, it is very clean, which was very much appreciated by me. It was nice to be able to enjoy the sweetness and romance of the relationships without things getting too smexy for my tastes. I also appreciated how the two main characters consciously made the effort to behave in a way that honored God and each other, even when it was hard for them because of how attracted they were to each other.
That said, the first third, or maybe even half of the book was mainly about developing the relationships. Sure, we got little hints about Lord Hamlin’s hunt for Moncore, but there wasn’t much in the way of “action” outside of feasts, dances and relationship drama. Around page 110 I started to wonder if anything REALLY dramatic was ever going to happen, or if it was going to be more like Jane Austen’s stories where the relationship drama is as dramatic as it gets. (Just so we’re clear, I like Jane Austen, so that wouldn’t have been a bad thing. I just wanted to know what to expect.) But then, only a few pages later, something dramatic did happen, and the more mysterious, exciting part of the story began.
The mystery here was predictable, and I admit that as soon as the action-y thing happened, I formed a theory as to who certain people were and what was going on and I turned out to be right about all of it. But I enjoy trying to guess plot points before they happen, so that didn’t bother me much and just had me excited to see if I was right. It did help, though, that the characters weren’t oblivious to the clues being put forth either and started to guess at these things themselves, but because there was still a reasonable doubt, they and the reader weren’t able to know for sure until the end whether or not they were right.
More things that I liked:
The historical authenticity. The author obviously did her research on medieval Germany, and according to the author interview in the back of the book, has actually been to Germany herself, which is where she fell in love with medieval architecture. This made the setting feel very realistic, and I enjoyed seeing the German names for some things, and the ye olde foods and culture.
And that ending. Guh. So much romance. So much sweetness. So much happy. *melts into a puddle with hearts floating up from it* It couldn’t have been more satisfying, IMHO.
Now, before I conclude, I do want to address one last thing, about the villain specifically, for the sake of younger readers, or those wondering if this book would be good for younger readers. But this section may be a little spoilery, so I’ll leave a little space here if anyone wants to skip it:
.
.
.
.SPOILER SPACE
.
.
.
.
While the villain of this story, Moncore, doesn’t feature prominently in most of the story, we do get some scenes from his perspective close to the end. We already knew he was evil and vengeful, but through these scenes, we find out the he is also N-U-T-S, NUTS! He has voices in his head, which are suggested to be demonic, and as such, they tell him to do very bad things, such as kill and/or demonize those people on whom he wants revenge. He does actually try to do these things, and the result of his attempts to terrorize a certain character with demons could be scary to younger or sensitive readers. I was personally glad I got to that section of the story during the daytime, because had I been reading it right before bedtime, I might have gotten creeped out myself!
But of course, the end of the story is happy, so Moncore’s plans eventually get thwarted and Moncore himself is killed. His demise, while well-deserved, is a tad icky: He is stabbed through the chest with a sword, and there was a brief description of blood as he died I could have gone without, but otherwise, his death is not drawn-out, and once he’s gone, he’s gone, and we don’t have to think about him again.
.
.
.
.
.END OF SPOILERS
.
.
.
.
.
Overall, I loved this book even more than I thought I would when I started it. It’s a sweet, clean, well-written, romance, and I liked the tie-ins to the Sleeping Beauty story as well. Now that I’ve discovered Melanie Dickerson, I’ll definitely be reading more books by her, particularly the rest of her series of fairy tale retellings, which will be going on my want-to-read list as soon as I finish this review.
This book gets 5 stars.
January 30, 2019
I’m so glad I’m finally starting this series and getting to dive into Hagenheim!
This book was so interesting and I really enjoyed all of the sub-plots within. It was beautifully written, and there was so much depth to a fairytale.
I LOVED Wilhelm so much! Every time he popped up in the story I got so happy.
I’m excited to read the Beauty & the Beast retelling.
4/5 stars
This book was so interesting and I really enjoyed all of the sub-plots within. It was beautifully written, and there was so much depth to a fairytale.
I LOVED Wilhelm so much! Every time he popped up in the story I got so happy.
I’m excited to read the Beauty & the Beast retelling.
4/5 stars
November 13, 2016
Disappointing.
The writing is rather ridiculous, the plot is lacking and very predictable, the historical accuracy regarding Christianity was such that even one whose knowledge of medieval times is as lacking as mine had to cringe (more on that below), and the characters are cookie cutter. There were also some serious inconsistencies going on; especially Rose and Lord Hamlin and ESPECIALLY Lord Hamlin. Both of them had plenty of double standards going on there. They're all propriety and decorum until they're daydreaming about (or actually executing) thoughts of kissing and cuddling each other, but HEAVEN FORBID that others should indulge in such immorality! Granted, they seem to be aware of this discrepancy in a hazy sort of way, and both are constantly asking God to forgive them for such thoughts/actions before continuing on their merry way.
And while we're discussing the faults of Lord Hamlin, can I just take a moment to say what an obnoxious hero he is?? He's supposedly the responsible boy who never stops his virtuous workings for the good of the realm, yet at every turn he appears to make Rose swoon, taking his trusty steed out for a trot and looking dashed good. Also, he seems to have plenty of time off from his hard work to extensively practice the lute, at which he excels and whips out from time to time to serenade the lady whom he is forbidden to love. Cliche much? And reading his painful inner battles on the subject of said lady got old, really fast. WE GET IT. WE REALLY DO. You love her, but you don't, because you are true to your betrothed! But you still love her...
And that whole thing with the demons? Ummm...just no. The way the author mixes medieval Catholicism and modern Protestantism just does not work. I'm sorry Ms. Dickerson. I know you have that footnote at the end of the book claiming you did the best you could at research, but this is not how things would have gone down. I'll mention merely a few of the most glaring ones. Rose at one point in the book questions the Church's teachings on certain subjects due to her study of Scripture. It is improbable to begin with that any woman at that time who was not in a holy order of some sort would have read the Bible (there weren't exactly a whole lot of copies floating around) and even if she had, she would NEVER have the cheek to question Church theology. That scene in the story made Rose and Rupert look absurdly pretentious. And although there is plenty of demon fighting going on, why is a priest never consulted? In actuality, there would have been several exorcisms in order.
One last little rant here. That end scene with Rose and Lord Hamlin. PLEASE MAKE IT STOP. Lord Hamlin and Rose are sitting there making out while he keeps praying and thanking God for giving her to him (cause' they're GOOD CHRISTIAN PEOPLE, folks! Don't you forget it! Don't worry...you won't be allowed to...) while Rose is thinking sensual thoughts about him. It was ridiculous and inappropriate and exactly the sort of thing that makes a lot of "Christian romance" awful.
So no, I did not like this book.
The writing is rather ridiculous, the plot is lacking and very predictable, the historical accuracy regarding Christianity was such that even one whose knowledge of medieval times is as lacking as mine had to cringe (more on that below), and the characters are cookie cutter. There were also some serious inconsistencies going on; especially Rose and Lord Hamlin and ESPECIALLY Lord Hamlin. Both of them had plenty of double standards going on there. They're all propriety and decorum until they're daydreaming about (or actually executing) thoughts of kissing and cuddling each other, but HEAVEN FORBID that others should indulge in such immorality! Granted, they seem to be aware of this discrepancy in a hazy sort of way, and both are constantly asking God to forgive them for such thoughts/actions before continuing on their merry way.
And while we're discussing the faults of Lord Hamlin, can I just take a moment to say what an obnoxious hero he is?? He's supposedly the responsible boy who never stops his virtuous workings for the good of the realm, yet at every turn he appears to make Rose swoon, taking his trusty steed out for a trot and looking dashed good. Also, he seems to have plenty of time off from his hard work to extensively practice the lute, at which he excels and whips out from time to time to serenade the lady whom he is forbidden to love. Cliche much? And reading his painful inner battles on the subject of said lady got old, really fast. WE GET IT. WE REALLY DO. You love her, but you don't, because you are true to your betrothed! But you still love her...
And that whole thing with the demons? Ummm...just no. The way the author mixes medieval Catholicism and modern Protestantism just does not work. I'm sorry Ms. Dickerson. I know you have that footnote at the end of the book claiming you did the best you could at research, but this is not how things would have gone down. I'll mention merely a few of the most glaring ones. Rose at one point in the book questions the Church's teachings on certain subjects due to her study of Scripture. It is improbable to begin with that any woman at that time who was not in a holy order of some sort would have read the Bible (there weren't exactly a whole lot of copies floating around) and even if she had, she would NEVER have the cheek to question Church theology. That scene in the story made Rose and Rupert look absurdly pretentious. And although there is plenty of demon fighting going on, why is a priest never consulted? In actuality, there would have been several exorcisms in order.
One last little rant here. That end scene with Rose and Lord Hamlin. PLEASE MAKE IT STOP. Lord Hamlin and Rose are sitting there making out while he keeps praying and thanking God for giving her to him (cause' they're GOOD CHRISTIAN PEOPLE, folks! Don't you forget it! Don't worry...you won't be allowed to...) while Rose is thinking sensual thoughts about him. It was ridiculous and inappropriate and exactly the sort of thing that makes a lot of "Christian romance" awful.
So no, I did not like this book.
June 27, 2022
I really enjoyed this! Melanie Dickerson writes what I wanted to read when I was a teenager but couldn't find.
November 1, 2018
2018 Review
These are the most charismatic Medieval Roman Catholics you will ever meet.
Also, can we talk for a moment about Frau Geruscha's plan?
Also, let's talk about Moncore's plan.
Not sure I'd give it four stars this read through but we'll leave it.
2011 Review
I wish I could give this book three and a half stars. I liked, but I'm not so sure I REALLY liked it. So I'm giving it four stars, but being a bit generous.
The first book I've read in 2011, I was really looking forward to "The Healer's Apprentice." I've been following Melanie Dickerson on goodreads for a while and we seem to read a lot of similar books.
The Plot
The life Rose knows is that of the woodcutter's daughter, apprentice of Hagenheim's healer. Though pretty, she does not wish to marry, but wants to be a healer, especially if that means avoiding the constant stream of eligible old men her mother sends after her. Life at Hagenheim Castle changes, though, with the arrival of the two young lords, Hamlin and Rupert. When Lord Hamlin is injured in a hunting accident, Rose is the one to care for him. Both young people find themselves curiously attracted, but Lord Hamlin has been betrothed since age 5.
Thoughts
A historical romance, "The Healer's Apprentice" is a retelling of the fairytale Sleeping Beauty, though it would be unfair to leave it at that. Definitely Christian, it is written for teenagers but might prove interesting to various ages. I can't imagine a guy reading it, being more girlish, but not necessarily chick-flickish
I did like how the story was that of Sleeping Beauty, yet much different. You didn't feel like you were going through the usual motions like a typical fairytale, but it flowed well together.
A few things annoyed me. For example, Rose and Lord Hamlin, though professing deep interest in the other's character, mostly seemed attracted to the other person physical appearance. I got bored of reading about Rose's "light brown curls" and Lord Hamlin's "muscular shoulders." Her perfect lips. His tussled appearance. etc.
Also, Frau Geruscha, the healer, was kind of a weak character. Though she willingly gave her life to watch the young girl, she doesn't seem very interested in watching over her well-being outside of a few angry looks and some not-very-effective comments.
Lord Hamlin struggles with his love....and struggles, struggles, struggles, struggles until I really don't care. Maybe you're suppose to like him for his imperfections, but seriously. Go hunting or something. Stop thinking a girl!
With that, though, I did like how Lord Hamlin worked to keep his thoughts and behavior pure for his future betrothal. Having him seek out the evil wizard who put his betrothal in so much danger gave him an interesting side, a hint of adventure. So many modern "romance" or "fantasy" or even fairy-tale novels have male characters so irritating, obnoxious, or just plain offensive in their romantic inclinations that you want to give them a cold shower and a knuckle sandwich. You don't feel that way about Lord Hamlin, though he isn't exactly a Mr Darcy or a character you get a fictional crush on, he is a good guy.
His brother, Lord Rufus wasn't very believable, though. There wasn't any real change in him...I wanted to slap Rose for ever thinking she liked him. He was kind of flat. A cold hearted jerk who took any romantic loss with barely a glimmer of regret.
Rose was....irritating and interesting. I liked her as a person, though she often got a bit dramatic.
I was rather iffy about the book until I hit maybe...early climax. About that point I went, "wow. This is getting interesting."
And it was.
While bad guys and real...evilness had remained somewhat hidden, maybe being found in emotions or relationships, until Moncore shows up. He's evil, and while maybe not very deeply drawn out, his hidden presence has been felt throughout. I liked how Dickerson used demonic influence over some sort of 'magical' stuff. I liked how the truth was proclaimed, that Jesus makes you more powerful then the evilest enchanter, hands down. The demons had no power but to create fear.
Up until the early climax, I read but wasn't interested. The end wasn't remarkable (I really wanted to be like, DUDES - STOP KISSING HER HAND) but the climax was good and made it worth it. I look forward to reading more by Melanie Dickerson.
These are the most charismatic Medieval Roman Catholics you will ever meet.
Also, can we talk for a moment about Frau Geruscha's plan?
Also, let's talk about Moncore's plan.
Not sure I'd give it four stars this read through but we'll leave it.
2011 Review
I wish I could give this book three and a half stars. I liked, but I'm not so sure I REALLY liked it. So I'm giving it four stars, but being a bit generous.
The first book I've read in 2011, I was really looking forward to "The Healer's Apprentice." I've been following Melanie Dickerson on goodreads for a while and we seem to read a lot of similar books.
The Plot
The life Rose knows is that of the woodcutter's daughter, apprentice of Hagenheim's healer. Though pretty, she does not wish to marry, but wants to be a healer, especially if that means avoiding the constant stream of eligible old men her mother sends after her. Life at Hagenheim Castle changes, though, with the arrival of the two young lords, Hamlin and Rupert. When Lord Hamlin is injured in a hunting accident, Rose is the one to care for him. Both young people find themselves curiously attracted, but Lord Hamlin has been betrothed since age 5.
Thoughts
A historical romance, "The Healer's Apprentice" is a retelling of the fairytale Sleeping Beauty, though it would be unfair to leave it at that. Definitely Christian, it is written for teenagers but might prove interesting to various ages. I can't imagine a guy reading it, being more girlish, but not necessarily chick-flickish
I did like how the story was that of Sleeping Beauty, yet much different. You didn't feel like you were going through the usual motions like a typical fairytale, but it flowed well together.
A few things annoyed me. For example, Rose and Lord Hamlin, though professing deep interest in the other's character, mostly seemed attracted to the other person physical appearance. I got bored of reading about Rose's "light brown curls" and Lord Hamlin's "muscular shoulders." Her perfect lips. His tussled appearance. etc.
Also, Frau Geruscha, the healer, was kind of a weak character. Though she willingly gave her life to watch the young girl, she doesn't seem very interested in watching over her well-being outside of a few angry looks and some not-very-effective comments.
Lord Hamlin struggles with his love....and struggles, struggles, struggles, struggles until I really don't care. Maybe you're suppose to like him for his imperfections, but seriously. Go hunting or something. Stop thinking a girl!
With that, though, I did like how Lord Hamlin worked to keep his thoughts and behavior pure for his future betrothal. Having him seek out the evil wizard who put his betrothal in so much danger gave him an interesting side, a hint of adventure. So many modern "romance" or "fantasy" or even fairy-tale novels have male characters so irritating, obnoxious, or just plain offensive in their romantic inclinations that you want to give them a cold shower and a knuckle sandwich. You don't feel that way about Lord Hamlin, though he isn't exactly a Mr Darcy or a character you get a fictional crush on, he is a good guy.
His brother, Lord Rufus wasn't very believable, though. There wasn't any real change in him...I wanted to slap Rose for ever thinking she liked him. He was kind of flat. A cold hearted jerk who took any romantic loss with barely a glimmer of regret.
Rose was....irritating and interesting. I liked her as a person, though she often got a bit dramatic.
I was rather iffy about the book until I hit maybe...early climax. About that point I went, "wow. This is getting interesting."
And it was.
While bad guys and real...evilness had remained somewhat hidden, maybe being found in emotions or relationships, until Moncore shows up. He's evil, and while maybe not very deeply drawn out, his hidden presence has been felt throughout. I liked how Dickerson used demonic influence over some sort of 'magical' stuff. I liked how the truth was proclaimed, that Jesus makes you more powerful then the evilest enchanter, hands down. The demons had no power but to create fear.
Up until the early climax, I read but wasn't interested. The end wasn't remarkable (I really wanted to be like, DUDES - STOP KISSING HER HAND) but the climax was good and made it worth it. I look forward to reading more by Melanie Dickerson.
December 29, 2010
I got a copy of this book through the Amazon Vine program. This looked like a wonderful book, a great historical romance with a bit of fantasy flare to it. It was okay, in fact the beginning of the book was pretty good, but it declined from the middle of the book on. Keep in mind I approached this as a historical fantasy, I was not aware that the publisher was a Christian fiction publisher....so when characters started setting aside action to wait for God to save them and then the Duke of the realm used his divine right as a leader to banish demons I was confused and irritated.
This is the story of Rose. Rose is apprenticed to the Healer of the realm. When the Duke's sons come for a visit; both of them are drawn to her beauty. Rose knows her place in the realm and, as a Healer's Apprentice, does not want the attention of either brother. When one of the brothers, Wilhelm, is injured Rose heals him. Wilhelm and Rose are drawn to each other's personalities, but it cannot be. Wilhelm is betrothed to a Princess whose identity will not be revealed until the evil mage is defeated. Meanwhile Wilhelm's younger brother, a rogue of sorts, has started courting Rose. Wilhelm struggles to keep his feelings for Rose under wraps while trying to hunt down the evil mage that plagues the realm.
This book started out pretty good. It had a lot of a fairy tale feel to it, with a definite German tone. You can't help but love the characters in the beginning they are all so sweet, pure, and innocent. Rose is determined to be good and to have a life as a healer. Rose can get to be a little much at points; she is pure to the point of not exposing her arms, not touching a man's hand, or wearing makeup. But that seemed to be mostly cultural, so went well with the story. The writing is fairly well done and engaging; there are beautiful descriptions but the dialogue between characters is a bit stilted. I was really enjoying this as a sweet historical romance with a bit of a fantasy flare to it...then we get to the second half of the book.
Keep in mind I did not know this book was released by a christian fiction publisher, so readers beware. As the book continues God is mentioned a lot (I mean a lot a lot) and scripture is quoted. Wilhelm is especially religious; all of which I don't have a problem with. The problem comes in when the characters decide to stop taking action and sit on their bums praying for God to save them. I was like "what is going on here?"... "Why are these wonderful characters waiting around for God to do their work for them rather than taking positive action themselves?"
Then suddenly things get even stranger; Rose is haunted by demons and speaking in tongues. Wilhelm enters to save the day by using his power as a Duke to cast the evil forces out of his realm in God's name. It all got very weird, was very predictable, and made me very uncomfortable. I couldn't figure out why the author would drop such a sweet positive story and turn it into some weird parable of religious text.
Overall I loved the beginning of this book. The characters are positive, sweet, and likable. The romance between Rose and Wilhelm is well-founded and they have great chemistry together. I hated the ending of the book, I thought the overpowering use of God as a solution to the characters problems and Wilhelm's sudden ability to make use of divine intervention were strange and distasteful. So just be warned; this is a Christian fantasy and gets very preachy towards the end of the book. If that's not your thing pick up a different book with sweet characters and wonderful romance; I recommend Crown Duel by Sherwood Smith or The Hero and the Crown by Robin McKinley. This book is appropriate for all young adults and older.
This is the story of Rose. Rose is apprenticed to the Healer of the realm. When the Duke's sons come for a visit; both of them are drawn to her beauty. Rose knows her place in the realm and, as a Healer's Apprentice, does not want the attention of either brother. When one of the brothers, Wilhelm, is injured Rose heals him. Wilhelm and Rose are drawn to each other's personalities, but it cannot be. Wilhelm is betrothed to a Princess whose identity will not be revealed until the evil mage is defeated. Meanwhile Wilhelm's younger brother, a rogue of sorts, has started courting Rose. Wilhelm struggles to keep his feelings for Rose under wraps while trying to hunt down the evil mage that plagues the realm.
This book started out pretty good. It had a lot of a fairy tale feel to it, with a definite German tone. You can't help but love the characters in the beginning they are all so sweet, pure, and innocent. Rose is determined to be good and to have a life as a healer. Rose can get to be a little much at points; she is pure to the point of not exposing her arms, not touching a man's hand, or wearing makeup. But that seemed to be mostly cultural, so went well with the story. The writing is fairly well done and engaging; there are beautiful descriptions but the dialogue between characters is a bit stilted. I was really enjoying this as a sweet historical romance with a bit of a fantasy flare to it...then we get to the second half of the book.
Keep in mind I did not know this book was released by a christian fiction publisher, so readers beware. As the book continues God is mentioned a lot (I mean a lot a lot) and scripture is quoted. Wilhelm is especially religious; all of which I don't have a problem with. The problem comes in when the characters decide to stop taking action and sit on their bums praying for God to save them. I was like "what is going on here?"... "Why are these wonderful characters waiting around for God to do their work for them rather than taking positive action themselves?"
Then suddenly things get even stranger; Rose is haunted by demons and speaking in tongues. Wilhelm enters to save the day by using his power as a Duke to cast the evil forces out of his realm in God's name. It all got very weird, was very predictable, and made me very uncomfortable. I couldn't figure out why the author would drop such a sweet positive story and turn it into some weird parable of religious text.
Overall I loved the beginning of this book. The characters are positive, sweet, and likable. The romance between Rose and Wilhelm is well-founded and they have great chemistry together. I hated the ending of the book, I thought the overpowering use of God as a solution to the characters problems and Wilhelm's sudden ability to make use of divine intervention were strange and distasteful. So just be warned; this is a Christian fantasy and gets very preachy towards the end of the book. If that's not your thing pick up a different book with sweet characters and wonderful romance; I recommend Crown Duel by Sherwood Smith or The Hero and the Crown by Robin McKinley. This book is appropriate for all young adults and older.
October 27, 2016
The Healer's Apprenticewas a very interesting book and I quite loved it! The cover caught my eye right away; and the promise that it was a Christian retelling ofSleeping Beauty... I just had to read it! *smiles*
This book is a historical, set in medieval Germany, I believe. It had sweet romance, action, rejection, and mystery - swept me away with its captivating quality, really!
But the villain and happenings involving demons were a little much for me. I readThe Healer's Apprenticequite a few years ago, probably when I was fourteen/fifteen; so I don't know what I'd think about it now. But at the time, those creepy parts diminished my enjoyment of the book overall. So that's the reason for my lowerrating. If you don't mind that kind of content, then I recommend this book wholly!
Besides those things,The Healer's Apprenticewas a excellent, beautiful read!
This book is a historical, set in medieval Germany, I believe. It had sweet romance, action, rejection, and mystery - swept me away with its captivating quality, really!
But the villain and happenings involving demons were a little much for me. I readThe Healer's Apprenticequite a few years ago, probably when I was fourteen/fifteen; so I don't know what I'd think about it now. But at the time, those creepy parts diminished my enjoyment of the book overall. So that's the reason for my lowerrating. If you don't mind that kind of content, then I recommend this book wholly!
Besides those things,The Healer's Apprenticewas a excellent, beautiful read!
September 14, 2010
The Healer's Apprentice was like being transported to a world of castles and kinds, knights and curses, love and danger. I could see the castle, I could hear the voices of the hero and heroine. Melanie Dickerson created a vivid medieval world and set a beautiful love story in these charmed surroundings.
I absolutely loved it. I saw it was described as bening for Young Adults and I know this would appeal to that age but it's a wonderful love story for anyone who reads romance, at any age.
I can't wait for more from Dickerson, because I want to go back to this world.
Was this review helpful?
I absolutely loved it. I saw it was described as bening for Young Adults and I know this would appeal to that age but it's a wonderful love story for anyone who reads romance, at any age.
I can't wait for more from Dickerson, because I want to go back to this world.
Was this review helpful?
March 9, 2022
I enjoyed this more than I thought I would! It reminded me of a mix of the first and third Daughters of Peverell books! Also, I feel like the bad guy didn't have much page time and wasn't a very deep bad guy. XD (weird sounding sentence. you know how there are villains you LOVE because they're perfectly bad? Well, that wasn't this guy) Anyway, the casting out demons scene was a little weird. I don't know what to believe about us casting out demons, so I don't know what to think about that. there's some Christian fiction that has a scene where something happens that I don't know what to believe about it.
March 12, 2019
This book shouldn't even be tagged as "fantasy". Did I miss something? Because I really don't understand why it would be considered fantasy. It's a Christian historical romance and that's it. Unfortunately, this book wasn't for me. I'm not into books with a lot of religion in it and it felt a bit too religious and preachy for my taste. I hoped the Christian part wouldn't be really present but I was wrong.
However, religion aside, I didn't care about any of the characters. I listened to the audiobook and I only wanted it to be over. I didn't care and I rolled my eyes many times... The "story" was predictable. It was obvious she'd end up with the love interest. There was nothing that interested me in this book and I'm really disappointed. I was looking for a fantasy book with a Healer as the FMC but this book didn't deliver what I needed.
Anyway, moving on!
However, religion aside, I didn't care about any of the characters. I listened to the audiobook and I only wanted it to be over. I didn't care and I rolled my eyes many times... The "story" was predictable. It was obvious she'd end up with the love interest. There was nothing that interested me in this book and I'm really disappointed. I was looking for a fantasy book with a Healer as the FMC but this book didn't deliver what I needed.
Anyway, moving on!
August 25, 2018
Title: The Healer's Apprentice
Written By: Melanie Dickerson
Genre: Christian Historical Fiction/Fairy Tale Retelling
Recommended Ages: 13 & up
Introduction:
I read this book once before and remember enjoying it. This is a Sleeping Beauty retelling. It doesn't have any magic and there are quite a few differences from the original tale, but it is a very enjoyable read and I loved all the nuances in the book.
Characters: 1/1
Rose, Wilhelm, and Rupert were all great characters as were all of the side characters. Melanie did a great job setting each character up and have each of them grow in different ways.
Dialogue: 1/1
The dialogue fit the location of the setting and though I'm sure it didn't technically fit the time period since they talked very differently back then, it was easy to understand which is more important. The dialogue fit the book and each of the characters perfectly.
Plot/Storyline: 1/1
I love the German setting and all the changes Melanie made to the Sleeping Beauty tale. This one is much better. I love the intricacies she wove into the story and the love triangle she put in there. I don't always like love triangles, but this one worked well.
Overall Writing and Production Quality:.75/1
Melanie's writing was quite good. I can't give it a full star, however. I hold traditionally published books to a higher standard than indie published ones because I know they go through many more extensive edits. This book I thought could have had a few sentences restructured that were fine as is, but could have been made more clear with a little extra thought.
Un-put-down-ability: 1/1
I read the entire book in less than a week. For a full-length novel, that is rare. It helps that I was not feeling well for an entire day and read about half the book that day, but that's beside the point. I didn't ever want to put it down. Just ask my husband...
Conclusion: 4.75/5
If you like fairy tales, but don't like the magic, you'll enjoy this series. A lot. The romance is also sweet and not even very mushy like so many. There are a few kisses, but they description lasts a few words rather than paragraphs or even sentences. ****SPOILER**** There is a man who tries to force himself on Rose a couple of times, but he does not succeed ****END SPOILER**** If not for that, I would say this book could be read by the entire family. Either way, I think it is a good read and would be appropriate for teens and older.
Written By: Melanie Dickerson
Genre: Christian Historical Fiction/Fairy Tale Retelling
Recommended Ages: 13 & up
Introduction:
I read this book once before and remember enjoying it. This is a Sleeping Beauty retelling. It doesn't have any magic and there are quite a few differences from the original tale, but it is a very enjoyable read and I loved all the nuances in the book.
Characters: 1/1
Rose, Wilhelm, and Rupert were all great characters as were all of the side characters. Melanie did a great job setting each character up and have each of them grow in different ways.
Dialogue: 1/1
The dialogue fit the location of the setting and though I'm sure it didn't technically fit the time period since they talked very differently back then, it was easy to understand which is more important. The dialogue fit the book and each of the characters perfectly.
Plot/Storyline: 1/1
I love the German setting and all the changes Melanie made to the Sleeping Beauty tale. This one is much better. I love the intricacies she wove into the story and the love triangle she put in there. I don't always like love triangles, but this one worked well.
Overall Writing and Production Quality:.75/1
Melanie's writing was quite good. I can't give it a full star, however. I hold traditionally published books to a higher standard than indie published ones because I know they go through many more extensive edits. This book I thought could have had a few sentences restructured that were fine as is, but could have been made more clear with a little extra thought.
Un-put-down-ability: 1/1
I read the entire book in less than a week. For a full-length novel, that is rare. It helps that I was not feeling well for an entire day and read about half the book that day, but that's beside the point. I didn't ever want to put it down. Just ask my husband...
Conclusion: 4.75/5
If you like fairy tales, but don't like the magic, you'll enjoy this series. A lot. The romance is also sweet and not even very mushy like so many. There are a few kisses, but they description lasts a few words rather than paragraphs or even sentences. ****SPOILER**** There is a man who tries to force himself on Rose a couple of times, but he does not succeed ****END SPOILER**** If not for that, I would say this book could be read by the entire family. Either way, I think it is a good read and would be appropriate for teens and older.
December 4, 2017
I loved the title and even the cover. I wanted to like this, even just a little. I wish I could just say this book was not for me and be done, but I can't seem to leave it at that. This book is a perfect example of all that I hate when reading or listening. I'm not sure which I disliked more…the writing or the narration. Talk about fantasy romance…that is truly my least favorite genre. I've read one other book by this author, and I had the same complaints with that one: requires a sweet tooth to get through, the characters are TOO perfect, and the story is predictable.
This was one star for the whole first half, but I upped it by one star because I felt like a knew where the author wanted to go, but all in all, it was coated too heavily with the sugar.
This was one star for the whole first half, but I upped it by one star because I felt like a knew where the author wanted to go, but all in all, it was coated too heavily with the sugar.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 2,469 reviews